To better understand homicide, 28 women convicted of the crime of murder were interviewed in three American prisons. The data were characterized into a typology of delayed, reactive, and intentional murder responses. From the descriptions of the delayed and reactive respondents, a continuum of imminent danger existed in their daily lives suggesting that homicide was seen as an event which utilized reasonable force as a last resort to end an abusive relationship with partners, children, parents, or others, occurring after a progression of interactions. One implication of this finding is that these women have a different understanding of their crime than legal officials and jury members suggesting that the American legal system itself may possess a gender disparity within its law. Recommendations emerging from this implication include a recognition of battered wife syndrome as a legal defense for self-defense and the redefinition of relevant legal policies in keeping with the reality of today's at-risk communities. Future research is called for to examine the relationship between mandatory arrest and domestic violence calls.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BeanC.A. (1992). Women murdered by the men they loved. Harrington Park Press; New York.
2.
BiggersT.A. (1979). Death by murder: A study of women murderers. Death-Education, 3 (1), 1–9.
3.
BlackH.C. (1979). Black's law dictionary. 5th Ed., West Publishing Company; St. Paul, MN.
4.
BrettC. (1992). From victim to victimizer. Federal Bureau of Prisons, spring.
5.
Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) (1997). Source book of criminal justice statistics 1996. Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice; Washington DC.
6.
CaplanG. (1991). Battered wives, battered justice. National Review, February.
7.
EastealP. (1995). Reconstructing Reality. The Alternative Law Journal, 20 (3), 108–112.
8.
EastealP.W. (1993). Killing the beloved: Homicide between adult sexual intimates. Australian Institute of Criminology; Australia.
FlethcerB.MoonD.G. (1993). Introduction; the population. In Women prisoners: A forgotten population, (FlethcerB.R.ShaverL.D.MoonD.G., eds) pp. 5–14. Praeger; Westport, Connecticut.
11.
GlickL. (1995). Criminology. Allyn and Bacon; Boston.
12.
GottfredsonM.HirschiT. (1990). A general theory of crime. Stanford University Press; Stanford, CA.
13.
GrantB.CurryD. (1993). Women murderers and victims of abuse in southern state. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 17 (2), 73–83.
14.
HerrnsteinR.J. (1995). Criminogenic traits. In Crime (WilsonJ.Q.PetersiliaJ., eds), pp. 39–65. ICS Press; San Francisco, CA.
15.
HirschelJ.D.HutchisonI. (1991). Police preferred arrest policies. In Woman battering: Policy responses, (SteinmanMichael, ed.) pp. 49–70. Anderson; Cincinnati, OH.
16.
JohnsonI.M. (1996). Female murders in a southern city. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 20 (2), 207–224.
17.
JonesA. (1986). Women who kill. Holt, Rienhart and Wilson; NY.
18.
KarmenA. (1996, November 30). What's driving New York's crime rate down?Law Enforcement News, John Jay College of Criminal Justice/CUNY.
19.
KatzJ. (1988). Seductions of Crime. Basic Books, NY.
20.
KristalA. (1991). You've come along way, baby: The battered woman's syndrome revisited. New York Law School Journal of Human Rights, 9111–160.
21.
LevyD. (1995 June 14). Nation gets D in war on violence. USA Today, p. 1.
22.
LuckenbillD. (1977). Criminal homicide as a situated transaction. Social Problems, 25, 176–186.
23.
MannC.R. (1988). Getting even? Women who kill in domestic encounters, Justice Quarterly, March.
24.
MillsC. Wright. (1940). Situated actions and vocabularies of motive. American Sociological Review, 5 (6).
NettlerG. (1982). Killing one another. Anderson; Cincinnati.
28.
NewtonJ. (1996). Number of arrests by LAPD plunges since ′91. LA Times, March.
29.
OgleR.S.KatkinD.M.BernardT.J. (1995). A theory of homicidal behavior among women. Criminology, 33 (2), 173–187.
30.
PeeleS. (1991). Getting away with murder. Reason Magazine, August.
31.
RobertsA.R. (1996). Battered women who kill: A comparative study of incarcerated participants with community sample of battered women. Journal of Family Violence, 11 (3), 291–304.
32.
SargentE.Marcus-MendozaS.Ho YuC. (1993). Abuse and the women prisoner. In Women Prisoners: A Forgotten Population, (FlethcerB.R.ShaverL.D.MoonD.G., eds), pp. 55–64. Praeger; Westport, Connecticut.
33.
SeligmanM.E. (1975). Helplessness: On depression. Development, and death. W.H. Freeman; San Francisco.
34.
SnellT.L. (1994). Women in prison. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Special Report. US Department of Justice.
35.
StevensD.J. (1998a). The impact of time-served and regime on prisoners' anticipation of crime: Female prisonisation effects. The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 37 (2), 188–205.
36.
StevensD.J. (1998b). Incarcerated women, crime, and drug addiction. The Criminologist, 22 (1), 3–14
37.
StevensD.J. (1998c). Serial rapists. Bethesda, Md: Austin-Winfield.
38.
StevensD.J. (1997a). Urban communities and homicide: Why blacks resort to murder. Criminologist, 21 (3), 145–158.
39.
StevensD.J. (1997b). What do law enforcement officers think about their jobs. The Law Enforcement Journal, 5 (1), 60–62.
40.
StevensD.J. (1997c). Influences of early childhood experiences on subsequent criminally violent behavour. Studies on Crime and Crime Prevention, 6 (1), 34–50.
41.
StevensD.J. (1995). American criminals and attitudes. International Review of Modern Sociology, 25 (2), 27–42.
42.
StevensD.J. (1994). The Depth of Imprisonment and Prisonisation: Levels of Security and Prisoners' Anticipation of Future Violence. The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 33 (2), 137–157.
43.
StevensD.J. (1992a). Research note: The death sentence and inmate attitudes. Crime and Delinquency, 38, 272–79.
44.
StevensD.J. (1992b). Examining inmate attitudes: Do prisons deter crime?The State of Corrections — American Correctional Association: 1991, pp. 272–79.
45.
WalkerL.E. (1979). The battered woman. Harper; NY.
46.
WebsdaleN. (1998). Rural woman battering and the justice system: An ethnography. Sage Publications; Thousand Oaks, CA.
47.
WilliamsM. (1995). Court turns down battered woman syndrome defense: Case number 94APA12-1728. The Daily Reporter, July.
48.
WilsonM.I.DalyM. (1992). Who kills whom in spouse killing? On the exceptional sex ration of spousal homicides in the United States. Criminology, 30 (2), 189–215.
