To define the role of radiotherapy in the treatment of small-cell lung cancer (SCLC) on the basis of clinical data reported in the medical literature.
Methods
Published reports are critically reviewed, with particular attention to randomized trials.
Results
Thoracic radiotherapy has an important role in improving local control and 3-year survival in limited-stage SCLC; radiation should be delivered early in the course of the chemotherapy program, avoiding large volumes and total doses exceeding 40-50 Gy. Thoracic radiotherapy probably has no role in resected patients treated with adjuvant chemotherapy and may even be detrimental in patients with extensive SCLC. Prophylactic cranial irradiation has been shown to reduce the risk of brain relapse, but it is not associated with a consistent increase in survival or cure rate: its use in clinical practice is therefore not advised.
Conclusions
Survival rates approaching 50% at 2 years are now possible in limited SCLC with the integrated effort of the surgeon, the medical oncologist and the radiation oncologist; their strict cooperation appears to be of the utmost importance in the earliest phase of treatment planning.
AroneyR.S., AisnerJ., WesleyM.N., WhitacreM.Y., Van EchoD.A., SlaesonR.G., WiernikP.H.: Value of prophylactic cranial irradiation given at complete remission in small cell lung cancer. Cancer Treat. Rep., 67: 675–682, 1983.
2.
ArriagadaR., Le ChevalierT., BaldeyrouP., PicoJ.L., RuffleP., MartinM., El BakryH. M., DurouxP., BignonJ., LenfantB., HayatM., RouesseJ.G., Sancho-GarnierH., TubianaM.: Alternating radiotherapy and chemotherapy schedules in small cell lung cancer limited disease. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys., 11: 1461–1467, 1985.
3.
ArriagadaR., Pellae-CossetB., Cueto Ladron de GuevaraJ., El BakryH., BennaF., MartinM., de CremouxH., BaldeyrouP., CerrinaM.L., Le ChevalierT.: Alternating radiotherapy and chemotherapy schedules in limited small cell lung cancer: analysis of local chest recurrences. Radiother. Oncol., 20: 91–98, 1991.
4.
ArriagadaR., KramarA., Le ChevalierT., De CremouxH.: Competing events determining relapse-free survival in limited small-cell lung carcinoma. J. Clin. Oncol., 10: 447–451, 1992.
5.
ArriagadaR., Le ChevalierT., BoireF., RiviereA., ChomyP., MonnetI., TardivonA., ViaderF., TarayreM., BenhamouS.: Prophylactic cranial irradiation for patients with small-cell lung cancer in complete remission. J. Natl. Cancer Inst., 87: 183–190, 1995.
6.
BallD.L., MatthewsJ.P.: Prophylactic cranial irradiation: more questions than answers. Semin. Radiat. Oncol., 5: 61–68, 1995.
7.
BeilerD.D., KaneR.C., BernathA.M., CashdollarM.R.: Low dose elective brain irradiation in small cell carcinoma of the lung. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys., 5: 941–945, 1979.
8.
BergsagelD.E., JenkinR.D.T., PringleJ.F., WhiteD.M., Fet-terlyJ.C.M., KlaassenD.J., McDermotR.S.R.: Lung cancer: clinical trial of radiotherapy alone vs radiotherapy plus cyclo-phoshamide. Cancer, 30: 621–627, 1972.
9.
BirchR., OmuraG.A., GrecoF.A., PerezC.A.: Patterns of failure in combined chemotherapy and radiotherapy for limited small-cell lung cancer: Southeastern Cancer Study Group experience. NCI Monogr., 6: 265–270, 1988.
10.
BunnP.A., LichterA.S., MakuchR.W., CohenM.H., VeachS.R., MatthewsM.J., AndersonA.J., EdisonM., GlatsteinE., MinnaJ.D., IhdeD.C.: Chemotherapy alone or chemotherapy with radiation therapy in limited stage small cell lung cancer. Ann. Intern. Med., 106: 655–662, 1987.
11.
BunnP.A., KellyK.: Prophylactic cranial irradiation for patients with small-cell lung cancer (editorial). J. Natl. Cancer Inst., 87: 161–162, 1995.
12.
CarlsonR.W., SikicB.I., GandaraD.R., HendricksonC.G., WittlingerP.S., ShieldsJ.A., WongP.P., WhiteJ.E., MeakinC.J., McWhiterK.M., LambornK.R., PhillipsT.L.: Late consolidative radiation therapy in the treatment of limited-stage small cell lung cancer. Cancer, 68: 948–958, 1991.
13.
ChoiN.C., CareyR.W.: Importance of radiation dose in achieving improved loco-regional tumor control in limited stage small-cell lung carcinoma: an update. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys., 17: 307–310, 1989.
14.
CoxJ.D., PetrovicinZ., PaigC., StanleyK.: Prophylactic cranial irradiation in patients with inoperable carcinoma of the lung. Cancer, 42: 1135–1140, 1978.
15.
CoyP., HodsonI., PayneD.G., EvansW.K., FeldR., MacDonaldA.S., OsobaD., PaterJ.L.: The effect of dose of thoracic irradiation on recurrence in patients with limited stage small cell lung cancer. Initial results of a Canadian multicenter randomized trial. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys., 14: 219–226, 1988.
16.
CreechR., RichterM., FinkelsteinD.: Combination chemotherapy with or without consolidation radiation therapy for regional small cell carcinoma of the lung (Abst). Proc. Am. Soc. Clin. Oncol., 7: 196, 1988.
17.
DavisS., CrinoL., TonatoM., DarwishS., PelicciP.G., Grig-naniF.: A prospective analysis of chemotherapy following surgical resection of clinical stage I-II small lung cancer. Am. J. Clin. Oncol., 16: 93–95, 1993.
18.
DodwellD., GildersleveJ.Q.: Adjuvant thoracic radiation in small cell lung cancer. Clin. Oncol., 5: 384–385, 1993.
19.
EaganR.T., FrytakS., LeeR.E., CreaganE.T., IngleJ.N., NicholsW.C.: A case for preplanned thoracic and prophylactic whole brain radiation therapy in limited small cell lung cancer. Cancer Clin. Trials, 4: 261–266, 1981.
20.
EaganR.T., FrytakS., LeeR.E., TherneauT.M., RichardsonR.L., CreaganE.T.: No routine role for vincristine, adriamycin, and cyclophosphamide or thoracic radiation therapy in extensive stage small cell lung cancer. Am. J. Clin. Oncol., 10: 141–145, 1987.
21.
EinhornL.H.: The case against prophylactic cranial irradiation in limited lung cancer. Semin. Radiat. Oncol., 5: 57–60, 1995.
22.
FoxW., ScaddingJ.G.: Medical research council comparative trial of surgery and radiotherapy for primary treatment of small-celled or oat-celled carcinoma of bronchus. Ten-year follow-up. Lancet, 2: 63–65, 1973.
23.
GinsbergR.J., ShepherdF.A.: Surgery for small cell lung cancer. Semin. Radiat. Oncol., 5: 40–43, 1995.
24.
HansenH.H., DombernowskyP., HirschF.R., HansenM., RygardJ.: Prophylactic irradiation in bronchogenic small cell anaplastic carcinoma. Cancer, 46: 279–284, 1980.
HodsonD.I., MalakerK., MeikleA.L., LevittM.: Pilot studies of superfractionated radiotherapy and combination chemotherapy in limited oat cell carcinoma of the bronchus. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys., 10: 1941–1045, 1984.
27.
JacksonD.V., RichardsF., CooperM.R., FereeC., MussH.B., WhiteD.R., SpurrC.L.: Prophylactic cranial irradiation in small cell carcinoma of the lung. A randomized study. JAMA, 237: 2730–2733, 1983.
28.
JohnsonD., TurrisiA.T., ChangA.Y., BlumR., BonomiP., EttingerD., WagnerH.: Alternating chemotherapy and twice-daily thoracic radiotherapy in limited-stage small-cell lung cancer: a pilot study of the Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group. J. Clin. Oncol., 11: 879–884, 1993.
29.
JossR.A., AlbertoP., BleherE.A., LudwigC., SiegenthalerP., MartinelliG., SauterC., SchatzmannE., SennH.J.: Combined-modality treatment of small-cell lung cancer: randomized comparison of three induction chemotherapies followed by maintenance chemotherapy with or without radiotherapy to the chest. Ann. Oncol., 5: 921–928, 1994.
30.
KarrerK., ShieldsT.W., DenckH., HrabarB., Vogt-MoykopfI., SalzerG.M.: The importance of surgical and multimodal-ity treatment for small cell bronchial carcinoma. J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., 97: 168–176, 1989.
31.
KatsensisA.T., KarpasitisN., GiannakakisD., MaragoudakisN., KiparissiadisP.: Elective brain irradiation in patients with small-cell carcinoma of the lung: preliminary report. Lung Cancer. International Congress Series 558, pp. 277–284, Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, 1982.
32.
KiesM.S., MiraJ.G., CrowleyJ.J., ChenT.T., PazdurR., GrozeaP.N., RivkinS.E., ColtmanC.A., WardJ.K., LivingstonR.B.: Multimodal therapy for limited small-cell lung cancer: a randomized study of induction combination chemotherapy with or without thoracic radiotherapy in complete responders and with wide-field versus reduced-field radiation in partial responders: a Southwest Oncology Group Study. J. Clin. Oncol., 5: 592–600, 1987.
33.
KristjansenP.E.G., KristensenC.A.: The role of prophylactic cranial irradiation in the management of small cell lung cancer. Cancer Treat. Rev., 19: 3–16, 1993.
34.
LebeauB., ChastangC., BrechotJ.M., CapronF.: A randomized trial of delayed thoracic radiotherapy in complete responder patients with small-cell lung cancer. Chest, 104: 726–733, 1993.
35.
LiengswangwongV., BonnerJ.A., ShawE.G., FooteR.L., FrytakS., EaganR.T., JettJ.R., RichardsonR.L., CreaganE.T., SuJ.Q.: Limited-stage small-cell lung cancer: patterns of intrathoracic recurrence and the implications for thoracic radiotherapy. J. Clin. Oncol., 12: 496–502, 1994.
36.
MaurerL.H., TullohM., WeissR.B., BlomJ.B., LeonaL., GliedewellO., PajakT.E.: A randomized combined modality trial in small cell carcinoma of the lung: comparison of combination chemotherapy-radiation therapy versus cyclophosphamide-radiation therapy and effects of maintenance chemotherapy and prophylactic whole brain irradiation. Cancer, 45: 30–39, 1980.
37.
Medical Research Council Working Party:Comparative trial of surgery and radiotherapy for the primary treatment of small-celled or oat-celled carcinoma of the bronchus. Lancet, 2: 979–986, 1966.
38.
Medical Research Council Working Party:Radiotherapy alone or with chemotherapy in the treatment of small-cell carcinoma of the lung: the results at 36 months. Br. J. Cancer, 44: 611–617, 1981.
39.
MurrayN., CoyP., PaterJ.L., HodsonI., ArnoldA., ZeeB.C., PayD., CostashukE.C., EvansW. K., DixonE.P., Sa-duraA., FeldR., LevittM., WierzbickiR., AyoubJ., MarounJ.A., WilsonK.S.: Importance of timing for thoracic irradiation in the combined modality treatment of limited-stage small-cell lung cancer. J. Clin. Oncol., 11: 336–344, 1993.
40.
NiiranenA., HolstiP., SalmoM.: Treatment of small cell lung cancer. Acta Oncol., 28: 501–505, 1989.
41.
NouE., BrodinO., BerghJ.: A randomized study of radiation treatment in small cell bronchial carcinoma treated with two types of four-drug chemotherapy regimens. Cancer, 62: 1079–1090, 1988.
42.
OhnoshiT., HirakiS., KimuraI.: Randomized trial of chemotherapy alone or with chest irradiation in limited stage small cell lung cancer. In: Cancer chemotherapy: challenges for the future, KimuraK., OtaK., HerbermannR.B., TakitaH. (Eds.), pp. 186–191, Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, 1987.
43.
OsterlindK., HansenH.H., HansenH.S., DombernowskyP., HansenM., RorthM.: Chemotherapy versus chemotherapy plus irradiation in limited small cell lung cancer. Results of a controlled trial with 5 years follow-up. Br. J. Cancer, 54: 7–17, 1986.
44.
PerezC.A., EinhornL., OldhamR.K., GrecoF.A., CohenH.J., SilbermanH., KraussS., HornbackN., ComasF., OmuraG., SalterM., KellerJ.W., McLarenJ., KellermeyerR., StoraasliJ., BirchR., DandyM.: Randomized trial of radiotherapy to the thorax in limited small-cell carcinoma of the lung treated with multiagent chemotherapy and elective brain irradiation: a preliminary report. J. Clin. Oncol., 2: 1200–1208, 1984.
45.
PerryM.C., EatonW.L., PropertK.J., WareJ.H., ZimmerB., ChahinianA.P., SkarinA., CareyR., KreismanH., FaulknerC., ComisR., GreenM.: Chemotherapy with or without radiation therapy in limited small-cell carcinoma of the lung. N. Engl. J. Med., 316: 912–919, 1987.
46.
PignonJ.-P., ArriagadaR., IhdeD.C., JohnsonD.J., PerryM.C., SouhamiR.L., BrodinO., JossR.A., KiesM.S., LebeauB., OnoshiT., OsterlindK., TattersallM.H.N., WagnerH.: A meta-analysis of thoracic radiotherapy for small-cell lung cancer. N. Engl. J. Med., 327: 1618–1624, 1992.
47.
RosenthalM.A., TattersallM.H.N., FoxR.M., WoodsR.L., BrodieG.N.: Adjuvant thoracic radiotherapy in small cell lung cancer: ten-year follow-up of a randomized study. Lung Cancer, 7: 235–241, 1991.
48.
SalzerG.M., MullerL.C., HuberH., DenzH., GasserR., FrommholdH., EbnerI.: Operation for N2 small cell lung carcinoma. Ann. Thorac. Surg., 49: 759–762, 1990.
49.
SeydelH.G., CreechR., PaganoM., SalazarO., RubinP., ConcannonJ., CarboneP., MohuiddinM., PerezC., MatthewsM.: Prophylactic versus no brain irradiation in regional small cell lung carcinoma. Am. J. Clin. Oncol., 8: 218–223, 1985.
50.
ShawE.G., SuJ.Q., EaganR.T., JettJ.R., Maksymiuk DeigertF.A.: Prophylactic cranial irradiation in complete responders with small-cell lung cancer: analysis of the Mayo Clinic and North Central Cancer Treatment Group data bases. J. Clin. Oncol., 12: 2327–2332, 1994.
51.
ShepherdF.A., EvansW.K., FeldR., YoungV., PattersonG.A., GinsbergR., JohansenE.: Adjuvant chemotherapy following surgical resection for small-cell carcinoma of the lung. J. Clin. Oncol., 6: 832–838, 1988.
52.
ShepherdF.A., GinsbergR.J., FeldR., EvansW.K., JohansenE.: Surgical treatment for limited small-cell lung cancer. J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., 101: 385–393, 1991.
53.
SouhamiR.L., GeddesD.M., SpiroS.G., HarperP.G., TobiasJ.S., MantellB.S., FearonF., BradburyI.: Radiotherapy in small cell cancer of the lung treated with combination chemotherapy: a controlled trial. BMJ., 288: 1643–1646, 1984.
54.
TurrisiA.T., GloverD.J.: Thoracic radiotherapy variables: influence on local control in small cell lung cancer limited disease. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys., 19: 1473–1479, 1990.
55.
TurrisiA.T., KimK., JohnsonD.H., KomakiR., SauseW., CurranW., LivingstonR., WagnerH., BlumR.: Daily vs twice-daily thoracic irradiation with concurrent cisplatin-etoposide for limited small cell lung cancer. Preliminary results on 352 randomized eligible patients (Abst.). Lung Cancer, 11(S1): A667, 1994.
56.
WardeP., PayneD.: Does thoracic irradiation improve survival and local control in limited-stage small cell carcinoma of the lung? A meta-analysis. J. Clin. Oncol., 10: 890–895, 1992.
57.
WilliamsC., AlexanderM., GlatsteinE.J., DanielsJ.R.: Role of radiation therapy in combination with chemotherapy in extensive oat cell cancer of the lung: a randomized study. Cancer Treat. Rep., 61: 1427–1431, 1977.
58.
WilsonH.E., StanleyK., VincentR.G., MountainC.F., SealyR., CohenM., ChenT.Y., BatleyF., KilmanJ., KakosG., VaskoJ., WilliamsT.E., TuckerR.D.: Comparison of chemotherapy alone versus chemotherapy and radiation therapy of extensive small cell carcinoma of the lung. J. Surg. Oncol., 23: 181–184, 1983.
