Nightly network news coverage of the accident at Three Mile Island raised questions about the nature of TV news as well as the capacity of the three major networks to inform viewers during disasters. A key emphasis in TV news is story-telling, especially the weaving of fables. Quantitative and qualitative analyses of the content of netework news coverage of TMI reveals differences between networks in techniques of newsgathering and reporting, but even more so in stories told: CBS narrated a tale of responsible political and technological elites, ABC a nightmare of common folk victimized by elites, and NBC a story of resignation and demystification. Coverage of TMI, when compared to network coverage of other crises, suggests that in reporting disasters CBS, ABC, and NBC respectively and consistently construct rhetorical visions of reassurance, threat, and primal assurance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsWilliam, and SchretbmanFay (eds.) 1978Televison network news: Issues in content research.Washington, D.C.: George Washington University.
2.
AltheideDavid1976Creating reality.Beverly Hills, California: Sage.
3.
AltheideDavid, and SnowRobert1979Media logic.Beverly Hills, California: Sage.
4.
BergDavid1972. “Rhetoric, reality and mass media.” Quarterly Journal of speech58(Aug.): 255–263.
5.
BernaysEdward1979. “Crisis communication failure: Three Mile Island.” Perspective1(June): 4–8.
6.
BormannErnest1972. “Fantasy and rhetorical vision: The rhetorical criticism of social reality.” Quarterly journal of speech58(Nov.): 396–407.
7.
BreenNyles, and CorcoranFarrell1982. “Myth in television discourse.” Communication monographs49(spring): 127–136.
8.
BurkeKenneth1966Language as social action.Berkeley, California: University of California Press.
9.
arntonRobert1975. “Writing news and telling stories.” Daedalus104(Sept.): 175–194.
10.
amondEdward1982Sign off.Cambridge, Massachusetts: The M.I.T. Press.
11.
psteinEdward J.1974News from nowhere.New York, N.Y.: Vintage Books.
12.
FarrellThomas B., and Thomas GoodnightG.1981. “Accidental rhetoric: The root metaphors of Three Mile Island.” Communication monographs48(Dec.): 271–300.
13.
FisherWalter1970. “A motive view of communication.” Quarterly journal of speech56(Feb.): 132–139.
14.
FisherWalter1980. “Rhetorical fiction and the presidency.” Quarterly journal of speech66(Apr.): 119–126.
15.
FrankRobert1973Message dimensions of television news.Lexington, Mass.: Lexington Books.
16.
FriedmanSharon1981. “Blueprint for breakdown: Three Mile Island and the media before the accident.” Journal of communication31(spring): 116–128.
17.
Hawkins“Robert, and PingreeSusan1981. “Using television to construct social reality.” Journal of broadcasting25(fall): 347–364.
18.
HerzogArthur1973The B.S. factor.New York: Simon and Schuster.
19.
HolstiOle1969. “Content analysis.” Pp. 596–692 in Gardner, Lindzey, and Eliott (eds.), The handbook of social psychology.Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley.
20.
IyengarS., PetersM., and KinderD.R.1982. “Experimental demonstrations of the ‘not so minimal’ consequences of television news programs.” American political science review76(Sept.): 848–858.
21.
KnightGraham, and DeanTony1982. “Myth and the structure of the news.” Journal of communication32(spring): 144–161.
22.
KrippendorfKlaus1980Content analysis.Beverly Hills, California: Sage.
23.
KukichDiane1982. “Natural disasters fact and fantacy.” Enquiry2(Winter): 7–11.
24.
LawrenceJohn S., and TimbergBernard1979. “News and mythic selectivity.” Journal of American culture2: 224–234.
MeadGeorge Herbert1934Mind, self, and society.Chicago, Ill.: University of Chicago Press.
28.
President's Commission on Three Mile Island1979a Report of the public's right to information task force.Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
29.
President's Commission on Three Mile Island1979b The need for change: The legacy of TMI.Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
30.
RubinDavid n.d. “What the President's Commission learned about the media.” Department of Journalism and Mass Communication (unpublished paper).
31.
SandmanPeter, and PadenMary1979. “At Three Mile Island.” Columbia Journalism review18(July/Aug.): 43–58.
32.
SchudsonMichael1982. “The politics of narrative form.” Daedalus3(fall): 97–112.
33.
SchulmanMark A.1979The impact of Three Mile Island.” Public opinion2 (June/July): 7–13.
34.
ScottWilliam A.1955. “Reliability of content analysis: The case of nominal scaling.” Public opinion quarterly19(fall): 321–325.
35.
SperrySharon1981. “Television news as narrative.” Pp. 295–312 in AdlerRobert P. (ed.), Understanding television.New York: Praeger.
36.
StephensMitchell, and EdisonNadyne G.1982. “News media coverage of issues during the accident at Three Mile Island.” Journalism quarterly59(summer): 199–204, 259.
37.
ThebergeLeonard J.1979Television evening news covers nuclear energy: A ten year perspective.Washington, D.C.: The Media Institute.
38.
ThrallWilliam F., HibbardAddison, and HolmanC. Hugh1960A handbook to literature.New York: Odyssey Press.
39.
TuchmanGaye1978Making news.New York: The Free Press.
40.
VogelAlfred1980. “Three Mile Island attitudes.” A response analysis update on energy (occasional newsletter).
41.
WengerDennis E.1980. “A few empirical observations concerning the relationship between the mass media and disaster knowledge: A research report.” Pp. 241–253 in Disasters and the mass media, Proceedings of the Committee on Disasters and the Mass Media workshop, National Research Council.Washington, D.C.: National Academy of Sciences.
42.
WestinAv1982. Newswatch.New York: Simon and Schuster.
