To compare advanced imaging techniques in the diagnosis of recurrent rectal cancer.
Material and Methods:
Twenty-five consecutive patients with either suspected or verified recurrence were examined by CT (n=25), MR with phased-array capabilities (n=24) and CEA scintigraphy (n=16). Three experienced radiologists (who were blinded to results obtained at surgery and histopathology) independently evaluated the films, one observer for each modality.
Results:
The MR radiologist arrived at a correct diagnosis in 87.5% of the examinations, the CT radiologist in 76% and the CEA radiologist in 75%. The MR radiologist's results correlated more often with reported pathology than did those of the CT radiologist with regard to the relation of recurrent tumor to surrounding structures in the pelvis.
Conclusion:
MR imaging is the most effective of the 3 modalities in the diagnosis of recurrent rectal cancer.
AdalsteinssonB.PåhlmanL.HemmingssonA.GlimeliusB.GraffmanS.: Computed tomography in early diagnosis of local recurrence of rectal carcinoma. Acta Radiol.28 (1987), 41.
2.
BaumR. P.HertelA.LorenzM.SchwarzA.EnckeA.HörG.: 99Tcm-labelled anti-CEA monoclonal antibody for tumor immunoscintigraphy. First clinical results. Nucl. Med. Commun.10 (1989), 345.
3.
ButchR. J.StarkD. D.WittenbergJ.: Staging rectal cancer by MR and CT. AJR146 (1986), 1150.
4.
de LangeE. E.FechnerR. E.WaneboH. J.: Suspected recurrent rectosigmoid carcinoma after abdominoperineal resection. MR imaging and histopathologic findings. Radiology170 (1989), 323.
5.
EbnerF.KresselH. Y.MintzM. C.: Tumor recurrence versus fibrosis in the female pelvis. Differentiation with MR imaging at 1.5 T. Radiology166 (1988), 333.
6.
FrykholmG.HemmingssonA.NymanR.PåhlmanL.GlimeliusB.: Nonresectable adenocarcinoma of the rectum assessed by MR imaging before and after chemotherapy and irradiation. Acta Radiol.33 (1992), 447.
7.
GrabbeE.WinklerR.: Local recurrence after sphincter-saving resection for rectal and rectosigmoid carcinoma. Value of various diagnostic methods. Radiology155 (1985), 305.
8.
HodgmanC. G.MaccartyR. L.WolffB. G.: Preoperative staging of rectal carcinoma by computed tomography and 0.15 T magnetic resonance imaging. Dis. Colon Rectum28 (1986), 446.
9.
HricakH.: Magnetic resonance imaging evaluation of the irradiated female pelvis. Semin. Roentgenol.29 (1994), 70.
10.
HusbandJ. E.HodsonN. J.ParsonsC. A.: The use of computed tomography in recurrent rectal tumors. Radiology134 (1980), 677.
11.
ItoK.KatoT.TadokoroM.: Recurrent rectal cancer and scar. Differentiation with PET and MR imaging. Radiology182 (1992), 549.
12.
KrestinG. P.SteinbrichW.FriedmannG.: Recurrent rectal cancer. Diagnosis with MR imaging versus CT. Radiology168 (1988), 307.
13.
LindP.LechnerP.Arian-SchadK.: Anti-carcinoembryonic antigen immunoscintigraphy (technetium-99m-monoclonal antibody BW 431/26) and serum CEA levels in patients with suspected primary and recurrent colorectal carcinoma. J. Nucl. Med.32 (1991), 1319.
Müller-SchimpfleM. M.BrixG.SemmlerW.: Role of contrast-enhanced MRI in the diagnosis of recurrent rectal carcinoma. Adv. MRI Contr.2 (1994), 78.
18.
NgheimH. V.HerfkensR. J.FrancisI. R.: The pelvis. T2-weighted fast spin-echo MR imaging. Radiology185 (1992), 213.
19.
PemaP. J.BennettW. F.BovaJ. G.WarmanP.: CT vs MRI in diagnosis of recurrent rectosigmoid carcinoma. J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr.18 (1994), 256.
20.
ReznekR. H.WhiteF. E.YoungJ. W. R.FryI. KelseyNichollsR. J.: The appearances on computed tomography after abdominoperineal resection for carcinoma of the rectum. A comparison between the normal appearances and those of recurrence. Br. J. Radiol.56 (1983), 237.
21.
SchlagP.LehnerB.StraussL. G.GeorgiP.HerfarthC.: Scar or recurrent rectal cancer. Position emission tomography is more helpful for diagnosis than immunoscintigraphy. Arch. Surg.124 (1989), 197.
22.
SmithR. C.ReinholdC.LangeR.MaccauelyT. R.KierR.McCarthyS.: Fast spin-echo imaging of the female pelvis. Part I. Use of a whole-volume coil. Radiology184 (1992), 665.
23.
SmithR. C.ReinholdC.LangeR.MaccauelyT. R.KierR.McCarthyS.: Multicoil high-resolution fast spin-echo MR-imaging of the female pelvis. Radiology184 (1992), 671.
24.
StraussL. G.CloriusJ. H.SchlagP.: Recurrence of colorectal tumors. PET evaluation. Radiology170 (1989), 329.
25.
VieiraM. R.RodriquezM.SalgadoL.SantosR.de AlmeidaX. Mendes: Immunoscintigraphy with 99Tcm-labelled anti-CEA monoclonal antibody in colorectal carcinoma. Eur. J. Surg. Oncol.19 (1993), 294.
26.
WahrenB.HammarströmS.von KrusenstiernaS.: Radioimmunolocalization of cancer of the colon and rectum. In: Tumor marker antigens. Properties and usefulness of carcinoma associated antigens CEA, CA 19–9 and CA 50, p. 70. Studentlitteratur, Sweden1985.
