Reproducibility of Doppler Ultrasound Measurements

Abstract

Purpose:

The reproducibility of Doppler ultrasound measurements was studied in a group of radiologists with different experience of such measurements.

Material and Methods:

The 12 participating radiologists measured peak systolic velocity (PSV), resistance index (RI), and pulsatility index (PI) from 3 arteries and PSV alone in one artery of a healthy person under standardized circumstances. Each participant repeated the measurements 10 times.

Results:

Significant (p<0.005) interobserver variation was seen in all of the variables, with an up to 14-fold difference in the PSV values measured and most variation resulting from differences between observers. The reproducibility of RI was better, most variation being within observers. Experience improved the reproducibility of the Doppler US measurements. Significant difference (p<0.05) in Doppler US measurements was seen between the 3 experience groups. The difference was marked between the highly experienced and the medium experienced group when the variances of the measured values of PSV, RI, and PI from all 4 arteries were combined.

Conclusion:

The reproducibility of Doppler ultrasound measurements is poor. The value of the method is questionable.

Keywords

Arteries,reproducibility Doppler ultrasound experience comparison

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Demolis

Chalon

Giudicelli

J.-F.

: Repeatability of transcranial Doppler measurements of arterial blood flow velocities in healthy subjects. Clin. Sci. 84 (1993), 599.

Fillinger

M. F.

Schwartz

R. A.

: Volumetric blood flow measurements with color Doppler ultrasonography. The importance of visual clues. J. Ultrasound Med. 3 (1993), 123.

Foley

W. D.

Scott

J. E.

: Color Doppler flow imaging. AJR 156 (1991), 3.

Gill

W. G.

: Measurement of blood flow by ultrasound. Accuracy and sources of error. Ultrasound Med. Biol. 11 (1985), 625.

Kimme-Smith

Hussain

Duerinckx

Tessler

Grant

: Assurance of consistent peak-velocity measurements with a variety of duplex Doppler instruments. Radiology 177 (1990), 265.

Leng

G. C.

Whymam

M. R.

Donnan

P. T.

Ruckley

C. V.

Gillespie

: Accuracy and reproducibility of duplex ultrasonography in grading femoropopliteal stenoses. J. Vasc. Surg. 17 (1993), 510.

London

N. J.

Aldoori

M. I.

Lodge

V. G.

Bates

J. A.

Irving

H. C.

: Reproducibility of Doppler ultrasound measurement of resistance index in renal allografts. Br. J. Radiol. 66 (1993), 510.

Mitchell

D. G.

: Color Doppler imaging. Principles, limitations, and artifacts. Radiology 177 (1990), 1.

Mullaart

R. A.

Hopman

J. C. W.

Daniels

Rotteveel

J. J.

De Haan

A. F. J.

: Repeatability of Doppler ultrasound measurement of blood flow velocity and its variability in the supraclinoid segment of the internal carotid artery in preterm newborns. Ultrasound Med. Biol. 6 (1989), 545.

10.

Nelson

T. R.

Pretorius

D. H.

: The Doppler signal. Where does it come from and what does it mean? AJR 15 (1988), 439.

11.

Oates

C. P.

Williams

E. D.

McHugh

M. I.

: The use of a Diasonics DRF 400 duplex ultrasound scanner to measure volume flow in arterio-venous fistulae in patients undergoing haemodialysis. An analysis of measurement uncertainties. Ultrasound Med. Biol. 6 (1990), 571.

12.

Orr

N. M.

Taylor

K. J. W.

: Doppler detection of tumor vascularity. In: Duplex Doppler ultrasound, p. 149. Churchill Livingstone, New York 1990.

13.

Perko

M. J.

Just

: Duplex ultrasonography of superior mesenteric artery. Inter-observer variability. J. Ultrasound Med. 5 (1993), 259.

14.

Polak

J. F.

Dobkin

G. R.

O'Leary

D. H.

Wang

A.-M.

Cutler

S. S.

: Internal carotid artery stenosis. Accuracy and reproducibility of color-Doppler assisted duplex imaging. Radiology 173 (1989), 793.

15.

Ranke

Hendrickx

Roth

Brassel

Creutzig

: Color and conventional image-directed Doppler ultrasonography. Accuracy and sources of error in quantitative blood flow measurements. J. Clin. Ultrasound 20 (1992), 187.

16.

Rimoy

G. H.

Bhaskar

N. K.

Rubin

P. C.

: Reproducibility of Doppler blood flow velocity waveform measurements. Study on variability within and between days and during haemodynamic intervention in normal subjects. Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 41 (1991), 125.

17.

Rizzo

R. J.

Sandager

Astleford

Payne

Pettersson-Kennedy

: Mesenteric flow velocity variations as a function of angle of insonation. J. Vasc. Surg. 11 (1990), 688.

18.

Scherjon

S. A.

Kok

J. H.

Oosting

Zondervan

H. A.

: Intraobserver and interobserver reliability of the pulsatility index calculated from pulsed Doppler flow velocity waveforms in three fetal vessels. Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol. 100 (1993), 134.

19.

Scheurlen

Waller

Hartmann

: In vivo validation of image-directed Doppler measurement of superior mesenteric artery blood flow. J. Clin. Ultrasound 20 (1992), 19.

20.

Scoutt

L. M.

Zawin

M. L.

Taylor

K. J. W.

: Doppler US. II. Clinical applications. Radiology 174 (1990), 309.

21.

Snedecor

G. W.

Cochran

W. G.

: Statistical methods, 6th edn., pp. 260, 271, 279. Iowa State University Press, Ames, IO 1978.

22.

Taylor

K. J. W.

Holland

: Doppler US. I. Basic principles, instrumentation and pitfalls. Radiology 174 (1990), 297.

23.

Tessler

F. N.

Kimme-Smith

Sutherland

M. L.

: Inter- and intra-observer variability of Doppler peak velocity measurements. An in vitro study. Ultrasound Med. Biol. 6 (1990), 653.

24.

de Vries

P. J.

van Hattum

Hoekstra

J. B. L.

de Hooge

: Duplex Doppler measurements of portal venous flow in normal subjects. J. Hepatol. 13 (1991), 358.

25.

Whyman

M. R.

Hoskins

P. R.

Leng

G. C.

Allan

P. L.

Donnan

P. T.

: Accuracy and reproducibility of duplex ultrasound imaging in a phantom model of femoral artery stenosis. J. Vasc. Surg. 17 (1993), 524.