Victimization through violence against personnel in the emergency ward (EW) was studied in all 25 general hospitals in Israel, using a self-report questionnaire (N = 1,484). Informed by routine activity theory as well as stress (negative affect) theories, the study analyzed victim and offender related variables, as well as structural, situational and interactional variables. A Victimization Seriousness Score (VSS) was constructed, based on participants' reports about the most serious type of violence they had experienced from patients and/or their relatives during the preceding year. The multiple regression analysis to explain the VSS was comprised of 35 independent variables relating to the victim's professional and personal characteristics, the hospital's structural features, and the offenders' personal characteristics, as well as situational and interactional factors, jointly explaining 47.4% of the variance (R2 = 0.474). As predicted, victimization by more serious violence was related to being security or nursing staff, positions of authority, and having no access to an emergency button. Male gender and being of Israeli or European/American origin (mainly from the former Soviet Union) was also related to more severe victimization. Offenders behaving more violently were younger, of Asian/African origin, new immigrants, and initially unstable (alcoholics, drug addicts, homeless, or psychiatric disorders). More serious victimization took place during evening shifts, related to severe medical problems and was characterized by the victim's inability to verbally communicate with the offender, and by calling other staff for help. The study demonstrates the importance of situational and interactional variables, and that violence in the EW is best explained by a comprehensive theoretical model that combines a routine activity approach with stress (negative affect) models. Suggestions are put forward for further research in this area.
AdibS.M.Al-ShattiA.K.KamalS.El-GeresN.Al-RaqemM. (2002). Violence Against Nurses in Healthcare Facilities in Kuwait. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 39, 469–478.
2.
AgrewR. (1992). Foundation for a General Strain Theory of Crime and Delinquency. Criminology, 30,47–87.
3.
AgrewR.WhiteH.R. (1992). An Empirical Test of General Strain Theory. Criminology, 30, 475–499.
4.
Al-SahlawiK.S.ZahidM.A.ShahidA.A.HatimM.Al-BaderM. (1997). Violence Against Doctors: 1. A Study of Violence Against Doctors in Accident and Emergency Departments. European Journal of Emergency Medicine, 6, 301–304.
5.
AndersonC.ParishM. (2003). Report of Workplace Violence by Hispanic Nurses. Journal of Transcultural Nursing, 14, 237–243.
6.
AnglinD.KyriacouD.N.HustonH.R. (1999). Residents' Perspectives on Violence and Personal Safety in the Emergency Department. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 25, 1082–1084.
7.
AmetzJ.E.AmetzB.B. (2001). Violence toward Health Care Staff and Possible Effects on the Quality of Patient Care. Social Science and Medicine, 52, 417–427.
8.
ArnetzJ.E.ArnetzB.B.PetersonI.L. (1996). Violence in the Nursing Profession: Occupational and Lifestyle Risk Factors in Swedish Nurses. Work & Stress, 10, 119–127.
9.
ArnetzJ.E.ArnetzB.B.SodermanE. (1998). Violence toward Health Care Workers. American Association of Occupational Health Nurse, 46, 107–114.
10.
BarlowC.B.RizzoA.G. (1997). Violence Against Surgical Residents. Western Journal of Medicine, 167, 74–78.
11.
BennetR. (1991). Routine Activities: A Cross-national Assessment of a Criminological Perspective. Social Forces, 70, 147–163.
12.
BerkowitzL. (1993). Aggression: Its Causes, Consequences and Control. McGraw-Hill; New York.
13.
BernburgJ.G.KrohnM.D. (2003). Labeling, Life Chances, and Adult Crime: The Direct and Indirect Effects of Official Intervention in Adolescence on Crime in Early Adulthood. Criminology, 41, 1287–1317.
14.
BradyC.DicksonR. (1999). Violence in Health Care Settings. In Work-Related Violence: Assessment and Intervention (CoxT., ed.) pp. 166–182. Routledge; London.
15.
British Medical Association (October, 2003). Violence at Work: The Experience of UK Doctors. www.bma.gov.uk.
16.
British Medical Association (2006). Bullying and Harassment of Doctors in the Workplace. BMA; London.
17.
BrunetJ.R. (2002). Discouragement of Crime through Civil Remedies: An Application of a Reformulated Routine Activities Theory. Western Criminology Review, 4, 68–79.
18.
Carmi-IluzT.PelegR.FreudT.Pesach ShvartzmanP. (2005). Verbal and Physical Violence towards Hospital- and Community-based Physicians in the Negev: an Observational Study. BMC Health Services Research2005, 5, 54. http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6963/5/54.
19.
CembrowiczS.RitterS.WrightS. (2001). Attacks on Doctors and Nurses. In Violence in Health Care: Understanding, Preventing and Surviving Violence: A Practical Guide for Health Professionals (ShepherdJ., ed.) pp. 118–154. Oxford University Press; Oxford.
20.
Central Bureau of Statistics (2005). Statistical Abstract of Israel. Central Bureau of Statistics; Jerusalem. www.cbs.gov.il/shnaton56/st04/_04.pdf.
21.
ClarkeR.V. (2001). Effective Crime Prevention: Keeping Pace with New Developments. Forum on Crime and Society, 1, 17–33.
22.
CohenL.E.FelsonM. (1979). Social Change and Crime Rate Trends: A Routine Activity Approach. American Sociological Review, 44, 588–608.
23.
CohenL.E.FelsonM. (1981). Modeling Crime Trends: A Criminal Opportunity Perspective. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 18, 138–164.
24.
CollinsJ. (1994). Nurses' Attitudes towards Aggressive Behavior Following Attendance at the Prevention and Management of Aggressive behavior Programme. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 20, 117–131.
25.
CollinsJ.CoxB.LanganP. (1987). Job Activities and Personal Crime Victimization: Implications for Theory. Social Science Research, 16, 345–360.
26.
CooperC.L.SwansonN. (eds) (2002). Workplace Violence in the Health Sector: State of the Art. ILO/ICN/WHO/PSI Joint Programme on Workplace Violence in the Health Sector. World Health Organization; Geneva.
27.
CoxT. (ed.) (1999). Work-Related Violence: Assessment and Intervention. Routledge; London.
28.
CrillyJ.ChaboyerW.CreedyD. (2004). Violence towards Emergency Department Nurses by Patients. Accident and Emergency Nursing, 3, 1–7.
29.
CurbowB. (2002). Origins of Violence at Work. In Workplace Violence in the Health Sector: State of the Art (CooperC.L.SwansonN., eds) pp. 35–48. ILO/ICN/WHO/PSI Joint Programme on Workplace Violence in the Health Sector. World Health Organization; Geneva.
30.
De CosterS.EstesS.B.MuellerC.W. (1999). Routine Activities and Sexual Harassment in the Work Place. Work and Occupation, 26, 21–49.
31.
DerazonH.NisimianS.YosefiH.PeledR.HaiE. (1999). Violence in an Emergency Ward, Harefua, 137,95-101. (In Hebrew).
32.
DerletR.W.RichardsJ.R. (2000). Overcrowding in the Nation's Emergency Departments: Complex Causes and Disturbing Effects. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 35, 63–68.
33.
Di MartinoV. (2002). Workplace Violence in the Health Sector: Country Case Studies — Synthesis Report. International Council of Nurses; Geneva.
34.
Di MartinoV. (2003). Relationship of Work Stress and Workplace Violence in the Health Sector. ILO/ICN/WHO/PSI Joint Programme on Workplace Violence in the Health Sector. World Health Organization; Geneva.
35.
DollardJ.DoobL.W.MillerN.M.MowrerO.H.SearsR.R. (1939). Frustration and Aggression. Yale University Press; New Haven.
EmpieK.M. (2003). Workplace Violence and Mental Illness. LFB Scholarly Publishing; New York.
38.
FelsonM. (1986). Linking Criminal Choices, Routine Activities, Informal Social Control, and Criminal Outcomes. In The Reasoning Criminal (CornishD.ClarkeR., eds) pp. 119–128. Springer-Verlag; New York.
39.
FelsonM. (1987). Routine Activities and Crime Prevention in the Developing Metropolis. Criminology, 25, 911–932.
40.
FelsonM. (1995). Those who Discourage Crime. In Crime and Place: Crime Prevention Studies (EckJ.WeisburdD., eds) pp. 53–60. Volume 4. Criminal Justice Press; Monsey, NY.
41.
FelsonM. (1998). Crime and Everyday Life (2nd ed.). Pine Forge Press; Thousand Oaks, CA.
42.
FelsonM. (2000). The Routine Activity Approach as a General Crime Theory. In Of Crime and Criminality (SimpsonS., ed.) pp. 205–216. Pine Forge Press; Thousand Oaks, CA.
43.
FelsonR.B. (1992). ‘Kick ‘em When They're Down’: Explanations of the Relationship Between Stress and Interpersonal Aggression and Violence. Sociological Quarterly, 33, 1–16.
44.
FernandesC.M.B.BouthilletteF.RabuodJ.M.BullockL.MoorC.F.ChristensonJ.M.GrafsteinE.RaeS.OulletL.GillrieC.WayM. (1999). Violence in the Emergency Department: A Survey of Health Care Workers. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 161, 1245–1248.
45.
FernandesC.M.B.RabuodJ.M.ChristensonJ.M.BouthilletteF.BullockL.OulletL.MooreF. (2002). The Effects of an Education Program on Violence in the Emergency Department. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 39, 47–55.
46.
FrancisS. (2001). Limiting Violence Through Good Design. In Violence in Health Care. Understanding, Preventing and Surviving Violence: A Practical Guide for Health Professionals (ShepherdJ., ed.) pp. 94–117. Oxford University Press; Oxford.
47.
GerberichS.G.ChurchT.R.McGovernP.M.HansenH.E.NachreinerN.M.GeiserM.S.RyanA.D.MonginS.J.WattG.D. (2004). An Epidemiological Study of the Magnitude and Consequences of Work-Related Violence: The Minnesota Nurses' Study. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 61, 495–503.
48.
Health and Safety Executive (1999). Violence at Work: Findings from the British Crime Survey. Home Office Information and Publication Group: Research, Development, and Statistics Directorate; London.
49.
Health Services Advisory Committee (HSAC) (1987). Violence to Staff in the Health Services. HMSO; London.
50.
HegneyD.PlankA.ParkerV. (2003). Workplace Violence in Nursing in Queensland, Australia: A Self-reported Study. International Journal of Nursing Practice, 9, 261–268.
51.
HeskethK.L.DuncanS.M.EstabrooksC.A.ReimerM.A.GiovannettiP.HyndmanK.AcornS. (2003). Workplace Violence in Alberta and British Columbia Hospitals. Health Policy, 63, 311–321.
52.
HillierB. (1994). Estates Design Against Crime — A Strategic Approach of Hospital Planning. Health Facility Notes NHS. HMSO; London.
53.
HindelangM.J.GottfredsonM.R.GarofaloJ. (1978). Victims of Personal Crime: An Empirical Foundation for a Theory of Personal Victimization. Ballinger; Cambridge, MA.
54.
HislopE.MelbyV. (2003). The Lived Experience of Violence in Accident and Emergency. Accident and Emergency Nursing, 11,5-11.
55.
InfantinoJ.A.MusingoS.Y. (1985). Assault and Injuries among Staff with and without Training in Aggression Control Techniques. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 36, 1312–1314.
56.
KennedyM.P. (2005). Violence in Emergency Departments: Under-reported, Unconstrained, and Unconscionable. The Medical Journal of Australia, 183, 362–365.
57.
KeoughV.A.SchlomerR.S.BollenbergB.W. (2003). Serendipitous Findings from an Illinois ED Nursing Educational Survey Reflect a Crisis in Emergency Nursing. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 29, 17–22.
58.
KowalenkoT.WaltersB.L.KhareR.K.ComptonS. (2005). Workplace Violence: A Survey of Emergency Physicians in the State of Michigan. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 46, 142–147.
59.
KuhnW. (1999). Violence in the Emergency Department: Managing Aggressive Patients in a High-stress Environment. Postgraduate Medicine, 105, 143–148, 154.
60.
LandauS.F. (1997a). Crime Patterns and Their Relation to Subjective Stress and Support Indicators: The Role of Gender. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 13, 29–56.
61.
LandauS.F. (1997b). Homicide in Israel: Its Relation to Subjective Stress and Support Indicators on the Macro Level. Homicide Studies, 1, 377–400.
62.
LandauS.F. (1998). Crime, Subjective Social Stress and Support Indicators, and Ethnic Origin: The Israeli Experience. Justice Quarterly, 15, 244–272.
63.
LandauS.F. (2002). Violence in Israeli Society: Its Relation to Social Stress. In Studies in Contemporary Jewry (MeddingP.Y., ed.) Vol. 18. Jews and Violence: Images, Ideologies, Realities. pp. 126–148. Oxford University Press; New York.
64.
LandauS.F. (2004). Violence Against Medical and Non-Medical Personnel in Hospital Emergency Wards in Israel. The Israel National Institute for Health Policy and Health Services Research; Tel Aviv. (Research Report) (In Hebrew).
65.
LandauS.F.Beit-HallahmiB. (1983). Aggression in Israel: A Psychohistorical Perspective. In Aggression in Global Perspective (GoldsteinA.P.SegallM.H., eds) pp. 261–286. Pergamon Press; New York.
66.
LandauS.F.BendalakJ. (2008). Personnel Exposure to Violence in Hospital Emergency Wards: A Routine Activity Approach. Aggressive Behavior, 34, 88–103.
67.
LandauS.F.FridmanD. (1993). The Seasonality of Violent Crime: The Case of Robbery and Homicide in Israel. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 30, 163–191.
68.
LaposaJ.M.AldenL.E.FullertonL.M. (2003). Work Stress and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder in ED Nurses/Personnel. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 29, 23–28.
69.
LeatherP.CoxT.FarnsworthW. (1990). Violence at Work: An Issue for the 1990s. Work and Stress, 4, 3–5.
70.
LynchJ.P. (1987). Routine Activity and Victimization at Work. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 3, 283–300.
71.
LynchJ.AppelbaumR.McQuillanP.J. (2003). Survey of Abuse and Violence by Patients and Relatives toward Intensive Care Staff. Anaesthesia, 58, 893–897.
72.
MackayC. (1994). Violence to Health Care Professionals: A Health and Safety Perspective. In Violence and Health Care Professionals (WykesT., ed.) pp. 9–22. Chapman and Hall; London.
73.
MadrizE. (1996). The Perception of Risk in the Workplace: A Test of Routine Activity Theory. Journal of Criminal Justice, 24, 407–418.
74.
MayD.D.GrubbsL.M. (2002). The Extent, Nature, and Precipitating Factors of Nurse Assault Among Three Groups of Registered Nurses in a Regional Medical Center. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 28, 11–17.
75.
MayerB.Y.SmithF.B.KingC.A. (1999). Factors Associated with Victimization of Personnel in Emergency Departments. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 26, 361–366.
76.
McLaughlinE. (2006). Routine Activity Theory. In The Sage Dictionary of Criminology (McLaughlinE.MuncieJ., eds) pp. 365–367. Sage; London.
77.
MessnerS.TardiffK. (1985). The Social Ecology of Urban Homicide: An Application of the Routine Activities Approach. Criminology, 23, 241–267.
78.
MietheT.StaffordM.LongJ. (1987). Social Differentiation in Criminal Victimization: A Test of Routine Activities/Lifestyle Theories. American Sociological Review, 52, 184–194.
79.
Ministry of Health (1999). Report of the Committee for the Evaluation of Strategies for Dealing with Violence in the Health System. Ministry of Health, Security; Jerusalem. (In Hebrew.)
80.
MorrisonJ.L.LantosJ.D.LevinsonW. (1998). Aggression and Violence Directed Towards Physicians. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 13, 556–561.
81.
Mustaine-EhrhardtE.TewksburyR. (1998). Predicting Risks of Larceny Theft Victimization: A Routine Activity Analysis using Refined Lifestyle Measures. Criminology, 36, 829–857.
82.
NachreinerN.M.GerberichS.G.McGovernP.M.ChurchT.R.HansenH.E.GeiserM.S.RyanA.D. (2005a). Impact of Training on Work-Related Assaults. Research in Nursing & Health, 28, 67–78.
83.
NachreinerN.M.GerberichS.G.McGovernP.M.ChurchT.R.HansenH.E.GeiserM.S.RyanA.D. (2005b). Relation Between Policies and Work Related Assault: Minnesota Nurses' Study. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 62, 675–681.
84.
NigroL.G.WaughW.L.Jr. (1996). Violence in the American Workforce: Challenges to the Public Employer. Public Administration Review, 56, 326–333.
85.
PaternosterR.MazerolleP. (1994). General Strain Theory and Delinquency: A Replication and Extension. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 31, 235–263.
86.
PatersonB.TurnbullJ.AitkenI. (1992). An Evaluation of a Training Course in the Short-term Management of Violence. Nurse Education Today, 12, 368–375.
87.
Peek-AsaC.CubbinL.HubbellK. (2002). Violent Events and Security Programs in California Emergency Departments Before and After the 1993 Hospital Security Act. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 28, 420–426.
88.
RoseM. (1997). A Survey of Violence toward Nursing Staff in One Large Irish Accident and Emergency Department. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 23, 214–220.
89.
Senuzun ErgunF.KaradakovanA. (2005). Violence Towards Nursing Staff in Emergency Departments in One Turkish City. International Nursing Review, 52, 154–160.
90.
SibbaldB. (1998). Physician, Protect Thyself. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 159, 987–989.
91.
StirlingG.HigginsJ.E.CookeM.W. (2001). Violence in A&E Departments: A Systematic Review of the Literature. Accident and Emergency Nursing, 9, 77–85.
92.
SwanS.C.GamboneL.J.FieldsA.M.SullivanT.P.SnowD.L. (2005). Women Who Use Violence in Intimate Relationships: The Role of Anger, Victimization and Symptoms of Posttraumatic Stress and Depression. Violence and Victims, 20, 267–285.
TurnbullJ. (1999). Violence to Staff: Who is at Risk? In Aggression and Violence: Approaches to Effective Management (TurnbullJ.PatersonB., eds) pp. 5–30. Macmillan; London.
95.
U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics (2001). National Crime Victimization Survey: Violence in the Workplace, 1993–99. http://www.ojp.-gov/bjs/pub/pdf/vw99.pdf.
96.
UzunÖ. (2003). Perceptions and Experiences of Nurses in Turkey about Verbal Abuse in Clinical Settings. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 35, 81–85.
97.
WellsJ.BowersL. (2002). How Prevalent is Violence Towards Nurses Working in General Hospitals in the UK?Journal of Advanced Nursing, 39, 230–240.
98.
WinstanleyS.WhittingtonR. (2004). Aggressive Encounters Between Patients and General Hospital Staff: Staff Perception of the Context and Assailants' Levels of Cognitive Processing. Aggressive Behavior, 30, 534–543.
99.
WooldredgeJ.CullenF.LatessaE. (1992). Victimization in the Workplace: A Test of Routine Activities Theory. Justice Quarterly, 9, 325–335.
100.
YassiA.TateR.CooperJ.JenkinsJ.TrottierJ. (1998). Causes of Staff Abuse in Health Care Facilities. American Association of Occupational Health Nurse, 46, 484–491.
101.
ZahidM.A.Al-SahlawiK.S.ShahidA.A.AwadhJ.A.Abu-ShammahH. (1999). Violence Against Doctors: 2. Effects of Violence on Doctors Working in Accident and Emergency Departments. European Journal of Emergency Medicine, 6, 305–309.
