Distributive justice, the fair apportioning of benefits and costs, is a social performance criterion in marketing and in organizational and other social contexts. In determining what is more or less just or fair, conflicts arise because of differing perspectives. Benefit-cost analysis offers an appropriate framework and method for evaluating and resolving these conflicts. This article examines several macromarketing issues, and policy alternatives are identified and evaluated. Some correctives that intuitively promise better outcomes, after more careful analysis, may not be more just. However, the principal contribution here is to demonstrate how the lens of benefit-cost analysis can aid in assessing both existing inequities and the effects of interventions intended to correct them. Finally, the limitations and implications of this approach to addressing this aspect of market performance are discussed.
Adolphson, Donald L.2004. A new perspective on ethics, ecology, and economics . Journal of Business Ethics54 (3): 203—16.
2.
Alexander, Sheldon, and Marion Ruderman .1983. The influence of procedural and distributive justice on organizational behavior. ERIC Paper ED239132 presented to theAmerican Psychological Association, Anaheim, CA.
3.
———. 1987. The role of procedural and distributive justice in organizational behavior. Social Justice Research1 (2): 177—98.
4.
Avtonomov, Vladiir.2006. Balancing state, market, and social Justice: Russian experiences and lessons to learn. Journal of Business Ethics66 (1): 3—9.
5.
Bain, Joe S.1958. Industrial organization. New York: John Wiley.
6.
Baker, Stacey M., James W. Gentry, and Terri L. Rittenburg .2005. Building understanding of the domain of consumer vulnerability. Journal of Macromarketing25 (2): 128—39.
7.
Beattie, Alan2006. Follow the thread. Financial Times , July 22—23, W1—W2.
8.
Beauchamp, Tom L., and Norman E. Bowie, eds. 2004. Ethical theory and business . 7th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.
9.
Beaulieu, Suzanne, and Jean Pasquero.2002. Reintroducing stakeholder dynamics in stakeholder thinking: A negotiated-order perspective. Journal of Corporate Citizenship6 (Summer): 53—69.
10.
Brat, Ilan, and Timothy Aeppel.2007. Why Deere is weeding out dealers even as farms boom. Wall Street Journal, August 14, A1,A10.
11.
Brenkert, George.1998. Marketing and the vulnerable. Business Ethics Quarterly (Ruffin Series 1): 7—20.
12.
Buchholz, Rogene A.1998. The ethics of consumption activities: A future paradigm?Journal of Business Ethics17 (8): 871—82.
13.
Bunderson, J. Stuart.2001. Normal injustices and morality in complex organizations . Journal of Business Ethics33 (3): 181—90.
14.
Cappelen, Alexander W., Astri D. Hole, Erik O. Sorensen, and Bertil Tungodden .2007. The pluralism of fairness ideals: An experimental approach. American Economic Review97 (3): 818—27.
15.
Carroll, Daniel J., and Steven J. Weber .2004. Evaluation report: EPA needs to consistently implement the intent of the Executive Order on Environmental Justice. Report 2004-P-00007. Washington, DC: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
16.
Choi, Chong J., Tarek I. Eldomiaty, and Sae W. Kim .2007. Consumer trust, social marketing, and ethics of welfare exchange. Journal of Business Ethics74 (1): 17—23.
17.
Christensen, Sandra L., and Brian Grinder.2001. Justice and financial market allocation of the social costs of business. Journal of Business Ethics29 (1—2): 105—12.
18.
Churchman, C. West.1968. The systems approach. New York : Dell.
19.
Davis, Joel J.1992. Ethics and environmental marketing. Journal of Business Ethics11 (2): 81—87.
20.
DeCremer, David, Marius van Dijke, and Arian E. R. Bos .2007. When leaders Are seen as transformational: The effects of organizational justice. Journal of Applied Social Psychology37 (8): 1797—1816.
21.
DeGeorge, Richard T.2006. Business ethics. 6th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.
22.
Dolan, Catherine S., and Maggie Opondo.2005. Seeking common ground: Multi-stakeholder processes in Kenya's cut flower industry. Journal of Corporate Citizenship18 (Summer): 87—98.
23.
Donaldson, Thomas, and Thomas W. Dunfee .1999. Ties that bind: A social contracts approach to business ethics. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
24.
Dowie, Mark.1977. Pinto madness. Mother Jones (September—October). http://www.motherjones.com/news/feature/1977/09/dowie.html (accessed July 15, 2007).
25.
Dumas, Chris, and Troy Schmitz.1995. Measuring the impact of environmental regulations . American Journal of Agricultural Economics77 (5): 1172—76.
26.
Ebert, Udo, and Heinz Welsch.2007. Environmental emissions and production economics: Implications of the materials balance. American Journal of Agricultural Economics89 (2): 287—93.
27.
Edmunds, Stahrl W.1972. Market failure in the environment. In Marketing education and the real world/Dynamic marketing in a changing world , ed. Boris W. and Helmut Becker, 208—12. Chicago: American Marketing Association.
28.
Elkington, John.2006. The triple bottom line. In The accountable corporation, Vol. 3 of Corporate social responsibility, ed. Marc J. Epstein and Kirk O. Hansen, 97—110. Westport, CT: Praeger .
29.
Epstein, Marc J., and Priscilla S. Wisner .2006. Actions and measures to improve sustainability. In The accountable corporation, Vol. 3 of Corporate social responsibility, ed. Marc J. Epstein and Kirk O. Hansen, 207—34. Westport, CT: Praeger.
30.
Etzioni, Amitai.1988. The moral dimension: Toward a new economics. New York: Free Press.
31.
Fagothey, Austin.1953. Right and reason: Ethics in theory and practice . St. Louis, MO: C. V. Mosby.
32.
Fisk, George.1973. Criteria for a theory of responsible consumption . Journal of Marketing37 (2): 24—31.
33.
Folger, R., and J. Greenberg.1985. Procedural justice: An interpretive analysis of personnel systems. In Research in personnel and human resources management, Vol. 3, ed. K. Rowland and G. Ferris , 141—83. Greenwich, CT: JAI .
34.
Freeman, R. Edward.1984. Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Boston: Pitman.
35.
Galbraith, John Kenneth.1952. American capitalism: The concept of countervailing power . Boston: Houghton Mifflin .
36.
———. 1983. The anatomy of power. Boston : Houghton Mifflin.
37.
Garrett, Thomas.1966. Business ethics. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
38.
Gilbert, Dirk U., and Andreas Rasche.2007. Discourse ethics and social accountability: The ethics of SA 8000. Business Ethics Quarterly17 (2): 187—216.
39.
Graddy, Kathryn, and Diana C. Robertson .1999. Fairness of pricing decisions . Business Ethics Quarterly9 (2): 225—43.
40.
Greenberg, Jerald.1987. A taxonomy of organizational justice theories. Academy of Management Review12 (1): 9—22.
41.
———. 1990. Organizational justice: Yesterday, today, and tomorrow . Journal of Management16 (2): 399—432.
42.
Guiltinan, Joseph P., and Alan C. Sawyer .2001. Pricing strategy, competition, and consumer welfare. In Handbook of marketing and society , ed. Paul N. Bloom and Gregory T. Gundlach, 232—62. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
43.
Habermas, Juergen.1990. Moral consciousness and communicative action. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
44.
Harris, Robert G., and James M. Carman .1983. Public regulation of marketing activity, part I: Institutional typologies of market failure. Journal of Macromarketing3 (1): 49—58.
45.
Hoffman, W. Michael.1991. Business and environmental ethics. Business Ethics Quarterly1 (2): 169—84.
46.
Holliday, Ian.2005. Doing business with rights violating regimes: Corporate social responsibility and Myanmar's military junta. Journal of Business Ethics61 (4): 329—42.
47.
Hosmer, LaRue T., and Christian Kiewitz .1995. Organizational justice: A behavioral science concept with critical implications for business ethics and stakeholder theory. Business Ethics Quarterly15 (1): 67—91.
48.
Hsieh, Nien-he.2004. The obligations of transnational corporations: Rawlsian justice and the duty of assistance. Business Ethics Quarterly14 (4): 643—61.
49.
Husted, Bryan W.1998. Organizational justice and the management of stakeholder relations. Journal of Business Ethics17 (6): 643—51.
50.
Jackson, Kevin T.1993. Global distributive justice and the corporate duty to aid. Journal of Business Ethics12 (7): 547—51.
51.
Johnston, David C.2007. Income gap is widening, data shows. New York Times, March 29. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/29/business/29tax.html?adxnnl=1&adxnnlx=1191080553-c32rPmGE1hY/Ee+NafFvhA (accessed September 29, 2007).
52.
Kapp, K. William.1950. The social costs of private enterprise. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
53.
Kennelly, Arthur, and Edmund Fantino.2007. The sharing game: Fairness in resource allocation as a function of incentive, gender, and recipient types. Judgment and Decision Making2 (3): 204—16.
54.
Kilbourne, William E., Pierre McDonough, and Andrea Prothero .1997. Sustainable consumption and the quality of life: A macromarketing challenge to the dominant social paradigm . Journal of Macromarketing17 (1): 4—24.
55.
Klein, Thomas A.1977. Social costs and benefits of business. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
56.
———. 1987. Prophets and profits—A macromarketing perspective on “Economic justice for all: Catholic social teaching and the U.S. economy.”Journal of Macromarketing7 (1): 59—77.
57.
———. 2002. Justice in the food chain: Balancing benefits and costs in supply networks. In Macromarketing in the Asia Pacific century , ed. Jack Cadeaux and Anthony Pecotich, 136—39. Sydney, Australia: University of New South Wales.
58.
Klein, Thomas A., and Robert W. Nason .2001. Marketing and development: Macromarketing perspectives. In Handbook of marketing and society , ed. Paul N. Bloom and Gregory T. Gundlach, 263—97. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
59.
Kung, Hans.1999. A global ethic in an age of globalization. In International business ethics: Challenges and approaches, ed. Georges Enderle, 109—28. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
60.
Lee, Matthew T., and M. David Ermann .1999. Social Problems46 (1): 30—47.
61.
Li, Haiyang, John B. Bingham, and Elizabeth E. Umphress .2007. Fairness from the top: Perceived procedural justice and collaborative problem solving in new product development . Organization Science18 (2): 200—216.
62.
Lindsey-Mullikin, Joan, and Dhruv Grewal.2006. Imperfect information: The persistence of price dispersion on the web. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science34 (2): 236—43.
63.
Logsdon, Jeanne M.2004. Global business citizenship: Applications to environmental issues. Business and Society Review109 (1): 67—87.
64.
Luo, Yadong.2007. The independent and interactive roles of procedural, distributive, and interactional justice in strategic alliances. Academy of Management Journal56 (3): 644—64.
65.
Malone, David, and Susanna Goodin.1997. An analysis of U.S. disinvestment from South Africa: Unity, rights, and justice. Journal of Business Ethics16 (16): 1687—1703.
66.
Marcoux, Alexei.2006. Much ado about price discrimination. Journal of Markets and Morality9 (1): 57—69.
67.
Meyerson, Harold.2007. Can free trade be a fair deal?Washington Post, February 22, A19.
68.
Michel, Christian.1999. What is a just price?Journal of Markets and Morality2 (2): 182—96.
69.
Mishan, Ezra J.1971. Cost-benefit analysis. London : Allen & Unwin.
70.
Moore, Geoff, Jane Gibbon, and Richard Slack.2006. The mainstreaming of fair trade: A macromarketing perspective . Journal of Strategic Marketing14 (4): 329—52.
71.
Morrison, Catherine.1991. Managing environmental affairs: Corporate practices in the U.S., Canada, and Europe. New York: Conference Board.
72.
Morrison, Kevin.2006. The conscience of the consumer. Financial Times, October9, 8.
73.
Murphy, Patrick E., Gene R. Laczniak, Norman E. Bowie, and Thomas A. Klein .2005. Ethical marketing. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.
74.
Nill, Alexander.2003. Global marketing ethics: A communicative approach . Journal of Macromarketing23 (2): 90—105.
75.
Nozick, Robert.1974. Anarchy, state, and utopia. New York : Basic Books.
76.
Organ, Dennis W., and Robert H. Moorman .1993. Fairness and organizational citizenship behaviors: What are the connections?Social Justice Research6 (1): 5—18.
77.
Oyewole, Philemon.2001. Social costs of environmental justice associated with the practice of green marketing. Journal of Business Ethics29 (3): 239—51.
78.
Pearlstein, Steven.2006. Of public debt and private wealth. Washington Post, December 27, D1.
79.
Perrow, Charles B.1984. Normal accidents: Living with high risk technologies . New York: Basic Books.
80.
Pfeifer, Christian.2007. The perceived fairness of layoffs in Germany: Participation, compensation, or avoidance?Journal of Business Ethics74 (1): 25—36.
81.
Prieto-Carron, Marina.2006. Corporate social responsibility in Latin America . Journal of Corporate Citizenship21 (Summer): 85—94.
82.
Rawls, John.1971. A theory of justice. Cambridge, MA : Belknap.
83.
Ray, Debraj.1998. Development economics. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press.
84.
Rich, Arthur.2004. Business and economic ethics: The ethics of economic systems. Leuven, Belgium: Peeters.
85.
Schall, James V.2004. Justice: The most terrible of the virtues. Journal of Markets and Morality7 (2): 409—21.
86.
Seiders, Kathleen, and Leonard L. Berry .1998. Service fairness: What it is and why it matters. Academy of Management Executive12 (2): 8—20.
87.
Sen, Amartya.1987. On ethics and economics. New York: Basil Blackwell.
88.
Shafer, William E.2006. Social paradigms and attitudes toward environmental accountability . Journal of Business Ethics65 (2): 121—47.
89.
Singer, Peter.1979. Practical ethics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
90.
Solum, Leonard.2004. Procedural justice. Legal Working Paper Series 1001. San Diego, CA: University of San Diego, School of Law .
91.
Sosnick, Stephen H.1964. Operational criteria for evaluating market performance . In Market structure research, ed. Paul L. Farris, 81—125. Ames: Iowa State University Press.
92.
Svendsen, Ann C., and Myriam Laberge.2005. Convening stakeholder networks: A new way of thinking, being, and engaging. Journal of Corporate Citizenship19 (Autumn): 91—104.
93.
Valor, Carmen.2006. What if all trade was fair trade? The potential of a social clause to achieve the goals of fair trade. Journal of Strategic Marketing14 (3): 263—75.
94.
Van Buren, Harry J., III.2001. Corporate citizenship and the obligations of fairness. Journal of Corporate Citizenship1 (Autumn): 55—62.
95.
Vann, John W., and Erdogan Kumcu.1995. Achieving efficiency and distributive justice in marketing programs for economic development. Journal of Macromarketing15 (2): 5—22.
96.
Varble, Dale L.1972. Social and environmental considerations in new product development. Journal of Marketing36 (4): 11—15.
97.
Viswanathan, Siva, Jason Kurozovich, Sanjay Gosain, and Ritu Agarwal.2007. Online infomediaries and price discrimination: Evidence from the automotive retailing sector. Journal of Marketing71 (3): 89—107.
98.
Wade, Robert H.2004. Is globalization reducing poverty and inequality?World Development32 (4): 567—89.
99.
Weakland, Rembert G., Thomas Donellan, George Speltz , William Weigand, and Peter Rosazza .1986. Economic justice for all: Catholic social teaching and the U.S. economy. Origins16 (June 5): 33—76.
100.
Wong, Alan, and Uric Dufrene.2001. A model to assess the ethics of benefits distribution . Journal of Markets and Morality4 (1): 73—82.
101.
Wood, David.1994. Business justice: Transactions, resources, and organizations . Journal of Business Ethics13 (6): 481—86.
102.
Zikmund, William G., and William J. Stanton .1971. Recycling solid wastes: A channels-of-distribution problem. Journal of Marketing35 (3): 34—39.
103.
Zuniga, Gloria.1998. Truth in economic subjectivism. Journal of Markets and Morality1 (2): 158—68.
