This study explores how technology attains agency in a service system. By applying a systems view through the lenses of service-dominant logic and actor-network theory (ANT), we clarify and conceptualize resource and agency forms for a technology as it connects with other actors in a network as part of the value cocreation process. We conduct a qualitative study to explore a technology's role (i.e., VR-tours) in the residential real estate market. We find that VR-tour technology gains causal agency through others’ connection to and reliance on the technology. As value is determined, there is potential for structural agency, where it cocreates and transforms valuations, influencing actors to renegotiate their roles and practices and enabling value destabilization in the marketing system. Theoretical and macromarketing implications are discussed.
AkakaMelissa A.SchauHope J. (2019), “Value Creation in Consumption Journeys: Recursive Reflexivity and Practice Continuity,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 47 (3), 499‐515.
3.
AkakaMelissa A.VargoStephen L. (2014), “Technology as an Operant Resource in Service (Eco)systems,” Information Systems and E-Business Management, 12 (3), 367‐384.
4.
AkakaMelissa A.VargoStephen L.O’BrienMatthew (2023), “Microfoundations for Macromarketing: A Metatheoretical Lens for Bridging the Micro-Macro Divide,” Journal of Macromarketing, 43 (1), 61‐75.
5.
AkakaMelissa A.VargoStephen L.SchauHope J. (2015), “The Context of Experience,” Journal of Service Management, 26 (2), 206‐223.
6.
AkmanHadePlewaCarolineConduitJodie (2018), “Co-Creating Value in Online Innovation Communities,” European Journal of Marketing, 53 (6), 1205-1123.
7.
AllenMarcus T.CadenaAnjelitaRutherfordJessicaRutherfordRonald C. (2015), “Effects of Real Estate Brokers’ Marketing Strategies: Public Open Houses, Broker Open Houses, MLS Virtual Tours, and MLS Photographs,” The Journal of Real Estate Research, 37 (3), 343‐369.
8.
AndersonKelley CoursFreyboteJuliaManisKerry T. (2022), “The Impact of Virtual Marketing Strategies on the Price-TOM Relation,” The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 1‐17. doi.org/10.1007/s11146-022-09908-x.
9.
AndersonKelley CoursThyroffAnastasia (2022), “Panel: The Role of Actors in Macromarketing,” in Proceedings of the 47th Annual Macromarketing Conference: The New Normal, 74‐75.
10.
ArnouldEric J.PriceLinda L.MalsheAvinash (2006), “Toward a Cultural Resource-Based Theory of the Customer,” in The Service-Dominant Logic of Marketing: Dialog, Debate and Directions, LuschR. F.VargoS. L., eds. M.E. Sharpe, 320‐333.
11.
ArselZeynep (2017), “Asking Questions with Reflexive Focus: A Tutorial on Designing and Conducting Interviews,” Journal of Consumer Research, 44 (4), 939‐948.
BakerStacy M.HillRonald P.BakerCourtney N.MittelstaedtJohn D. (2015), “Improvisational Provisioning in Disaster: The Mechanisms and Meanings of Ad Hoc Marketing Exchange Systems in Community,” Journal of Macromarketing, 35 (3), 334‐352.
14.
BarrettMichaelDavidsonElizabethPrabhuJaideepVargoStephen L. (2015), “Service Innovation in the Digital Age: Key Contributions and Future Directions,” MIS Quarterly, 39 (1), 135‐154.
15.
BeckerMarenWiegandNicoReinartzWerner (2019), “Does it Pay to be Real? Understanding Authenticity in TV Advertising,” Journal of Marketing, 83 (1), 24‐50.
16.
BenefieldJustin D.CainChristopher L.JohnsonKen H. (2011), “On the Relationship between Property Price, Time-on-market, and Photo Depictions in a Multiple Listing Service,” The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 43, 401-422.
17.
BenefieldJustin D.SirmansStaceSirmansChristopherSirmansG. Stacy (2019), “Observable Agent Effort and Limits to Innovation in Residential Real Estate,” Journal of Real Estate Research, 41 (1), 1‐36.
18.
BijkerWiebe E.LawJohn (1992), Shaping Technology/Building Society: Studies in Sociotechnical Change. MIT Press.
19.
BoydD. EricKolesBernadett (2019), “Virtual Reality and its Impact on B2B Marketing: A Value-in-Use Perspective,” Journal of Business Research, 100, 590‐598.
20.
BreidbachChristopher F.MaglioPaul P. (2016), “Technology-Enabled Value Co-creation: An Empirical Analysis of Actors, Resources, and Practices,” Industrial Marketing Management, 56, 73‐85.
21.
CallonMichaelLatourBruno (1981), “Unscrewing the Big Leviathan: How Actors Macro-Structure Reality and How Sociologists Help Them To Do So,” in Advances in Social Theory and Methodology, Knorr-CetinaK.CicourelA., eds. Routledge & Kegan Paul, 277‐303.
22.
CallonMichel (1984), “Some Elements of a Sociology of Translation: Domestication of the Scallops and the Fishermen of St. Brieuc Bay,” The Sociological Review, 32 (1_suppl), 196‐233.
23.
CallonMichel (1993), “Society in the Making: The Study of Technology as a Tool for Sociological Analysis,” in The Social Construction of Technological Systems, BijkerWiebe E.HughesThomas ParkePinchTrevor, eds. The MIT Press, 83‐103.
24.
CaridàAngeloEdvardssonBoColurcioMario (2019), “Conceptualizing Resource Integration as an Embedded Process: Matching, Resourcing and Valuing,” Marketing Theory, 19 (1), 65‐84.
25.
ChandlerJennifer D.VargoStephen L. (2011), “Contextualization and Value-in-Context: How Context Frames Exchange,” Marketing Theory, 11 (1), 35‐49.
26.
ClauretieTerance. M.DaneshvaryNasser (2008), “Principal-Agent Conflict and Broker Effort Near Listing Contract Expiration: The Case of Residential Properties,” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 37, 147‐161.
27.
CreedW. E. DouglasTaylorSteven S.HudsonBryant A. (2020), “Institutional Aesthetics: Embodied Ways of Encountering, Evaluating, and Enacting Institutions,” Organization Studies, 41 (3), 415‐435.
28.
Denegri-KnottJaniceMolesworthMike (2013), “Redistributed Consumer Desire in Digital Virtual Worlds of Consumption,” Journal of Marketing Management, 29 (13–14), 1561‐1579.
29.
DomeganChristineBrychkovDmitryMcHughPatriciaMcNamaraÁineHarkinKatharineFitzgeraldChristineO’DonovanDiarmuid (2020), “Marketing Systems: A Listen, Learn, Leverage Framework,” Journal of Macromarketing, 40 (3), 380‐395.
30.
DonthuNaveenGustafssonAnders (2020), “Effects of COVID-19 on Business and Research,” Journal of Business Research, 117, 284‐289.
31.
DrentenJennaZayerLinda T. (2017), “The Role of Digital Virtual Consumption in Navigating Risk-Laden Life Events,” Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 3 (1), 46‐62.
32.
EcheverriPerSkålénPer (2011), “Co-Creation and Co-Destruction: A Practice-Theory Based Study of Interactive Value Formation,” Marketing Theory, 11 (3), 351‐373.
33.
EisenhardtKathleen M. (1989), “Building Theories From Case Study,” Academy of Management Review, 14 (4), 532‐550.
34.
EmirbayerMustafaMischeAnn (1998), “What is Agency?” American Journal of Sociology, 103 (4), 962‐1023.
35.
FigueiredoBernardoScarabotoDianae (2016), “The Systemic Creation of Value Through Circulation in Collaborative Consumer Networks,” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (4), 509‐533.
36.
FindsrudRolfTronvollBardEdvardssonBo (2018), “Motivation: The Missing Driver for Theorizing about Resource Integration,” Marketing Theory, 18 (4), 493‐519.
37.
FlintDaniel J. (2006), “Innovation, Symbolic Interaction and Customer Valuing: Thoughts Stemming from a Service-Dominant Logic of Marketing,” Marketing Theory, 6 (3), 349‐362.
GiddensAnthony (1984), The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration. The University of California Press.
41.
GieslerMarkus (2012), “How Doppelgänger Brand Images Influence the Market Creation Process: Longitudinal Insights from the Rise of Botox Cosmetic,” Journal of Marketing, 76 (6), 55‐68.
42.
GieslerMarkusThompsonCraig J. (2016), “Process Theorization in Cultural Consumer Research,” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (4), 497‐508.
GrantAnnettaHandelmanJay M. (2023), “Dysplacement and the Professionalization of the Home,” Journal of Consumer Research, 49 (5), 882‐903.
45.
GrönroosChristianVoimaPäivi (2013), “Critical Service Logic: Making Sense of Value Creation and Co-creation,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 41, 133‐150.
46.
GummerusJohannaO’LoughlinDeirdreKelleherCarolPeñalozaLisa (2021), “Shifting Sands: Actor Role and Identity Reconfigurations in Service Systems,” Journal of Business Research, 137, 162‐169.
47.
GwinCarl R.OngSaes E.GwinCoral F. (2002), “Seller versus Broker: Timing of Promotion,” Journal of Real Estate Research, 24 (1), 27‐45.
48.
HatchMary Jo (2018), Organization Theory: Modern, Symbolic, and Postmodern Perspectives, 4th ed., Oxford University Press.
49.
HeinonenKristinaCampbellColinFergusonSarah Lord (2019), “Strategies for Creating Value through Individual and Collective Customer Experiences,” Business Horizons, 62 (1), 95‐104.
50.
HilkenTimde RuyterKoChylinskiMathewMahrDominikKeelingDebbie I. (2017), “Augmenting the Eye of the Beholder: Exploring the Strategic Potential of Augmented Reality to Enhance Online Service Experiences,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 45 (6), 884‐905.
51.
HoffmanDonna L.NovakThomas P. (2018), “Consumer and Object Experience in the Internet of Things: An Assemblage Theory Approach,” Journal of Consumer Research, 44 (6), 1178‐1204.
52.
HolbrookMorris B. (1999), Consumer Value: A Framework for Analysis and Research. Routledge.
HustonSimonWarrenClive (2013), “Knowledge City and Urban Economic Resilience,” Journal of Property Finance and Investment, 31 (1), 78‐88.
55.
HyunMartin Y.O’KeefeRobert M. (2012), “Virtual Destination Image: Testing a Telepresence Model,” Journal of Business Research, 65 (1), 29‐35.
56.
International Data Corporation (2017), “Worldwide Quarterly Augmented and Virtual Reality Headset Tracker- Second Quarter,” (accessed April 7, 2018), [available athttps://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=IDC_P35095].
57.
JaworskiBernie J.KohliAjay K. (2006), “Co-creating the Voice of the Customer,” in The Service Dominant Logic of Marketing, LuschR. F.VargoS. L., eds. M.E. Sharpe, 109‐117.
58.
JoyAnnammaSherryJohn F.Jr. (2003), “Speaking of Art as Embodied Imagination: A Multisensory Approach to Understanding Aesthetic Experience,” Journal of Consumer Research, 30 (2), 259‐282.
59.
KaartemoValterriNyströmAnna G. (2021), “Emerging Technology as a Platform for Market Shaping and Innovation,” Journal of Business Research, 124, 458‐468.
60.
KaartemoValtteriHelkkulaAna (2018), “A Systematic Review of Artificial Intelligence and Robots in Value Co-creation: Current Status and Future Research Avenues,” Journal of Creating Value, 4 (2), 211‐228.
61.
KarpenIngo O.BoveLillana L.LukasBryan A. (2012), “Linking Service-Dominant Logic and Strategic Business Practice: A Conceptual Model of a Service-Dominant Orientation,” Journal of Service Research, 15 (1), 21‐38.
62.
KeelingDebbie I.KeelingKathleende RuyterKoLaingAngus (2020), “How Value Co-creation and Co-destruction Unfolds: A Longitudinal Perspective on Dialogic Engagement in Health Services Interactions,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 49, 236‐257.
63.
KerchSteve (2000), “Internet Accelerates Pace of Change in Real Estate Industry,” The Washington Post, 8.
64.
KleinLisa R. (2003), “Creating Virtual Product Experiences: The Role of Telepresence,” Journal of Interactive Marketing, 17 (1), 41‐55.
65.
Koskela-HuotariKaisaVargoStephen L. (2016), “Institutions as Resource Context,” Journal of Service Theory and Practice, 26 (2), 163‐178.
66.
KozinetsRobert V. (2019), “Consuming Technocultures: An Extended JCR Curation,” Journal of Consumer Research, 46 (3), 620‐627.
67.
KristenssonPer (2019), “Future Service Technologies and Value Creation,” Journal of Services Marketing, 33 (4), 502‐506.
68.
LambertonCaitStephenAndrew T. (2016), “A Thematic Exploration of Digital, Social Media, and Mobile Marketing: Research Evolution from 2000 to 2015 and an Agenda for Future Inquiry,” Journal of Marketing, 80 (6), 146‐172.
69.
LatourBruno (2004), “Why has Critique Run Out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of Concern,” Critical Inquiry, 30 (2), 225‐248.
70.
LatourBruno (2005), Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network Theory. Oxford University Press.
71.
LawJohn (1993), “Technology and Heterogeneous Engineering: The Case of Portuguese Expansion,” in The Social Construction of Technological Systems, BijkerW. E.HughesT. H.PichT., eds. The MIT Press, 111‐134.
72.
LaytonRoger A. (2007), “Marketing Systems-A Core Macromarketing Concept,” Journal of Macromarketing, 27 (3), 227‐242.
73.
LaytonRoger A. (2011), “Towards a Theory of Marketing Systems,” European Journal of Marketing, 45 (1/2), 259‐276.
74.
LaytonRoger A. (2015), “Formation, Growth, and Adaptive Change in Marketing Systems,” Journal of Macromarketing, 35 (3), 302‐319.
75.
LaytonRoger A. (2017), “Can Macromarketing Learn from 40,000 Years of History?” Journal of Macromarketing, 37 (3), 334‐335.
76.
LaytonRoger A. (2019), “Marketing Systems–Looking Backward, Sizing up and Thinking Ahead,” Journal of Macromarketing, 39 (2), 208‐224.
77.
LincolnYvonna S.GubaEgon G. (1985), Naturalistic Inquiry. Sage Publications.
78.
LuchtenbergKimberly F.SeilerMichael J.SunHua (2019), “Listing Agent Signals: Does a Picture Paint a Thousand Words?” The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 59, 617‐648.
79.
MacielAndre F.WallendorfMelanie (2017), “Taste Engineering: An Extended Consumer Model of Cultural Competence Constitution,” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (5), 726‐746.
80.
MadhavaramSreedharHuntShelby D. (2008), “The Service-Dominant Logic and a Hierarchy of Operant Resources: Developing Masterful Operant Resources and Implications for Marketing Strategy,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36, 67-82.
81.
MaglioPaul P.VargoStephen L.CaswellNathanSpohrerJim (2009), “The Service System is the Basic Abstraction of Service Science,” Information Systems and E-Business Management, 7, 395‐406.
82.
MartinDiane M.SchoutenJohn W. (2014), “Consumption-Driven Market Emergence,” Journal of Consumer Research, 40 (5), 855‐870.
83.
MaussMarcel (1925), The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies. Routledge.
84.
McAlexanderJames H.SchoutenJohn W.KoenigHarold F. (2002), “Building Brand Community,” Journal of Marketing, 66 (1), 38‐54.
85.
NenonenSuviStorbackaKajWindahlCharlotta (2019), “Capabilities for Market-Shaping: Triggering and Facilitating Increased Value Creation,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 47, 617‐639.
86.
NovakThomas P.HoffmanDonna L. (2019), “Relationship Journeys in the Internet of Things: A New Framework for Understanding Interactions between Consumers and Smart Objects,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 47 (2), 216‐237.
87.
NysveenHerbjørnPedersenPer E.SkardSiv (2020), “System Adoption of Practices Over Time (EAPT): Toward an Alternative View of Contemporary Technology Adoption,” Journal of Business Research, 116, 542‐551.
88.
PeltierJames W.DahlAndres J.SwanEric L. (2020), “Digital Information Flows Across a B2C/C2C Continuum and Technological Innovations in Service Systems: A Service-dominant Logic Perspective,” Journal of Business Research, 121, 724‐734.
89.
PiyathasananBabisMathiesChristinePattersonPaul G.de RuyterKo (2017), “Continued Value Creation in Crowdsourcing from Creative Process Engagement,” Journal of Services Marketing, 32 (1), 19‐33.
90.
PléLoïcCáceresRuben Chumpitaz (2010), “Not Always Co-creation: Introducing Interactional Co-Destruction of Value in Service-Dominant Logic,” Journal of Services Marketing, 24 (6), 430‐437.
91.
PohlmannAtillaKaartemoValterril (2017), “Research Trajectories of Service-Dominant Logic: Emergent Themes of a Unifying Paradigm in Business and Management,” Industrial Marketing Management, 63, 53‐68.
92.
RamaswamyVenkatOzcanKerimcan (2018), “What is Co-Creation? An Interactional Creation Framework and its Implications for Value Creation,” Journal of Business Research, 84, 196‐205.
93.
RedmondWilliam (2018), “Marketing Systems and Market Failure,” Journal of Macromarketing, 38 (4), 415‐424.
SawyerSteveWigandRolf T.CrowstonKevin (2005), “Redefining Access: Uses and Roles of Information and Communication Technologies in the US Residential Real Estate Industry from 1995 to 2005,” Journal of Information Technology, 20 (4), 213‐223.
96.
SayesEdwin (2014), “Actor-Network Theory and Methodology: Just What Does it Mean to Say That Nonhumans Have Agency?” Social Studies of Science, 44 (1), 134‐149.
97.
SchauHope J. (2019), “Identity Projects and the Marketplace,” in Consumer Culture Theory, ArnoldE. J.ThompsonC. J., eds. Sage Publications, 19‐39.
98.
SchauHope J.MuñizAlbert M.ArnouldEric J. (2009), “How Brand Community Practices Create Value,” Journal of Marketing, 73 (5), 30‐51.
99.
SchumpeterJoseph A. (1942), Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy. Routledge.
100.
SharmaPiyushJainKokilKingshottRussell P. J.UenoAkiko (2020), “Customer Engagement and Relationships in Multi-Actor Service Systems,” Journal of Business Research, 121, 487‐494.
101.
ShethJagdish N.NewmanBruce I.GrossBarbara L. (1991), Consumption Values and Market Choices: Theory and Applications. South-Western Publishing.
102.
SiddikeMd Abul KalamHidakaKazuyoshiKohdaYouji (2021), “Technology as Actors in Service Systems,” in 53rd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 1030‐1039.
103.
SpielmannNathalieMantonakisAntonia (2018), “In Virtuo: How User-driven Interactivity in Virtual Tours Leads to Attitude Change,” Journal of Business Research, 88, 255‐264.
104.
SpradleyJames P. (1980), Participant Observation. Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
105.
SrinivasanRajiLilienGary L.RangaswamyArnvid (2004), “First In, First Out? The Effects of Network Externalities on Pioneer Survival,” Journal of Marketing, 68 (1), 41‐58.
106.
StraussAnselmCorbinJuliet (1998), Basics of Qualitative Research. Sage Publications, Inc.
107.
SwaminathanVanithaSorescuAlinaSteenkampJan-BenedictO’GuinnThomas C. G.SchmittRobert (2020), “Branding in a Hyperconnected World: Refocusing Theories and Rethinking Boundaries,” Journal of Marketing, 84 (2), 24‐46.
108.
ThompsonBob (2015), “Innovation in Property Management,” Journal of Property Investment & Finance, 33 (5), 436‐445.
109.
TurnerVictor (1969), “Liminality and Communitas,” in The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. edited by Turner, Victor, Roger Abrahams, and Alfred Harris. Cornell University Press, 4‐130.
110.
TuzovicSven (2009), “Key Determinants of Real Estate Service Quality Among Renters and Buyers,” Journal of Services Marketing, 23 (7), 496‐507.
111.
UllahFahimSepasgozarSamad M.WangChangxin (2018), “A Systematic Review of Smart Real Estate Technology: Drivers of and Barriers to the Use of Digital Disruptive Technologies and Online Platforms,” Sustainability, 10 (3142), 1‐44.
112.
Van LaerTom,FeiereisenStephanieViscontiLuca M. (2019), “Storytelling in the Digital Era: A Meta-Analysis of Relevant Moderators of the Narrative Transportation Effect,” Journal of Business Research, 96, 135‐146.
113.
VargoStephen L. (2018), “Situating Humans, Technology and Materiality in Value Cocreation,” Journal of Creating Value, 4 (2), 202‐204.
114.
VargoStephen L.AkakaMelissa ArchpruWielandHeiko (2020), “Rethinking the Process of Diffusion in Innovation: A Service-Ecosystems and Institutional Perspective,” Journal of Business Research, 116, 526‐534.
115.
VargoStephen L.LuschRobert F. (2008), “Service-Dominant Logic: Continuing the Evolution,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36, 1-10.
116.
VargoStephen L.LuschRobert F. (2016), “Institutions and Axioms: An Extension and Update of Service-Dominant Logic,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 44 (1), 5‐23.
117.
VargoStephen L.WielandHeikoAkakaMelissa Archpru (2015), “Innovation Through Institutionalization: A Service Ecosystems Perspective,” Industrial Marketing Management, 44, 63‐72.
WatsonForrestWuYinglu (2022), “The Impact of Online Reviews on the Information Flows and Outcomes of Marketing Systems,” Journal of Macromarketing, 42 (1), 146‐164.
120.
WielandHeikoHartmannNathaniel N.VargoStephen L. (2017), “Business Models as Service Strategy,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 45, 925‐943.
121.
WilliamsJanineDaveyJanetJohnstoneMicael-Lee (2021), “Marketing System Failure: Revisioning Layton’s Marketing System Model,” Journal of Macromarketing, 41 (2), 411‐426.
122.
WirtzJochenZeithamlValerie (2018), “Cost-Effective Service Excellence,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 46 (1), 59‐80.
123.
WooliscroftBen (2021), “Macromarketing and the Systems Imperative,” Journal of Macromarketing, 41 (1), 116‐123.
124.
WooliscroftBenGanglmair-WooliscroftAlexandra (2018), “Growth, Excess and Opportunities: Marketing Systems’ Contributions to Society,” Journal of Macromarketing, 38 (4), 355‐363.
125.
YimMark Y.ChuShu-ChuanSauerPaul L. (2017), “Is Augmented Reality Technology an Effective Tool for E-commerce? An Interactivity and Vividness Perspective,” Journal of Interactive Marketing, 39 (1), 89‐103.
126.
YuBoVahidovRustamKerstenGregory E. (2021), “Acceptance of Technological Agency: Beyond the Perception of Utilitarian Value,” Information & Management, 58 (7), 103503.
127.
YuWeiMaZhongmingPantGautamHuJing (2020), “The Effect of Virtual Tours on House Price and Time on Market,” Journal of Real Estate Literature, 28 (2), 133‐149.
128.
ZainuddinNadiaDentKendallTamLeona (2017), “Seek or Destroy? Examining Value Creation and Destruction in Behaviour Maintenance in Social Marketing,” Journal of Marketing Management, 33 (5-6), 348‐374.
129.
ZhaoShanyang (2022), “Human Agency and Social Structure: From the Evolutionary Perspective,” Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 53 (3), 473‐493.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
