Call-to-action statements in tornado warnings are content analyzed to determine to what extent their wording has been influenced by recent research calling into question official safety guidelines and traditional advice regarding vehicles and mobile homes. While the statements do not directly contradict official guidelines and advice, there is significant variation among NWS offices regarding what advice is given and what guidelines are emphasized in call-to-action statements in tornado warnings. Some of this variation is regional, and interviews with NWS meteorologists reveal a frequent opinion that what is best to do if in a vehicle during a tornado warning may vary by region, time of day, and terrain. The interviews also reveal widespread awareness among NWS meteorologists of debates over tornado safety in vehicles and mobile homes, and strong support for local office autonomy in decisions about the wording of call-to-action statements.
AguirreBenjamin E.2000. “Social Science and Severe Weather Warnings.” Pp. 98–108 in Storms Volume I.London, UK: Routledge.
2.
American Meteorological Society. 2000. Policy Statement: Tornado Preparedness and Safety, adopted by the AMS Council 28 February, 2000. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society81, 5 (May): 1061–1065.
3.
BurbyR.J., and WagnerF.. 1996. “Protecting Tourists from Death and Injury in Coastal Storms.” Disasters20(1): 49–60.
4.
CarterA. O., MillsonM. E., AllenD. E., 1989. “Epidemiologic Study of Deaths and Injuries due to Tornadoes.” American Journal of Epidemiology130: 1209–1218.
5.
ChristensenLarry, and RuchCarlton E.. 1980. “The Effect of Social Influence on Response to Hurricane Warnings.” Disasters4(2): 205–210.
6.
DaleyW. Randolph, BrownSheryll, ArcherPam, KrugerElizabeth, JordanFred, BattsDahna, and BalloneeSue. 2005. “Risk of Tornado-related Death and Injury in Oklahoma, May 3, 1999. American Journal of Epidemiology161: 1144–1150.
7.
DiGiovanniClete, ReynoldsBarbara, HarwellRobert, and StonecipherElliot B.. 2002. “A Prospective Study of the Reactions of Residents of an American Community to a Bioterrorist Attack.” Bethesda, MD: Defense Threat Reduction Agency.
8.
DrabekThomas E.1994a. “Disaster Evacuation and the Tourist Industry.” Boulder, CO: Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center, Institute of Behavioral Science, University of Colorado.
9.
DuClosP. J., and IngR. T.. 1989. “Injuries and Risk Factors for Injuries from the 29 May 1982 Tornado, Marion, Illinois.” International Journal of Epidemiology18: 213–219.
FarleyJohn E.1998. Earthquake Fears, Predictions, and Preparations in Mid-America.Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
12.
FineGary Alan. 2006. “Shopfloor Cultures: The Idioculture of Production in Operational Meteorology.” Sociological Quarterly47: 1–19.
13.
GoldenJoseph. 2002. “Comments on ‘Unsafe at Any (Wind) Speed? Testing the Stability of Motor Vehicles in Severe Winds.”’ Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society83: 1831–1833.
14.
GoldenJoseph H., and AdamsChristopher R.. 2000. “The Tornado Problem: Forecast, Warning, and Response.” National Hazards Review1(2): 107–118.
15.
GoldhammerRobert G.2002. “Comments on ‘Unsafe at Any (Wind) Speed? Testing the Stability of Motor Vehicles in Severe Winds.”’ Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society83: 1835–1837.
16.
HammerBarbara, and SchmidlinThomas W.. 2002. “Response to Warnings During the 3 May 1999 Oklahoma City Tornado: Reasons and Relative Injury Rates.” Weather and Forecasting17: 577–581.
17.
LopesRocky. 1997. “The Alternate Dilemma: How to Explain and Encourage Counterintuitive Behavior.” Natural Hazards Observer22: 3–4.
18.
MikamiShunji, and IkedaKen'ichi. 1985. “Human Response to Disasters.” International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters3(1): 107–132.
19.
MiletiDennis S.1997. The Role of Searching in Shaping Reactions to Earthquake Risk Information. Social Problems44: 89–103.
20.
MiletiDennis S., and DarlingtonJoanne DeRouen. 1997. “The Role of Searching in Shaping Reactions to Earthquake Risk Information.” Social Problems44: 89–103.
21.
MiletiDennis S., DarlingtonJoAnne D., FitzpatrickColleen, and O'BrienPaul W.. 1993. Communicating Earthquake Risk: Societal Response to the Revised Probabilities in the Bay Area.Fort Collins: Colorado State University, Hazards Assessment Laboratory and Department of Sociology.
22.
MiletiDennis S., and FitzpatrickColleen. 1993. The Great Earthquake Experiment: Risk Communication and Public Action.Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
23.
National Climatic Data Center.2000. Storm Data and Unusual Weather Phenomena. May, 1999. Vol. 41, No. 5. Asheville, NC: National Climatic Data Center. Available for download at http://www7.hcdc.noaa.gov/SerialPublications/SDPubs?action=createPDF (downloaded October 27, 2005).
24.
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. (No date). “Frequently Asked Questions About Tornadoes.” NOAA Outlook. World Wide Web, http://www.outlook.noaa.gov/tornadoes/q%26a.htm (downloaded January 20, 2006).
25.
National Weather Service.1999. “Thunderstorms, Tornadoes, Lightning: Natures Most Violent Storms, A Preparedness Guide.” World Wide Web, http://www.nws.noaa.gov/om/brochures/ttl.pdf (downloaded January 20, 2006).
NiggJoanne M.1987. “Communication and Behavior: Organizational and Individual Response to Warnings.” Pp. 103–117 in Sociology of Disasters, edited by DynesR. R., DeMarchiB., PelandaC.. Milan, Italy: Franco Angeli Libri.
28.
PerryRonald W., LindellMichael K., and GreeneMarjorie R.. 1980. “The Implications of Natural Hazard Evacuation Warning Studies for Crisis Relocation Planning.” Seattle, WA: Battelle Human Affairs Research Center.
29.
PfisterNeil. 2002. “Community Response to Flood Warnings: The Case of an Evacuation from Grafton, March 2001.” Australian Journal of Emergency Management17: 19–29.
30.
RogersGeorge O.1985. “Some Policy Implications of Human Components of Emergency Warning.” Pittsburgh, PA: Center for Social and Urban Research, University of Pittsburgh.
31.
RogersGeorge O., and SorensenJohn H.. 1989. “Warning and Response in Two Hazardous Materials Transportation Accidents in the U.S.” Journal of Hazardous Materials22: 57–74.
32.
SchmidlinThomas. 1997. “Closet, Car, or Ditch? The Mobile Home Dilemma During a Tornado.” Natural Hazards Observer22: 1–3.
33.
SchmidlinThomas, HammerBarbara, KingPaul, OnoYuichi, MillerL. Scott, and ThumannGregory. 2002. “Unsafe at Any (Wind) Speed? Testing the Stability of Motor Vehicles in Severe Winds.” Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society83: 1821–1830.
ThompsonRichard L., and VescioMichael D.. 1998. “The Destruction Potential Index: A Method for Comparing Tornado Days.” Paper presented at 19th Conference on Severe Local Storms, Minneapolis. Also available on Storm Prediction Center Web page, http://www.spc.noaa.gov/publications/thompson/dpi/dpi.htm (downloaded January 20, 2006).
36.
TurnerRalph H., NiggJoanne M., and PazDenise Heller. 1986. Waiting for Disaster: Earthquake Watch in Southern California.Berkeley: University of California Press.
