The Caporalato system parallels the gangmaster framework, underlining illicit labor practices mediated by intermediaries. This system is entrenched in master narratives—culturally ingrained stories that dictate behaviors and perpetuate power disparities, safeguarding the privileges of the elite. Within this oppressive framework, women face heightened challenges, including increased vulnerability to human trafficking and exploitation. This study explores the counter-narratives developed by women in response to Caporalato’s master narratives. It gathers empirical data from naturally occurring meetings with 11 women from diverse African nations, conducted between January 2023 and July 2023. Using the joint fantasizing approach, which focuses on collaboratively constructed stories with potential future impacts, the study unveils three prominent themes of resistance: ‘My son will make me a queen’, ‘My body will set me free’, and ‘I want to stay at home!’. This analysis reveals that effective resistance through counter-narratives does not rely on forming a single, unified story opposing the master narrative. Rather, these narratives selectively challenge and sometimes adopt aspects of the dominant stories they confront.
AndersonB (2001) Just another job? Paying for domestic work. Gender and Development9(1): 25–33.
2.
AndrewsM (2004) Opening to the original contributions: Counter-narratives and the power to oppose. In: BambergMAndrewsM (eds) Considering Counter-Narratives: Narrating, Resisting, Making Sense. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, pp. 1–6.
3.
AustinHCarpenterL (2008) Troubled, troublesome, troubling mothers: The dilemma of difference in women’s personal motherhood narratives. Narrative Inquiry18(2): 378–392.
4.
BambergM (2004) Considering counter-narratives. In: BambergMAndrewsM (eds) Considering Counter-Narratives: Narrating, Resisting, Making Sense. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, pp. 351–371.
5.
BéalCMullanK (2013) Issues in conversational humour from a cross-cultural perspective: Comparing French and Australian corpora. In: BéalCMullanKPeetersB (eds) Cross-Culturally Speaking, Speaking Cross-Culturally. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Press, pp. 107–140.
6.
BertrandRPriego-ValverdeB (2011) Does prosody play a specific role in conversational humor?Pragmatics & Cognition19(2): 333–356.
7.
BoeriMW (2013) Women on Ice: Methamphetamine Use Among Suburban Women. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
8.
BourdieuP (2002 [1977]) Outline of a Theory of Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
9.
BourdieuP (1996) Masculine domination revisited. Berkeley Journal of Sociology41: 189–203.
10.
BrookmanFCopesHHochstetlerA (2011) Street codes as formula stories: How inmates recount violence. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography40(4): 397–424.
11.
BrunerJ (1986) Actual Minds, Possible Worlds. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
12.
BrunerJS (1990) Acts of Meaning. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
13.
CarranzaIE (1998) Argumentar, explicar y justificar con preguntas retóricas. Revista Iberoamericana sobre Discurso y Sociedad3(2): 61–83.
14.
CoatesJ (2007) Talk in a play frame: More on laughter and intimacy. Journal of Pragmatics39: 29–49.
15.
CopesH (2016) A narrative approach to studying symbolic boundaries among drug users: A qualitative meta-synthesis. Crime, Media, Culture12(2): 193–213.
16.
CopesHBrookmanFRaglandJ, et al. (2022) Sex, drugs, and coercive control: Gendered narratives of methamphetamine use, relationships, and violence. Criminology60(1): 187–218.
17.
CopesHLebanLRaglandJ (2021) Changing narratives of intimate partner violence: A longitudinal photo-ethnography. Conflict and Society7: 123–142.
18.
CrossmanKAHardestyJLRaffaelliM (2016) ‘He could scare me without laying a hand on me’. Mothers’ experiences of nonviolent coercive control during marriage and after separation. Violence Against Women22(4): 454–473.
De FinaA (2008) Who tells which story and why? Micro and macro contexts in narrative. Text and Talk28(3): 421–442.
21.
De FinaAJohnstoneB (2015) Discourse analysis and narrative. In: TannenDHamiltonHESchiffrinD (eds) The Handbook of Discourse Analysis. 2nd ed.Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 152–167.
22.
De FinaAGeorgakopoulouA (2015) The Handbook of Narrative Analysis. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
23.
DelgadoR (1989) Storytelling for oppositionists and others: A plea for narrative. Michigan Law Review87: 2411–2441.
24.
Di MarzioF (2017) Agricoltura senza caporalato: Osservatorio sulla criminalità nell’agricoltura e sul sistema agroalimentare. Rome: Donzelli editore.
25.
DoekhieJVan GinnekenE (2020) House, bells and bliss? A longitudinal analysis of conventional aspirations and the process of desistance. European Journal of Criminology17(6): 744–763.
26.
DorsonJ (2016) Counternarrative Possibilities. Frankfurt am Main: Campus Verlag.
27.
DynelM (2011) Joker in the pack: Towards determining the status of humorous framing in conversations. In: DynelM (ed.) The Pragmatics of Humour across Discourse Domains. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, pp. 217–242.
28.
Esteban-GuitartM (2012) Towards a multimethodological approach to identification of funds of identity, small stories and master narratives. Narrative Inquiry22(1): 173–180.
29.
EwickPSilbeySS (1995) Subversive stories and hegemonic tales: Toward a sociology of narrative. Law and Society Review29(2): 197–226.
30.
FivushRHabermasTReeseE (2019) Retelling lives: Narrative style and stability of highly emotional events over time. Qualitative Psychology6(2): 156–166.
31.
FreemanM (1993) Rewriting the Self: History, Memory, Narrative. London: Routledge.
32.
GeorgakopoulouA (2003) Plotting the ‘right place’ and the ‘right time’: Place and time as interactional resources in narratives. Narrative Inquiry13(2): 413–423.
33.
GergenKJGergenMM (1988) Narrative and the self as relationship. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology21: 17–56.
34.
GilliganC (1993) In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
35.
GracykTA (1987) Pornography as representation: Aesthetic considerations. Journal of Aesthetic Education21(4): 103–121.
36.
GrossmanAS (1980) Women in domestic work: Yesterday and today. Monthly Labor Review103: 17.
37.
HallF (1974) Conversational joking: A look at applied humour. In: McDowellJ (ed.) Folklore Annual of the University Folklore Association. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press, pp. 24–45.
38.
HammackPL (2006) Identity, conflict, and coexistence: Life stories of Israeli and Palestinian adolescents. Journal of Adolescent Research21: 323–369.
39.
HammackPL (2008) Narrative and the cultural psychology of identity. Personality and Social Psychology Review12: 222–247.
40.
HardingDJDobsonCCWyseJJ, et al. (2017) Narrative change, narrative stability, and structural constraint: The case of prisoner reentry narratives. American Journal of Cultural Sociology5: 261–304.
41.
HarrisACarneySFineM (2001) Counter work: Introduction to ‘under the covers: Theorising the politics of counter stories’. In: FineMHarrisAM (eds) Under the Covers: Theorising the Politics of Counter Stories. London: Lawrence and Wishart, pp. 6–18.
42.
HaugF (1999) Female Sexualization: A Collective Work of Memory, vol. 25). London: Verso Books.
43.
HochmanYSpector-MerselG (2020) Three strategies for doing narrative resistance: Navigating between master narratives. British Journal of Social Psychology59(4): 1043–1061.
44.
KölblC (2004) ‘Blame it on psychology?! In: BambergMAndrewsM (eds) Considering Counter- Narratives: Narrating, Resisting, Making Sense. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, pp. 27–50.
45.
KotthoffH (1999) Coherent keying in conversational humour: Contextualising joint fictionalisation. In: BublitzWLenkUVentolaE (eds) Coherence in Spoken and Written Discourse. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, pp. 125–150.
46.
KotthoffH (2007) Oral genres of humour: On the dialectic of genre knowledge and creative authoring. Pragmatics17: 263–296.
47.
LeeJ (1994) Menarche and the (hetero) sexualization of the female body. Gender and Society8(3): 343–362.
48.
LeeJSasser-CoenJ (2015) Blood Stories: Menarche and the Politics of the Female Body in Contemporary US Society. New York: Routledge.
49.
LosekeDR (2007) The study of identity as cultural, institutional, organizational, and personal narratives: Theoretical and empirical integrations. The Sociological Quarterly48: 661–688.
50.
LuegKLundholtMW (eds) (2020) Routledge Handbook of Counter-Narratives. New York: Routledge.
51.
LundholtMWMaagaardmCAPiekutA (2018) Counternarratives. In: HeathRLJohansenW (eds) The International Encyclopedia of Strategic Communication. New York: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 1–11.
52.
MaorM (2014) Stories that matter: Subverting the before-and-after weight-loss narrative. Social Semiotics24(1): 88–105.
53.
McAdamsDP (1993) The Stories We Live by: Personal Myths and the Making of the Self. New York: William Morrow.
54.
McAdamsDP (2001) The psychology of life stories. Review of General Psychology5(2): 100–122.
55.
McCleary-SillsJDouglasZRwehumbizaA, et al. (2013) Gendered norms, sexual exploitation and adolescent pregnancy in rural Tanzania. Reproductive Health Matters21(41): 97–105.
56.
McKenzie-MohrSLafranceMN (2017) Narrative resistance in social work research and practice: Counter-storying in the pursuit of social justice. Qualitative Social Work16(2): 189–205.
57.
McLeanKCSyedM (2015) Personal, master, and alternative narratives: An integrative framework for understanding identity development in context. Human Development58: 318–349.
58.
McLeanKCLilgendahlJPFordhamC, et al. (2018) Identity development in cultural context: The role of deviating from master narratives. Journal of Personality86(4): 631–651.
59.
McLeanKCSyedMShucardH (2016) Bringing identity content to the fore: Links to identity development processes. Emerging Adulthood4(5): 356–364.
60.
MelossiE (2021) ‘Ghetto tomatoes’ and ‘taxi drivers’: The exploitation and control of Sub-Saharan African migrant tomato pickers in Puglia, Southern Italy. Journal of Rural Studies88: 491–499.
61.
MillerJCarbone-LopezKGundermanMV (2015) Gendered narratives of self, addiction, and recovery among women methamphetamine users. In: PresserLSandbergS (eds) Narrative Criminology: Understanding Stories of Crime. New York: NYU Press, pp. 69–95.
62.
MoranRFarleyM (2019) Consent, coercion, and culpability: Is prostitution stigmatized work or an exploitive and violent practice rooted in sex, race, and class inequality?Archives of Sexual Behavior48(7): 1947–1953.
NorrickN (2000) Conversational Narrative: Storytelling in Everyday Talk. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
65.
PerrottaD (2015) Il caporalato come sistema: un contributo sociologico. In: RigoE (ed.) Leggi, migranti e caporali. Prospettive critiche e di ricerca sullo sfruttamento del lavoro in agricoltura. Pisa: Quaderni de L’altro diritto, Pacini Giuridica, pp. 15–30.
66.
PerrottaDCSacchettoD (2014) Migrant farmworkers in Southern Italy: Ghettoes, caporalato and collective action. Workers of the World1(5): 75–98.
67.
PolkinghorneDE (1988) Narrative Knowing and the Human Sciences. New York: State University of New York Press.
68.
PonterottoD (2014) Trivializing the female body: A cross-cultural analysis of the representation of women in sports journalism. Journal of International Women’s Studies15(2): 94–111.
69.
PoppiFIM (2021) Sancte et sapienter: Joint fantasizing as the interactional practice of micro and macro contextual understanding. Pragmatics and Society12(3): 437–460.
70.
PoppiFIM (2023a) Mater familias: Counter-narratives of sexism and heteronormativity in the Italian food culture. Food, Culture & Society27(4): 953–972.
71.
PoppiFIM (2023b) Principiis Obsta: Strategies of narrative resistance to Italian organized crime governance. Deviant Behavior44(9): 1303–1319.
72.
PoppiFIM (2023c) Non serviam: Narrative dimensions of organized crime resistance and susceptibility. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice75: 100627.
73.
PoppiFIM (2024) Per imaginem ad veritatem: Joint fantasizing of crime. Criminal Justice Studies37(2): 99–123.
74.
PoppiFIMCopesH (2024) Identitas per fabulam: Joint fantasising in the construction of criminal group identities. Critical Criminology32: 457–478.
75.
PoppiFIMCopesH (in prep.) Visio Colletiva: The Role of Joint Fantasizing in Qualitative Social Research.
76.
PoppiFIMGattinaraPC (2018) Aliud pro alio: Context and narratives within a neo-Nazi community of practice. Journal of Language and Politics17(4): 552–572.
77.
PoppiFIMSandbergS (2020) A bene placito: Narratives of sex work. Narrative Inquiry30(2): 294–293.
78.
PoppiFIMTravaglinoGA (2019) Parea non servin: Strategies of exploitation and resistance in the caporalato discourse. Modern Italy24(1): 81–97.
79.
PresserL (2004) Violent offenders, moral selves: Constructing identities and accounts in the research interview. Social Problems51(1): 82–101.
80.
Priego-ValverdeB (2006) How funny it is when everyone gets going! A case of co- construction of humour in conversation. CÍRCULO de Lingüística Aplicada a la Comunicación27: 5.
81.
RandallW (2017) The Narrative Complexity of Ordinary Life: Tales from the Coffee Shop. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
82.
RicoeurP (1984) Time and Narrative, vol. 1. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
83.
RiessmanCK (2008) Narrative Methods for the Human Sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
84.
RonaiCRCrossR (1998) Dancing with identity: Narrative resistance strategies of male and female stripteasers. Deviant Behavior19(2): 99–119.
85.
RydzikAAnithaS (2020) Conceptualising the agency of migrant women workers: Resilience, reworking and resistance. Work, Employment and Society34(5): 883–899.
86.
SandbergSColvinS (2020) ‘ISIS is not Islam’: Epistemic injustice, everyday religion, and young Muslims’ narrative resistance. The British Journal of Criminology60(6): 1585–1605.
87.
SantoroE (2009) La regolamentazione dell’immigrazione come questione sociale. In: SantoroE (ed.) Diritto Come Questione Sociale. Torino: Giappichelli, pp. 129–180.
88.
SchiumaD (2015) Il caporalato in agricoltura tra modelli nazionali e nuovo approccio europeo per la protezione dei lavoratori immigrati. Rivista di diritto agrario1: 87.
89.
ScottJC (1985) Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
90.
ScottJC (1990) Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
91.
SilverH (1993) Homework and domestic work. Sociological Forum8: 181–204.
92.
SinghPPattanaikF (2020) Unfolding unpaid domestic work in India: Women’s constraints, choices, and career. Palgrave Communications6(1): 1–13.
93.
SirotaKG (2010) Narratives of transformation: Family discourse, autism and trajectories of hope. Discourse and Society21(5): 544–564.
94.
SkalliLH (2001) Women and poverty in Morocco: The many faces of social exclusion. Feminist Review69(1): 73–89.
95.
SmolakLMurnenSK (2011) The sexualization of girls and women as a primary antecedent of self-objectification. In: CalogeroRMTantleff-DunnSThompsonJK (eds) Self-Objectification in Women: Causes, Consequences, and Counteractions. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, pp. 53–75.
96.
SnajdrE (2013) Beneath the master narrative: Human trafficking, myths of sexual slavery and ethnographic realities. Dialectical Anthropology37: 229–256.
97.
SolorzanoDGYossoTJ (2002) Critical race methodology: Counter-storytelling as an analytical framework for education research. Qualitative Inquiry8(1): 23–44.
98.
Spector-MerselG (2010) Narrative research: Time for a paradigm. Narrative Inquiry20(1): 204–224.
99.
StalloneLHaughM (2017) Joint fantasising as relational practice in Brazilian Portuguese interactions. Language and Communication55: 10–23.
100.
SuttonLA (2012) Bitches and skankly hobags: The place of women in contemporary slang. In: HallKBucholtzM (eds) Gender Articulated. New York: Routledge, pp. 279–296.
101.
TannenD (2010) Abduction and identity in family interaction: Ventriloquizing as indirectness. Journal of Pragmatics42(2): 307–316.
102.
TardyRW (2000) ‘But I Am a Good Mom’ the social construction of motherhood through health-care conversations. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography29(4): 433–473.
103.
ToolisEEHammackPL (2015) The lived experience of homeless youth: A narrative approach. Qualitative Psychology2(1): 50–68.
104.
TovaresA (2010) All in the family: Small stories and narrative construction of a shared family identity that includes pets. Narrative Inquiry20: 1–19.
105.
UgarteMBZarateLFarleyM (2004) Prostitution and trafficking of women and children from Mexico to the United States. Journal of Trauma Practice2(3–4): 147–165.
106.
VincentJMCastelfranchiC (1981) On the art of deception: How to lie while saying the truth. Possibilities and Limitations of Pragmatics: 749–777.
107.
WearingB (1984) The Ideology of Motherhood: A Study of Sydney Suburban Mothers. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin.
108.
YuT (2010) Deconstructing the master narrative on Tibet: Lessons for education. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education31(1): 1–15.
