In a retrospective approach the medical records and radiographs of 618 patients with midfacial trauma were reviewed by radiologists who were classified into four groups according to the length of their training and experience. Initially reported diagnoses were compared with discharge diagnoses, and the impact of training and experience on diagnostic performance was assessed. The same parameters were also investigated in a prospective study. Neither of the investigations revealed any statistically significant improvement in diagnostic performance with increased training and experience. After the basic radiologic education, innate perceptive and cognitive abilities seem to have a larger influence on radiologic diagnostic preformance than training and experience.
AlcornF. S.O'DonnellE.: The training of nonphysician personnel for use in mammography program. Cancer23 (1969), 879.
2.
BarkerE. G.RosenbaumH. D.SelkeA. C.HendersonD.HildnerJ. H.: Film screening by physician assistants in diagnostic radiology. Amer. J. Roentgenol.126 (1976), 1069.
3.
BerbaumK. S.SmokerW. R.SmithW. L.: Measurement and prediction of diagnostic performance during radiology training. Amer. J. Roentgenol.145 (1985), 1305.
4.
BerlinL.: Is a radiologic ‘miss’ malpractice? An ominous example. Editorial. Amer. J. Roentgenol.140 (1983), 1031.
5.
BlesserB.OzonoffD.: A model for the radiologic process. Radiology103 (1972), 515.
6.
CampbellJ. A.LiebermanM.MillerR. E.DreesenR. G.HooverC.: Experience with technician performance of gastrointestinal examinations. Radiology92 (1969), 65.
7.
CappM. P.GrayJ.SeeleyG.FreundlichI. M.: Psychophysics from a radiologist's point of view. Proc. SPIE47 (1974), 142.
8.
ChristensenE. E.MurryR. C.HollandK.ReynoldsJ.LandayM. J.MooreJ. G.: The effect of search time on perception. Radiology138 (1981), 361.
9.
DolanK. D.JacobyC. G.: Facial fractures. Sem. Roentgenol.12 (1978), 37.
10.
FinebergH. V.: Assessing the diagnostic contribution of imaging tests. Computed tomography and ultrasound of the pancreas. In: Evaluation of efficacy of medical action, p. 149. Edited by AllperovitchA.de DombalE.T.GremyF., North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam1979.
11.
FlehingerB. J.MelamedM. R.HeelanR. T.McGinnisC. M.ZamanM. B.MartiniN.: Accuracy of chest film screening by technologists in the New York early lung cancer detection program. Amer. J. Roentgenol.131 (1978), 593.
12.
GarlandL. H.: Studies on the accuracy of diagnostic procedures. Amer. J. Roentgenol.82 (1959), 25.
13.
GerlockA. J.McBrideK. L.SinnD. P.: Clinical and radiographic interpretation of facial fractures. Little. Brown and Comp.. Boston1981.
14.
HebbD. O.FavreauO.: The mechanism of perception. Radiol. Clin. N. Amer.7 (1969), 393.
15.
HermanP. G.HesselS. J.: Accuracy and its relationship to experience in the interpretation of chest radiographs. Invest. Radiol.10 (1975), 62.
16.
HillmanB. J.SwenssonR. G.HesselS. J.GersonD. E.HermanP. G.: The value of consultation among radiologists. Amer. J. Roentgenol.127 (1976), 807.
KundelH. L.NodineC. F.Peripheral and cognitive guidance of eye scan paths during the search for lung nodules. Amer. J. Roentgenol.145 (1985), 659.
19.
KundelH. L.NodineC. F.CarmodyD.: Visual scanning, pattern recognition and decision-making in pulmonary nodule detection. Invest. Radiol.13 (1978), 175.
20.
MetzC. E.: Basic principles of ROC analysis. Sem. Nucl. Med.7 (1978), 283.
21.
MoilanenA.: Errors in the primary diagnosis of maxillofacial fractures. Fortschr. Röntgenstr.137 (1982), 129.
22.
PotchenE. J.GardJ. W.WoltersomR. J.GiftD. A.RehfieldP. L.: Improvement in chest film interpretation through classroom instruction. Invest. Radiol.13 (1978), 423.
23.
ReveszG.: Conspicuity and uncertainty in the radiographic detection of lesions. Radiology154 (1985), 625.
24.
RheaJ. T.PotsaidM. S.DeLucaS. A.: Errors of interpretation as elicited by a quality audit of an emergency radiology facility. Radiology132 (1979), 277.
25.
SchargusG.: Irrtümer und Fehler bei der Röntgendiagnostik von Mittelgesichtsfrakturen. Dtsch. Zahnärztl. Z.29 (1974), 548.
26.
SchultzR. C.: Facial injuries, p. 23, 143. Year Book Medical Publisher Inc., Chicago1970.
27.
SeltzerS. E.HesselS. J.HermanP. G.SwenssonR. G.SheriffC. R.: Resident film interpretations and staff review. Amer. J. Roentgenol.137 (1981), 129.
28.
SewerinI.: Three dimensional perception of radiographic images among dental students and dentists. Oral Surg.56 (1983), 332.
29.
SheftD. J.JonesM. D.BrownR. F.RossS. E.: Screening of chest roentgenograms by advanced roentgen technologists. Radiology94 (1970), 427.
30.
ShermanR. S.: The nature of radiologic diagnosis in diseases of bone. Radiol. Clin. N. Amer.7 (1970), 227.
