The interdisciplinary nature of marketing and macromarketing has resulted in borrowing theories from other disciplines. Informed and purposeful theory borrowing, that is, the use of a theory in a context different from its original one to explain a new phenomenon, has developed and enriched the field. To the extent that theory borrowing is indiscriminate or opportunistic, however, researchers may be misled in their attempts to understand the phenomenon of interest. This article presents the key philosophical issues involved in theory borrowing and develops evaluative criteria for appropriate borrowing. The criteria are a workbench heuristic, useful to researchers engaged in theory borrowing, and important issues are illustrated with examples from marketing and macromarketing, including population ecology, financial economics, and motivation research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alderson, Wroe (1957). Market Behavior and Executive Action. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
2.
Anderson, Beverlee B. , and M. Venkatesan (1987). "Interdisciplinary Borrowing in Consumer Behavior: Legitimate Offspring?" In 1987AMA Winter Educator's Conference: Marketing Theory, edited by Russell W. Belk, Gerald Zaltman, Richard Bagozzi, David Brinberg, Rohit Deshpande, A. Fuat Firat, Morris B. Holbrook, Jerry C. Olson, John F. Sherry, and Barton Weitz. Chicago: American Marketing Association.
3.
Anderson, Paul F. (1982). "Marketing, Strategic Planning, and the Theory of the Firm."Journal of Marketing, 46 (Spring): 15-26.
4.
Anderson, Paul F. (1983). "Marketing, Scientific Progress, and Scientific Method."Journal of Marketing, 47 (Fall): 18-31.
5.
Anderson, Paul F. (1986). "On Method in Consumer Research: A Critical Relativist Perspective."Journal of Consumer Research, 13 (September): 155-173.
6.
Anderson, Paul F. , and John G. Thatcher (1986). "On Borrowing, Epistemology, and Category Mistakes in Business Research." Working paper, Harvard Business School.
7.
Anderson, Paul F. , and John G. Thatcher (1987). "On Borrowing, Epistemology, and Extensibility in Business and Economic Research." Working paper, Harvard Business School.
8.
Amdt, Johan (1985). "On Maldng Marketing Science More Scientific: Role of Orientations, Paradigms, Metaphors, and Puzzle Solving."Journal of Marketing, 49 (Summer): 11-23.
9.
Berger, Peter L. , and Thomas Luckmann (1967). The Social Construction of Reality. New York: Doubleday Anchor.
10.
Berrien, E. Kenneth (1968). General and Social Systems. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
11.
Blau, Peter M. (1964). Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
12.
Bloom, Paul N. , and Philip Kotler (1975). "Strategies for High Market-Share Companies."Harvard Business Review, 53 (November-December): 63-72.
13.
Buckley, Walter (1967). Sociology and Modern Systems Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
14.
Cook, Thomas D. , and Donald T. Campbell (1979). Quasi Experimentation: Design and Analysis for Field Settings. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
15.
Crane, Diane (1969). "Social Structure in a Group of Scientists: ATest of the `Invisible College' Hypothesis."American Sociological Review, 34 (June): 335-352.
16.
Cundiff, Edward W. (1982). "A Macromarketing Approach to Economic Development."Journal of Macromarketing, 2 (Spring): 14-19.
17.
Day, George S. , Allan D. Shocker, and Rajendra K. Srivastava (1979). "Customer-Oriented Approaches to Identifying Product-Markets."Journal of Marketing, 43 (Fall): 8-19.
18.
Dixon, Donald F. (1984). "Macromarketing: A Social Systems Perspective."Journal of Macromarketing, 4 (Fall): 4-17.
19.
Fama, Eugene F. , and Merton H. Miller (1972). The Theory of Finance. Hinsdale, IL: Dryden Press.
20.
Fisk, George (1982). "Editor's Working Definition of Macromarketing."Journal of Macromarketing, 2 (Spring): 3-4.
21.
Fisk, George , and Patricia Meyers (1982). "Macromarketers' Guide to Paradigm Development." In Marketing Theory: Philosophy of Science Perspectives, edited by Ronald F. Bush and Shelby D. Hunt. Chicago: American Marketing Association, pp. 281-285.
22.
Friedrichs, Robert (1970). A Sociology of Sociology. New York: Free Press.
23.
Fuhrman, Ellsworth R. (1980). The Sociology of Knowledge in America. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia.
24.
Fuhrman, Ellsworth R. (1984). "Alvin Gouldner and the Sociology of Knowledge: Three Significant Problem Shifts."Sociology Quarterly, 25 (Summer): 287-300.
25.
Gouldner, Alvin (1970). The Coming Crisis of Western Sociology. New York: Basic Books.
26.
Gouldner, Alvin (1974). The Dark Side of the Dialectic: Toward a New Objectivity. Dublin, Ireland: Economic and Social Research Institute, pp. 1-29.
27.
Habermas, Jurgen (1971). Knowledge and Human Interests. Boston: Beacon Press.
28.
Held, David (1980). Introduction to Critical Theory. Berkeley: University of California Press.
29.
Henderson, Bruce D. (1983). "The Anatomy of Competition."Journal of Marketing, 47 (Spring): 7-11.
30.
Hirschman, Elizabeth C. (1986). "Humanistic Inquiry in Marketing Research: Philosophy, Method, and Criteria."Journal of Marketing Research, 23 (August): 237-249.
31.
Hirschman, Elizabeth C. (1989). "Interpretation and Reinterpretation in Theory Construction and Application: The Views of Some Prominent Consumer Behavior Theorists." In Advances in Consumer Research, vol. 16, edited by Thomas K. Srull. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research.
32.
Holbrook, Morris B. (1987). "What Is Consumer Research?"Journal of Consumer Research, 14 (June): 128-132.
33.
Homans, George C. (1961). Social Behavior: Its Elementary Forms. New York: Harcourt, Brace, and World.
34.
Horkheimer, Max (1972). Critical Theory. New York: Seabury Press.
35.
Horton, R.L. (1984). Buyer Behavior: Its Elementary Forms. New York: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich.
36.
Howard, John A. (1983). "Marketing Theory of the Firm."Journal of Marketing, 47 (Fall): 90-100.
37.
Hudson, Laurel , and Julie L. Ozanne (1988). "Alternative Ways of Seeking Knowledge in Consumer Research."Journal of Consumer Research, 14 (March): 508-521.
38.
Hunt, Shelby D. (1983). Marketing Theory. Homewood, IL: Irwin.
39.
Hunt, Shelby D. (1989a). Marketing Theory: The Philosophy of Marketing Science. Working manuscript, Texas Tech University.
40.
Hunt, Shelby D. (1989b). "Naturalistic, Humanistic, and Interpretive Inquiry: Challenges and Ultimate Potential." In Interpretive Consumer Research, edited by Elizabeth C. Hirschman. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research.
41.
Jones, David B. (1987). "A Framework for Classifying Ontologies in Marketing and Its Implications for Borrowing across Paradigms." In 1987A.M.A. Winter Educator's Conference: Marketing Theory, edited by Russell W. Belk, Gerald Zaltman, Richard Bagozzi, David Brinberg, Rohit Deshpande, A. Fuat Firat, Morris B. Holbrook, Jerry C. Olson, John F. Sherry, and Barton Weitz. Chicago: American Marketing Association.
42.
Lambkin, Mary , and George S. Day (1989). "Evolutionary Processes in Competitive Markets: Beyond the Product Life Cycle."Journal of Marketing, 53 (July): 4-20.
43.
Lincoln, Yvonna S. , and Edward G. Guba (1985). Naturalistic InquiryBeverly Hills, CA: Sage.
44.
Mannheim, Karl (1936). Ideology and Utopia. Translated by E. Shils. New York: Harcourt, Brace, and World.
45.
Martindale, Don (1960). The Nature and Types of Sociological Theory. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
46.
Merton, Robert K. (1968). Social Theory and Social Structure. New York: Free Press.
47.
Morgan, Gareth (1980). "Paradigms, Metaphors, and Puzzle Solving in Organization Theory."Administrative Science Quarterly, 25 (December): 605-622.
48.
Muncy, James A. , and Raymond P. Fisk (1987). "Cognitive Relativism and the Practice of Marketing Science."Journal of Marketing, 51 (January): 20-33.
49.
Murray, Jeff B. , and Deborah J. Evers (1989). "Theory Borrowing and Reflectivity in Interdisciplinary Fields." In Advances in Consumer Research, vol. 16, edited by Thomas K. Srull. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research.
50.
Murray, Jeff B. , and Julie L. Ozanne (1991). "The Critical Imagination: Emancipatory Interests in Consumer Research."Journal of Consumer Research, 18 (September): 129-144.
51.
Peter, J. Paul , and Jerry C. Olson (1983). "Is Science Marketing?"Journal of Marketing, 47 (Fall): 111-125.
52.
Petty, Richard E. , and John T. Cacioppo (1980). "Effects of Issue Involvement on Attitudes in an Advertising Context." In Proceedings of the Division 23 Program, edited by G. Gorn and M. Goldberg. Montreal: American Psychological Association.
53.
Petty, Richard E. , and John T. Cacioppo (1981). Attitudes and Persuasion: Classic and Contemporary Approaches. Dubuque, IA: William C. Brown.
54.
Petty, Richard E. , John T. Cacioppo, and David W. Schumann (1983). "Central and Peripheral Routes to Advertising Effectiveness: The Moderating Role of Involvement."Journal of Consumer Research, 10 (September): 135-146.
55.
Pinder, Craig C. , and V. Warren Bourgeois (1982). "Controlling Tropes in Administrative Science."Administrative Science Quarterly, 27: 641-652.
56.
Reidenbach, R. Eric , and Terence A. Oliva (1981). "General Living Systems Theory and Marketing: A Framework for Analysis."Journal of Marketing, 45 (Fall): 30-37.
57.
Rogers, Everett (1987). "The Critical School and Consumer Research." In Advances in Consumer Research, vol. 14, edited by Melanie Wallendorf and Paul Anderson. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research.
58.
Schroyer, Trent (1970). "Toward a Critical Theory for Advanced Industrial Society." In Recent Sociology edited by H.P. Dritzel. New York: Macmillan.
59.
Tellis, Gerard J. , and C. Merle Crawford (1981). "An Evolutionary Approach to Product Growth Theory."Journal of Marketing, 45 (Fall): 125-132.
60.
Wrong, Dennis (1961). "The Oversocialized Conception of Man in Modern Sociology."American Sociological Review, 26 (April): 183-193.
