This research explores the ways in which safety and emotion were drivers of evacuation for people residing in high-density inner-city housing in the Central Business District of Te Whanganui-a-Tara (Wellington) following the 2016 Kaikωura earthquake. Drawing predominantly on qualitative free-response answers from a survey of 803 people approximately one year after the Kaikωura earthquake, the study argues that ontological insecurity was a key driver of people's actions. Key themes identified in relation to ontological insecurity and emotional responses were the severity of the shaking and how it was experienced, the building damage, official warnings, the ongoing earthquake aftershocks, and the social actions of others. This work argues that with the ongoing growth in high-density inner-city living, disaster risk and emergency management should encompass preparedness, response, and recovery strategies that include emotional responses and social processes while valuing the specificity of inner-city living.
AldrichDaniel P.2012. Building Resilience: Social Capital in Post-Disaster Recovery. Chicago IL: The University of Chicago Press.
2.
BairdAndrew and FernerHelen. 2017. “Damage to Non-Structural Elements in the 2016 Kaikoura Earthquake.” New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering Bulletin50(2):187–93.
3.
BanduraAlbert. 1977. Social Learning Theory. New York, NY: General Learning Press.
4.
BeckerJulia, BebanJames, SaundersWendy, Van DissenRussell, and KingAndrew. 2013. “Land Use Planning and Policy for Earthquakes in the Wellington Region, New Zealand (2001–2011).” Australasian Journal of Disaster and Trauma Studies 2013–1:3–17.
5.
BeckerJulia, PatonDouglas, JohnstonDavid, and RonanKevin. 2013. “Salient Beliefs about Earthquake Hazards and Household Preparedness.” Risk Anal33(9):1710–27.
6.
BeckerJulia, CoomerMaureen, BlakeDenise, GardenEmily, RamptonAngela, Newman-HallGrace, Van der VeldeMelanie, and JohnstonDavid. 2018. “Impact of the 2016 Kaikωura Earthquake on Wellington Cbd Apartment Residents: Results of a Survey.” GNS Science Report 2018/45. GNS Science, Lower Hutt, NZL. doi:10.21420/RH0PMM18.
7.
BlakeDenise, BeckerJulia S., HodgettsDarrin, and ElwoodKenneth J.. 2021. “The Impact of Earthquakes on Apartment Owners and Renters in Te Whanganui-a-Tara (Wellington) Aotearoa New Zealand.” Applied Sciences11(15): Art.6818. doi:10.3390/app11156818.
8.
BlakeDenise, MarloweJay, and JohnstonDavid. 2017. “Get Prepared: Discourse for the Privileged?” International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction25:283–8.
BourqueLinda, ReederLoe G., CherlinAndrew, RavenBertram H., and Michael WaltonD.. 1973. “The Unpredictable Disaster in a Metropolis: Public Response to the Los Angeles Earthquake of February, 1971.” Final Report submitted to Defense Civil Preparedness Agency, Accession # AD0765513, Defense Technical Information Center, Fort Belvoir, VA.
11.
BourqueLinda and RussellLisa. 1994. Experiences During and Responses to the Loma Prieta Earthquake. Sacramento, CA: Governor's Office of Emergency Services.
12.
BraunVirginia and ClarkeVictoria. 2006. “Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology.” Qualitative Research in Psychology3(2):77–101.
13.
BrunsdonDave, ElwoodKenneth J., and HenryRichard. 2017. “Wellington City Council Targeted Assessment Programme: Following the Kaikoura Earthquake of 14 November 2016.” Kestrel WCC TAP Technical Report 20170507, Kestrel Group Ltd., Wellington, NZL.
14.
Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission: Te Komihana Rūwhenua o Waitaha. 2012. “Volume 2 the Performance of Christchurch CBD Buildings.” Final Report, Canterbury Earthquake Royal Commission: Te Komihana Rūwhenua o Waitaha, Christchurch, NZL.
15.
ChangStephanie, PasionCathy, YavariSoheil, and ElwoodKenneth J.. 2009. “Social Impacts of Lifeline Losses: Modeling Displaced Populations and Health Care Functionality.” In proceedings of TCLEE 2009: Lifeline Earthquake Engineering in a Multihazard Environment, edited by TangA. and WernerS.. Reston, VA: ASCE. doi:10.1061/41050(357)54.
DemuthJulie L., MorssRebecca E., LazoJeffrey K., and TrumboCraig. 2016. “The Effects of Past Hurricane Experiences on Evacuation Intentions through Risk Perception and Efficacy Beliefs: A Mediation Analysis.” Weather, Climate, and Society8(4):327–44.
18.
DizhurDmytro, GiarettonMarta, and InghamJason. 2017. “Performance of Early Masonry, Cob, and Concrete Buildings in the 14 November 2016 Kaikoura Earthquake.” New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering Bulletin50(2):194–205.
19.
DorahyMartin J., RenoufCharlotte, RowlandsAmy, HannaDonncha, BrittEileen, and CarterJanet D.. 2016. “Earthquake Aftershock Anxiety: An Examination of Psychosocial Contributing Factors and Symptomatic Outcomes.” Journal of Loss and Trauma21(3):246–58.
20.
DoyleEmma E., JohnstonDavid M., SmithRichard, and PatonDouglas. 2019. “Communicating Model Uncertainty for Natural Hazards: A Qualitative Systematic Thematic Review.” International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction33:449–76.
21.
DrabekThomas E.1969. “Social Processes in Disaster: Family Evacuation.” Social Problems16(3):336–49.
22.
DrabekThomas E.2001. “Disaster Warning and Evacuation Responses by Private Business Employees.” Disasters25(1):76–94.
23.
DupuisAnn and ThornsDavid C.. 1998. “Home, Home Ownership and the Search for Ontological Security.” The Sociological Review46(1):24–47.
24.
FishbeinMartin and AjzenIcek. 1975. Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
25.
FraserStuart A.2014. “Informing the Development of Tsunami Vertical Evacuation Strategies in New Zealand.” Ph.D. dissertation, Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Emergency Management, Massey University, Palmerston North, NZL.
FraserStuart A., LeonardGraham S., MurakamiHitomi, and MatsuoIchiro. 2012. “Tsunami Vertical Evacuation Buildings – Lessons for International Preparedness Following the 2011 Great East Japan Tsunami.” Journal of Disaster Research7(sp):446–57.
GiddensAnthony. 1991. Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age. Standford, CA: Stanford University Press.
30.
GoltzJames D, ParkHyejeong, NakanoGenta, and YamoriKatsuya. 2020. “Earthquake Ground Motion and Human Behavior: Using Dyfi Data to Assess Behavioral Response to Earthquakes.” Earthquake Spectra36(3):1231–53.
31.
GoltzJames D, ParkHyejeong, QuitorianoVincent, and WaldDavid J. 2020. “Human Behavioral Response in the 2019 Ridgecrest, California, Earthquakes: Assessing Immediate Actions Based on Data from “Did You Feel It?”.” Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America110(4):1589–602.
32.
Grab & Go: Be prepared. 2019. “Your Personal Kit in an Emergency.” Retrieved Feburary 5, 2019 (https://grabandgo-kits.com/).
33.
GustafssonKarl and Krickel-ChoiNina C.. 2020. “Returning to the Roots of Ontological Security: Insights from the Existentialist Anxiety Literature.” European Journal of International Relations26(3):875–95.
34.
HaneyTimothy J. and Gray-ScholzDaran. 2020. “Flooding and the ‘New Normal’: What Is the Role of Gender in Experiences of Post-Disaster Ontological Security?” Disasters44(2):262–84.
35.
HarriesTim. 2008. “Feeling Secure or Being Secure? Why It Can Seem Better Not to Protect Yourself against a Natural Hazard.” Health, Risk & Society10(5):479–90.
36.
HawkinsRobert L. and MaurerKatherine. 2011. ““You Fix My Community, You Have Fixed My Life”: The Disruption and Rebuilding of Ontological Security in New Orleans.” Disasters35(1):143–59.
37.
HenryRichard S., DizhurDmytro, ElwoodKenneth J., HareJohn, and BrunsdonDave. 2017. “Damage to Concrete Buildings with Pre-Case Floors during the 2016 Kaikωura Earthquake.” New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering Bulletin50(2):174–86.
38.
HommerichCarola. 2012. “Trust and Subjective Well-Being after the Great East Japan Earthquake, Tsunami and Nuclear Meltdown: Preliminary Results.” International Journal of Japanese Sociology21(1):46–64.
39.
HorneyJennifer, SniderCynthia, MaloneSandra, GammonsLaura, and RamseySteve. 2008. “Factors Associated with Hurricane Preparedness: Results of a Pre-Hurricane Assessment.” Journal of Disaster Research3(2):143–9.
40.
HorspoolNick, CousinsWalter J., and PowerWilliam L.. 2015. “Review of Tsunami Risk Facing New Zealand: A 2015 Update.” GNS Science Consultancy Report 2015/38. GNS Science, Lower Hutt, NZL.
41.
HuangShih-Kai, LindellMichael K., and PraterCarla S.. 2016. “Who Leaves and Who Stays? A Review and Statistical Meta-Analysis of Hurricane Evacuation Studies.” Environment and Behavior48(8):991–1029.
42.
InnesAlexandria J. and SteeleBrent J.. 2013. “Memory, Trauma and Ontological Security.” Pp. 15–30 in Memory and Trauma in International Relations: Theories, Cases and Debates, edited by ResendeE. and BudryteD.. London, GBR: Taylor & Francis Ltd.
43.
KoshibaYusuke and SuzukiYuji. 2018. “Factors Affecting Post-Evaucation Behaviors Following an Earthquake: A Questionnarie-Based Survey.” International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction31:548–54.
44.
LindellMichael K. and PerryRonald W.. 2012. “The Protective Action Decision Model: Theoretical Modifications and Additional Evidence.” Risk Analysis32(4):616–32.
45.
LindellMichael K., PraterCarla S., WuHao-Che, HuangShih-Kai, JohnstonDavid M., BeckerJulia S., and ShiroshitaH.. 2015. “Immediate Behavioural Responses to Earthquakes in Christchurch, New Zealand, and Hitachi, Japan.” Disasters40(1):85–111.
46.
McClureJohn, AllenMichael W., and WalkeyFrank. 2001. “Countering Fatalism: Causal Information in News Reports Affects Judgments about Earthquake Damage.” Basic and Applied Social Psychology23(2):109–21.
47.
McIvorDavid, PatonDouglas, and JohnstonDavid M.. 2009. “Modelling Community Preparation for Natural Hazards: Understanding Hazard Cognitions.” Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology3(2):39–46.
48.
McKeeMartin. 2017. “Grenfell Tower Fire: Why We Cannot Ignore the Political Determinants of Health. A Public Health Response Must Confront the Underlying Causes.” British Medical Journal357:j2966. doi: 10.1136/bmj.j2966.
49.
MiletiDennis S. and SorensenJohn H.. 1990. Communication of Emergency Public Warnings: A Social Science Perspective and State of-the-Art Assessment. Oakridge, TN: Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
MorrisonPhilip S. and McMurrayScott. 1999. “The Inner-City Apartment versus the Suburb: Housing Sub-Markets in a New Zealand City.” Urban Studies36(2):377–97.
52.
MurtiMichelle, BayleyegnTesfaye M., StanburyMartha, FlandersWilliam Dana, YardEllen, NyakuMawuli, and WolkinAmy F.. 2014. “Household Emergency Preparedness by Housing Type from a Community Assessment for Public Health Emergency Response (Casper), Michigan.” Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness8(1):12–19.
53.
NakayachiKazuya, BeckerJulia S., PotterSally H., and DixonMaximilian. 2019. “Residents' Reactions to Earthquake Early Warnings in Japan.” Risk Analysis39(8):1723–40.
NoyesMark. 2019, “Personal Communication, Neighbourhood Resilience Advisor at Wellington City Council Wellington, Aotearoa Zealand: Data Based on Statistics New Zealand, 2013”.
58.
OlsonRichard Stuart. 2000. “Toward a Politics of Disaster: Losses, Values, Agendas, and Blame.” International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters18(2):265–87.
59.
OlympiaRobert P., RiveraRuby, HeverleySteven, AnyanwuUchechi, and GregoritsMadeline. 2010. “Natural Disasters and Mass-Casualty Events Affecting Children and Families: A Description of Emergency Preparedness and the Role of the Primary Care Physician.” Clinical Pediatrics49(7):686–98.
60.
PadgettDeborah K.2007. “There's No Place Like (a) Home: Ontological Security among Persons with Serious Mental Illness in the United States.” Social Science and Medicine64(9):1925–36.
61.
PaolaSbarra, FodarellaAntonio, TosiPatrizia, De RubeisValerio, and RovelliAntonio. 2015. “Difference in Shaking Intensity between Short and Tall Buildings: Known and New Findings.” Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America105(3):1803–9.
62.
PerryRonald W.1983. “Population Evacuation in Volcanic Eruptions, Floods, and Nuclear Power Plant Accidents: Some Elementary Comparisons.” Journal of Communily Psychology11(1):36–47.
63.
PowerWilliam, ClarkKate, KingDarren N., BorreroJose, HowarthJamie, LaneEmily M., GoringDerek, GoffJames, Chagué-GoffCatherine, WilliamsJames, ReidCatherine, WhittakerColin, MuellerChristof, WilliamsShaun, HughesMatthew W., HoyleJo, BindJochen, StrongDelia, LitchfieldNicola, and BensonAdrian. 2017. “Tsunami Runup and Tide-Gauge Observations from the 14 November 2016 M7.8 Kaikωura Earthquake, New Zealand.” Pure and Applied Geophysics174(7):2457–73.
64.
PratiGabriele, CatufiValeria, and PietrantoniLuca. 2012. “Emotional and Behavioural Reactions to Tremors of the Umbria-Marche Earthquake.” Disasters36(3):439–51.
65.
RogersRonald W.1975. “A Protection Motivation Theory of Fear Appeals and Attitude Change1.” Journal of Psychology91(1):93–114.
66.
RogersRonald W.1983. “Cognitive and Physiological Processes in Fear Appeals and Attitude Change: A Revised Theory of Protection Motivation.” Pp. 153–77 in Social Psychophysiology: A Sourcebook, edited by CacioppoJ. T. and PettyR. E.. New York, NY: Guilford Press.
67.
Santos-ReyesJaime and GouzevaTatiana. 2020. “Mexico City's Residents Emotional and Behavioural Reactions to the 19 September 2017 Earthquake.” Environmental Research186:109482. doi:10.1016/j.envres.2020.109482.
68.
ScheeleFinn R. and HorspoolNicholas A.. 2017. “Modelling Fire Following Earthquake in Wellington: A Review of Globally Available Methodologies.” GNS Science report 2017/42. GNS Science, Lower Hutt, NZL. doi: 10.21420/G27S&V.
69.
SchoutenHank. 2011. “Council Gets Tough on Earthquake Risk: Wellington Buildings Put on Notice Red Stickers or Final Notices.” Dominion Post, June 23, pp. A1.
70.
ShapiraStav, Aharonson-DanielaLimor, and Bar-DayanaYaron. 2018. “Anticipated Behavioral Response Patterns to an Earthquake: The Role of Personal and Household Characteristics, Risk Perception, Previous Experience and Preparedness.” International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction31:1–8.
71.
ShawMary. 2004. “Housing and Public Health.” Annual Review of Public Health25:397–418.
72.
SorensenJohn H. and MiletiDennis S.. 1988. “Warning and Evacuation: Answering Some Basic Questions.” Organization and Environment2(3–4):195–209.
73.
SowashAlexandra and HastingsAntoinette. 2015. “Survey of Central City Dwellers: Final Report.” Final report submitted to Wellington City Council, Wellington, NZL. Nielsen, New York, NY.
StirlingMark W., LitchfieldNicola J., VillamorPilar, Van DissenRuss J., NicolAndy, PettingaJarg, BarnesPhilip, LangridgeRobert M., LittleTim, BarrellDavid, MountjoyJoshu, RiesWilliam F., RowlandJulie V., FentonClark, HamlingIan, AsherCameron, BarrierAndrea, BensonAdrian, BischoffAlan, BorellaJosh, CarneRachel, CochranUrsula, CockcroftMatt, CoxSimon, DukeGrace, FentonF., GasstonCaleb, GrimshawChris, HaleD., HallBrendan S., HaoKen X., HatemAlex, Hemphill-HaleyMark, HeronDavid, HowarthJamie, JuniperZoe, KaneTim, KearseJesse, KhajaviNarges, LamarcheGeoffroy, LawsonSteve, LukovicBiljana, MadugoChristopher, ManousakisJohn, McCollSam, NobleDuncan, PedleyKate, SauerKatrina, StahlT., StrongDelia, TownsendDougal, ToyVirginia, VilleneuveMarlene, WandresAnekant, WilliamsJack, WoelzSusanne, ZinkeRobert. 2017. “The Mw7.8 2016 Kaikωura Earthquake: Surface Fault Rupture and Seismic Hazard Context.” Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering50(2):73–84.
76.
ThompsonRebecca R., GarfinDana Rose, and SilverRoxane Cohen. 2017. “Evacuation from Natural Disasters: A Systematic Review of the Literature.” Risk Analysis37(4):812–39.
77.
TurnerJonathan H.2009. “The Sociology of Emotions: Basic Theoretical Arguments.” Emotion Review1(4):340–54.
78.
United Nations.2017, “Sustainable Development Knowledge Platform: Sustainable Development Goals”. Retrieved August 7, 2017 (https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/sdgs).
79.
United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR).2017. Public Communication for Disaster Risk Reduction.Geneva, CHE: UNDRR.
Wellington Lifelines Group.2002. Fire Following Earthquake: Identifying Key Issues for New Zealand.Wellington, NZL: New Zealand Fire Service Commission Research.
WilligCarla. 2013. Introducing Qualitative Research in Psychology 3rd Edition. New York, NY: Open University Press.
84.
WoodMichelle M., MiletiDennis S., BeanHamilton, LiuBrooke F., SuttonJeannette, and MaddenStephanie. 2017. “Milling and Public Warnings.” Environment and Behavior50(5):535–66.
WrightKim and JohnstonDavid M.. 2010. “Post-Earthquake Sheltering Needs; How Loss of Structures and Services Affects Decision Making for Evacuation.” Pp. 21–3 in Proceedings of the 2010 New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering Conference (NZSEE). Wellington, NZL: NZSEE.
87.
ZaretskyEli. 2002. “Trauma and Dereification: September 11 and the Problem of Ontological Security.” Constellations9(11):98–105.
