Many studies explore the clinical and ethical dimensions of care at the end-of-life, but fewer use administrative data to examine individual and geographic differences, including the use of palliative care.
Aim:
Provide a population-based perspective on end-of-life and hospital palliative care among local authorities and hospitals in France.
Design:
Retrospective cohort study of care received by 17,928 decedents 65 and over (last 6 months of life), using the French national health insurance database
Results:
55.7% of decedents died in acute-care hospitals; 79% were hospitalized in them at least once; 11.7% were admitted at least once for hospital palliative care. Among 31 academic medical centers, intensive care unit admissions ranged from 12% to 67.4%; hospital palliative care admissions, from 2% to 30.6%. Across local authorities, for intensive care unit days and hospital palliative care admissions, the ratios between the values at the third and the first quartile were 2.4 and 1.5. The odds of admission for hospital palliative care or to an intensive care unit for more than 7 days were more than twice as high among people ⩽85 years (aOR = 2.11 (1.84–2.43) and aOR = 2.59 (2.12–3.17), respectively). The odds of admission for hospital palliative care were about 25% lower (p = 0.04) among decedents living in local authorities with the lowest levels of education than those with the highest levels.
Conclusion:
The variation we document in end-of-life and hospital palliative care across different categories of hospitals and 95 local authorities raises important questions as to what constitutes appropriate hospital use and intensity at the end-of-life.
KnaulFMFarmerPEKrakauerEL, et al.. Alleviating the access abyss in palliative care and pain relief—an imperative of universal health coverage: the Lancet Commission report. Lancet2018; 391(10128): 1391–1454.
3.
EmmanuelEJ.The status of end-of-life care in the United States. JAMA2018; 320(3): 239–241.
PredergastTJClaessensMTLuceJM.A national survey of end-of-life care for critically ill patients. Crit Care Med1998; 158: 1163–1167.
8.
BerlingerNJenningsBWolfSM. The hastings center guidelines for decisions on life-sustaining treatment and care near the end of life: revised and expanded second edition. New York: Oxford University Press, 2013.
MurtaghFEBauseweinCVerneJ, et al. How many people need palliative care? A study developing and comparing methods for population-based estimates. Palliat Med2014; 28(1): 49–58.
12.
AslaksonRALorenzK.Being CAREFuL about improving end-of-life care in hospitals. Lancet2017; 390(10090): 97–98.
13.
SioutaNvan BeekKPrestonN, et al. Towards integration of palliative care in patients with chronic heart failure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a systematic literature review of European guidelines and pathways. BMC Palliat Care2016; 15: 18.
14.
MorinLAubryRFrovaL, et al. Estimating the need for palliative care at the population level: a cross-national study in 12 countries. Palliat Med2017; 31(6): 526–536.
15.
JanahAGauthierLRMorinL, et al. Access to palliative care for cancer patients between diagnosis and death: a national cohort study. Clin Epidemiol2019; 11: 443–55.
16.
GusmanoMKRodwinVGWeiszD, et al. Comparative metrics and policy learning: end-of-life care in France and the US. J Comp Policy Anal2019; 21(5): 481–498.
17.
WennbergJEFisherESStukelTA, et al. Use of hospitals, physician visits, and hospice care during last six months of life among cohorts loyal to highly respected hospitals in the United States. BMJ2004; 328(7440): 607.
18.
WennbergJGittelsohnA.Small area variations in health care delivery. Science. 1973; 182: 102–108.
19.
GusmanoMKWeiszDRodwinVG, et al. Disparities in access to health care in three French regions. Health Policy2014; 114(1): 31–40.
CoralloACroxfordRGoodmanD, et al. A systematic review of medical practice variation in OECD countries. Health Policy2013; 114(1): 5–14.
22.
Oosterveld-VlugMGPasmanHRWten KoppelM, et al. Physician visits and recognition of residents’ terminal phase in long-term care facilities: findings from the PACE cross-sectional study in 6 EU countries. J Am Med Dir Assoc2019; 20(6): 696–702.
23.
KuoLCChenJHLeeCH, et al. End-of-life health care utilization between chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and lung cancer patients. J Pain Symptom Manage2019; 57(5): 933–943.
24.
JenningsLATurnerMKeeblerC, et al. The effect of a comprehensive dementia care management program on end-of-life care. J Am Geriatr Soc2019; 67: 443–448.
25.
SathitratanacheewinSEngelbergRADowneyL, et al. Temporal trends between 2010 and 2015 in intensity of care at end-of-life for patients with chronic illness: influence of age under vs. over 65 years. J Pain Symptom Manage2018; 55(1): 75–81.
26.
RomanoAMGadeKENielsenG, et al. Early palliative care reduces end-of-life intensive care unit (ICU) use but not ICU course in patients with advanced cancer. Oncologist2017; 22(3): 318–323.
27.
LeeRYBrumbackLCSathitratanacheewinS, et al. Association of physician orders for life-sustaining treatment with ICU admission among patients hospitalized near the end of life. JAMA2020; 323(10): 950–960.
28.
YouHDizonDSWongN, et al. Retrospective chart review to characterize admission to the ICU in the last 30 days of life and use of systemic anticancer therapy in the last two weeks of life at the Lifespan Cancer Institute. J Clin Oncol2020; 38(15 suppl): e19202–e19202.
29.
BaumannAAudibertGClaudotF, et al. Ethics review: end of life legislation – the French model. Crit Care2009; 13(1): 204.
30.
FerrandEJabrePVincent-GenodC, et al. Circumstances of death in hospitalized patients and nurses’ perceptions: French multicenter Mort-a-l’Hôpital survey. Arch Intern Med2008; 168(8): 867–875.
31.
PoulalhonCRotelli-BihetLRasoC, et al. Deaths in France: characteristics, place of death, hospitalisations and use of palliative care during the year before death. Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique2018; 66(1): 33–42.
32.
TuppinPRudantJConstantinouP, et al. Value of a national administrative database to guide public decisions: from the système national d’information interrégimes de l’Assurance Maladie (SNIIRAM) to the système national des données de santé (SNDS) in France. Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique2017; 65(Suppl 4): S149–S167.
33.
GoldbergMJouglaEFassaM, et al. The French public health information system. J Int Assoc Off Stat2012; 28(1): 31–41.
34.
TuppinPde RoquefeuilLWeillA, et al. French national health insurance information system and the permanent beneficiaries sample. Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique2010; 58(4): 286–290.
35.
DaviesJMSleemanKELenizJ, et al. Socioeconomic position and use of healthcare in the last year of life: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Med2019; 16(7): e1002878.
36.
GusmanoMKRodwinVGWeiszD, et al. A comparative analysis of hospital readmissions in France and the U.S.A. J Comp Policy Anal Res Pract2015; 18(2): 195–209.
37.
AllinSMasseriaCMossialosE.Measuring socioeconomic differences in use of health care services by wealth versus by income. Am J Public Health2009; 99(10): 1849–1855.
38.
AustinPCGoelVvan WalravenC.An introduction to multilevel regression models. Can J Public Health2001; 92(2): 150–154.
39.
BrownLD.Stealing on insensibly: end of life politics in the United States. Health Econ Policy Law2012; 7: 467–483.
40.
CallahanD.What kind of life? The limits of medical progress. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 1990.
41.
CallahanDNulandSB.The quagmire: how American medicine is destroying itself. New Republic, 9June2011.
42.
ZhangBWrightAAHuskampHA, et al. Health care costs in the last week of life: associations with end of life conversations. Arch Intern Med2009; 169(5): 480–488.
43.
GroffACCollaCHLeeTH.Days spent at home—a patient-centered goal and outcome. N Engl J Med2016; 375(17): 1610–1612.
44.
CallahanD.The roots of bioethics: health, progress, technology, death. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.
45.
SphiePGaymuJRiouF, et al. A majority of people would prefer to die at home, but few actually do so. Popul Soc2015; 524(7): 1–4.
46.
Le GuenMTobinA. Epidemiology of in-hospital mortality in acute patients admitted to a tertiary-level hospital. Intern Med J2016; 46(4): 457–464.
47.
TenoJMMitchellSLGozaloPL, et al. Hospital characteristics associated with feeding tube placement in nursing home residents with advanced cognitive impairment. JAMA2010; 303(6): 544–550.
48.
SérézalIGBeaussantYRochigneuxP, et al. End-of-life care for hospitalized patients with metastatic melanoma in France: a nationwide, register-based study. Br J Dermatol2016; 175(3): 583–592.
49.
CongdonE.Implementing easy-to-read advance directives at the CMMC family residency. Family Medicine Clerkship Student Projects2019: 511. https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/fmclerk/511
50.
WickershamEGowinMDeenMH, et al. Improving the adoption of advance directives in primary care practices. J Am Board Fam Med2019; 32(2): 168–179.
51.
PivodicLVan den BlockLPardonK, et al. Burden on family carers and care-related financial strain at the end of life: a cross-national population-based study. Eur J Public Health2014; 24(5): 819–826.
52.
CurtisJREngelbergRATenoJM.Understanding variability of end-of-life care in the ICU for the elderly. Intensive Care Med2017; 43(1): 94–96.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
