This article reports the results of a two-wave consumer panel study (n = 749) of the relationship between consumer alienation and a number of variables and issues reported in previous research to be of interest to consumer affairs theorists and practitioners. The results suggest that consumer alienation warrants consideration in subsequent explanations of consumer issues. Consumer complaints, however, do not appear to be necessarily manifestations of a general alienated consumer segment, as has been previously suggested.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, David L. (1969), "Analysis of a Life Satisfaction Index,"Journal of Gerontology, 24, 470-474.
2.
Alberti, R. E. , and M. L. Emmons (1974), Your Perfect Right: A Guide to Assertive Behavior, 2nd edition, San Luis Obispo: Impact.
3.
Alf, Edward F., Jr. , and Norman M. Abrahams (1975), "The Use of Extreme Groups in Assessing Relationships,"Psychometrika, 40 (December), 563-572.
4.
Allison, Neil K. (1977), "Consumer Alienation from the Marketplace: Scale Construction and Application," Ph.D. dissertation, The University of Texas (Austin).
5.
Allison, Neil K. (1978), "A Psychometric Development of a Test for Consumer Alienation from the Marketplace,"Journal of Marketing Research, 15 (November), 565-575.
6.
Anderson, Ronald D. , Jack L. Engledow, and Helmut Becker (1979), "Evaluating the Relationships among Attitudes toward Business, Product Satisfaction, Experience, and Search Effort,"Journal of Marketing Research, 16 (August), 394-400.
7.
Anderson, W. T., Jr. , Karl E. Henion, and Eli P. Cox (1974), "Socially vs. Ecologically Responsible Consumers," in Combined Proceedings of the American Marketing Association, Ronald C. Curhan, ed., Chicago: American Marketing Association, 304-311.
8.
Andreasen, Alan R. (1976), "The Differing Nature of Consumerism in the Ghetto,"Journal of Consumer Affairs, 10 (Winter), 179-190.
9.
Andreasen, Alan R. (1977), "A Taxonomy of Consumer Satisfaction/Dissatisfaction Measures,"The Journal of Consumer Affairs, 11 (Winter), 11-22.
10.
Andreasen, Alan R. , and Arthur Best (1977), "Consumers Complain-Does Business Respond?"Harvard Business Review, 55 (July-August), 93-101.
11.
Barksdale, Hiram C. , and William R. Darden (1972), "Consumer Attitudes toward Marketing and Consumerism,"Journal of Marketing, 36 (October), 28-35.
12.
Barnes, James G. , and Karen Kelloway (1980), "Consumerists: Complaining Behavior and Attitudes toward Social and Consumer Issues,"Advances in Consumer Research, vol. 7, Chicago: Association for Consumer Research, 329-334.
13.
Bearden, William O. , and Jesse Teel (1980), "An Investigation of Personal Influences on Consumer Complaining,"Journal of Retailing, 56 (Fall), 3-20.
14.
Bearden, William O. , Donald R. Lichtenstein, and Jesse E. Teel (1983), "Reassessment of the Dimensionality, Internal Consistency, and Validity of the Consumer Alienation Scale,"AMA Educator's Proceedings, forthcoming.
15.
Bell, Gerald (1968), "Self-Esteem, Responsibility and Remorse among Car Buyers,"Explorations on Consumer Behavior, Montrose Summers and Jerome Keran, eds., Studies in Marketing Number 10, Austin: The Bureau of Business Research, The University of Texas, 77-102.
16.
Bell, Wendell (1959), "Anomie, Social Isolation, and Class Structure,"Sociometry (March), 105-116.
17.
Berkowitz, L. , and Kenneth G. Lutterman (1968), "The Traditional Socially Responsible Personality,"Public Quarterly, 32 (Summer), 169-185.
18.
Bernhardt, Kenneth (1981), "Consumer Problems and Complaint Action of Older Americans: A National View,"Journal of Retailing, 57 (Fall), 107-123.
19.
Best, Arthur , and Alan Andreasen (1977), "Consumer Response to Unsatisfactory Purchases: A Survey of Perceiving Defects, Voicing Complaints and Obtaining Redress,"Law and Society Review, 11 (Spring), 701-742.
20.
Bloom, Paul N. , and Gary T. Ford (1979), "Evaluation of Consumer Education Programs,"Journal of Consumer Research, 6 (December), 270-279.
21.
Bourgeois, Jacques C. , and James G. Barnes (1979), "Viability and Profile of the Consumerist Segment,"Journal of Consumer Research, 5 (March), 217-228.
22.
Campbell, A. , P. E. Converse, W. E. Miller, and D. E. Stokes (1960), The American Voter, New York: John Wiley & Sons.
23.
Campbell, Angus , and Howard Schuman (1968), Racial Attitudes in Fifteen American Cities, Ann Arbor: Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan.
24.
Caplovitz, David (1967), The Poor Pay More, 2nd edition, New York: The Free Press.
25.
Carlin, Jerome E. , Jan Howard, and Sheldon L. Messinger (1967), Civil Justice and the Poor: Issues for Sociological Research, New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
26.
"Consumers Who Complain Irked by Firm's Response,"The Marketing News, April 16, 1982, p. 3.
27.
Danzig, Richard , and Michael J. Lowy (1975), "Everyday Dignities and Mediation in the United States: Reply to Professor Felstiner,"Law and Society Review, 9.
28.
Davis, Joseph S. (1945), "Standards and Content of Living,"American Economic Review, 35, 1-15.
29.
Day, G. S. (1978), "Are Consumers Satisfied?" in Consumerism: Search for the Consumer Interest, 3rd edition, D. A. Aaker and C. S. Day, eds., New York: Free Press, 406-417.
30.
Day, Ralph L. (1977), "Extending the Concept of Consumer Satisfaction," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 4, William Perreault, ed., Atlanta: Association for Consumer Research, pp. 149-154.
31.
Day, Ralph L. (1980), "Research Perspectives on Consumer Complaining Behavior," in Theoretical Developments in Marketing, Charles W. Lamb and Patrick Dunne, eds., Chicago: American Marketing Association, pp. 211-215.
32.
Day, Ralph L. , and Stephen B. Ash (1979), "Consumer Response to Dissatisfaction with Durable Products," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 6, William L. Wilkie, ed., Miami: Association for Consumer Research, 438-444.
33.
Day, Ralph L. , and Stephen B. Ash (1979), "Comparison of Patterns of Satisfaction/Dissatisfaction and Complaining Behavior for Durables, Non-Durables and Services," in New Dimensions of Satisfaction and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day and Keith Hunt, eds., Bloomington: Indiana University Graduate School of Business, 190-195.
34.
Day, Ralph L. , and Muzaffer Bodur (1977), "A Comprehensive Study of Satisfaction with Consumer Services," in Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction, and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day, ed., Bloomington: Indiana University Graduate School of Business, 64-74.
35.
Day, Ralph L. , and Muzaffer Bodur (1978), "Consumer Response to Dissatisfaction with Services and Intangibles," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 5, Keith Hunt, ed., Chicago: Association for Consumer Research, 263-272.
36.
Day, Ralph L. , and E. Laird Landon (1976), "Collecting Comprehensive Consumer Complaint Data by Survey Research," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 3, B. B. Anderson, ed., Chicago: Association for Consumer Research, 263-268.
37.
Day, Ralph L. , and E. Laird Landon (1977), "Toward a Theory of Consumer Complaining Behavior," in Consumer and Industrial Buying Behavior, A. G. Woodside, J. N. Sheth, and P. D. Bennett, eds., New York: North-Holland, 425-437.
38.
Dean, Dwight G. (1961), "Alienation: Its Meaning and Measurement,"American Sociological Review, 26 (October), 753-758.
39.
Diamond, Steven L. , Scott Ward, and Ronald Faber (1976), "Consumer Problems and Consumerism: Analysis of Calls to a Consumer Hot Line,"Journal of Marketing, 40 (January), 58-62.
40.
Edwards, John N. , and David L. Klemmack (1973), ""orrelates of Life Satisfaction,"Journal of Gerontology, 28, 497-502.
41.
Engel, James F. , and Roger D. Blackwell (1982), Consumer Behavior, 4th edition, Hinsdale, IL: The Dryden Press.
42.
English, Wilkie , and Mary F. Hilger (1978), "Consumer Alienation in the Marketplace," in Proceedings: Southern Marketing Association Conference, Robert S. Franz, Robert M. Hopkins, and Al Toma, eds., Lafayette, LA: University of Southwestern Louisiana, 307-310.
43.
Feldt, Leonard S. (1961), "The Use of Extreme Groups to Test for the Presence of a Relationship,"Psychometrika, 26 (September), 307-316.
44.
Fishbein, Martin , and Icek Ajzen (1975), Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior, Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
45.
Fornell, Claes , and Robert A. Westbrook (1979), "An Exploratory Study of Assertiveness, Aggressiveness, and Consumer Complaining Behavior," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 6, William L. Wilkie, ed., Miami: Association for Consumer Research, 105-110.
46.
Friedman, Karl A. (1974), Complaining: Comparative Aspects of Complaint Behavior and Attitudes Toward Complaining in Canada and Britain, Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
47.
Friedman, Monroe (1972), "Consumer Response to Unit Pricing, Open Code Dating, and Nutrient Labeling," in Proceedings of the Third Annual Conference of the Association for Consumer Research, 361-369.
48.
Friedman, Monroe (1977), "Consumer Use of Informational Aids in Supermarkets,"Journal of Consumer Affairs, 11 (Summer), 78-89.
49.
Gustafson, Wiliam , William O. Bearden, and J. Barry Mason (1978), "Consumer Alienation and Food Shopping: An Exploratory Analysis of the Behavior of the Elderly,"Proceedings of the American Council on Consumer Interests Conference, Columbia, MO: American Council on Consumer Interests.
50.
Grikscheit, Gary M. , and Kent L. Granzin (1975), "Who are the Consumerists?"Joumal of Business Research, 3 (January), 1-12.
51.
Haefner, James E. , and John D. Leckenby (1975), ""Consumers Use and Awareness of Consumer Complaint Agencies,"Journal of Consumer Affairs, 9, 205-211.
52.
Hafstrom, Jeanne L. , and Marilyn Dunsing (1973), "Level of Living: Factors Influencing the Homemaker's Satisfaction,"Home Economics Research Journal, 2, 119-132.
53.
Handy, Charles R. (1976), "Monitoring Consumer Satisfaction With Food Products," in Conceptualization and Measurement of Consumer Satisfaction and Dissatisfaction, H. Keith Hunt, ed., Cambridge, MA: Marketing Science Institute, 215-239.
54.
Horton, John E. , and Wayne Thompson (1962), ""Powerlessness and Potential Negativeness: A Study of Defeated Local Referendums,"American Journal of Psychology, 67 (March), 485-493.
55.
Howard, J. A. , and J. N. Sheth (1969), The Theory of Buyer Behavior, New York: John Wiley and Sons.
56.
Hustad, Thomas P. , and Edgar A. Pessemier (1973), "Will the Real Consumer Activist Please Stand Up: An Examination of Consumers' Opinions About Marketing Practices,"Journal of Marketing Research, 10 (August), 318-324.
57.
Jacoby, Jacob , and James J. Jaccard (1981), "The Sources, Meaning and Validity of Consumer Complaint Behavior: A Psychological Analysis,"Journal of Retailing, 57 (Fall), 4-24.
58.
Kerlinger, Fred N. (1973), Foundations of Behavioral Research, 2nd edition, New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 308-309.
59.
Killian, Lewis M. , and Charles M. Grigg (1962), "Urbanism, Race, and Anomia,"American Journal of Sociology, 67 (May), 661-665.
60.
Koeske, Randi D. , and Rajendra Srivastava (1977), "The Sources and Handling of Consumer Complaints and the Elderly," in Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction, and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day, ed., Bloomington: Indiana University Graduate School of Business, 138-143.
61.
Lambert, Zarrell V. (1980), "Consumer Alienation, General Dissatisfaction and Consumerism: Conceptual and Managerial Perspectives,"Journal of Retailing, 56 (Summer), 3-24.
62.
Lambert, Zarrell V. (1981), "Profiling Characteristics of Alienated Consumers,"Journal of Business Research, 9, 65-86.
63.
Lambert, Zarrell V. , and Fred W. Kniffin (1975), "Consumer Discontent: A Social Perspective,"California Management Review, 18 (Fall), 36-44.
64.
Landon, E. Laird, Jr. (1977), "A Model of Consumer Complaint Behavior," in Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction, and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day, ed., Bloomington: Indiana University Graduate School of Business, 31-35.
65.
Landon, E. Laird, Jr. (1980), ""The Direction of Consumer Complaint Research," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 7, Jerry C. Olson, ed., San Francisco: Association for Consumer Research, 335-338.
66.
Lawther, Karen (1978), "Social Integration and the Elderly Consumer: Unfairness Awareness, Complaint Actions, and Information Usage," in Research Frontiers in Marketing: Dialogue and Directions, Subash Jain, ed., Chicago: American Marketing Association, 341-345.
67.
Lawther, Karen ,.S. Krishnan, and Valerie Valle (1979), "The Consumer Complaint Process: Directions for Theoretical Development," in New Dimensions of Consumer Satisfaction and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day and Keith Hunt, eds., Bloomington: Indiana University Graduate School of Business, 10-14.
68.
Lce, Gary K. (1974), "Marriage and Anomie: A Causal Argument,"Joumal of Marriage and Family, 36 (August), 523-532.
69.
Locander, William , and P. W. Hermann (1979), "Effects of Self-Confidence and Anxiety on Information Seeking and Risk Reduction,"Journal of Marketing Research, 16, 268-274.
70.
Longman, Douglas , and Henry Pruden (1971), "Alienation From the Marketplace: A Study in Black, Brown, and White," in Combined Proceedings, Fred C. Allvine, ed., Chicago: American Marketing Association, 616-619.
71.
Lundstrom, William and William Zikmund (1977), ""Consumer Discontent and Locus of Control: A Study in Business and Social Science Typologies," paper presented at the Southwestern Marketing Association Annual Meeting, New Orleans (March).
72.
Lundstrom, William , Gerald O. Skelley, and Donald Sciglimpaglia (1979), "How Deep Are the Roots of Consumer Discontent?" in New Dimensions of Consumer Satisfaction and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day and Keith Hunt, eds., Bloomington: Indiana University School of Business, 157-161.
73.
Lundstrom, William , Gerald O. Skelley, Roger A. Kerin, and Donald Sciglimpaglia (1979), "A Path Analytic Comparison of Three Causal Models Contributing to the State of Consumer Discontent," in 1979 Educators' Conference Proceedings, Neil Beckwithet al., eds., Chicago: American Marketing Association, 235-238.
74.
Lystad, Mary Hanemann (1972), "Social Alienation: A Review of Current Literature,"Sociology Quarterly, 13 (Winter), 90-113.
75.
Marion, Donald , and Charles Goodman (1972), ""Operating Problems of Marketing Firms in Low-Income Areas," in Improving Inner-City Marketing, Alan Andreasen, ed., Chicago: American Marketing Association, 115-148.
76.
Mason, Joseph Barry , and Samuel H. Himes, Jr. (1973), "An Exploratory Behavioral and Socio-Economic Profile of Consumer Action about Dissatisfaction with Selected Household Appliances,"The Journal of Consumer Affairs, 7 (Winter), 121-127.
77.
Medley, Morris L. (1976), "Satisfaction with Life among Persons Sixty-Five Years and Older: A Causal Model,"Journal of Gerontology, 31, 448-455.
78.
Meier, Dorothy L. , and Wendell Bell (1959), "Anomie and Differential Access to the Achievement of Life Goals,"American Sociology Review, 24 (April), 189-202.
79.
Merton, R. (1949), Social Theory and Social Structure, Glencoe: Free Press.
80.
Moyer, Mel S. (1978), "Ontario Consumer Issues," a paper prepared for the Ontario Ministry of Consumer and Commercial Relations (August).
81.
Munns, Joyce Matthews (1978), "Consumer Complaints as Pre-Purchase Information: An Evaluation of Better Business Bureau Reports to Consumers,"The Journal of Consumer Affairs, 12 (Summer), 76-87.
82.
Nader, Laura (1979), ""Complainer Beware,"Psychology Today (December), 45-60, 98.
83.
Neal, Arthur G. , and Theodore H. Groat (1974), "Social Class Correlates of Stability and Change in Levels of Alienation: A Longitudinal Study,"Sociology Quarterly, 15 (Autumn), 548-558.
84.
Perloff, Robert , and Patrick McCaskey (1978), "Non-Monetary Costs Associated with Consumer Fraud and Dissatisfaction of the Elderly," paper presented at the 1978 American Council on Consumer Interests Conference, Chicago, April 21.
85.
Peter, J. Paul (1981), "Construct Validity: A Review of Basic Issues and Marketing Practices,"Journal of Marketing Research, 18 (May), 133-145.
86.
Pfaff, Martin , and Stephen Blivice (1977), "Socioeconomic Correlates of Consumer and Citizen Dissatisfaction and Activism," in Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction, and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day, ed., Bloomington: Indiana University Graduate School of Business, 115-123.
87.
Pruden, Henry , and Jean-Paul Leonardi (1976), "Instability and Consumer Alienation in France,"Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 4 (Fall).
88.
Pruden, Henry , and Douglas L. Longman (1972), "Race, Alienation and Consumerism,"Jourmal of Marketing, 36, 58-62.
89.
Richards, Louise (1966), "Consumer Practices of the Poor," in Low-Income Life Styles, Lola M. Ireland, ed., Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.
90.
Ritchie, J. R. Brent , and John D. Claxton (1979), "In Search of Actions to Reduce Consumer Shopping Problems," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol 6, William L. Wilkie, ed., Miami: Association for Consumer Research, 466-471.
91.
Ritchins, Marsha L. (1981), "Consumer Perceptions of Costs and Benefits Associated with Complaining," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 9, A. Mitchel, ed., St. Louis: Association for Consumer Research.
92.
Ritchins, Marsha L. (1983), "An Analysis of Consumer Interaction Styles in the Marketplace,"Journal of Consumer Research, forthcoming.
93.
Robinson, John , and Philip Shaver (1973), Measures of Social Psychological Attitudes, Ann Arbor, MI: Institute for Social Research.
94.
Robinson, Larry and Roy D. Adler (1979), "Personality as an Explanatory Variable for Complaint Action of Automobile Buyers," in Proceedings of the Division 23 Program, Ivan Ross, ed., New York: American Psychological Association, 90-93.
95.
Rotter, J. B. (1967), "A New Scale for the Measurement of Interpersonal Trust,"Joumal of Personality, 35, 651-665.
96.
Rushing, William A. (1971), "Class, Culture, and Social Structure and Anomie,"American Journal of Sociology, 76 (March), 857-872.
97.
Scott, Jerome E. , and Lawrence M. Lamont (1973), "Consumerism: A Theoretical Framework for Analysis," in 1972 Combined Proceedings, Boris Becker and Helmut Becker, eds., Chicago: American Marketing Association, 241-248.
98.
Seeman, Melvin (1959), "On the Meaning of Alienation,"American Sociology Review, 24 (December), 783-791.
99.
Shuptrine, Kelley , Henry O. Pruden, and Douglas F. Longman (1977), "Alienation from the Marketplace,"Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 5 (Summer), 233-248.
100.
Spreitzer, Elmer , and Eldon Snyder (1974), "Correlates of Life Satisfaction Among the Aged,"Journal of Gerontology, 29, 454-458.
101.
Srole, L. T. , Michale S. Langer, M. Opler, and T. Rennie (1962), Mental Health in the Metropolis, New York: McGraw-Hill.
102.
Stokes, R. L. (1974), "Consumer Complaints and Consumer Dissatisfaction," paper delivered to the Food and Drug Law Institute, Phoenix, Arizona (April).
103.
"Survey of Automotive Repair Practices" (1979), Washington, DC: Office of the Secretary of Transportation, Division for Consumer Affairs.
104.
Swan, John (1977), "Consumer Satisfaction with a Retail Store Related to the Fulfillment of Expectations on an Initial Shopping Trip," in Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction, and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day, ed., Bloomington: School of Business, Indiana University.
105.
Technical Assistance Research Programs, Inc. (1976), A National Survey of the Complaint Handling Procedures Used by Consumers, Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (Document NTIS-PB-263081).
106.
Thompson, Wayne E. , and John E. Horton (1960), "Political Alienation as a Force in Political Action,"Social Forces (March), 190-195.
107.
Thorelli, Hans B. , Helmut Becker, and Jack Engledow (1975), The Information Seekers, Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing Company.
108.
Unger, Lynette , and Jerome Kernan (1981), "Leisure and the QOL Construct: A Review and Some Modest Proposals," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 8, Kent B. Monroe, ed., Ann Arbor: Association for Consumer Research, 607-611.
109.
Valle, Valerie , and Randi Koeski (1977), "Elderly Consumer Problems: Actions, Sources of Information and Attributions of Blame," in Proceedings of the Division 23 Program, Clark Leavitt, ed., San Francisco: American Psychological Association, 7-8.
110.
Valle, Valerie , and Karen Lawther (1978), "Interpersonal Trust and Attribution of Responsibility: Determinants of Elderly Consumer Complaining," in Opportunities for Psychologists in Consumer Psychology, Franco Nicosia, ed., Berkeley: American Psychological Association, 64-67.
111.
Wall, Marjorie , Lois E. Dickey, and Wayne Talrzyk (1977), "Predicting and Profiling Consumer Satisfaction and Propensity to Complain," in Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction and Complaining Behavior, Ralph Day, ed., Bloomington: Indiana University Graduate School of Business, 91-101.
112.
Wall, Marjorie , Lois E. Dickey, and Wayne Talrzyk (1978), ""Correlates of Satisfaction and Dissatisfaction with Clothing Performance,"Journal of Consumer Affairs, 12 (Summer), 104-115.
113.
Wall, Marjorie , Lois E. Dickey, and Wayne Talrzyk (1979), "Profiling Consumer Communication of Complaints about Clothing Performance,"Home Economics Research Journal, 7 (July), 368-378.
114.
Warland, Rex H. , Robert O. Herrmann, and Jane Willits (1975), "Dissatisfied Consumers: Who Gets Upset and Who Takes Action,"The Journal of Consumer Affairs, 6 (Winter), 148-163.
115.
Webbink, Douglas W. (1978), "Automobile Repair: Does Regulation of Consumer Information Matter?"Journal of Consumer Research, 5 (December), 206-209.
116.
Westbrook, Robert A. (1980), "Intrapersonal Affective influences upon Consumer Satisfaction with Products,"Journal of Consumer Research, 7 (June), 49-59.
117.
Westbrook, Robert A. , and Joseph W. Newman (1978), "An Analysis of Shopper Dissatisfaction for Major Household Appliances,"Journal of Marketing Research, 15 (August), 456-466.
118.
Zaltman, Gerald , Rajendra K. Srivastava, and Rohit Deshpande (1978), "Perceptions of Unfair Marketing Practices: Consumer Implications," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 5, Keith Hunt, ed., Ann Arbor: Association for Consumer Research, 247-253.
