The overcompensation thesis posits that men react to gender insecurities by demonstrating their masculinity in extreme ways, some of which include highly gendered forms of consumer behavior known as male compensatory consumption. Though such consumption can be relatively benign, even healthy and positive, several forms of male compensatory behavior might harm public safety, the environment, and social accord. Support for the thesis exists, but is not overwhelming and further research is needed. This article approaches compensatory consumption in the United States from a historical perspective. It presents evidence from four separate periods – circa 1900, the 1930s, the 1950s, and circa 2000 – showing cultural continuities and change in the meaning of masculinity, but also similarities and differences in the perceived threats, the groups of men most affected, and their responses. These historical findings provide macromarketing insights into the societal consequences of market behavior.
AbbottPhilip (2006), “Titans/Planners, Bohemians/Revolutionaries: Male Empowerment in the 1930s,” Journal of American Studies, 40 (3), 463–85.
2.
AndersonEric (2009), Inclusive Masculinity: The Changing Nature of Masculinities. New York: Routledge.
3.
ArmengolJosep M. (2014), “Gendering the Great Depression: Rethinking the Male Body in 1930s American Culture and Literature,” Journal of Gender Studies, 23 (1), 59–68.
4.
AtwanRobertMcQuadeDonaldWrightJohn W. (1979), Edsels, Luckies, & Frigidaires: Advertising the American Way. New York: Dell Publishing Company.
5.
AudSusanHussarWilliamJohnsonFrankKenaGraceRothErinManningEileenWantXiaoleiZhangJijun (2012), The Condition of Education. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Educational Statistics, (accessed March 21, 2018), [available athttp://nces.ed.gov/pubs2012/2012045.pdf].
6.
BakkeE. Wight (1940), Citizens Without Work: A Study of the Effects of Unemployment upon the Workers’ Social Relations and Practices. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
7.
BanduraAlbert (1986), Social Foundations of Thought and Action: A Social Cognitive Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
8.
BedermanGail (1995), Manliness and Civilization: A Cultural History of Gender and Race in the United States, 1880-1917. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
9.
BelewKathleen (2018), Bring the War Home: The White Power Movement and Paramilitary America. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
10.
BelkRussell W.CostaJaneen (1998), “The Mountain Man Myth: A Contemporary Consuming Fantasy,” Journal of Consumer Research, 25 (December), 218–40.
BrannonRobert (1976), “The Male Sex Role: Our Culture’s Blueprint of Manhood, and What It’s Done for Us Lately,” in The Forty-Nine Percent Majority, DavisDeborah S.BrannonRobert, eds. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1–45.
13.
BreazealeKenon (1994), “In Spite of Women: Esquire Magazine and the Construction of the Male Consumer,” Signs, 20 (1), 1–22.
14.
BroughAaron R.WilkieJames E. B.MaJingjingIsaacMathew S.GalDavid (2016), “Is Eco-Friendly Unmanly? The Green-Feminine Stereotype and Its Effect on Sustainable Consumption,” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (4), 567–82.
15.
BurbickJoan (2006), Gun Show Nation: Gun Culture and American Democracy. New York: The New Press.
16.
BurnettLeo (1958), “The Marlboro Story,” The New Yorker, (November 15), 41–43.
ConnellR. W. (2005), Masculinities, 2nd ed. Berkeley: University of California Press.
19.
ConnellR. W.MesserschmidtJames W. (2005), “Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept,” Gender and Society, 19 (6), 829–59.
20.
CourtenayWill H. (2000), “Constructions of Masculinity and Their Influence on Men’s Well-Being: A Theory of Gender and Health,” Social Science & Medicine, 50 (10), 1385–401.
21.
CoxAmy Ann (2007), “Aiming for Manhood: The Transformation of Guns into Objects of American Masculinity,” in Open Fire: Understanding Global Gun Cultures, SpringwoodCharles Fruehling, ed. Oxford, UK: Berg, 141–52.
22.
CuordileoneK. A. (2000), “‘Politics in an Age of Anxiety’: Cold War Political Culture and the Crisis of American Masculinity, 1949 – 1960,” The Journal of American History, 87 (2), 515–45.
23.
DavidsonDebra J.FreudenburgWilliam R. (1996), “Gender and Environmental Risk Concerns: A Review and Analysis of Available Research,” Environment and Behavior, 28 (3), 302–39.
24.
EhrenreichBarbara (1983), The Hearts of Men: American Dreams and the Flight from Commitment. New York: Anchor Books/Doubleday.
GilbertJames (2005), Men in the Middle: Searching for Masculinity in the 1950s. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
27.
GordonRobert J. (2016), The Rise and Fall of American Growth: The U.S. Standard of Living Since the Civil War. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
28.
GrayJohn (1992), Men Are from Mars, Women Are from Venus: A Practical Guide for Improving Communications and Getting What You Want in Your Relationships. New York: HarperCollins.
29.
GreenHarvey (1986), Fit for America: Health, Fitness, Sport, and American Society. New York: Pantheon Books.
30.
GrunertSuzanne C. (1994), “On Gender Differences in Eating Behavior as Compensatory Consumption,” in Gender Issues and Consumer Behavior, CostaJaneen Arnold, ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 63–83.
31.
HaagPamela (2016), The Gunning of America: Business and the Making of American Gun Culture. New York: Basic Books.
32.
HaleGrace Elizabeth (1998), Making Whiteness: The Culture of Segregation in the South, 1890-1940. New York: Pantheon Books.
33.
HantoverJeffrey P. (1978), “The Boy Scouts and the Validation of Masculinity,” Journal of Social Issues, 34 (1), 184–95.
34.
HerlihyDavid V. (2004), Bicycle: The History. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
35.
HillRonald PaulHirschmanElizabeth C.BaumanJohn F. (1997), “Consumer Survival During the Great Depression: Reports from the Field,” Journal of Macromarketing, 17 (Spring), 107–27.
36.
HirschmanElizabeth C. (2003), “Men, Dogs, Guns, and Cars: The Semiotics of Rugged Individualism,” Journal of Advertising, 32 (1), 9–22.
37.
HogansonKristin L. (1998), Fighting for American Manhood: How Gender Politics Provoked the Spanish-American and Philippine-American Wars. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
38.
HollanderStanley C.RassuliKathleen M.Brian JonesD. G.DixLaura F. (2005), “Periodization in Marketing History,” Journal of Macromarketing, 25 (June), 32–41.
39.
HoltDouglas B.ThompsonCraig J. (2004), “Man-of-Action Heroes: The Pursuit of Heroic Masculinity in Everyday Consumption,” Journal of Consumer Research, 31 (2), 425–40.
40.
HumphreysAshlee (2010), “Semiotic Structure and the Legitimation of Consumption Practices: The Case of Casino Gambling,” Journal of Consumer Research, 37 (3), 490–510.
41.
Journal of the American Medical Association (1908), “Truth’s Cautionary List,” 50 (13), (March 28), 1065–66.
42.
KimmelMichael S. (1994a), “Consuming Manhood: The Feminization of American Culture and the Recreation of the American Male Body, 1832-1920,” Michigan Quarterly Review, 33 (1), 7–36.
43.
KimmelMichael S. (1994b), “Masculinity as Homophobia: Fear, Shame, and Silence in the Construction of Gender Identity,” in Theorizing Masculinities, BrodHarryKaufmanMichael, eds. Newbury Park, CA: Sage, 119–41.
44.
KimmelMichael S. (1996), Manhood in America: A Cultural History. New York: The Free Press.
45.
KimmelMichael S. (2013), Angry White Men: American Masculinity at the End of an Era. New York: Nation Books.
46.
KingC. Richard (2007), “Arming Desire: The Sexual Force of Guns in the United States,” in Open Fire: Understanding Global Gun Cultures, SpringwoodCharles Fruehling, ed. Oxford, UK: Berg, 87–97.
47.
KomarovskyMirra (1940), The Unemployed Man and His Family—The Effect of Unemployment Upon the Status of the Man in Fifty-Nine Families. New York: The Dryden Press.
48.
LairdPamela Walker (1998), Advertising Progress: American Business and the Rise of Consumer Marketing. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
49.
LearsJackson (1994), Fables of Abundance: A Cultural History of Advertising in America. New York: Basic Books.
MarchandRoland (1985), Advertising the American Dream: Making Way for Modernity, 1920-1940. Berkeley: University of California Press.
52.
MatthewsKristin L. (2009), “One Nation Over Coals: Cold War Nationalism and the Barbecue,” American Studies, 50 (3/4), 5–34.
53.
McCrackenGrant (1986), “Culture and Consumption: A Theoretical Account of the Structure and Movement of the Cultural Meaning of Consumer Goods,” Journal of Consumer Research, 13 (June), 71–84.
54.
McElvaineRobert S. (1984), The Great Depression: America, 1929-1941. New York: Times Books.
55.
MenckenF. CarsonFroesePaul (2019), “Gun Culture in Action,” Social Problems, 66 (1), 3–27.
56.
MillsC. Wright (1951), White Collar: The American Middle Classes. New York: Oxford University Press.
57.
MoisioRistoArnouldEric J.GentryJames W. (2013), “Productive Consumption in the Class-Mediated Construction of Domestic Masculinity: Do-It-Yourself (DIY) Home Improvement in Men’s Identity Work,” Journal of Consumer Research, 40 (August), 298–316.
58.
MoisioRistoBeruchashviliMariam (2016), “Mancaves and Masculinity,” Journal of Consumer Culture, 16 (3), 656–76.
59.
MoskinJ. Robert (1958), “The American Male: Why Women Dominate Him?” Look, (February 4), 77–80.
60.
NeuhausJessamyn (1999), “The Way to a Man’s Heart: Gender Roles, Domestic Ideology, and Cookbooks in the 1950s,” Journal of Social History, 32 (3), 529–55.
61.
OkrentDaniel (2010), Last Call: The Rise and Fall of Prohibition. New York: Scribner.
62.
OsgerbyBill (2001), Playboys in Paradise: Masculinity, Youth and Leisure-style in Modern America. Oxford, UK: Berg.
63.
PappasStephanie (2019), “APA Issues First-Ever Guidelines for Practice With Men and Boys,” CE Corner, American Psychological Association, 50 (1), 34, (accessed February 16, 2019), [available athttps://www.apa.org/monitor/2019/01/ce-corner].
64.
PettyRoss D. (2019), “PAIN-KILLER: A 19th Century Global Patent Medicine and the Beginnings of Modern Brand Marketing,” Journal of Macromarketing, 39 (3), 287–303.
RotundoE. Anthony (1993), American Manhood: Transformations in Masculinity from the Revolution to the Modern Era. New York: Basic Books.
71.
RozinPaulHormesJulia M.FaithMyles S.WansinkBrian (2012), “Is Meat Male? A Quantitative Multimethod Framework to Establish Metaphoric Relationships,” Journal of Consumer Research, 39, 629–43.
72.
SchlesingerArthurJr (1958), “The Crisis of American Masculinity,” Esquire, (November 1), 65–67.
73.
SchoutenJohn W.McAlexanderJames H. (1995), “Subcultures of Consumption: An Ethnography of the New Bikers,” Journal of Consumer Research, 22 (June), 43–61.
74.
SewellWilliam H.Jr (2005), Logics of History: Social Theory and Social Transformation. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
ShepherdStephenKayAaron C. (2018), “Guns as a Source of Order and Chaos: Compensatory Control and the Psychological (Dis)Utility of Guns for Liberals and Conservatives,” Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 3 (1), 16–26.
77.
SlotkinRichard (1992), Gunfighter Nation: The Myth of the Frontier in Twentieth-Century America. New York: Antheneum.
78.
SobalJeffery (2005), “Men, Meat, and Marriage: Models of Masculinity,” Food and Foodways, 13 (1/2), 135–58.
79.
SpellmanSusan V. (2016), Cornering the Market: Independent Grocers and Innovation in American Small Business. New York: Oxford University Press.
StreteskyPaul B.PogrebinMark R. (2007), “Gang-Related Gun Violence: Socialization, Identity, and Self,” Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 36 (1), 85–114.
83.
StroudAngela (2012), “Good Guys with Guns: Hegemonic Masculinity and Concealed Handguns,” Gender and Society, 26 (2), 216–38.
84.
SwiencickiMark A. (1998), “Consuming Brotherhood: Men’s Culture, Style and Recreation as Consumer Culture, 1880-1930,” Journal of Social History, 31 (4), 773–808.
85.
TabuchiHiroko (2016), “‘Rolling Coal’ in Diesel Trucks, to Rebel and Provoke,” The New York Times, (September 5), A1, A11.
86.
TaylorJimmy D. (2009), American Gun Culture: Collectors, Shows and the Story of the Gun. El Paso, TX: LFB Scholarly Publishing LLC.
TwitchellJames B.RossKenneth Charles (2006), Where Men Hide. New York: Columbia University Press.
89.
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2007), “Changes in Men’s and Women’s Labor Force Participation Rates,” TED: The Economics Daily, (January 10), (accessed April 22, 2018), [available athttps://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2007/jan/wk2/art03.htm].
90.
U.S. Bureau of the Census (1975), Tables D 49-62, Historical Statistics of the United States, Colonial Times to the Present. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
WhiteCameronOliffeJohn L.BottorffJoan L. (2012), “From the Physician to the Marlboro Man: Masculinity, Health, and Cigarette Advertising in America, 1946-1964,” Men and Masculinities, 15 (5), 526–47.
96.
WhyteWilliam H. (1956), The Organization Man. New York: Simon & Schuster.
97.
WillerRobbConlonBridgetRogalinChristabel L.WojnowiczMichael T. (2013), “Overdoing Gender: A Test of the Masculine Overcompensation Thesis,” American Journal of Sociology, 118 (4), 980–1022.
98.
WinklerAdam (2011), Gun Fight: The Battle Over the Right to Bear Arms in America. New York: W.W. Norton & Company.
99.
WintemuteGaren J. (2007), “Gun Shows Across a Multistate American Gun Market: Observational Evidence of the Effects of Regulatory Policies,” Injury Prevention, 13 (3), 150–55.
100.
WintemuteGaren J. (2009), Inside Gun Shows: What Goes on When Everybody Thinks Nobody’s Watching. Sacramento, CA: Violence Prevention Research Program, UC Davis School of Medicine, (accessed March 21, 2018), [available athttps://www.ucdmc.ucdavis.edu/vprp/pdf/IGS/IGScoverprefweb.pdf].
101.
WitkowskiTerrence H. (2003), “World War II Poster Campaigns: Preaching Frugality to American Consumers,” Journal of Advertising, 32 (Spring), 69–82.
102.
WitkowskiTerrence H. (2013), “The Visual Politics of U.S. Gun Culture,” in Research in Consumer Behavior, Vol. 15, BelkRussell W.PriceLindaPeñalozaLiza, eds. Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited, 3–23.
103.
WoodruffeHelen R. (1997), “Compensatory Consumption: Why Women Go Shopping When They’re Fed Up and Other Stories,” Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 15 (7), 325–34.
104.
WyliePhilip (1958), “The Womanization of America,” Playboy, 5, 51–52, 77–79.
105.
YamaneDavid (2017), “The Sociology of U.S. Gun Culture,” Sociology Compass, 11 (7), 1–10.
106.
YamaneDavidIvorySebastian L.YamanePaul C. (2019), “The Rise of Self-Defense in Gun Advertising: The American Rifleman, 1918-2017,” in Gun Studies: Interdisciplinary Approaches to Politics, Policy, and Practice, CarlsonJenniferGossKristin A.ShapiraHarel, eds. New York: Routledge, 9–27.
107.
YoungWilliam H.YoungNancy K. (2002), The 1930s. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
