Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2022-4
Effects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation on exercise capacity,muscle strength and quality of life in COPD patients: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis
To determine the effects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation on disabilities and activity limitation of individuals affected by chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
Data sources
MEDLINE, PEDro database, Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, and SciELO, were searched from inception until October 2021.
Review methods
Inclusion criteria were patients with COPD, randomized controlled trials comparing neuromuscular electrical stimulation alone or combined conventional pulmonary rehabilitation and neuromuscular electrical stimulation versus control or sham or pulmonary rehabilitation in disabilities and activity limitation in COPD. There were no mandatory language or publication date restrictions. Two reviewers selected studies independently. Weighted mean differences and 95% confidence intervals were calculated. Results 32 studies met the study criteria, including 1.269 participants. Neuromuscular electrical stimulation improved exercise capacity (MD 1.10, 95% CI: 0.33, 1.86, N = 147), and muscle strength (0.53, 95% CI: 0.20, 0.87, N = 147) compared to sham group. Combined neuromuscular electrical stimulation and conventional rehabilitation improved exercise capacity (MD 34.28 meters, 95% CI: 6.84, 61.73, N = 262) compared to conventional rehabilitation alone. No adverse events were reported.
Conclusions
Neuromuscular electrical stimulation resulted in small improvement in disabilities and activity limitation (below the MCID) in COPD. Thus, the inclusion of neuromuscular electrical stimulation in rehabilitation programs must consider the cost Because of inadequate methodological conduction and reporting of methods, some studies were of low quality.
Rodriguez-RoisinRRabeKFVestboJ,et al.Global initiative for chronic obstructive lung disease (GOLD) 20th anniversary: a brief history of time. Eur Respir J2017; 50: 1700671.
2.
GeaJCasadevallCPascualS,et al.Clinical management of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients with muscle dysfunction. J Thorac Dis2016; 8: 3379–3400.
3.
BarreiroEGeaJ. Respiratory and limb muscle dysfunction in COPD. COPD2015; 12: 413–426.
4.
MaltaisFDecramerMCasaburiR, et al. An official American thoracic society/european respiratory society statement: update on limb muscle dysfunction in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Am J Respir Crit Care Med2014; 189: e15–e62.
5.
JonesSManWDGaoW,et al.Neuromuscular electrical stimulation for muscle weakness in adults with advanced disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2016; 10: CD009419.
6.
SillenMJFranssenFMGoskerHR,et al.Metabolic and structural changes in lower-limb skeletal muscle following neuromuscular electrical stimulation: a systematic review. PLoS One2013; 8: e69391.
7.
SaitohMDos SantosMRAnkerM,et al.Neuromuscular electrical stimulation for muscle wasting in heart failure patients. Int J Cardiol2016; 225: 200–205.
8.
SillenMJHSpeksnijderCMEtermanRA,et al.Effects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation of muscles of ambulation in patients with chronic heart failure or COPD: a systematic review of the English-language literature. Chest2009; 136: 44–61.
9.
ChenRCLiXYGuanLL, et al. Effectiveness of neuromuscular electrical stimulation for the rehabilitation of moderate-to-severe COPD: a meta-analysis. Int J Chron Obstruct Pulmon Dis2016; 11: 2965–2975. eCollection 2016.
10.
PanLGuoYLiuX, et al.Lack of efficacy of neuromuscular electrical stimulation of the lower limbs in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients: a meta-analysis. Respirology2014; 19: 22–29.
11.
HillKCavalheriVMathurS, et al.Neuromuscular electrostimulation for adults with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2018; 5: CD010821.
12.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJ, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Br Med J2009; 339: b2535.
13.
Higgins JPT, Thomas J, Chandler J, Cumpston M, Li T, Page MJ, Welch VA (editors). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions version 6.2 (updated February 2021). Cochrane, 2021. Available from www.training.cochrane.org/handbook.
14.
OlivoSAMacedoLGGadottiIN,et al.Scales to assess the quality of randomized controlled trials: a systematic review. PhysTher2008; 88: 156–175.
15.
VerhagenAPde VetHCWde BieRA, et al. The delphi list: a criteria list for quality assessment of randomized clinical trials for conducting systematic reviews developed by delphi consensus. J ClinEpidemiol1998; 51: 1235–1241.
16.
Gomes-NetoMRodrigues-EJrSilva-WJr, et al.Effects of yoga in patients with chronic heart failure: a meta-analysis. Arq Bras Cardiol2014; 103: 433–439.
17.
HigginsJPThompsonSGDeeksJJ, et al.Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. Br Med J2003; 327: 557–560.
18.
Collaboration TC. Available at: www.cochrane.org. [Accessed 3 may 2021].
19.
BonnevieTGravierFEDebeaumontD, et al.Home-based neuromuscular electrical stimulation as an add-on to pulmonary rehabilitation does not provide further benefits in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a multicenter randomized trial. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2018; ;99(8):1462–1470. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2018.01.024.
20.
MedrinalCPrieurGCombretY, et al. Functional electrical stimulation-A new therapeutic approach to enhance exercise intensity in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients: a randomised controlled cross-over trial. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2018; 99(8):1454–1461. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2018.02.002.
21.
ValenzaMCTorres-SánchezILópez-LópezL,et al.Effects of home-based superimposed neuromuscular electrical stimulation in severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients: a randomized controlled clinical trial. Eur J Phys Rehabil Med2017; 54(3):323–332. doi: 10.23736/S1973-9087.17.04745-1
22.
KucioCNiesporekJKucioE,et al.Evaluation of the effects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation of The lower limbs combined with pulmonary rehabilitation on exercise tolerance in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. J Hum Kinet2016; 54: 75–82.
23.
MaddocksMNolanCMManWD, et al.Neuromuscular electrical stimulation to improve exercise capacity in patients with severe COPD: a randomised double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. Lancet Respir Med2016; 4: 27–36.
24.
AkarOGünayESarinc UlasliS, et al.Efficacy of neuromuscular electrical stimulation in patients with COPD followed in intensive care unit. Clin Respir J2017; 11: 743–750.
25.
TasdemirFInal-InceDErgunP,et al.Neuromuscular electrical stimulation as an adjunct to endurance and resistance training during pulmonary rehabilitation in stable chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Expert Rev Respir Med2015; 9: 493–502.
26.
VieiraPJChiappaAMCiprianoGJr,et al.Neuromuscular electrical stimulation improves clinical and physiological function in COPD patients. Respir Med2014; 108: 609–620.
27.
SillenMJFranssenFMDelbressineJM,et al.Efficacy of lower-limb muscle training modalities in severely dyspnoeic individuals with COPD and quadriceps muscle weakness: results from the DICES trial. Thorax2014; 69: 525–531.
28.
GreeningNJWilliamsJEHussainSF, et al.An early rehabilitation intervention to enhance recovery during hospital admission for an exacerbation of chronic respiratory disease: randomised controlled trial. Br Med J2014; 349: g4315.
29.
Dall’ AcquaAADohnertMdos SantosL. Neuromuscular electrical stimulation with Russian current for expiratory muscle training in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. J Phys Ther Sci2012; 24: 955–959.
30.
VivodtzevIDebigaréRGagnonP, et al.Functional and muscular effects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation in patients with severe COPD: a randomized clinical trial. Chest2012; 141: 716–725.
AbdellaouiAPréfautCGouziF, et al.Skeletal muscle effects of electrostimulation after COPD exacerbation: a pilot study. Eur Respir J2011; 38: 781–788.
33.
Dal CorsoSNápolisLMalagutiC, et al.Skeletal muscle structure and function in response to electrical stimulation in moderately impaired COPD patients. Respir Med2007; 101: 1236–1243.
34.
VivodtzevIPépinJLVotteroG,et al.Improvement in quadriceps strength and dyspnea in daily tasks after 1 month of electrical stimulation in severely deconditioned and malnourished COPD. Chest2006; 129: 1540–1548.
35.
ZanottiEFelicettiGMainiM, et al.Peripheral muscle strength training in bed-bound patients with COPD receiving mechanical ventilation: effect of electrical stimulation. Chest2003; 124: 292–296.
36.
Bourjeily-HabrGRochesterCLPalermoF,et al.Randomised controlled trial of transcutaneous electrical muscle stimulation of the lower extremities in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Thorax2002; 57: 1045–1049.
37.
NederJASwordDWardSA,et al.Home based neuromuscular electrical stimulation as a new rehabilitative strategy for severely disabled patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Thorax2002; 57: 333–337.
38.
PéranLCastelMBeaumontM. Effets de l’électrostimulation neuromusculaire combinée des triceps suraux et des quadriceps dans la BPCO sévère et très sévère lors d’un programme de réhabilitation respiratoire. Kinesitherapie2018; 18: 877–887.
39.
ZanottiEBizzarriCGrassoR, et al.Combination of pulmonary rehabilitation and neuromuscular electrical stimulation in COPD patients: a randomized clinical trial of efficacy. J Pulmonar Respirat Med2012; 2:1–6. doi:10.4172/2161-105X.1000112
40.
GiavedoniSDeansAMcCaugheyP,et al.Neuromuscular electrical stimulation prevents muscle function deterioration in exacerbated COPD: a pilot study. Resp Med2012; 10: 1429–1434.
41.
MekkiMPaillardTSahliS, et al.Effect of adding neuromuscular electrical stimulation training to pulmonary rehabilitation in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: randomized clinical trial. Clin Rehabil2019; 33: 195–206.
42.
GigliottiFBalliniMBertoliniMG,et al.Effect of neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) as an adjunct to an exercise training program (EXT) in patients with severe COPD. Eur Respir J2004; 24: 256s.
43.
DangDNGluckMPirnayF,et al.Interest of neuromuscular electro-stimulation (NMES) in COPD patients during an ambulatory comprehensive respiratory rehabilitation program. Eur Respir J2011; 38: p4807.
44.
AkinlabiKMainEGarrodR, et al.Neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES), A new strategy in the pulmonay rehabilitation of patients with severe and very severe MRC 4 and 5 chronic obstrutive pulmonary disease (COPD). Thorax2013 68: A17. doi: 10.1136/thoraxjnl-2013-204457.35
45.
LatimerLGreeningNMorganM,et al.Unilateral neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) of the quadriceps muscles in stable COPD. Eur Respir J2013; 42: P3571.
46.
DolmageTBrooksDGoldsteinR. The effects Of high And Low frequency transcutaneous electrical muscle stimulation (tcems) On exercise In patients With COPD: a pilot study. ATS J2016; 193: A3990.
47.
TardifCRoyAViacrozeC, et al. Does neuromuscular electrical stimulation of the quadriceps during rehabilitation in COPD outpatients adds a benefit?Eur Respir J2013; 46: OA1755.
48.
ChenSJiangYYuB,et al.Effect of transcutaneous neuromuscular electrical stimulation on prevention of intensive care unit-acquired weakness in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients with mechanical ventilation. Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue. 2019; 31: 709–713.
49.
Lopez LopezLGranados SantiagoMDonaire GalindoM,et al.Efficacy of combined electrostimulation in patients with acute exacerbation of COPD: randomised clinical trial. Med Clin (Barc)2018; 151: 323–328. English, Spanish.
50.
AchecheAMekkiMPaillardT,et al.The effect of adding neuromuscular electrical stimulation with endurance and resistance training on exercise capacity and balance in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a randomized controlled trial. Can Respir J2020; 2020: 9826084. PMID: 33062081
51.
PuhanMAGimeno-SantosECatesCJ, et al.Pulmonary rehabilitation following exacerbations of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2016; 12: CD005305. PMID: 27930803; PMCID: PMC6463852.
HongZSuiMZhuangZ,et al.Effectiveness of neuromuscular electrical stimulation on lower limbs of patients With hemiplegia after chronic stroke: a systematic review. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2018; 99(5):1011–1022.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr2017.12.019.
54.
American Thoracic Society, Board of Directors. ATS Statement: guidelines for the six-minute walk testAm J Respir Crit Care Med2002; 166: 111–117.
55.
WiseRABrownCD. Minimal clinically important differences in the six-minute walk test and the incremental shuttle walking test. COPD2005; 2: 125–129.
56.
HollandAEHillCJRasekaba,et al.Updating the minimal important difference for six-minute walk distance in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Ach Phys Med Rehabil2010; 91: 221–225.
57.
MarklundSBuiKLNybergA. Measuring and monitoring skeletal muscle function in COPD: current perspectives. Int J Chron Obstruct Pulmon Dis2019; 14: 1825–1838. PMID: 31695351; PMCID: PMC6707440.
58.
De BrandtJSpruitMAHansenD, et al. Changes in lower limb muscle function and muscle mass following exercise-based interventions in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a review of the English-language literature. Chron Respir Dis2018; 15: 182–219.
59.
WoutersEF. Minimal clinically important diferences in COPD: body mass index and muscle strength. COPD2005; 2: 149–155.
60.
BlazevichAJCollinsDFMilletGY,et al.Enhancing adaptations to neuromuscular electrical stimulation training interventions. Exerc Sport Sci Rev2021; 49(4): 244–252.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
