Abstract
This article builds on conclusions drawn in the article “Eyeless in America,” by the same author and considers how 50 American films about the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan intended to function as what Jacques Ellul called “integration propaganda,” fared. This article considers and rejects a number of theories about why most feature war films failed between 2002 and 2012 and proposes what war films might look like in the near future.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.aljoschu . (2011 ). How many US Casualties in Iraq? Guess again . Retrieved from http://www.readersupportednews.org/opinion2/266-32/9181-focus-how-many0-
2.
Anno
H.
(Director). (1995 ). Neon genesis evangelion [Japanese media franchise]. Japan : ADV Films .
3.
Aufderheide
P.
(2007 ). Your country, my country: How films about the Iraq War construct publics . Framework: The Journal of Cinema and Media , 48 , 56 -65 .
4.
Bacevich
A. J.
(2010 , September 1 ). Unequal sacrifice . The Nation . Retrieved from http://www.thenation.com/article/154459/unequal-sacrifice#
5.
Baker
Peter
. 2009 . “How Obama Came to Plan for ‘Surge’ in Afghanistan.” New York Times , December 5 . http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/06/world/asia/06reconstruct.html?pagewanted=all.
6.
Barker
M.
(2011 ). A “toxic genre.” London, England : Pluto Press .
7.
Beattie
K.
(1998 ). The scar that binds . New York : New York University Press .
8.
Berg
P.
(Director). (2007 ). The kingdom [Motion picture]. USA : Universal Pictures .
9.
Berry
E.
(Director). (2007 ). Time bomb [Motion picture]. Canada : Peace Arch Entertainment .
10.
Bigelow
K.
(Producer Director). (2008 ). The hurt locker [Motion picture]. USA : Maple Pictures .
11.
Blackmore
T.
(2005 ). War X: Human extensions in battlespace . Toronto, Ontario, Canada : University of Toronto Press .
12.
Blackmore
T.
(2007 ). The speed death of the eye: The ideology of Hollywood special effects . Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society , 27 , 367 -372 .
13.
Bochco
J.
Gerolmo
C.
(Creators). (2005 ). Over there [Television series]. USA : FX .
14.
Boggs
C.
Pollard
T.
(2007 ). The Hollywood war machine . Boulder, CO : Paradigm .
15.
Burger
N.
(2008 ). The lucky ones [Motion picture]. USA : Lionsgate & Roadside Attractions .
16.
Buzzell
C.
(2005 ). My war: Killing time in Iraq . New York, NY : GP Putnam .
17.
Cameron
J.
(Director). (1986 ). Aliens [Motion picture]. USA : Twentieth Century Fox .
18.
Cameron
J.
(Producer Director). (2009 ). Avatar [Motion picture]. USA : Twentieth Century Fox .
19.
Carnahan
J.
(Director). (2010 ). The A-team [Motion picture]. USA : Twentieth Century Fox .
20.
Carruthers
S. L.
(2008 ). No one’s looking: The disappearing audience for war . Media, War & Conflict , 1 , 70 -76 .
21.
Chambers
D.
(2002 ). Will Hollywood go to war? TBS Archives , 8 , 1 -11 .
22.
Cimino
M.
(Director). (1978 ). The deer hunter [motion picture]. USA : EMI Films .
23.
Cobb
J. T.
LaCour
C.
Hight
W. H.
(2005 ). TF 2-2 in FSE AAR:Indirect fires in the Battle of Fallujah . Field Artillery, March-April , 22 -28 .
24.
Cole
B. G.
(Director). (2007 ). Day Zero [Motion picture]. USA : Indalo Productions .
25.
Colpaert
C.
(Director). (2006 ). G.I. Jesus [Motion picture]. USA : Cineville .
26.
Conrad
J.
(1999 ). Heart of darkness . London, England : Modern Library . (Original work published 1902)
27.
Cooper
M.
(2001 , December 10 ). Lights! Cameras! Attack! Hollywood enlists . The Nation . Retrieved from www.thenation.com/article/lights-cameras-attack-hollywood-enlists
28.
Coppola
F. F.
(Director). (1979 ). Apocalypse now [Motion picture]. USA : Paramount .
29.
Cornish
P.
(2001 ). War crimes. The Oxford companion to military history . Oxford, England : Oxford University Press .
30.
Dante
J.
(Director). (2006 ). Homecoming [Television series episode DVD]. Troy, MI : Anchor Bay Entertainment .
31.
Del Vecchio
J. M.
(1982 ). The 13th valley . New York, NY : St. Martin’s Press .
32.
DeMonaco
J.
(Producer). (2007 ). The kill point [Television series]. USA : Spike TV .
33.
De Palma
B.
(Director). (2007 ). Redacted [Motion picture]. USA : Magnolia Pictures .
34.
Donnelly
P. J.
(Director). (2007 ). Divergence [Motion picture]. USA : Vanguard .
35.
Eberwein
R.
(2009 ). The Hollywood war film (B. K. Grant, Ed.). Chichester, England : Wiley-Blackwell .
36.
Ellul
J.
(1964 ). The technological society (J. Wilkinson, Trans.). New York, NY : Vintage Books . (Original work published 1954)
37.
Ellul
J.
(1973 ). Propaganda: The formation of men’s attitudes (K. Kellen & J. Lerner, Trans.). New York, NY : Vintage Books . (Original work published 1962)
38.
Finkel
D.
(2009 ). The good soldiers . New York, NY : Farrar, Straus & Giroux .
39.
Froomkin
D.
(n.d. ). How many US casualties in Iraq? Guess again . Retrieved from http://www.readersupportednews.org/opinion2/266-32/9181-focus-how-many-us-casualties-in-iraq-guess-again
40.
Furie
S. J.
(Director). (2005 ). American soldiers [Motion picture]. Canada : Peace Arch .
41.
Greengrass
P.
(Director). (2010 ). Green zone [Motion picture]. USA : Universal Pictures .
42.
Haas
P.
(Director). (2006 ). The situation [Motion picture]. USA : Shadow Distribution .
43.
Haggis
P.
(Director). (2007 ). In the valley of Elah [Motion picture]. USA : Warner Independent Pictures .
44.
Hunter
S.
(2009 ). The first decent Iraq-War movie . Commentary , 128 , 78 -80 .
45.
Irvin
J.
(Director). (1987 ). Hamburger hill [Motion picture]. USA : RKO Pictures .
46.
Jewison
N.
(Director). (1989 ). In country [Motion picture]. Warner Brothers.
47.
Joffé
R.
(Director). (1984 ). The killing fields [Motion picture]. UK : Enigma .
48.
Jones
D.
(Director). (2011 ). Source code [Motion picture]. USA : Vendome Pictures .
49.
Katz
R.
(Producer Director). (2009 ). Taking chance [Television film]. USA : HBO Films .
50.
Kubrick
S.
(Producer Director). (1987 ). Full metal jacket [Motion picture]. USA : Warner Bros .
51.
Lean
D.
(Director). (1962 ). Lawrence of Arabia [Motion picture]. USA : Columbia Pictures .
52.
Levinson
B.
(Director). (1987 ). Good morning Vietnam! [Motion picture] . USA : Touchstone Pictures .
53.
Liebesman
J.
(Director). (2011 ). Battle: Los Angeles [Motion picture]. USA : Columbia Pictures .
54.
Liman
D.
(Director). (2010 ). Fair game [Motion picture]. USASummit Entertainment.
55.
Lucente
F.
(Director). (2007 ). Badland [Motion picture]. USA : Vanguard Cinema .
56.
Makhmalbaf
S.
(Director). (2003 ). At five in the afternoon [Motion picture]. Iran : Seville Pictures .
57.
Malkin
L.
(Director). (2006 ). Five fingers [Motion picture]. USA : Lionsgate .
58.
Mejia
C.
(2007 ). The road from Ar Ramadi . New York, NY : New Press .
59.
Miles
S. H.
(2006 ). Oath betrayed . New York, NY : Random House .
60.
Moverman
O.
(Director). (2009 ). The messenger [Motion picture]. USA : Alliance Films .
61.
Munden
M.
(Director). (2007 ). The mark of Cain [Motion picture]. UK : Film 4 .
62.
Packer
G.
(2005 ). The assassin’s gate . New York, NY : Farrar, Straus & Giroux .
63.
Packer
G.
(2008 ). Over here: Iraq the place vs. Iraq the abstraction . World Affairs, Winter , 14 -23 .
64.
Paschall
R.
(1999 ). War crimes: The Oxford companion to American military history . Oxford, England : Oxford University Press .
65.
Peckinpah
S.
(Director). (1977 ). Cross of iron [Motion picture]. UK : Paradox .
66.
Peirce
K.
(Director). (2008 ). Stop-loss [Motion picture]. USA : Paramount Pictures .
67.
Penn
A.
(Director). (1970 ). Little big man [Motion picture]. USA : CBS .
68.
Ricks
T. E.
(1997 ). The widening gap between military and society . The Atlantic, July , 1 -16 . Retrieved from http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1997/07/the-widening-gap-between-military-and-society/306158/
69.Riverbend . (2006 ). Baghdad burning II: More girl blog from Iraq . New York, NY : The Feminist Press at the City University of New York .
70.
Robbins
T.
(Director). (2005 ). Embedded [Motion picture]. USA : Cinema Libre .
71.
Robinson
P. A.
Loncraine
R.
Salomon
M.
(Directors). (2001 ). Band of brothers [Television miniseries]. USA : HBO .
72.
Roussel
V.
(2010 ). Making “a political movie that does not take a political stand:” Specialization and depoliticization in American cinema . International Journal of Politics, Culture and Society , 23 , 137 -155 .
73.
Ross
G.
(Director). (2012 ). The hunger games [Motion picture]. USA : Lionsgate .
74.
Scott
R.
(2005 ). Kingdom of heaven [Motion picture]. USA : Twentieth Century Fox .
75.
Scott
R.
(Director). (2008 ). Body of lies [Motion picture]. USA : Warner Brothers .
76.
Sheridan
J.
(Director). (2009 ). Brothers [Motion picture]. USA : Lionsgate .
77.
Smithson
R.
(2009 ). Ghosts of war: The true story of a 19-year-old GI . New York, NY : Collins .
78.
Snyder
Z.
(Director). (2007 ). 300 [Motion picture] . USA : Warner Bros .
79.
Solomon
N.
(2004 ). Spinning war and blotting out memory . In
Kamalipour
Y. R.
Snow
N.
(Eds.), War, media, and propaganda: A global perspective (pp. 47 -58 ). Lanham, MD : Rowman & Littlefield .
80.
Spielberg
S.
(Director). (1998 ). Saving private Ryan [Motion picture]. USA : Dreamworks SKG .
81.
Stallone
S.
(Director). (2008 ). Rambo [Motion picture]. USA : Alliance Films .
82.
Stewart
G.
(2009 ). Digital fatigue: Imaging war in recent American film . Film Quarterly , 62 (4 ), 45 -55 .
83.
Stiglitz
J. E.
Bilmes
L. J.
(2008 ). The three trillion dollar war: The true cost of the Iraq conflict . New York, NY : W. W. Norton & Company .
84.
Stone
O.
(Director). (1986 ). Platoon [Motion picture]. USA : Hemdale Film .
85.
Stone
O.
(Director). (1989 ). Born on the fourth of July [Motion picture]. USA : Universal Pictures .
86.
Strouse
J. C.
(Director). (2007 ). Grace is gone [Motion picture]. USA : Alliance Films .
87.
Swofford
A.
(2003 ). Jarhead: A marine’s chronicle of the Gulf War and other battles . New York, NY : Scribner .
88.
Valderrama
K.
(Director). (2008 ). Garrison [Motion picture]. USA : Phase4Films .
89.
Van Patten
T.
Nutter
D.
Podeswa
J.
(Directors). (2010 ). The Pacific [Television miniseries]. USA : HBO Films .
90.
Wachowski
A.
Wachowski
L.
(Directors). (1999 ). The matrix [Motion picture]. USA : Warner Brothers .
91.
Whedon
J.
(Director). (2012 ). The avengers [Motion picture]. USA : Walt Disney .
92.
White
S.
Jones
S. C.
(Directors). (2008 ). Generation kill [Television miniseries]. USA : HBO Films .
93.
Winkler
I.
(Director). (2006 ). Home of the brave [Motion picture]. USA : Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Pictures .
94.
Wyler
W.
(Director). (1959 ). Ben-hur [Motion picture]. USA : Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer .