Focusing on gender differences, this article synthesizes the literature on gender, risk, and disasters, and presents a comprehensive view of what is known in this area. Data are limited, yet, by using a nine-stage typology to delineate disaster preparedness, impact, and recovery, noteworthy findings are documented and discussed. The literature reveals a pattern of gender differentiation throughout the disaster process. The differences are largely attributed to childcare responsibilities, poverty, social networks, traditional roles, discrimination, and other issues of gender stratification. The emergent patterns have important implications and recommendations for future directions are offered.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersonKaren M., and ManuelGerdenio. 1994. “Gender Differences in Reported Stress Response to the Loma Prieta Earthquake.” Sex Roles30: 9–10.
2.
BartonAllen H.1969. Communities in Disasters: A Sociological Analysis of Collective Stress Situations.Garden City, NY: Anchor Books, Doubleday.
3.
BeadyCharles H.Jr., and BolinRobert C.. 1986. The Role of the Black Media in Disaster Reporting to the Black Community.Boulder, Colorado: Institute for Behavioral Science, The University of Colorado, Working Paper #56.
4.
BeelmanFloyd C.1967. “Disaster Planning: Report of Tornado Casualties in Topeka.” Journal of the Kansas Medical Society96: 153–161.
5.
BidingerP. D., WalkerT.S., SarkerB., MurthyA. Ram, and BabuP.. 1991. “Consequences of Mid-1980s Drought: Longitudinal Evidence from Mahbubnagar.” Economic and Political Weekly26(39): A105–A114.
6.
BolinRobert C.1982. Long-Term Family Recovery from Disaster.Boulder. Colorado: Institute of Behavioral Science, The University of Colorado.
7.
BolinRobert C., and BoltonPatricia A.1986. Race, Religion, and Ethnicity in Disaster Recovery.Boulder, Colorado: Institute of Behavioral Science, The University of Colorado.
8.
BordRichard J., and O'ConnorRobert E.. 1990. “Risk Communication, Knowledge, and Attitudes: Explaining Reactions to a Technology Perceived.” Risk Analysis10(4): 499–506.
9.
BullardRobert. 1990. Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality.Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press.
10.
BurtonIan, KatesRobert W., and WhiteGilbert F.. 1993. The Environment as Hazard. (2nd Ed.). New York, NY: Guilford Press.
11.
CarleyMichael, and ChristieIan. 1993. Managing Sustainable DevelopmentMinneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
12.
CarterAnne O., MillsonMargaret E., and AllenDavid E.. 1989. “Epidemiologic Study of Deaths and Injuries Due to Tornadoes.” American Journal of Epidemiology130(6): 1209–1218.
13.
ChowdhuryA., MushtaqueR., BhuyiaAbbas U., ChoudhuryA. Yusuf, and SenRita. 1993. “The Bangladesh Cyclone of 1991: Why So Many People Died.” Disasters: The Journal of Disaster Studies and Management17(4): 291–304).
14.
ClasonChristine. 1983. “The Family as a Life-saver in Disaster,” Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters1(1): 43–62.
15.
CoatesLucinda, BlongRussell, and SicilianoFrank. 1993. “Lightning Fatalities in Australia, 1824–1991.” Natural Hazards8(3): 217–233.
16.
CookLesley. 1993. “Charleville in Conjunction with Women of the Community.” Symposium: Women in Emergencies and Disasters. Queensland Bureau of Emergency Services. Brisbane, Queensland.
17.
CutterSusan L., TiefenbacherJohn, and SoleckiWilliam D.. 1992. “En-Gendered Fears: Femininity and Technological Risk Perception.” Industrial Crisis Quarterly6: 5–22.
18.
DannSusan, and WilsonPaul1993. “Women and Emergency Services.” Symposium: Women in Emergencies and Disasters. Queensland Bureau of Emergency Services. Brisbane, Queensland.
19.
deManAnton, and Simpson-HousleyPaul. 1987. “Factors in Perception of Tornado Hazard: An Exploratory Study.” Social Behavior and Personality15(1) 13–19.
20.
DobsonNarelle. 1993. “From Under the Mud-Pack: Women and the Charleville Floods.” Symposium: Women in Emergencies and Disasters. Queensland Bureau of Emergency Services. Brisbane, Queensland.
21.
DrabekThomas E.1969. “Social Processes in Disaster: Family Evacuation.” Social Problems16(3): 336–349.
22.
DrabekThomas E., and BoggsKeith S.. 1968. “Families in Disaster: Reactions and Relatives.” Journal of Marriage and the Family August: 443–451.
23.
DrabekThomas E., and KeyWilliam H.. 1983. Conquering Disaster: Family Recovery and Long-Term Consequences.New York: Irvington.
24.
DrabekThomas E., KeyWilliam H., EriksonPatricia E., and CroweJuanita L.. 1975. “The Impact of Disaster on Kin Relationships.” Journal of Marriage and the Family.37(3): 481–494.
25.
DullDiana. 1994. “To Protect One's Place: Contested Meanings of Home, Help and Loss in a Natural Disaster.” Pp. 82–96 in Qualitative Approaches to Disaster, edited by SayreShay, and HorneDavidNewbury Park: Sage.
26.
Federal Emergency Management Agency.1995. National Mitigation Strategy. Draft Report.
27.
FlynnC. B.1979. Three Mile Island Telephone Survey: Preliminary Report on Procedures and Findings.Tempe, AZ: Mountain West Research.
28.
FlynnC. B., and ChalmersJ. A.. 1980. The Social and Economic Effects of the Accident at Three Mile Island.Washington, D.C.: Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
29.
FlynnJames, SlovicPaul, and MertzC. K.. 1994. “Gender, Race, and Perception of Environmental Health Risks.” Risk Analysis14(6): 1101–1108.
30.
FormWilliam H., and NosowSigmund. 1958. Community in Disaster.New York: Harper and Brothers.
31.
ForrestThomas R.1978. “Group Emergence in Disaster.” Pp. 105–125 in Disasters: Theory and Research, edited by QuarantelliE. L.. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
32.
FritzCharles E., and MarksEli S.. 1954. “NORC Studies of Human Behavior in Disaster.” Journal of Social Issues10(3): 26–41.
33.
GarrisonCarol Z., WeinrichMartin W., HardinSally B., WeinrichSally, and WangLixia. 1993. “Post-traumatic Stress Disorder in Adolescents after a Hurricane. “American Journal of Epidemiology138(7): 522–530.
34.
GlassR. I., CravenR. B., BregmanD. J., StollB. J., HorowitzN., KerndtP., WinkleJ.. 1980. “Injuries from the Wichita Falls Tornado: Implications for Prevention.” Science207: 734–738.
35.
GoltzJames D., RussellLisa A., and BourqueLinda B.. 1992. “Initial Behavioral Response to a Rapid Onset Disaster: A Case Study.” International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters10(1): 43–69.
36.
GrayLeslie. 1993. “The Effect of Drought and Economic Decline on Rural Women in Western Sudan.” Geoforum24(1): 89–98.
37.
GreenBonnie L.1993. Mental Health and Disaster: Research Review. Paper for the National Institute of Mental Health Violence and Traumatic Stress Research Branch.
38.
GreenBonnie L., KorolMindy, GraceMarcy C., VaryMarshall G., LeonardAnthony C., GleserGoldine C., and Smitson-CohenSheila. 1991. “Children and Disaster: Age, Gender, and Parental Effects on PTSD Symptoms.” Journal of the American Academy of Child Adolescence Psychiatry30(6): 945–951.
39.
HaiderRaana, RahmanA. Atiq, and HuqSaleemul (eds.). 1991. Cyclone ‘91: An Environmental and Perceptional Study.Dhaka, Bangladesh: Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies.
40.
HardinSally Brosz, WeinrichMartin, WeinrichSally, HardinThomas L., and GarrisonCarol. 1994. “Psychological Distress of Adolescents Exposed to Hurricane Hugo.” Journal of Traumatic Stress7(3): 427–440.
41.
HillReuben, and HansenDonald A.. 1962. “Families in Disaster.” Pp. 185–221 in Man and Society in Disaster, edited by BakerG. W., ChapmanD. W.. New York: Basic Books.
42.
HochschildArlie. 1989. The Second Shift: Working Parents and the Revolution at Home, New York: Viking.
43.
HodgeDavid, SharpVirginia, and MartsMarion. 1981. “Contemporary Responses to Volcanism: Case Studies from the Cascades and Hawaii.” Pp. 161–179 in Volcanic Activity and Human Ecology, edited by SheetsP. D., GraysonD. K.. New York: Academic Press.
44.
HoneycombeBeth. 1993. “Special Needs of Women in Emergency Situations.” Symposium: Women in Emergencies and Disasters.Queensland Bureau of Emergency Services. Brisbane, Queensland.
45.
HoweHolly L.1990. “Public Concern about Chemicals in the Environment: Regional Differences Based on Threat Potential.” Public Health Reports105(2): 186–195.
46.
International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies.1994. World Disasters Report: 1994.The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
47.
KapoorRenu. 1992. “The Psychosocial Consequences of an Environmental Disaster: Selected Case Studies of the Bhopal Gas Tragedy.” Population and Environment13(3): 209–215.
48.
KrauseN.1987. “Exploring the Impact of a Natural Disaster on the Health and Psychological Well-Being of Older Adults.” Journal of Human Stress13: 61–69.
49.
League of the Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies.1991. Working with Women in Emergency Relief and Rehabilitation Programmes. Field Studies Paper No. 2. Geneva, Switzerland.
50.
LeikRobert K., LeikSheila A., EkkerKnut, and GiffordGregory A.. 1982. Under the Threat of Mount St. Helens, A Study of Chronic Family Stress.Minneapolis: Family Study Center, University of Minnesota.
51.
LogueJames N., HansenHolger, and StrueningElmer. 1979. “Emotional and Physical Distress Following Hurricane Agnes in Wyoming Valley of Pennsylvania.” Public Health Reports94(6): 495–502.
52.
LogueJames N., HansenHolger, and StrueningElmer. 1981. “Some Indications of the Long-Term Health Effects of a Natural Disaster.” Public Health Reports96(1): 67–79.
53.
LogueJ. N., MelickM. E., StrueningE. L.. 1981. “A Study of Health and Mental Health Status Following a Major Natural Disaster.” Pp. 217–274 in Research in Community and Mental Health, edited by SimmonsR. G.. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
54.
MackRaymond W., and BakerGeorge W.. 1961. The Occasion Instant.Washington, D.C.: National Academy of Sciences, National Research Council.
55.
MiletiDennis S., DrabekThomas E., and HaasH. Eugene. 1975. Human Systems in Extreme Environments: A Sociological Perspective.Boulder: University of Colorado, Institute of Behavioral Science, Monograph #21.
56.
MiletiDennis S., DarlingtonJoAnne DeRouen, PasseriniEve, ForrestBetsy C., and MyersMary Fran. 1995. “Toward an Integration of Natural Hazards and Sustainability.” The Environmental Professional17(2): 117–126.
57.
MillerJudith A., TurnerJoseph G., and KimballEdith. 1981. “Big Thompson Flood Victims: One Year Later.” Family Relations30(1): 111–116.
58.
MillicanPam. 1993. “Women in Disaster.” Symposium: Women in Emergencies and Disasters.Queensland Bureau of Emergency Services. Brisbane, Queensland.
59.
MiyanoMichio, JianLu Heng, and MochizukiToshio. 1991. “Human Casualty Due to the Nankai Earthquake Tsunami, 1946.” Pp. 707–715 in Proceedings of the IUGG/IOC International Tsunami Symposium.Tokyo, Japan.
60.
MooreHarry Estill, and FriedsamH. J.. 1959. “Reported Emotional Stress Following a Disaster.” Social Forces38: 135–139.
61.
MorrowBetty Hearn, and EnarsonElaine. 1994. “Making the Case for Gendered Disaster Research.” Paper presented to the XIIIth World Congress of Sociology. Bielefeld Germany: July 19th.
62.
NealDavid M., and PhillipsBrenda D.. 1990. “Female-Dominated Local Social Movement Organizations in Disaster-Threat Situations,” in Women and Social Protest, edited by WestG., BlumbergR. L.. New York: Oxford University Press.
63.
NealDavid M., PerryJoseph B.Jr., and HawkinsRandolph. 1982. “Getting Ready for Blizzards: Preparation Levels in the Winter of 1977–1978.” Sociological Focus15(1): 67–76.
64.
NehnevajsaJiri. 1989. Volunteering For Emergency Preparedness: Final Report.Washington, D.C.: Federal Emergency Management Agency.
65.
NielsenJoyce McCarl. 1984. “Sex and Gender in Disaster Research.” Unpublished Report. Boulder, Colorado: University of Colorado.
66.
NielsenJoyce McCarl. 1990. Sex and Gender in Society: Perspectives on Stratification.Prospect Heights, Illinois: Waveland Press, Inc.
67.
NiggJoanne M.1984. “Comments on Sex and Gender in Disaster Research.” Unpublished Response to Nielsen's 1984 Report.
68.
NiggJoanne M., and TierneyKathleen J.. 1990. “Explaining Differential Outcomes in the Small Business Disaster Loan Application Process.” Preliminary Paper #156. University of Delaware: Disaster Research Center.
69.
NoelGloria E.1990. “The Role of Women in Disaster Management.” Paper presented to the 17th Biennial Conference of the Caribbean Nurses’ Organization, Saint Lucia.
70.
O'BrienPaul, and MiletiDennis S.. 1992. “Citizen Participation in Emergency Response Following the Loma Prieta Earthquake.” Mass Emergencies and Disasters10(1): 71–89.
71.
OrrBernadette. 1994. “Preparing for Disaster by Organizing People.” Oxfam America News5: 7–11.
72.
PalinkasLawrence A., DownsMichael A., PettersonJohn S., and RusselJohn1993. “Social, Cultural, and Psychological Impacts of the Exxon Valdez Oil Spill.” Human Organization52(1): 1–13.
73.
ParasuramanS.1995. “The Impact of the 1993 Latur-Osmanabad (Maharashtra) Earthquake on Lives, Livelihoods and Property.” Disasters19(2): 156–169.
74.
PaulsenR. L.1981. Human Behavior and Fire Emergencies: An Annotated Bibliography.Washington, DC: National Bureau of Standards, U.S. Department of Commerce.
75.
PearceDiana. 1979. “Women, Work, and Welfare: The Feminization of Poverty.” Pp. 103–124 in Working Women and Families, edited by FeinsteinK. W.. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
76.
PerryJoseph B.Jr., HawkinsRandolph, and NealDavid M.. 1983. “Giving and Receiving Aid.” International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters1(March): 171–188.
77.
PerryRonald W., and LindellMichael K.. 1986. “Twentieth Century Volcanicity at Mt, St. Helens: The Routinization of Life Near an Active Volcano.” Arizona State University.
78.
PhiferJames F.1990. “Psychological Distress and Somatic Symptoms after Natural Disaster: Differential Vulnerability among Older Adults.” Psychology and Aging5(3): 412–420.
79.
PhillipsBrenda D.1990. “Gender as a Variable in Emergency Response.” The Loma Prieta Earthquake: Studies of Short-Term Impacts.Boulder, CO: Institute of Behavioral Science, The University of Colorado.
80.
PhillipsBrenda D.1993. “Cultural Diversity in Disasters: Sheltering, Housing, and Long-Term Recovery.” Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters, 11(1): 99–110.
81.
Queensland Bureau of Emergency Services.1993. Symposium: Women in Emergencies and Disasters.Brisbane, Queensland, Australia: Queensland Bureau of Emergency Services.
82.
RiversJ. P. W.1982. “Women and Children Last: An Essay on Sex Discrimination in Disasters.” Disasters6(4): 256–267.
83.
RussellGordon W., and MentzelRobert K.. 1990. “Sympathy and Altruism in Response to Disasters.” Journal of Social Psychology130(3): 309–316.
84.
SchmidlinThomas W.1993. “Tornado Fatalities in Ohio, 1950–1989.” Geophysical Monograph.79: 529–534.
85.
SchmidlinThomas W., and KingPaul S.. 1994. “Risk Factors for Death in the 27 March 1994 Georgia and Alabama Tornadoes.” Disasters19(2): 170–177.
86.
SchroederRichard A.1987. Gender Vulnerability to Drought: A Case Study of the Hausa Social Environment.Boulder: University of Colorado, Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center, Working Paper no. 58.
87.
ShannonMitsuko P., LoniganChristopher J., FinchA. J.Jr., and TaylorCharlotte M.. 1994. “Children Exposed to a Disaster: I. Epidemiology of Post-Traumatic Symptoms and Symptom Profiles.” Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry33(1): 80–93.
88.
SolomonS. D., SmithE. M., RobinsL. N., RischbachR. L.. 1987. “Social Involvement as a Mediator of Disaster-Induced Stress.” Journal of Applied Psychology17: 1092–1112.
89.
StaceyJudith, and ThomeBarrie. 1985. “The Missing Feminist Revolution in Sociology.” Social Problems32: 301–316.
90.
SzalayLorand B., InnAndres, VilovShelley K., and StrohlJean B.. 1986. “Regional and Demographic Variations in Public Perceptions Related to Emergency Preparedness.” Report for Federal Emergency Management Agency. Bethesda, Maryland: Institute of Comparative Social and Cultural Studies, Inc.
91.
TierneyKathleen J.1993. “Socio-Economic Aspects of Hazard Mitigation.” Preliminary Paper #190. University of Delaware: Disaster Research Center.
92.
ToppF. M., and SauveA. G.. 1988. Winds of Terror: Report on the Edmonton Tornado, 31 July 1987, Edmonton Police Department, Edmonton, Canada.
93.
TurnerRalph H., NiggJoanne M., and PazDenise Heller1986. Waiting for Disaster: Earthquake Watch in California.Berkeley: University of California Press.
94.
TurnerRalph H., NiggJoanne M., PazDenise H., and YoungBarbara S.. 1979. Earthquake Threat: The Human Response in Southern California.Los Angeles: Institute for Social Science Research, University of California, Los Angeles.
95.
TurnerRalph H., NiggJoanne M., PazDenise H., and YoungBarbara S.. 1981. Community Response to Earthquake Threat in Southern California, Part 10, Summary and Recommendations.Los Angeles: Institute for Social Science Research, University of California, Los Angeles.
96.
U.S. Bureau of the Census.1994. Statistical Abstract of the United States: 1994.114th ed.Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
97.
U.S. Department of Commerce, National Weather Service's Office of Meteorology.1995. “A Summary of Natural Hazard Fatalities for 1994 in the United States.” Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
98.
WallaceRuth. 1989. Feminism and Sociological Theory.Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
99.
WengerDennis E.1972. “DRC Studies of Community Functioning,” Proceedings of the Japan-United States Disaster Research Seminar: Organizational and Community Responses to Disasters. Columbus, Ohio: Disaster Research Center, The Ohio State University.
100.
WengerDennis E., and JamesThomas F.. 1994. “The Convergence of Volunteers in a Consensus Crisis: The Case of the 1985 Mexico City Earthquake.,” Pp. 229–243 in Disasters, Collective Behavior, and Social Organization, edited by DynesR. R., TierneyK. J.. Newark: University of Delaware Press.
101.
WiestRaymond E., MocellinJane S.P., and MotsisiDodo T.. 1992. The Needs of Women and Children in Disasters and Emergencies.Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada: University of Manitoba for the United Nations.
102.
WilkinsonKenneth P., and RossPerry J.. 1970. Citizens Response to Warnings of Hurricane Camille. Report no. 35. State College: Social Science Research Center, Mississippi State University.
103.
WilliamsJan. 1993. “Responding to Women in Emergencies and Disasters: The Role of Community Services Development.” Symposium: Women in Emergencies and Disasters.Queensland Bureau of Emergency Services. Brisbane, Queensland.
104.
World Resources Institute and The United Nations.1992. World Resources 1992–3.New York: Oxford University Press.
105.
ZimmermanRae. 1993. “Social Equity and Environmental Risk.” Journal of Risk Analysis13(6): 649–666.
