Still not Developing after all these Years? The Intra-Organizational Role of Public Personnel Departments

Abstract

According to prominent but dated research, public personnel departments do not effectively serve the needs of intraorganizational stakeholders, such as management, supervisors, and employees. Researchers have found that stakeholders, facing high public demands for service but constrained by limited revenues, want help from their personnel departments to improve performance. Personnel departments, however, remain too entrenched in their traditional oversight role to respond to these demands effectively.

However, such research is quite dated-it was conducted more than ten years ago, and more recent research in the private sector and methodological considerations suggest that those findings may no longer be, if they ever were, accurate. Meanwhile, revenue constraints and service demands have intensified, and public service employment is undergoing fundamental changes, making the role of the personnel department in meeting stakeholder demands more critical. Relying on a quantitative analysis of 26 North Carolina county personnel departments, this paper finds that previous depictions of stakeholder demands may be inaccurate. Furthermore, it suggests that personnel departments are more responsive to those demands than has heretofore been found but that the stakeholders are not oriented to improving organizational performance.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barzelay, M. , & Armajani, B. J. (1990). Managing state government operations: Changing visions of staff agencies. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 9 (Autumn), 307-338.

Hayes, S. W. (1989). Environmental change and the personnel function: A review of the research. Public Personnel Management, 18 (2), 110-126.

Katz, D. , & Kahn, R. L. (1978). The social psychology of organizations. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

Klingner, D. E. , & Nalbandian, Jr. (1978). Personnel management by whose objectives? Public Administration Review, 38 (July-August), 366-372.

Levine, C. H. , & Nigro, L. G. (1975). The public personnel system: Can juridical administration and manpower management coexist? Public Administration Review, 35 (January-February), 98-107.

McGregor, E. B., Jr. (1989). The public sector human resource puzzle: Strategic management of a strategic resource. Public Administration Review, 18 (2), 110-126.

Mitroff, I. (1983). Stakeholders of the organization mind. San Francisco: Jossey Bass Publishers.

Nalbandian, J. (1982). From compliance to consultation: The changing role of the public personnel administrator. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 1 (Spring), 37-51.

Nalbandian, J. , & Klingner, D. E. (1980). Integrating context and decision strategy. Administration and Society, 12 (6), 178-202.

10.

Newland, C. A. (1976). Public personnel administration: Legalistic reforms vs. effectiveness, efficiency, and economy. Public Administration Review, 36 (September-October), 529-536.

11.

Perrow, C. S. (1979). Complex organizations: A critical essay (2nd Ed.). Glenview, IL: Scott Foresman.

12.

Pfeffer, J. , & Salancik, G. R. (1978). The external control of organizations: A resource dependence perspective. New York: Harper and Row.

13.

Rainey, H. G. , Backoff, R. W. , & Levine, C. H. (1983). Comparing public and private organizations. In H. G. Rainey , R. W. Backoff , & C. H. Levine (Eds.), Public management: Public and private perspectives (pp. 93-108). Palo Alto: Mayfield Publishing Company.

14.

Savas, E. S. , & Ginsburg, S. G. (1973). The civil service: A meritless system? The Public Interest, 32 (Summer), 70-84.

15.

Scott, W. G. (1979). Organicism: The moral anesthetic of management. Academy of Management Review, 4 (January), 21-28.

16.

Shafritz, J. M. (1974). The cancer eroding public personnel professionalism. Public Personnel Management, 3 (November-December), 486-492.

17.

Straus, S. K. (1991). Multiple constituencies activities and standards: A framework for evaluating the effectiveness of public personnel departments. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 11 (Spring), 55-70.

18.

Thompson, J. D. (1967). Organizations in action. New York: McGraw Hill.

19.

Tsui, A. S. (1990). A multiple constituency model of effectiveness: An empirical examination at the human resource subunit level. Administrative Science Quarterly, 40 (September), 458-483.

20.

Tsui, A. S. , & Milkovich, G. T. (1987). Personnel department activities: Constituency perspectives and preferences. Personnel Psychology, 40 (Autumn), 519-537.