Positron Emission Tomography Compared with Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Computed Tomography in Supratentorial Gliomas Using Multiple Stereotactic Biopsies as Reference

Abstract

Ten patients with findings at computed tomography (CT) suggesting intracranial supratentorial glioma were investigated to compare the diagnostic efficacy of this technique with that of positron emission tomography (PET) using ¹¹C-methionine and exminations with magnetic resonance (MR). The findings were related to histopathologic examination of serial stereotactic biopsies, which were guided by the appearance of the lesions on PET examination. To obtain corresponding slice orientation with the different examination techniques, an individually shaped helmet fixation was used. However, in 3 cases this fixation device could not be used for MR. Histopathologic diagnosis, obtained in all cases from multiple target stereotactic biopsies, included glioma in 9 patients and reactive gliosis in one case. A detailed comparison of the three imaging techniques and the findings at stereotactic biopsies was possible in 7 patients, while in 3 patients comparison with MR was less exact due to the patient's refusal to wear the helmet during this examination. MR was the most accurate method for outlining the total extent of a lesion, i.e. the tumor and the edema surrounding it. Four lesions had homogeneous signal characteristics and in 6 lesions two (or more) compartments could be distinguished with MR. In 5 cases the MR findings were in complete agreement with the histopathologic findings. However, a thorough correlation between signal characteristics and histology was not possible. Using PET the occurrence and the extent of tumor tissue was correctly predicted in 7 patients. The PET was normal in one case. Findings at CT were in agreement with the histopathologic diagnosis in 5 patients. MR was the most sensitive method for the detection of lesions. PET using methionine appeared to have a somewhat higher capacity to outline correctly the true extent of a tumor. The combination of CT and PET was superior to MR for determining the type and grade of the tumors.

Keywords

Brain neoplasms CT —,MR studies —,PET

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Becker

Vogelsang

Schwarzrock

: Vergleichende MR- und CT-Untersuchungen bei ausgewählten neuroradiologischen Fragestellungen. Fortschr. Röntgenstr. 142 (1985), 23.

2. Bergström

Boëthius

Eriksson

Greitz

Ribbe

Widén

: Head fixation device for reproducible position alignment in transmission CT and positron emission tomography. J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr. 5 (1981), 136.

3. Bergström

Collins

V. P.

, Ehrin R. and coll.: Discrepancies in brain tumor extent as shown by CT and positron emission tomography using 68-Ga-EDTA, 11-C-glucose and 11-C-methionine. J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr. 7 (1983), 1062.

4. Boëthius

Bergström

Greitz

: Stereotaxic computerized tomography with a GE 8800 scanner. J. Neurosurg. 52 (1980), 794.

5. Collins

V. P.

: Monoclonal antibodies to glial fibrillary acidic protein in the cytologic diagnosis of brain tumours. Acta Cytol. 28 (1984), 401.

6. Englund

Brun

Larsson

E.-M.

Györffy-Wagner

Persson

: Tumours of the central nervous system. Proton magnetic resonance relaxation times T1 and T2 and histopathologic correlates. Acta Radiol. Diagnosis 27 (1986), 653.

7. Ericson

von Holst

, Mosskin M. and coll.: Positron emission tomography of cavernous haemangiomas of the brain. Acta Radiol. Diagnosis 27 (1986), 379.

8. Ericson

Lilja

, Bergström M. and coll.: Positron emission tomography with 11-C-methyl-L-methionine, 11-C-D-glucose and 68-Ga-EDTA in supratentorial tumors. J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr. 9 (1985), 683.

9. Eriksson

Bohm

, Bergström M. and coll.: Design characteristics of a multi-ring positron camera system for emission tomography of the brain. In: Positron emission tomography of the brain, p. 40. Edited by Heiss

W.-D.

Phelps.

Springer Verlag, Berlinm Heidelberg, New York 1983.

10.

10. Eriksson

Bohm

, Kesselberg M. and coll.: A four ring positron camera system for emission tomography of the brain. IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. 29 (1982), 539.

11.

11. Ethier

Kuzniecky

Melanson

Robitaille

de la Sayette

: Magnetic resonance imaging. Pathologic correlations in temporal lobe epilepsy. Acta Radiol. (1986) Suppl. No. 369, p. 762 (abstract).

12.

12. Greitz

Bergström

Boëthius

Kingsley

Ribbe

: Head fixation system for integration of radiodiagnostic and therapeutic procedures. Neuroradiology 19 (1980), 1.

13.

13. Hiyama

Kobayashi

, Ono Y. and coll.: Correlation between MR signal intensity and histologic findings in neurinomas and meningiomas of the brain. Acta Radiol. (1986) Suppl. No. 369, p. 176.

14.

14. Hoffman

E. J.

van der Stee

Ricci

A. R.

Phelps

M. E.

: System design features that are determinate in precision and accuracy in positron emission tomographs. In: The metabolism of the human brain studied with positron emission tomography, p. 69. Edited by Greitz

Ingvar

Widén.

Raven Press, New York 1985.

15.

15. Kingsley

D. P. E.

Bergström

Berggren

B.-M.

: A critical evaluation of two methods of head fixation. Neuroradiology 19 (1980), 7.

16.

16. Kjær

Gjerris

Nielsen

Henriksen

: In vivo estimation of relaxation processes in brain tumors by magnetic resonance imaging. Acta Radiol. (1986) Suppl. No. 369, p. 766 (abstract).

17.

17. Komiyama

Yagura

, Baba M. and coll.: MR imaging. Possibility of tissue characterization of brain tumors using T1 and T2 values. Amer. J. Neuroradiol. 8 (1987), 65.

18.

18. Lewander

Bergström

, Boëthius J. and coll.: Stereotactic computer tomography for biopsy of gliomas. Acta Radiol. Diagnosis 19 (1978), 867.

19.

19. Lunsford

L. D.

Martinez

A. J.

Latchaw

R. E.

: Magnetic resonance imaging does not define tumor boundaries. Acta Radiol. (1986) Suppl. No. 369, p. 154.

20.

20. Mazziotta

J. C.

Phelps

M. E.

Plummer

Kuhl

D. E.

: Quantitation in positron emission computed tomography. 5. Physical-anatomical effects. J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr. 5 (1981), 734.

21.

21. Mosskin

von Holst

, Bergström M. and coll.: Positron emission tomography with ¹¹C-methionine and computed tomography of intracranial tumours compared with histopathologic examination of multiple biopsies. Acta Radiol. 28 (1987), 673.

22.

22. Mosskin

von Holst

Ericson

Norén

: The blood tumour barrier in intracranial tumours studied with X-ray computed tomography and positron emission tomography using 68-Ga-EDTA. Neuroradiology 28 (1986), 259.

23.

23. Oldendorf

W. H.

: The use and promise of nuclear magnetic resonance imaging in epilepsy. Epilepsia 25 (1984) Suppl. No. 2, S105.

24.

24. Patronas

N. J.

Brooks

R. A.

DeLaPaz

R. L.

Smith

B. H.

Kornblith

P. L.

Di Chiro

: Glycolytic rate (PET) and contrast enhancement (CT) in human cerebral gliomas. Amer. J. Neuroradiol. 4 (1983), 533.

25.

25. Patronas

N. J.

Di Chiro

, Brooks R. A. and coll.: 18-F-fluorodeoxyglucose and positron emission tomography in the evaluation of radiation necrosis of the brain. Radiology 144 (1982), 885.

26.

26. Schober

Creutzig

, Meyer G.-J. and coll.: 11-C-methionine PET, IMP-SPECT, CT und MRI bei Hirntumoren. Fortschr. Röntgenstr. 143 (1985), 133.

27.

27. Schober

Meyer

G.-J.

, Duden C. and coll.: Die Aufnahme von Aminosäuren in Hirntumoren mit der Positronen Emissionstomographie als Indikator für die Beurteilung von Stoffwechselaktivität und Malignität. Fortschr. Röntgenstr. 147 (1987), 503.

28.

28. Thuomas

K.-Å.

Bergström

Ericsson

Hemmingsson

Jung

Sperber

: Subtraction in magnetic resonance imaging. Acta Radiol. (1986) Suppl. No. 369, p. 483.

29.

29. Tovi

Thuomas

K.-Å.

, Bergström K. and coll.: Tumour delineation with magnetic resonance imaging in gliomas. A comparison with positron emission tomography and computed tomography. Acta Radiol. (1986) Suppl. No. 369, p. 161.

30.

30. Vaghi

M. A.

Strada

Visciani

Passerini

Longone

Broggi

: Magnetic resonance imaging of gliomas. Comparison with computed tomography, surgery and serial stereotactic biopsy. Acta Radiol. (1986) Suppl. No. 369, p. 151.

31.

31. Weinstein

M. A.

Duchesneau

P. M.

Pavlicek

Rosenbloom

S.A.

: Differentiation of tumor and edema with magnetic resonance imaging. Acta Radiol. (1986) Suppl. No. 369, p. 764 (abstract).