Holistic suffering is a debilitating problem for cancer patients. Although many treatments have been suggested for its alleviation, they have not been compared for effectiveness.
Aim:
This literature review seeks to identify what interventions are effective in treatment of holistic suffering of cancer patients.
Design:
A systematic review was conducted to identify and evaluate studies of interventions for holistic suffering in adult cancer patients. Search terms were generated iteratively from the literature.
Data sources:
MEDLINE, EMBASE, the Cochrane Library and PsycINFO databases were searched for the years 1992–2015. Included studies were peer-reviewed, English language reports of either a controlled trial or a randomised controlled trial focusing on therapies aimed at relieving suffering in adult cancer patients. Articles were excluded if focused predominantly on spiritual or existential issues or concerns not leading to suffering. Studies were graded for quality using the QualSyst quantitative checklist. Levels of evidence were ascertained by completing the National Health and Medical Research Council criteria. Results are reported according to AMSTAR guidelines.
Results:
The studies represented seven intervention types. Meaning-centred, hope-centred and stress-reduction interventions were found to be effective. Results of both psycho-educational and spiritual interventions in improving spiritual well-being were mixed. Supportive-expressive interventions – with the exception of forgiveness therapy – were not efficacious. There was little or no evidence for the efficacy of creative and healing arts and other assessed interventions such as animal therapy and haptotherapy.
Conclusion:
This systematic review found that spiritual well-being, meaning, hope and benefit finding can be positively impacted by a variety of treatment modalities.
DaneaultSLussierVMongeauS. Primum non nocere: could the health care system contribute to suffering? In-depth study from the perspective of terminally ill cancer patients. Can Fam Physician2006; 52: 1574–1575.
2.
LeMayKWilson KG. Treatment of existential distress in life threatening illness: a review of manualized interventions. Clin Psychol Rev2008; 28: 472–493.
3.
BradyMJPetermanAHFitchettG. A case for including spirituality in quality of life measurement in oncology. Psychooncology1999; 8(5): 417–428.
4.
McGrathP. Creating a language for ‘spiritual pain’ through research: a beginning. Support Care Cancer2002; 10(8): 637–646.
5.
LinH-RBauer-WuSM. Psycho-spiritual well-being in patients with advanced cancer: an integrative review of the literature. J Adv Nurs2003; 44(1): 69–80.
6.
NadenDSaeterenB. Cancer patients’ perception of being or not being confirmed. Nurs Ethics2006; 13: 222–235.
7.
BestMAldridgeLButowP. Conceptual Analysis of Suffering in Cancer: a systematic review. Psychooncology. Epub ahead of print 9March2015. DOI: 10.1002/pon.3795.
8.
BestMAldridgeLButowP. Assessment of spiritual suffering in the cancer context: a systematic literature review. Palliat Support Care2014; 1–27. DOI: 10.1017/S1478951514001217
9.
HenochIDanielsonE. Existential concerns among patients with cancer and interventions to meet them: an integrative literature review. Psychooncology2009; 18(3): 225–236.
10.
KmetLMLeeRCCookLS. Standard quality assessment criteria for evaluating primary research papers from a variety of fields. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research, 2004.
11.
MerlinTWestonATooherR. Extending an evidence hierarchy to include topics other than treatment: revising the Australian ‘levels of evidence’. BMC Med Res Methodol2009; 9(1): 34.
12.
SheaBJBouterLMPetersonJ. External validation of a measurement tool to assess systematic reviews (AMSTAR). PLoS ONE2007; 2(12): e1350.
13.
BadgerTASegrinCFigueredoAJ. Psychosocial interventions to improve quality of life in prostate cancer survivors and their intimate or family partners. Qual Life Res2011; 20: 833–844.
14.
KoinbergILangius-EklofAHolmbergL. The usefulness of a multidisciplinary educational programme after breast cancer surgery: a prospective and comparative study. Eur J Oncol Nurs2006; 10: 273–282.
15.
MenesesKDMcNeesPLoerzelVW. Transition from treatment to survivorship: effects of a psychoeducational intervention on quality of life in breast cancer survivors. Oncol Nurs Forum2007; 1007–1016.
16.
MenesesKMcNeesPAzueroA. Preliminary evaluation of psychoeducational support interventions on quality of life in rural breast cancer survivors post-primary treatment. Cancer Nurs2009; 32(5): 385–397.
17.
MeyersFJCarducciMLoscalzoMJ. Effects of a problem-solving intervention (COPE) on quality of life for patients with advanced cancer on clinical trials and their caregivers: simultaneous care educational intervention (SCEI): linking palliation and clinical trials. J Palliat Med2011; 14: 465–473.
18.
HawkesALPakenhamKIChambersSK. Effects of a multiple health behavior change intervention for colorectal cancer survivors on psychosocial outcomes and quality of life: a randomized controlled trial. Ann Behav Med2014; 48(3): 359–370.
19.
NorthouseLKershawTMoodD. Effects of a family intervention on the quality of life of women with recurrent breast cancer and their family caregivers. Psychooncology2005; 14(6): 478–491.
20.
NorthouseLLMoodDWSchafenackerA. Randomized clinical trial of a family intervention for prostate cancer patients and their spouses. Cancer2007; 110: 2809–2818.
21.
DelbarVBenor DanE. Impact of nursing intervention on cancer patients’ ability to cope. J Psychosoc Oncol2001; 19: 57–75.
22.
FergusonRJMcDonaldBCRocqueMA. Development of CBT for chemotherapy-related cognitive change: results of a waitlist control trial. Psychooncology2012; 21: 176–186.
23.
YavuzsenTKaradibakDCehreliR. Effect of group therapy on psychological symptoms and quality of life in Turkish patients with breast cancer. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev2012; 13(11): 5593–5597.
24.
AndoMMoritaTAkechiT. Efficacy of short-term life-review interviews on the spiritual well-being of terminally ill cancer patients. J Pain Symptom Manage2010; 39(6): 993–1002.
25.
HoumannLJChochinovHMKristjansonLJ. A prospective evaluation of Dignity Therapy in advanced cancer patients admitted to palliative care. Palliat Med2014; 28(5): 448–458.
26.
ChochinovHMKristjansonLJBreitbartW. Effect of dignity therapy on distress and end-of-life experience in terminally ill patients: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet Oncol2011; 12(8): 753–762.
27.
BreitbartWPoppitoSRosenfeldB. Pilot randomized controlled trial of individual meaning-centered psychotherapy for patients with advanced cancer. J Clin Oncol2012; 30(12): 1304–1309.
28.
HenryMCohenSRLeeV. The Meaning-Making intervention (MMi) appears to increase meaning in life in advanced ovarian cancer: a randomized controlled pilot study. Psychooncology2010; 19: 1340–1347.
29.
BreitbartWRosenfeldBGibsonC. Meaning-centered group psychotherapy for patients with advanced cancer: a pilot randomized controlled trial. Psychooncology2010; 19: 21–28.
30.
TravadoLGrassiLGilF. Do spirituality and faith make a difference? Report from the Southern European Psycho-Oncology Study Group. Palliat Support Care2010; 8(4): 405–413.
31.
HansenMJEnrightRDBaskinTW. A palliative care intervention in forgiveness therapy for elderly terminally ill cancer patients. J Palliat Care2009; 25: 51–60.
32.
CowardDD. Facilitation of self-transcendence in a breast cancer support group: II. Oncol Nurs Forum2003; 291–300.
33.
HeineySPMcWayneJHurleyTG. Efficacy of therapeutic group by telephone for women with breast cancer. Cancer Nurs2003; 26: 439–447.
34.
SalzerMSPalmerSCKaplanK. A randomized, controlled study of Internet peer-to-peer interactions among women newly diagnosed with breast cancer. Psychooncology2010; 19: 441–446.
35.
BoutinDL. Effectiveness of cognitive behavioral and supportive-expressive group therapy for women diagnosed with breast cancer: a review of the literature. J Spec Gr Work2007; 32(3): 267–284.
36.
ChandwaniKDThorntonBPerkinsGH. Yoga improves quality of life and benefit finding in women undergoing radiotherapy for breast cancer. J Soc Integr Oncol2010; 8: 43–55.
37.
DanhauerSCMihalkoSLRussellGB. Restorative yoga for women with breast cancer: findings from a randomized pilot study. Psychooncology2009; 18: 360–368.
38.
MoadelABShahCWylie-RosettJ. Randomized controlled trial of yoga among a multiethnic sample of breast cancer patients: effects on quality of life. J Clin Oncol2007; 25(28): 4387–4395.
39.
GarlandSNCarlsonLECookS. A non-randomized comparison of mindfulness-based stress reduction and healing arts programs for facilitating post-traumatic growth and spirituality in cancer outpatients. Support Care Cancer2007; 15: 949–961.
40.
HendersonVPClemowLMassionAO. The effects of mindfulness-based stress reduction on psychosocial outcomes and quality of life in early-stage breast cancer patients: a randomized trial. Breast Cancer Res Treat2012; 131: 99–109.
41.
Witek-JanusekLAlbuquerqueKChroniakKR. Effect of mindfulness based stress reduction on immune function, quality of life and coping in women newly diagnosed with early stage breast cancer. Brain Behav Immun2008; 22(6): 969–981.
42.
ZernickeKACampbellTSSpecaM. A randomized wait-list controlled trial of feasibility and efficacy of an online mindfulness-based cancer recovery program: the eTherapy for cancer applying mindfulness trial. Psychosom Med2014; 76(4): 257–267.
43.
LabelleLELawlor-SavageLCampbellTS. Does self-report Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) on spirituality and posttraumatic growth in cancer patients?J Posit Psychol2015; 10(2): 153–166.
44.
AntoniMHLehmanJMKilbournKM. Cognitive-behavioral stress management intervention decreases the prevalence of depression and enhances benefit finding among women under treatment for early-stage breast cancer. Health Psychol2001; 20(1): 20–32.
45.
AntoniMHLechnerSCKaziA. How stress management improves quality of life after treatment for breast cancer. J Consult Clin Psychol2006; 74(6): 1143–1152.
46.
PenedoFMoltonIDahnJ. A randomized clinical trial of group-based cognitive-behavioral stress management in localized prostate cancer: development of stress management skills improves quality of life and benefit finding. Ann Behav Med2006; 31(3): 261–270.
47.
NidichSIFieldsJZRainforthMV. A randomized controlled trial of the effects of transcendental meditation on quality of life in older breast cancer patients. Integr Cancer Ther2009; 8(3): 228–234.
48.
FallahRGolzariMDastaniM. Integrating spirituality into a group psychotherapy program for women surviving from breast cancer. Iran J Cancer Prev2011; 4: 142–148.
49.
HsiaoFHJowGMKuoWH. The effects of psychotherapy on psychological well-being and diurnal cortisol patterns in breast cancer survivors. Psychother Psychosom2012; 81: 173–182.
50.
RummansTAClarkMMSloanJA. Impacting quality of life for patients with advanced cancer with a structured multidisciplinary intervention: a randomized controlled trial. J Clin Oncol2006; 24: 635–642.
51.
DjuricZMirasoloJKimbroughL. A pilot trial of spirituality counseling for weight loss maintenance in African American breast cancer survivors. J Natl Med Assoc2009; 101: 552–564.
52.
JafariNFarajzadeganZZamaniA. Spiritual therapy to improve the spiritual well-being of Iranian women with breast cancer. A randomized controlled trial. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med2013; 2013: 353262.
53.
KristellerJRhodesMCripeL. Oncologist Assisted Spiritual Intervention Study (OASIS): patient acceptability and initial evidence of effects. Int J Psychiatry Med2005; 35(4): 329–347.
54.
HerthK. Enhancing hope in people with a first recurrence of cancer. J Adv Nurs2000; 32: 1431–1441.
55.
RustoenTWiklundIHanestadBR. Nursing intervention to increase hope and quality of life in newly diagnosed cancer patients. Cancer Nurs1998; 21: 235–245.
56.
DugglebyWDDegnerLWilliamsA. Living with hope: initial evaluation of a psychosocial hope intervention for older palliative home care patients. J Pain Symptom Manage2007; 33: 247–257.
57.
RosenfeldBPessinHLewisC. Assessing hopelessness in terminally ill cancer patients: development of the hopelessness assessment in illness questionnaire. Psychol Assess2011; 23: 325–336.
58.
SachsEKolvaEPessinH. On sinking and swimming: the dialectic of hope, hopelessness, and acceptance in terminal cancer. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2012; 30(2): 121–127.
59.
PuigALee SMGoodwinL. The efficacy of creative arts therapies to enhance emotional expression, spirituality, and psychological well-being of newly diagnosed Stage I and Stage II breast cancer patients: a preliminary study. Arts Psychother2006; 33: 218–228.
60.
Hanser SBBauer-WuSKubicekL. Effects of a music therapy intervention on quality of life and distress in women with metastatic breast cancer. J Soc Integr Oncol2006; 4: 116–124.
61.
MosherCEDuHamelKNLamJ. Randomised trial of expressive writing for distressed metastatic breast cancer patients. Psychol Health2012; 27: 88–100.
62.
McMillanSCSmallBJHaleyWE. Improving hospice outcomes through systematic assessment: a clinical trial. Cancer Nurs2011; 34: 89–97.
63.
JohnsonRAMeadowsRLHaubnerJS. Animal-assisted activity among patients with cancer: effects on mood, fatigue, self-perceived health, and sense of coherence. Oncol Nurs Forum2008; 35: 225–232.
64.
Van den BergMVisserASchoolmeestersA. Evaluation of haptotherapy for patients with cancer treated with chemotherapy at a day clinic. Patient Educ Couns2006; 60: 336–343.
65.
BüchiSBuddebergCKlaghoferR. Preliminary validation of PRISM (Pictorial Representation of Illness and Self Measure) – A brief method to assess suffering. Psychother Psychosom2002; 71(6): 333–341.
66.
CanadaALMurphyPEFitchettG. A 3-factor model for the FACIT-Sp. Psychooncology2008; 17(9): 908–916.
67.
SudoreRLVillarsPCareyEC. Sitting with you in your suffering: lessons about intractable pain at the end of life. J Palliat Med2010; 13: 779–782.
68.
PensonRTYusufRZChabnerBA. Losing God. Oncologist2001; 6(3): 286–297.
69.
LangegardUAhlbergK. Consolation in conjunction with incurable cancer. Oncol Nurs Forum2009; 36: E99–E106.
70.
LethborgCArandaSKissaneD. Meaning in adjustment to cancer: a model of care. Palliat Support Care2008; 6: 61–70.
