Problems in Fine-Needle Aspiration Biopsy Cytology of Clinically or Mammographically Uncertain Breast Tumors

Abstract

From June 1978 to December 1980 at the Istituto Nazionale Tumori of Milano, a fine-needle aspiration biopsy was performed on each of 4834 cases of palpable mammary nodules, the large majority of which were clinically and mammographically suspicious for cancer and only a small part clinically definitely positive. Of these, 1173 underwent surgery at this institution, and 534 (45.5%) had a histologically proven carcinoma. The aspirations were performed by individuals different from those who read the cytologic smears. The aspirations were never repeated, and methods for the retrieval of cells were never applied. Under the circumstances, sensitivity was 0.67, specificity 0.98, and the predictive value for positive results 0.97. The high percentage of inadequate samples (25.5%) influenced the low sensitivity. The few false-positive results occurred exclusively during the first year. Frozen sections can be avoided in those cases (about 50%) with definitely positive cytologic diagnosis by the application of strict criteria. The intrinsc incapability of cytology to yield any information on the extent and the invasiveness of a malignant lesion does not seem to effect its pre-operatory conclusiveness.