Virtual reality augments effectiveness of treadmill walking training in patients with walking and balance impairments: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online May, 2023
Virtual reality augments effectiveness of treadmill walking training in patients with walking and balance impairments: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
To systematically summarize and examine current evidence regarding the combination of virtual reality and treadmill training in patients with walking and balance impairments.
Data sources
English language randomized controlled trials, participants with walking and balance impairments, intervention group used virtual reality and treadmill, control group only used treadmill with the same training frequency and number of sessions. Six bioscience and engineering databases were searched.
Methods
Two independent reviewers conducted study selection, data extraction, and quality assessment. Methodological quality was assessed using the Physiotherapy Evidence Database (PEDro) scale.
Results
Sixteen randomized controlled trials including 829 participants were identified. Compared to treadmill-only training, virtual reality augmented treadmill training induced significantly faster walking (p < 0.001; standardized mean difference (SMD) = 0.55, 95%CI: 0.30 to 0.81), longer step length (p < 0.001; SMD = 0.74, 95%CI: 0.42 to 1.06), narrower step width (p = 0.03; SMD = −0.52, 95%CI: −0.97 to −0.06), longer single leg stance period (p = 0.003; SMD = 0.77, 95%CI: 0.27 to 1.27), better functional mobility (p = 0.003; SMD = −0.44, 95%CI: − 0.74 to −0.15), improved balance function (p = 0.04; SMD = 0.24, 95%CI: 0.01 to 0.47), and enhanced balance confidence (p = 0.03; SMD = 0.73, 95%CI: 0.08 to 1.37). Walking endurance did not differ significantly between groups (p = 0.21; SMD = 0.13, 95%CI: −0.07 to 0.34).
Conclusions
Virtual reality augmented treadmill walking training enhances outcomes compared to treadmill-only training in patients with walking and balance impairments. The results of this review support the clinical significance of combining virtual reality with treadmill training with level 1A empirical evidence.
BayonaNABitenskyJSalterK, et al. The role of task-specific training in rehabilitation therapies. Top Stroke Rehabil2005; 12: 58–65.
2.
HubbardIJParsonsMWNeilsonC, et al. Task-specific training: evidence for and translation to clinical practice. Occup Ther Int2009; 16: 175–189.
3.
DimyanMACohenLG. Neuroplasticity in the context of motor rehabilitation after stroke. Nature Reviews Neurology2011; 7: 76–85.
4.
CramerSCSurMDobkinBH, et al. Harnessing neuroplasticity for clinical applications. Brain2011; 134: 1591–1609.
5.
KleimJAJonesTA. Principles of experience-dependent neural plasticity: implications for rehabilitation after brain damage. J Speech Lang Hear Res2008; 51: S225–S239.
6.
PoleseJCAdaLDeanCM, et al. Treadmill training is effective for ambulatory adults with stroke: a systematic review. J Physiother2013; 59: 73–80.
7.
MehrholzJThomasSElsnerB. Treadmill training and body weight support for walking after stroke. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2017; 8.
8.
MehrholzJKuglerJStorchA, et al. Treadmill training for patients with Parkinson’s disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2015; 9.
9.
Torres-OviedoGBastianAJ. Seeing is believing: effects of visual contextual cues on learning and transfer of locomotor adaptation. J Neurosci2010; 30: 17015–17022.
10.
MassettiTDa SilvaTDCrocettaTB, et al. The clinical utility of virtual reality in neurorehabilitation: a systematic review. J Cent Nerv Syst Dis2018; 10.
11.
LevinMF. Can virtual reality offer enriched environments for rehabilitation?Expert Rev Neurother2011; 11: 153–155.
12.
HowardMC. A meta-analysis and systematic literature review of virtual reality rehabilitation programs. Comput Hum Behav2017; 70: 317–327.
13.
RohrbachNChicklisELevacDE. What is the impact of user affect on motor learning in virtual environments after stroke? A scoping review. J Neuroeng Rehabil2019; 16: 1–14.
14.
DockxKBekkersEMVan den BerghV, et al. Virtual reality for rehabilitation in Parkinson’s disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2016; 12.
15.
De KeersmaeckerEBeckwéeDDenissenS, et al. Virtual reality for multiple sclerosis rehabilitation. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2021; 1.
16.
LaverKELangeBGeorgeS, et al. Virtual reality for stroke rehabilitation. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2017; 11.
17.
PorrasDCSiemonsmaPInzelbergR, et al. Advantages of virtual reality in the rehabilitation of balance and gait: systematic review. Neurology2018; 90: 1017–1025.
18.
PageMJMcKenzieJEBossuytPM, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. Syst Rev2021; 10: 1–11.
19.
VerhagenAPDe VetHCDe BieRA, et al. The Delphi list: a criteria list for quality assessment of randomized clinical trials for conducting systematic reviews developed by Delphi consensus. J Clin Epidemiol1998; 51: 1235–1241.
20.
MaherCGSherringtonCHerbertRD, et al. Reliability of the PEDro scale for rating quality of randomized controlled trials. Phys Ther2003; 83: 713–721.
21.
HigginsJPThompsonSGDeeksJJ, et al. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. Br Med J2003; 327: 557-560.
22.
LeeK. Virtual reality gait training to promote balance and gait among older people: a randomized clinical trial. Geriatrics2021; 6.
23.
BekkersEMMirelmanAAlcockL, et al. Do patients with Parkinson’s disease with freezing of gait respond differently than those without to treadmill training augmented by virtual reality?Neurorehabil Neural Repair2020; 34: 440–449.
24.
ChoCHwangWHwangS, et al. Treadmill training with virtual reality improves gait, balance, and muscle strength in children with cerebral palsy. Tohoku J Exp Med2016; 238: 213–218.
25.
ChoKHLeeWH. Effect of treadmill training based real-world video recording on balance and gait in chronic stroke patients: a randomized controlled trial. Gait Posture2014; 39: 523–528.
26.
ChoKHLeeWH. Virtual walking training program using a real-world video recording for patients with chronic stroke: a pilot study. Am J Phys Med Rehabil2013; 92: 371–384.
27.
JungJYuJKangH. Effects of virtual reality treadmill training on balance and balance self-efficacy in stroke patients with a history of falling. J Phys Ther Sci2012; 24: 1133–1136.
28.
KimHChoiWLeeK, et al. Virtual dual-task treadmill training using video recording for gait of chronic stroke survivors: a randomized controlled trial. J Phys Ther Sci2015; 27: 3693–3697.
29.
MaidanINieuwhofFBernad-ElazariH, et al. Evidence for differential effects of 2 forms of exercise on prefrontal plasticity during walking in Parkinson’s disease. Neurorehabil Neural Repair2018; 32: 200–208.
30.
MaidanIRosenberg-KatzKJacobY, et al. Disparate effects of training on brain activation in Parkinson disease. Neurology2017; 89: 1804–1810.
31.
MirelmanARochesterLMaidanI, et al. Addition of a non-immersive virtual reality component to treadmill training to reduce fall risk in older adults (V-TIME): a randomised controlled trial. The Lancet2016; 388: 1170–1182.
32.
PelosinECerulliCOgliastroC, et al. A multimodal training modulates short afferent inhibition and improves complex walking in a cohort of faller older adults with an increased prevalence of Parkinson’s disease. The Journals of Gerontology: Series A2020; 75: 722–728.
33.
PeruzziAZarboIRCereattiA, et al. An innovative training program based on virtual reality and treadmill: effects on gait of persons with multiple sclerosis. Disabil Rehabil2017; 39: 1557–1563.
34.
YangSHwangWTsaiY, et al. Improving balance skills in patients who had stroke through virtual reality treadmill training. Am J Phys Med Rehabil2011; 90: 969–978.
35.
KangHKimYChungY, et al. Effects of treadmill training with optic flow on balance and gait in individuals following stroke: randomized controlled trials. Clin Rehabil2012; 26: 246–255.
36.
YangYTsaiMChuangT, et al. Virtual reality-based training improves community ambulation in individuals with stroke: a randomized controlled trial. Gait Posture2008; 28: 201–206.
37.
KrzisnikMRauterBHBizovicarN. Effects of virtual reality-based treadmill training on the balance and gait ability in patients after stroke: a randomized controlled trial. Hrvatska Revija za Rehabilitacijska Istrazivanja2021; 57: 92–102.
38.
AlexandreTSMeiraDMRicoNC, et al. Accuracy of Timed Up and Go Test for screening risk of falls among community-dwelling elderly. Braz J Phys Ther2012; 16: 381–388.
39.
BurnsPBRohrichRJChungKC. The levels of evidence and their role in evidence-based medicine. Plast Reconstr Surg2011; 128: 305–310.
40.
GhaiSGhaiILamontagneA. Virtual reality training enhances gait poststroke: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann N Y Acad Sci2020; 1478: 18–42.
41.
ZhangBLiDLiuY, et al. Virtual reality for limb motor function, balance, gait, cognition and daily function of stroke patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Adv Nurs2021; 77: 3255–3273.
42.
WangBShenMWangY, et al. Effect of virtual reality on balance and gait ability in patients with Parkinson’s disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Rehabil2019; 33: 1130–1138.
43.
SarassoEGardoniATettamantiA, et al. Virtual reality balance training to improve balance and mobility in Parkinson’s disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Neurol2022; 269: 1873–1888.
44.
ChenYGaoQHeC, et al. Effect of virtual reality on balance in individuals with Parkinson disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Phys Ther2020; 100: 933–945.
45.
LiRZhangYJiangY, et al. Rehabilitation training based on virtual reality for patients with Parkinson’s disease in improving balance, quality of life, activities of daily living, and depressive symptoms: A systematic review and meta-regression analysis. Clin Rehabil2021; 35: 1089–1102.
46.
LiKZBhererLMirelmanA, et al. Cognitive involvement in balance, gait and dual-tasking in aging: a focused review from a neuroscience of aging perspective. Front Neurol2018; 9.
47.
LeeI. Does the speed of the treadmill influence the training effect in people learning to walk after stroke? A double-blind randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil2015; 29: 269–276.
48.
de RooijIJvan de PortIGLPuntM, et al. Effect of Virtual Reality Gait Training on Participation in Survivors of Subacute Stroke: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Phys Ther2021; 101.
49.
HuangCBusterTSiuK, et al. Combining Virtual Reality Gaming With Motor-Assisted Elliptical Impacts Children’s Engagement in Exercise. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2018; 99.
50.
DeutschJEJames-PalmerADamodaranH, et al. Comparison of neuromuscular and cardiovascular exercise intensity and enjoyment between standard of care, off-the-shelf and custom active video games for promotion of physical activity of persons post-stroke. J Neuroeng Rehabil2021; 18: 1–12.
51.
DevereauxJ. Comparison of rates of perceived exertion between active video games and traditional exercise. International SportMed Journal2012; 13: 133–140.
52.
KeshnerE.LamontagneA. The untapped potential of virtual reality in rehabilitation of balance and gait in neurologic disorders. Frontiers in Virtual Reality2021; 2.
53.
Armijo-OlivoSFuentesJda CostaBR, et al. Blinding in physical therapy trials and its association with treatment effects: a meta-epidemiological study. Am J Phys Med Rehabil2017; 96: 34–44.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
