This study develops and tests a model of the influences on citizens' support for more open markets. The flow of influence in the model features eight antecedent constructs whose proposed explanatory power is based on three themes: citizens' economic concerns, group identification, and cognitive involvement in the issues. The model was tested by subjecting survey data from 240 respondents to structural equation analysis. The results support the three conceptual themes used to generate a pattern of proposed influences on the endorsement of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) (and the antecedent endogenous constructs in the model). Support for NAFTA increases with citizens' level of knowledge and assessed importance of NAFTA; support decreases with perceived U.S. economic vulnerability, call for job protection, conservatism, xenophobia, and believability of Perot.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aaronson, Susan . 1993. Selling Nafta—Close to home. Journal of Commerce and Commercial398 (October 26): 8A.
2.
Abramowitz, Alan I.1995. It's abortion, stupid: Policy voting in the 1992 presidential election. Journal of Politics57 (February): 176-186.
3.
Aldrich, John H. , and R. M. Alvarez. 1994. Issues and the presidential primary voter. Political Behavior16 (September): 289-317.
4.
Alvarez, R. M. , and Jonathan Nagler. 1995. Economics, issues and the Perot candidacy: Voter choice in the 1992 presidential election. American Journal of Political Science39 (August): 714-744.
5.
Bagozzi, Richard P. , and Youjae Yi. 1988. On the evaluation of structural equations models. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science16 (Spring): 74-94.
6.
Bartels, Larry M.1991. Constituency opinion and congressional policy making: The Reagan defense buildup. American Political Science Review85 (June): 457-474.
7.
Bollen, Kenneth A.1989. Structural equations with latent variables. New York: John Wiley.
8.
Borger, Gloria . 1993. Clinton vs. the populists on NAFTA. U.S. News & World Report115 (October 11): 55.
9.
Brockner, Joel , Steven Grover, Thomas F. Reed, and Rocki L. DeWitt. 1992. Layoffs, job insecurity, and survivors' work effort: Evidence of an inverted U-relationship. Academy of Management Journal35 (June): 41 3-25.
10.
Byrne, Barbara . 1989. A primer of LISREL: Basic applications and programming for confirmatory factor analytic models. New York: Springer-Verlag.
11.
Carroll, Douglas F., ed. Special Nafta issue. 1993. Business America114 (October 18).
12.
Chanley, Virginia . 1994. Commitment to political tolerance: Situational and activity-based differences. Political Behavior16 (September): 343-363.
13.
Churchill, Gilbert A., Jr.1979. A paradigm for developing better measures of marketing constructs. Journal of Marketing Research16 (February): 64-73.
14.
Condra, Mollie B.1992. The link between need for cognition and political interest, involvement, and media usage. Psychology, A Journal of Human Behavior29 (314): 13-18.
15.
Crawford, John C. , and Charles W. Lamb, Jr.1982. Effect of worldmindedness among professional buyers upon their willingness to buy foreign products. Psychological Reports50 (Spring): 859-862.
16.
Davis, Bob . 1993. Some U.S. companies find Mexican workers not so cheap after all. The Wall Street Journal129 (September 15): A1.
17.
de Miramon, Jacques, and Candice Stevens. 1992. The trade/environment policy balance. OECD Observer176 (June/July): 25-27.
18.
Dowd, Ann R.1993. Ross Perot is wrong about NAFTA. Fortune128 (November 15): 13-14.
19.
Drew, Elizabeth . 1994. On the edge: The Clinton presidency. New York: Simon & Schuster.
20.
Duckitt, John . 1992. The social psychology of prejudice. New York: Praeger.
21.
Duval, Michael . 1993. The weak case against Nafta. The Wall Street Journal202 (November 5): A8.
22.
Eat your NAFTA . 1993. The Economist329 (November 13): 15-16.
23.
Feather, Norman T.1989. The psychological impact of unemployment. New York: Springer-Verlag.
24.
Ferman, Louis A. , and John Gardner. 1979. Economic deprivation: Social mobility and mental health. In Mental health and the economy, edited by Louis A. Ferman and Jeanne P. Gordus, 193-224. Kalamazoo, MI: W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
25.
Feshbach, Seymour . 1991. Attachment processes in adult political ideology: Patriotism and nationalism. In Intersections with attachment, edited by Jacob L. Gewirtz and William M. Kurtines, 207-226. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
26.
Finn, Adam , and Shaun McQuitty. 1994. Empirical research in macro-marketing. Journal of Macromarketing14 (Fall): 63-68.
27.
Forbes, H. D.1985. Nationalism, ethnocentrism, and personality: Social science and critical theory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
28.
Fornell, Claes . 1992. A national customer satisfaction barometer: The Swedish experience. Journal of Marketing56 (January): 6-21.
29.
Fox, Annette B.1995. Environment and trade: The NAFIA case. Political Science Quarterly110 (Spring): 49-68.
30.
Garfield, Bob . 1993. Hits, misses for Nafta ad pitchman. Advertising Age64 (November 8): 56.
31.
The great NAFTA bazaar . 1993. The Economist329 (November 13): 27-28.
32.
Han, C. Min . 1988. The role of consumer patriotism in the choice of domestic versus foreign products. Journal of Advertising Research28 (June/July): 25-32.
33.
Hansen, L. S.1990. Shifting boundaries in Europe and North America: Reflections and synthesis. International Journal for the Advancement of Counselling13 (October): 327-341.
34.
Hanson, David . 1993. Administration pushes NAFTA environment deal. Chemical & Engineering News71 (November 1): 23.
35.
Harbrecht, Douglas , Richard S. Dunham, and Susan B. Garland. 1993. NAFTA: Let's make a deal. Business Week3344 (November 8): 32-34.
36.
Hartley, Thomas , and Bruce Russett. 1992. Public opinion and the common defense: Who governs military spending in the United States. American Political Science Review86 (December): 905-915.
37.
Harvey, Michael G.1995. The MNC's role and responsibility in deforestation of tropical forests. Journal of Macromarketing15 (Fall): 107-127.
38.
Hewstone, Miles . 1986. Understanding attitudes to the European Community: A social-psychological study in four member states. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
39.
Holzinger, Albert G.1993. Why small firms back NAFTA. Nation's Business81 (November): 36-37.
40.
Horwitz, Allan V.1984. The economy and social pathology. In Annual review of sociology, edited by Ralph Turner and James F Short, Jr., 95-119. Palo Alto, CA: Annual Reviews.
41.
Howell, Roy D.1987. Covariance structure modeling and measurement issues: A note on "interrelations among a channel entity's power sources."Journal of Marketing Research24 (February): 119-126.
42.
Howell, Susan E.1994. Racism, cynicism, economics, and David Duke. American Politics Quarterly22 (April): 190-207.
43.
Hufbauer, Gary C. , and Jeffrey J. Schott. 1993. NAFTA: An assessment. Rev. ed.Washington, D.C.: Institute for International Economics.
44.
Hurwitz, Jon , and Mark Peffley. 1987. How are foreign policy attitudes structured? A hierarchical model. American Political Science Review81 (December): 1099-1119.
45.
Hurwitz, Jon , and Mark Peffley. 1992. Traditional versus social values as antecedents of racial stereotyping and policy conservatism. Political Behavior14 (March): 395-419.
46.
Ingersoll, Bruce , and Asra Q. Nomani. 1993. Hidden force; as Perot bashes NAFTA, a textile titan fights it quietly with money. The Wall Street Journal202 (November 15): A1.
47.
Keatley, Robert . 1993. Not all Nafta foes are Perot followers, but their opposition runs just as deep. The Wall Street Journal202 (November 12): All.
48.
Kinder, Donald R. , and D. R. Kiewiet. 1979. Economic discontent and political behavior: The role of personal grievances and collective economic judgments in congressional voting. American Journal of Political Science23 (August): 495-527.
49.
Koch, Jeffrey W.1991. Explanations of group economic outcomes: Determinants and consequences. American Politics Quarterly19 (April): 211-228.
50.
Koch, Jeffrey W. . 1994. Group identification in political context. Political Psychology15 (December): 687-698.
51.
Ladd, Everett C.1993. A look at lineup on NAFTA. The Christian Science Monitor85 (August 20): 18.
52.
Langford, Tom , and J. R. Ponting. 1992. Canadians' responses to aboriginal issues: The roles of prejudice, perceived group conflict and economic conservatism. Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology29 (May): 140-166.
53.
Markus, George E. , and Michael B. MacKuen. 1993. Anxiety, enthusiasm, and the vote: The emotional underpinnings of learning and involvement during presidential campaigns. American Political Science Review87 (September): 672-685.
54.
Miller, Dyndee . 1993. North America marketers await trade pact. Marketing News27 (May 10): 1, 10.
55.
Mondak, Jeffery J.1993. Public opinion and heuristic processing of source cues. Political Behavior15 (June): 167-192.
56.
Moon, David . 1990. What you use still depends on what you have: Information effects on the determinants of electoral choice. American Politics Quarterly18 (January): 3-24.
57.
Moon, David . 1992. What you use still depends on what you have: Information effects in presidential elections, 1972-1988. American Politics Quarterly20 (October): 427-441.
58.
Mutz, Diana . 1992. Mass media and the depoliticization of personal experience. American Journal of Political Science36 (May): 483-508.
59.
Nadeau, Richard , Richard G. Niemi, and Timothy Amato. 1995. Emotions, issue importance, and political learning. American Journal of Political Science39 (August): 558-574.
60.
Nincic, Miroslav , and Barbara Hinckley. 1991. Foreign policy and the evaluation of presidential candidates. Journal of Conflict Resolution35 (June): 333-355.
61.
No way to sell Nafta . 1993. Journal of Commerce and Commercial398 (October 28): 6A.
62.
Olsen, Janeen E. , Kent L. Granzin, and Abhijit Biswas. 1993. Influencing consumers' selection of domestic versus imported products: Implications for marketing based on a model of helping behavior. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science21 (Winter): 307-321.
63.
Orpen, Christopher . 1993. Job dependence as a moderator of effects of job threat on employees' job insecurity and performance. Psychological Reports72 (2): 449-450.
64.
Peffley, Mark , and Jon Hurwitz. 1993. Models of attitude constraint in foreign affairs. Political Behavior15 (March): 61-90.
65.
Ray, John J.1983. A scale to measure conservatism of American public opinion. Journal of Social Psychology119 (April): 293-294.
Riggle, Ellen D.1992. Cognitive strategies and candidate evaluations.American Politics Quarterly20 (April): 227-246.
68.
Rosen, Jeffery . 1995. The war on immigrants: Why the courts can't save us. The New Republic212 (January 30): 22-26.
69.
Ruefle, William , William H. Ross, and Diane Mandell. 1992. Attitudes toward Southeast Asian immigrants in a Wisconsin community. International Migration Review26 (Fall): 877-898.
70.
Sampson, Donald L. , and Howard P. Smith. 1957. A scale to measure world-minded attitudes. Journal of Social Psychology45 (Spring): 99-106.
71.
Set in concrete: Trade . 1995. The Economist335 (June 3): 28-29.
72.
Shamir, Boas . 1994. Ideological position, leaders' charisma, and voting preferences: Personal vs. partisan elections. Political Behavior16 (June): 265-287.
73.
Sharma, Subhash , Terence A. Shimp, and Jeongshin Shin. 1995. Consumer ethnocentrism: A test of antecedents and moderators. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science23 (Winter): 26-37.
74.
Shimp, Terence A. , and Subhash Sharma. 1987. Consumer ethnocentrism: Construction and validation of the CETSCALE. Journal of Marketing Research24 (August): 280-289.
75.
Shorrock, Tim . 1993. AFL-CIO to employ trade zone study in anti-Nafta fight. Journal of Commerce and Commercial398 (November 12): 3A.
76.
Sidanius, Jim , Bo Ekehammar, and Rose M. Brewer. 1986. The political socialization determinants of higher order sociopolitical space: A Swedish example. Journal of Social Psychology126 (February): 7-22.
77.
Sidanius, Jim , Felicia Pratto, Michael Martin, and Lisa M. Stallworth. 1991. Consensual racism and career track: Some implications of social dominance theory. Political Psychology12 (December): 691-721.
78.
Sigelman, Lee , and Ernest J. Yanarella. 1986. Public information on public issues: A multivariate analysis. Social Science Quarterly67 (June): 402-410.
79.
Solis, Dianne . 1993. In Mexico, a dispute over a business deal can land you in jail. The Wall Street Journal129 (September 27): A3.
80.
Taylor, Charles R. , and Glenn S. Omura. 1994. An evaluation of alternative paradigms of marketing and economic development, Part 1. Journal of Macromarketing14 (Fall): 6-20.
81.
Turner, John C.1987. Rediscovering the social group. In Rediscovering the social group: A self-categorization theory, edited by John C. Turner, 18-41. Oxford, England: Basil Blackwell.
82.
Turner, John C. . 1991. Social influence. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.
83.
Uchitelle, Louis . 1993. Trade winds; Nafta and jobs: In a numbers war no one can count. The New York limes143 (November 14): Sect. 4, 1, 3.
84.
Vann, John W. , and Erdogan Kumcu. 1995. Achieving efficiency and distributive justice in marketing programs for economic development. Journal of Macromarketing15 (Fall): 5-22.
85.
Verba, Sidney , Kay L. Schlozman, Henry Brady, and Norman H. Nie. 1993. Citizen activity: Who participates? What do they say?American Political Review87 (June): 303-318.
86.
Wagner, Ulrich , and Andreas Zick. 1995. The relation of formal education to ethnic prejudice: Its reliability, validity and explanation. European Journal of Social Psychology25 (January-February): 41-56.
87.
Watson, Rip . 1993. Boom or bust? Rails, labor spar on Nafta prospects. Journal of Commerce and Commercial398 (October 27): 3B.
88.
Wilson, Glenn D.1973. The psychology of conservatism. London: Academic Press.
