Phenomenology of Death Counts in Disasters: The Invisible Dead in the 9/11 WTC Attack

Abstract

This essay uses information from Latino immigrants who were victims in the World Trade Center (WTC) terrorist attack of September 11, 2001 and are not included in the official list of the dead from this attack to illustrate the operation of counting as a central, theoretical issue in the construction of disaster statistics. A phenomenological approach would complement current emphases on the operation of organizations, their lack of coordination, and fraud as explanations for the lack of validity of disaster mortality statistics. The paper examines the social categories and understandings that were used to create the official New York City list of the dead, the link of the official list with receipt of money from charities, and the work of Asociación Tepeyac de New York (Tepeyac) in developing an unofficial list of Latino victims. Results show that the Mexican mass media exaggerated the number of Mexican dead by a ratio of 15 to 1. Contrary to mass media reports, Tepeyac also assisted people who were included in the official count of the dead and who were not Mexicans. The Tepeyac list is overwhelmingly a list of male names, but neither gender has a greater proportion of exclusion from the official NYC list. Exclusion from the official NYC list occurs more often to Mexican men recently arrived in the country and earning a living in the underground economy of Lower Manhattan if compared to Dominicans and Puerto Rican victims. We conclude that structural factors such as the operation of bureaucracies and systemic discrimination are not the sole causes of the social invisibility of some of these Latino victims. Nor is it solely the effect of the categories used to organize the count of the dead. It is also a function of the social behavior of Latino immigrants and of their surviving kin during the course of their immigration and incorporation into the US. The paper concludes with some suggestions to improve statistics on disaster deaths.

Keywords

Disaster death counts World Trade Center ethnic minorities phenomenology

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aguirre

B.E.

, Wenger

, Glass

T.A.

, Diaz-Murillo

, and Vigo

. 1995. “The Social Organization of Search and Rescue: Evidence from the Guadalajara Gasoline Explosion.” International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters 13(1): 67–92. Available at www.ijmed.org.

Albala-Bertrand

I.M.

(1993), The Political Economy of Large Natural Disasters, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Arreola

J. J.

2001. “Confirman desaparición de queretano; laboraba en WTC.” El Universal. Miercoles 26 de Septiembre (www.eluniversal.com.mx).

Articles. No date. http://www.tepeyac.org/notasprensa.htm. Accessed 27 September 2005.

Best

2001. Damned Lies and Statistics: Untangling Numbers from the Media, Politicians, and Activists. Berkeley CA: University of California Press.

Board on Natural Disasters. 1999a. “Mitigation emerges as major strategy for reducing losses caused by natural disasters.” Science, 234(13): 1043–1953.

Board on Natural Disasters. 1999b. Reducing Disaster Losses Through Better Information. Washington, DC: National Academy Press, National Research Council, Commission on Geosciences, Environment, and Resources.

Boodran

, Torian

, Thomas

, Wilt

, Pollock

, Bell

, Budnitz

. 2002. “Rapid Assessment of Injuries Among Survivors of the Terrorist Attack on the World Trade Center - New York City, September 2001.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 51, no. 01: 1–5 (Available at http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5101a1.htm).

Borakove

2001. Expediting Death Certificates for Families Who Request Them. NYC Department of Health, Office of Public Affairs (available at http://www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/public/press01/pr86-925.html).

10.

Burke

1994. “Turtle Grove: Dartmouth's Lost Mi'kmaq Community.” Pp. 45–53 in Ruffman

Alan

, and Howell

Colin D.

Ground Zero. A Reassessment of the 1917 Explosion in Halifax Harbour. Halifax, NS: Nimbus Publishing Limited.

11.

Canada Commission of Inquiry. 2007. Submission to the Commission of Inquiry Into the Investigation of the Bombing of Air India Flight 182. Ottawa, Ontario, Canadian Resource Centre for Victims of Crime http://www.crcvc.ca/docs/AirIndiaInquirysubmission_jan2007.pdf. Accessed March 12, 2008.

12.

Cardwell

2001. “The Toll: City Refines Its Counting of the Dead.” New York Times, November 25.

13.

Center for Disease Control. 1986. “Hurricanes and Hospital Emergency Room Visits. Mississippi, Rhode Island, Connecticut.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 3(51, 52): 765–770.

14.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2002. “Injuries and Illnesses Among New York City Fire Department Rescue Workers After Responding to the World Trade Center Attacks.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 51: 1–5.

15.

Cochrane

, and Howe

. 1993. Guidelines for the Uniform Definition, Identification, and Measurement of Damages from Natural Hazard Events. Boulder, CO: Institute of Behavioral Science, University of Colorado.

16.

Commission on Emergency Medical Services. 1966. Accidental Death and Disability: The Neglected Disease of Modern Society. Washington, DC: Division of Medical Sciences, National Academy of Sciences.

17.

Committee for Assessing the Costs of Natural Disasters. 1999. The Impacts of Natural Disasters. Washington, DC: Board on Natural Disasters, Commission on Geosciences, Environment, and Resources.

18.

DOH. www.rvminc.com. Accessed 22 February 2006

19.

Doocy

, Gorokhovich

, Burnham

, Balk

, Robinson

. 2007. “Tsunami Mortality Estimates and Vulnerability Mapping in Aceh, Indonesia.” American Journal of Public Health, 97, April, No. Supplement 1, S146–S151.

20.

Drabek

1968. Disaster in Aisle 13. Columbus, OH: College of Administrative Science Monograph Disaster Research Center Series.

21.

Federal Emergency Management Agency.

1997. Report on Costs and Benefits of Natural Hazard Mitigation, Washington, DC.

22.

Feinberg

K. R.

2005. What is Life Worth? The Unprecedented Effort to Compensate The Victims of 9/11. New York: Public Affairs.

23.

Funding. No date. www.NYPAS@newyork.bbb.org. Accessed 9 July 2005.

24.

Fuchs

R.J.

, Brennan

, Chamie

, Lo

F.C.

, Uitto

J.I.

. 1994. Mega City Growth and the Future. New York: United Nations University Press.

25.

Galindo

I. J.

2001. “Aumenta a catorce el numero de poblanos desaparecidos por los atentados en Nueva York.” La Jornada de Oriente, Miércoles 17 de Octubre (www.jornada.unam.mx).

26.

Galveston. No date. (www.gthcenter.org). Accessed 4 March 2005.

27.

Garcia

F. A.

2001. “Confirma la Asociacion Tepeyac solo dos mexicanos muertos y 21 desaparecidos.” La Jornada de Oriente, Viernes 14 de Septiembre (www.jornada.unam.mx).

28.

Gilbert

, and Kreimer

(1999), Learning From the World Bank's Experience of Natural Disaster Related Assistance, The World Bank, Washington DC.

29.

Giuliani. http://www.ci.nyc.ny.us/html/doh/html/public/press02/pr19-418.html. Accessed 7 March 2006.

30.

Glickman

, Golding

, and Silverman

(1992), Acts of God and Acts of Man: Recent Trends in Natural Disasters and Major Industrial Accidents, Resources for the Future, Washington DC.

31.

Gordon

P. D.

1982. Special Statistical Summary: Deaths, Injuries and Property Loss by Type of Disaster, 1970–1980. Washington DC: Federal Emergency Management Agency.

32.

Greene

C. E.

2005. Personal communication, February 12. Mr. Greene is the head of special collection of the Rosenberg Library in Galveston and the co-editor of the book Night of Horrors: Voices from the 1900 Galveston Storm, College Station TX: Texas A&M University Press, 2000 in which much of the evidence is presented.

33.

Hansen

, and Condon

(1989), Denial of Disaster: The Untold Story and Unpublished Photographs of the San Francisco Earthquake of 1906. San Francisco, CA: Cameron and Company.

34.

Henriques

D.B.

, and Barstow

. 2001. “Victims’ Funds May Violate U.S. Tax Law.” New York Times, November 12.

35.

Ingleton

(Ed.) (1999), Natural Disaster Management: A Presentation to Commemorate the International Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction (IDNDR) 1990–2000, Tudor Rose, Leicester.

36.

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies.

2000. World Disasters Report, Geneva.

37.

Kitsuse

J.I.

, and Cicourel

A. C.

. 1963. “A Note on the Uses of Official Statistics”, Social Problems 11: 131–39

38.

Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service. 2001. “Heartbroken families to receive $1 million in government benefits.” Daily News, December 6.

39.

Legome

, Robins

, Douglas

. 1995. “Injuries Associated With Floods: The Need for an International Reporting Scheme.” Disasters, 19(1): 50–54.

40.

Memorial. No date. www.cnn.com/specials/2001/memorial/people. Accessed 9 July 2006.

41.

Mileti

1999. Disaster by Design: A Reassessment of Natural Hazards in the United States, Joseph Henry Press, Washington DC.

42.

Miller

, and Iritani

. 2001. “Hundreds of Foreigners are Among Tower Victims.” New York Times, September 14.

43.

Munich

Re.

1982. Loss Adjustment After Natural Disasters, Munich Re, Munich.

44.

Mykle

2002. Killer ‘Cane. New York: Cooper Square Press.

45.

Natanson

1970. Phenomenology and Social Reality. Essays in Memory of Alfred Schutz. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.

46.

NIST. No date. http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/releases/wtc_victims_location.htm. Accessed 23 June 2006.

47.

NYC. No date. http://www.ci.nyc.ny.us/html/doh/html/public/press02/pr19-418.html. Accessed 25 June 2006.

48.

Noji

E. K.

1993. “Analysis of Medical Needs During Disasters Caused by Tropical Cyclones: Anticipated Injury Patterns.” Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 96: 1–7.

49.

Olson

, Baird

A.B.

, Estrada

, Gawronski

, Prieto

. (1999), Disaster and Institutional Response: Hurricane Georges in the Dominican Republic and Hurricane Mitch in Honduras and Nicaragua, September-October 1998, Robert Olson Associates, Folsom CA.

50.

Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD). Annex 3, Disaster Statistics. (available at www.oecd.org/dataoecd/37/7/1887740.pdf).

51.

Pollander

, and Rand

1989. “Analysis of Medical Needs in Disasters Caused by Earthquakes: The Need for a Uniform Injury Reporting System”, Disasters 13: 365–369.

52.

Quarantelli

E. L.

2001. “Statistical and Conceptual Problems in the Study of Disasters.” Disaster Prevention and Management, vol. 10(5): 325–338.

53.

Rosenthal

(1994). Complexity in Urban Crisis Management Amsterdam's Response to the Bijlmer Air Disaster. London: James and James (Science Publishers) Ltd.

54.

Rubin

C.B.

, Yezer

A. M.

, Hussain

, Webb

. 1986. Summary of Major Natural Disaster Incidents in the U.S. 1965–85. Washington, DC: The George Washington University, Graduate Program in Science, Technology and Public Policy.

55.

San Filippo

September 15, 1991. Death & Dying from an Observational, Phenomenological, & Hermeneutic Perspective. www.lutz-sanfilippo.com/library/counseling/lsfd&dperspectives.html. Accessed November 28, 2007.

56.

Sapir

D. G.

1993. “Health Effects of Earthquakes and Volcanoes: Epidemiological and Policy Issues.” Disasters 17(5): 255–262.

57.

Sapir

, and Misson

. 1992. “The Development of a Database on Disasters.” Disasters 16(1): 74–80.

58.

Scanlon

, McMahon

, and van Haastert

. 2007. “Handling Mass Death by Integrating the Management of Disasters and Pandemics: Lessons from the Indian Ocean Tsunami, the Spanish Flu and Other Incidents.” Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 15(2): 80–94.

59.

Schutz

1970. On Phenomenology and Social Relations. Edited and with an introduction by Helmut R. Wagner. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press.

60.

Schutz

1973. Collected Papers. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.

61.

Tepeyac1. No date. www.tepeyac.org/list.htm. Accessed 4 November 2005.

62.

Tepeyac2. No date. www.tepeyac.org/comunicado1010.htm. Accessed 6 December 2005.

63.

Tubbesing

S.K.

Editor. 1979. Natural Hazards Data Sources: Uses and Needs. Boulder, CO: University of Colorado, Institute of Behavioral Science.

64.

U.S. National Committee for the Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction. 1991. Reducing the Impact of Natural Disasters. Washington, DC: National Academy Press, National Research Council, Commission on Geosciences, Environment, and Resources.

65.

Wilson

T. D.

Alfred Schutz, Phenomenology and Research Methodology for Information Behaviour Research. Professor Emeritus, University of Sheffield, United Kingdom, http://informationr.net/tdw/publ/papers/schutz02.html. Accessed March 12, 2008.