There are few public programs which have escaped the vagaries of the economy and concomitant funding priorities. As a result, traditional strategies for public administration appear to be less cogent. A new vision in administrative approach is needed to address the realities of cutbacks. This paper discusses why innovative public administration methods are appropriate to the current and future context. A contingency perspective suggests an improved capability for administering under the prevailing constraints. Next, the process of matching administrative methods with the context is discussed. Fiscal retrenchment is viewed as an opportunity to introduce more substantial incentives for effective public administration. A research agenda is proposed which could clarify the most promising avenues for implementing this concept.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
1Levine, C.H. (1979). "More on Cutback Management: Hard Questions for Hard Times."Public Administration Review39(March/April): 179-183.
2.
2Lewis, C.W., and A.T. Lobalbo (1980). "Cutback Principles and Practices: A Checklist for Managers."Public Administration Review40(March/April): 184-188.
3.
3McTighe, J.J. (1979). "Management Strategies to Deal with Shrinking Resources."Public Administration Review39(January/February): 86-90.
5Bott, D.E. (1979). "Scarcity and Sanity-Can They Co-exist?"Public Personnel Management8(September/October): 305-308.
6.
6Greenhalgh, L., and R. McKersie (1980). "Cost Effectiveness of Alternative Strategies for Cutback Management."Public Administration Review50(November/December): 575-584.
7.
7Johnson, A.T. (1982). "Cutback Strategies and Public Personnel Management: An Analysis of Nine Maryland Counties."Review of Public Personnel Administration3(Fall): 41-55.
8.
8Wilburn, R., and M. Worman (1980). "Overcoming the Limits to Personnel Cutbacks: Lessons Learned in Pennsylvania."Public Administration Review40(November/December): 609-612.
9.
9Murray, M.A. (1975). "Comparing Public and Private Management: An Exploratory Essay."Public Administration Review35(July/August): 365-371.
10.
10Whorton, J.W., and J.A. Worthley (1981). "A Perspective on the Challenge of Public Management: Environmental Paradox and Organizational Culture."Academy of Management Review6: 357-361.
11.
11Jones, G.N. (1982). "Business School Professionals in Public Management: New Issues in Servicing the Public Personnel Function."Review of Public Personnel Administration3(Fall): 21-40.
12.
12Sharp, E.B., and D. Elkins (1987). "The Impact of Fiscal Limitation: A Tale of Seven Cities."Public Administration Review47(September/October): 385-392.
13.
13Eribes, B., and J. Hall (1981). "Revolt of the Affluent: Fiscal Controls in 3 States."Public Administration Review 41 (March/April): 107-121.
14.
14Bozeman, B., and J.D. Straussman (1982). "Shrinking Budgets and the Shrinkage of Budget Theory."Public Administration Review42(November/December): 509-515.
15.
15McGowan, R.P., and J.M. Stevens (1983). "Local Governments' Initiatives in a Climate of Uncertainty."Public Administration Review43(March/April): 127-136.
16.
16Kast, F.E., and J.R. Rosenzweig (1973). Contingency Views of Organization and Management. Palo Alto: Science Research Associates, Inc., p ix.
17.
17Lawrence, P.R., and J.W. Lorsch (1967). Organization and EnvironmentBoston: Harvard University Press, pp. 185-210.
18.
18Burns, T., and G.M. Stalker (1961). The Management of Innovation. London: Tavistock, pp. 119-125.
19.
19Gawthrop, L.C. (1979). "Developing Trends and Challenges in Public Management."Indiana University School of Public and Environmental Review4(Fall): 7-11.
20.
20Gold, K.A. (1982). "Managing for Success: A Comparison of the Private and Public Sectors."Public Administration Review42(November/December): 568-575.
21.
21Bryant, S., and J. Kearns (1982). "Workers' Brains as Well as Their Bodies: Quality Circles in a Federal Facility."Public Administration Review42(March/April): 144-150.
22.
22Denhardt, R.B., J. Pyle, and A.C. Bluedorn (1987). "Implementing Quality Circles in State Government."Public Administration Review47(July/August): 304-309.
23.
23Williams, H.W (1986). "In Search of Bureaucratic Excellence."The Bureaucrat15(Spring): 16-22.
24.
24Lovich, N.P. (1985). "The Dangers of Participative Management: A Test of Unexamined Assumptions Concerning Employee Involvement."Review of Public Personnel Administration5(Summer): 9-25.
25.
25Albritton, R.B., and E.M. Dran (1987). "Balanced Budgets and State Surpluses: The Politics of Budgeting in Illinois."Public Administration Review47(March/April): 143-152.
26.
26Elliott, R.H. (1985). "Personnel Professional and State Employees' Perceptions of Merit System Procedures: What is the Level of Support?"Review of Public Personnel Administration5(Summer): 26-41.
27.
27Spicer, M.W. (1985). "A Public Choice Approach to Motivating People in Bureaucratic Organizations."Academy of Management Review10(July): 518-526.
28.
28Greiner, J.M., H.P. Hatry, M.P. Koss, A.P. Miller, and J.R Woodward (1981). Productivity and Motivation: A Review of State and Local Government Productivity. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.
29.
29Cox, J.H. (1971). "Time and Incentive Pay Practices in Urban Areas."Monthly Labor Review94(December): 53-56.
30.
30Greiner, J.M., L. Bell, H.R. Hatry (1975). Employee Incentives to Improve State and Local Government Productivity. Washington, DC: National Commission on Productivity and Work Quality.
31.
31Morgenstern, M. (1977). "Merit Principle, Civil Service and Collective Bargaining."State Government Administration12(January): 7.
32.
32Deci, E.L. (1972). "The Effects of Contingent and Noncontingent Rewards and Controls on Intrinsic Motivation."Organization Behavior and Human Performance8: 217-229.
33.
33Farr, J.L. (1976). "Task Characteristics, Reward Contingency, and Intrinsic Motivation."Organization Behavior and Human Performance16(August): 294-307.
34.
34Collins, S.R. (1981). "Incentive Programs: Pros and Cons."Personnel Journal60(July): 571-574.
35.
35Deadrick, D.L., and K.D. Scott (1987). "Employee Incentives in the Public Sector: A Rational Survey of Urban Mass Transit Authorities."Public Personnel Management16(Summer): 135-143.
36.
36Ingraham, P.W., and C. Barrilleaux (1983). "Motivating Government Managers for Retrenchment: Some Possible Lessons from the Senior Executive Service."Public Administration Review43(September/October): 393-402.
37.
37Hills, F.S., R.M. Madigan, K.D. Scott, and S.E. Markham (1987). "Tracking the Merit of Merit Pay."Personnel Administrator32(March): 50-57.
38.
38Kopelman, R.E., L. Reinhaith, and A.A. Beer (1983). "The Link Between Judgmental Rewards and Performance."Personnel Administrator28(April): 78-79.
39.
39Perry, J.L., and L.W. Porter (1982). "Factors Affecting the Context for Motivation in Public Organizations."Academy of Management Review7(January): 89-98.
40.
40Perry, J.L. (1986). "Merit Pay in the Public Sector: The Case for a Failure of Theory."Review of Public Personnel Administration7(Spring): 36-53.
41.
41Sherwood, F., and B. Wechsler (1986). "The `Hadacol' of the Eighties: Paying Senior Public Managers for Performance."Review of Public Personnel Administration7(Fall): 27-41.
42.
42Daley, D. (1987). "Merit Pay Enters with a Whimper: The Initial Federal Civil Service Reform Experience."Review of Public Personnel Administration7(Spring): 72-79.
43.
43Thayer, F. (1987). "Performance Appraisal and Merit Pay Systems: The Disasters Multiply."Review of Public Personnel Administration7(Spring): 36-53.
44.
44Danzinger, J.N., and R.S. Ring (1982). "Fiscal Limitations: A Selective Review of Recent Research."Public Administration Review42(January/February): 47-55.
45.
45Latham, G.P., and G.A. Yukla (1975). "A Review of Research on the Application of Goal Setting in Organizations."Academy of Management Journal18(December): 824-825.
46.
46Steers, R.M., and L.W. Porter (1974). "The Role of Task-Goal Attributes in Employee Performance."Psychological Bulletin81: 434-452.
47.
47Brady, R.H. (1973). "MBO Goes to Work in the Public Sector."Harvard Business Review51(March/April): 65-74.
48.
48Malek, F.V. (1974). "Managing for Results in the Federal Government."Business Horizons17: 23-28.
49.
49Raia, A.R. (1965). "Goal Setting and Self-Control."Journal of Management Studies2(February): 34-53.
50.
50Lawler, E.E. (1971). Pay and Organizational Effectiveness: A Psychological View. New York: McGraw-Hill.
51.
51Raia, A.P. (1966). "A Second Look at Management Goals and Control."California Management Review8(Summer): 49-58.
52.
52Lovrich, N.P. (1987). "Merit Pay and Motivation in the Public Workforce: Beyond Concerns of Technique to More Basic Considerations."Review of Public Personnel Administration7(Spring): 54-71.
53.
53Behn, R. (1980). "Leadership for Cut-back Management: The Use of Corporate Strategy."Public Administration Review40(November/December): 603-604.
54.
54Biller, R.P. (1980). "Leadership Tactics for Retrenchment."Public Administration Review40(November/December): 604-609.
