The Discrepancy between Daily Practice and the Policy of a Decision-analytic Model

Abstract

The optimal treatment of children with fever of unknown origin is controversial, in spite of two decision analyses that advise treatment with antibiotics for all such children. The aim of this study was to analyze the differences between pediatricians' diagnostic and therapeutic decisions and the outcomes of the decision-analytic models. Thirty- six pediatricians were asked to evaluate 30 patient cases and to give their diagnostic and therapeutic judgments. In addition, the pediatricians were asked questions about the epidemiology of fever of unknown origin. Analyses showed that the differences in policy between pediatricians and the models could not be explained by the reasons mentioned in the literature, i.e., 1) differences in epidemiologic data used, 2) differ ences in the weighting of clinical information, and 3) differences in the evaluation of outcomes. The differences in policy might be due to a difference between the objective of the models and pediatricians' aim. In a curative setting, pediatricians are not trying to prevent meningitis (or another serious disease) by treating possible occult bacter emia, but rather aim to detect meningitis in an early stage. A decision analysis deter mining the most cost-effective strategy for early detection of meningitis might therefore be more easily accepted by pediatricians. Key words: diagnostic and therapeutic de cisions ; decision-analytic models; fever of unknown origin. (Med Decis Making 1996; 16:357-366)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Schwarz WB

Decision analysis a look at the chief complaints

N Engl J Med. 1979,300.556-9.

Cebul RD "A look at the chief complaints" revisited. Current obstacles and opportunities for decision analysis Med Decis Making 1984 ,4 271-83.

Balla JJ , Elstein A. , Christensen C.

Obstacles to acceptance of clinical decision analysis

Br Med J 1989;298.579-82.

Elstein AS , Holzman GB , Ravitch MM , et al. Comparison of physicians' decisions regarding estrogen replacement therapy for menopausal women and decisions derived from a decision analysis model. Am J Med 1986,80.246-58.

Downs SM , McNutt RA , Margolis PA Management of infants at risk for occult bacteremia. a decision analysis . J Pediatr 1991,118 11-20

Lieu TA , Schwartz JS , Jaffe DM , Fleisher GR Strategies for diagnosis and treatment of children at risk for occult bacteremia. clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. J Pediatr 1991;118 21-9

Hamrich HJ , Garfunkel JM

Clinical decisions how much analysis and how much judgment? Editor's column

J Pediatr 1991;118 67

Nelson JD , McCracken GH

Antibiotic therapy for occult bacteremia

Pediatr Infect Dis J Newsletter. 1991,17.18

McCarthy PL , Grundy GW , Spiesel SZ , et al. Bacteremia in children: an outpatient clinical review. J Pediatr. 1976,57 861-8

10.

Bass JW , Steele RW , Witter RR , et al Antimicrobial treatment of occult bacteremia. a multicenter cooperative study. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1993;12:446-73.

11.

Long S. Approach to the febrile patient with no obvious focus of infection . Pediatr Rev 1984,5305-15.

12.

Powell K. Evaluation and management of febrile infants younger than 60 days of age. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1990,9-153-75

13.

McCarthy C. , Powell K. , Jaskiewicz J. , et al. Outpatient management of selected infants younger than two months of age evaluated for possible sepsis. Pediatr Infect Dis. 1990,9.163-9.

14.

Wasserman G. , White C. Evaluation of the necessity for hospitalization of the febrile infant less than three months of age. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 1990;9 163-9.

15.

Jaffe DM , Fleisher GR

Temperature and total white blood cell count as indicators of bacteremia

Pediatrics. 1991,87 670-4

16.

Baraff LJ , Bass JW , Fleisher GR , et al. Practice guidelines for the management of infants and children of 0 to 36 months of age with fever without source. Pediatrics. 1993;92 1-12.

17.

Rubin LG , Carmody L.

Pneumococcal and Haemophilus influenza type b antigen detection in children at risk for occult bacteremia

Pediatrics 1987 ,80 92-6

18.

Saladino R. , Eriskson M. , Levy N. , et al Utility of serum interleukin-6 for diagnosis of invasive bacterial disease in children. Ann Emerg Med. 1992,21 1413-6

19.

McCarthy PL , James JF , Stashwick CA , et al. History and observation variables in assessing febrile children. Pediatrics. 1980; 65.1090-5.

20.

McCarthy PL , Jekel JF , Stashwick CA , et al. Further definition of history and observation variables in assessing febrile children. Pediatrics. 1981,67 687-93.

21.

McCarthy PL , Sharpe MR , Spiesel SZ , et al Observation scales to identify serious illness in febrile children Pediatrics 1982 ;70 802-9

22.

McCarthy PL , Lembo RM , Baron MA , Fink HD , Cicchetti DV Predictive value of abnormal physical examination findings in ill-appearing and well-appearing febrile children. Pediatrics 1985;76 167-71

23.

Teach SJ , Fleisher GR Efficacy of an observation scale in detecting bacteremia in febrile children three to thirty-six months of age, treated as outpatients. J Pediatr 1995;126: 877-81.

24.

Jaffe DM , Tanz RR , Davis AT , Henretig F. , Fleisher G.

Antibiotic administration to test possible occult bacteremia in febrile children

N Engl J Med 1987;317.1175-80

25.

Kahneman D. , Slovic P. , Tversky A. Judgment under Uncertainty Heuristics and Biases. New York Cambridge University Press, 1982 .