Insight and progress in rehabilitation

Abstract

The literature on the effect of insight on rehabilitation success is reviewed. Its role as a possible motivating factor is considered in the context of the development of the concept of motivation. The difficulties of research in this field are discussed. The aim of the present study is stated as an attempt to clarify the effect of insight on rehabilitation success by exploring the relationship between insight and motivation. In this study accuracy of insight was not found to be related to rehabilitation success. Clients who overrated their abilities, i.e., were optimistic, did better than the underconfident or pessimistic clients. Optimistic clients were more highly motivated in that they saw scope for improvements and were sure of achieving these gains without too much effort. Previous studies are reexamined in the light of these findings and possible explanations for the discrepant results are presented.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Prigatano GP , Fordyce DJ , Zeiner HK , Roueche JR , Pepping M. , Wood BC Neuropsychological rehabilitation after closed head injury in young adults. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1986; 47: 505-13.

Powell GE

The self after brain injury: theory, research and rehabilitation

Journal of Clinical & Experimental Neuropsychology 1986 ; 8: 115.

Hohmann GW The insider-outsider position and the maintenance of hope. Rehabilitation Psychology 1975; 22: 136-41.

Hackler RN , Tobis JS Reintegration into the community In: Rosenthal M , Griffith ER , Bond MR , Miller JD eds, Rehabilitation of the head-injured adult Philadelphia: FA Davis, 1984.

Fogel ML , Rosillo RH Correlation of psychological variables and progress in rehabilitation: II Motivation, attitudes and flexibility of goals. Diseases of the Nervous System 1969; 30: 593-601.

Zane MD , Lowenthal M.

Motivation in rehabilitation of the physically handicapped

Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1960; 41: 400-407.

McDaniel JW Physical disability & human behaviour Pergamon Press , 1976.

Hawryluk A.

Rehabilitation gain: a better indicator needed

J Rehabilitation 1972; 38: 22-25.

Ben-Yishay Y. , Silver SM , Piasetsky E. , Rattok J.

Relationship between employability and vocational outcome after intensive holistic cognitive rehabilitation

J Head Trauma Rehabilitation 1987; 2: 35-48.

10.

Barth JT , Boll TJ Rehabilitation and treatment of central nervous system dysfunction. A behavioural medicine perspective In: Prokop CK , Bradley LA eds, Medical psychology: contributions to behavioural medicine New York: Academic Press, 1981.