Research findings reveal a differential treatment by police officers of Dutch citizens and foreign born citizens belonging to minority groups. Differences in the degree to which both targets make a suspicious impression on the observing officer are hypothesized to be its main determinant. Theoretically this determinant is linked with the occurrence of nonverbal communication errors, which are a common source of misunderstanding in cross-cultural interactions. Three experiments, in which culturally determined nonverbal behaviors were systematically manipulated (defensive behavior, rhythmic behavior and gaze behavior) are presented. Experimental outcomes underline the importance of nonverbal communication errors in cross-cultural interactions. Results support the hypothesis that police-officers wrongfully interpret these behaviors of the interacting citizen as expressions of being a suspect, and thus victimize these citizens. These results are finally integrated in the theoretical framework of correspondence theory.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AalbertsM.M.J.KammingaE.M. (1983). Politie en Allochtonen. Staatsuitgeverij; s'Gravenhage.
BaxterJ.C.RozelleR.M. (1975). Nonverbal expression as a function of crowding during a simulated police-citizen encounter. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32, 40–50.
4.
BeerP. de. (1988). Nederlandse studies naar de criminaliteit van etnische minderheden. Migrantenstudies, 4, 17–27.
5.
BierbrauerG.VolkmanH.R. (1988). Legal culture: attitudes toward asylum seekers in West Germany. In Lawyers on Psychology and Psychologists on Law (van KoppenP.J.HessingD.J.van den HeuvelG., eds.) pp 93–105. Swets and Zeitlinger North America; Berwyn.
6.
BishopD.M.FrazierC.E. (1988). The influence of race in juvenile processing. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 25, 242–263.
7.
Council for Youth Policy (Raad voor het Jeugdbeleid). (1989). Tussen Inkeren en Uitkomen: commentaar op de regeringsvoorstellen inzake jongeren-uitkeringen. Ministerie van Welzijn, Volksgezondheid en Cultuur; Rijswijk.
8.
DruckmanD.RozelleR.M.BaxterJ.E. (1982). Nonverbal Communication: Survey, Theory and Research. Sage; Beverly Hills.
9.
EppinkA. (1982). Cultuurverschillen en Communicatie. Samsom; Alphen aan den Rijn.
10.
FugitaS.S.WexleyK.N.HillaryJ.M. (1974). Black-white differences in nonverbal behavior in an interview setting. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 4, 343–350.
11.
GarrattG.A.BaxterJ.C.RozelleR.M. (1981). Training university police in black American nonverbal behavior. Journal of Social Psychology, 113, 217–229.
12.
HallE.T. (1959). The Silent Language. Doubleday-Anchor; New York.
13.
HamiltonD.L. (1979). A cognitive attributional analysis of stereotyping. In Advances in Experimental Social Psychology (BerkowitzL., ed.) pp 53–81. Academic Press; New York.
14.
HemsleyG.D.DoobA.N. (1978). The effect of looking behavior on perceptions of a communicator's credibility. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 8, 136–144.
15.
IckesW. (1984). Compositions in black and white; determinants of interaction in interracial dyads. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 47, 330–341.
16.
JasparsJ.HewstoneM. (1982). Crosscultural interaction; social attribution and intergroup relations. In Cultures in Contact (BochnerS., ed.) pp 127–157. Pergamon Press; Oxford.
17.
JeffersonT. (1988). Race, crime, and policing: empirical, theoretical, and methodological issues. International Journal of the Sociology of Law, 16, 521–539.
18.
JongmanR.W. (1981). Tussen Misdaad en Straf: Justitiele afhandeling als symbool van de ongelijkheid. Callenbach; Nijkerk.
19.
Junger-TasJ. (1981). Discretie bij het politie-optreden. In Belissingsmomenten in het Strafrechtelijk Systeem (MoorL. GuntherLeuwE., eds.) pp 77–93. Ars Aequi Libri; Utrecht.
20.
JungerM. (1988). Racial discrimination in criminal justice in the Netherlands. Sociology and Social Research, 72, 211–217.
21.
KrautR.E. (1978). Verbal and nonverbal cues in the perception of lying. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 36, 380–391.
22.
KrautR.E.PoeD. (1980). The deception judgements of customs inspectors and layman. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39, 784–798.
23.
LafranceM.MayoC. (1979). Racial differences in gaze behavior during conversations: two systematic observational studies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 33, 547–552.
24.
SmithD.A.VisherC.A.DavidsonL.A. (1984). Equity and discretionary justice: the influence of race on police arrest decisions. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 75, 324–250.
25.
TimmermanH.BosmaJ.J.JongmanR.J. (1986). Minderheden voor de rechter. Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, 28, 57–73.
26.
UnneverJ.D.HembroffL.A. (1988). The prediction of racial/ethnic sentencing disparities: an expectations state approach. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 25, 53–82.
27.
VrijA.WinkelF.W. (1991). Police-black encounters: testing the non-cooperation hypothesis of differential treatment of minorities. Police Studies (forthcoming).
28.
WalkerM.A. (1988). The court disposal of young males by race in London in 1983. British Journal of Criminology, 28, 441–461.
29.
WatersR. (1988). Race and the criminal justice process: two empirical studies on social inquiry reports and ethnic minority defendants. British Journal of Criminology, 28, 8295.
30.
WinkelF.W. (1981). Beslissingen: het rechtspsychologisch perpectief. Delikt en Delinkwent, 11, 506–520.
31.
WinkelF.W. (1982). Omstanders en criminaliteit: psychologische waarnemingsfouten. Panopticon, 3, 400–415.
32.
WinkelF.W.VrijA. (1985). Etnische referenties in misdaadnieuws. Proces, 64, 242–250.
33.
WinkelF.W. (1986). Politienieuws en schade: toetsingsonderzoeken rond etnische referenties in misdaadnieuws. Massacommunicatie, 14, 50–58.
34.
WinkelF.W.KoppelaarL. (1986). Being suspect in cross-cultural interaction: a psychological analysis. Police Studies: International Review of Police Development, 9, 125–134.
35.
WinkelF.W.BruijinincxJ.Van Der KleyJ. (1987a). Beinvloeding van etnisch vooroordeel: het verwerken van informatie over andere groepen. InRelaties tussen Groepen: Sociaal Psychologiche Analyses en Interventies (WinkelF.W., ed.) pp 71–95. Samsom; Alphen aan de Rijn.
36.
WinkelF.W.KoppelaarL.VrijA. (1987b). De perceptie van allochtone criminaliteit: sociaal-psychologische voorwaarden voor vertekenende informatieverwerking. In Relaties tussen groepen: Sociaal psychologische Analyses en Interventies (WinkelF.W., ed) pp 139–165. Samsom; Alphen aan den Rijn.
37.
WinkelF.W.KoppelaarL.VrijA. (1988). Creating suspects in police-citizen interactions: two studies on personal space and being suspect. Social Behaviour, 3, 307–318.
38.
WinkelF.W.VrijA. (1990). Interaction and impression formation in a crosscultural dyad: frequency and meaning of cultural determined gaze behaviour in a police interview setting. Social Behaviour, 5, 335–350.
