Surgery or Angioplasty for Cost-effective Renal Revascularization?

Abstract

The authors retrospectively compared the cost-effectiveness of percutaneous transluminal angioplasty with that of renal artery bypass surgery for treating renal artery stenosis, using the experiences of 52 patients treated for renovascular hypertension between 1977 and 1983. The expected results of treatment for angioplasty and surgery were taken from pub lished literature and from experience. Based on the analysis, angioplasty is recommended for treating patients with fibromuscular disease, and patients less than 50 years old, while surgery is the preferred treatment for older patients and those with atherosclerotic disease. These strategies not only minimize the cost per life-year gained from treatment, but also maximize the life expectancy of treated patients. The results are quite robust for the discount rate used in the cost calculations, for variations in the expected rate of stenosis recurrence, and for variations in the treatment outcome probabilities. Key words: hypertension; renal artery stenosis; cost-effectiveness analysis; angioplasty; computer simulation. (Med Decis Making 7:84-91, 1987)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abridged Life Tables by Color and Sex: United States, 1976; Table 5.1. in Vital Statistics of the United States—1976 Washington, DC, U. S. Government Printing Office, 1976

Beck JR , Kassirer JP , Pauker SG : A convenient approximation of life expectancy (the "DEALE") Am J Med 73:883-897, 1982

Doubilet P. , Abrams HL : The cost of underutilization: percutaneous transluminal angioplasty for peripheral vascular disease N Engl J Med 310: 95-102, 1984

Efron B. : The jackknife, the bootstrap, and other resampling plans Philadelphia, Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics , 1982, pp 27-36

Finkler FA : The distinction between costs and charges Ann Intern Med 96:102-109, 1982

Grim CE , Weinberger MH : Renal artery stenosis and hypertension Semin Nephrol 3:52-64, 1983

Grim CE , Weinberger MH , Higgins JT, et al : Diagnosis of secondary forms of hypertension: a comprehensive protocol JAMA 237:1331-1335, 1977

Grim CE , Whitworth JA , Thompson KR, et al : Treatment of renal artery stenosis with percutaneous transluminal angioplasty Austral Radiol 29:42-49, 1985

Grim CE , Yune HY , Weinberger MH, et al : Balloon dilatation for renal artery stenosis causing hypertension: criteria, concerns, and cautions Ann Intern Med 92:117-119, 1980

10.

Kuhlmann U. , Greminger P. , Gruntzig A., et al : Long-term experience in percutaneous transluminal dilatation of renal-artery stenosis Am J Med 79:692-698, 1985

11.

Lawrie GM , Morris GC , Soussou ID, et al : Late results of reconstructive surgery for renovascular disease Ann Surg 191:528-533, 1980

12.

Luft FC , Grim CE , Weinberger MH : Intervention in patients with renovascular hypertension and renal insufficiency J Urol 130:654-656, 1983

13.

Maxwell MH , Bleifer KH , Franklin SS, et al : Cooperative study of renovascular hypertension: demographic analysis of the study JAMA 220:1195-1204, 1972

14.

Roberts SD , Klein RW : Simulation of logical networks (SLN) Simulation, November 1984

15.

Roberts SD , Klein RW : Simulation of medical decisions: applications of SLN Simulation , November 1984

16.

Roberts SD , Maxwell DR : Encouraging cost-effective treatment of ESRD Grant #95-92585/5-03, HCFA, Final Report, July 1, 1983

17.

Sos TA , Pickering TG , Sniderman K., et al : Percutaneous transluminal renal angioplasty in renovascular hypertension due to atheroma or fibromuscular dysplasia N Engl J Med 309:274-279, 1983

18.

Stanley JC , Fry WJ : Renovascular hypertension secondary to arterial fibrodysplasia in adults: criteria for operation and results of surgical therapy Arch Surg 110:922-928, 1975

19.

Walpole RE , Myers RH : Probability and Statistics for Engineers and Scientists New York, Macmillan, 1972