The effectiveness of adding a scapular exercise programme to physical therapy treatment in patients with distal radius fracture treated conservatively: a randomized controlled trial
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online December, 2019
The effectiveness of adding a scapular exercise programme to physical therapy treatment in patients with distal radius fracture treated conservatively: a randomized controlled trial
To determine the effectiveness of a scapular exercise programme in addition to a physical therapy treatment in patients with distal radius fracture.
Design:
A single-blinded randomized controlled trial was conducted.
Setting:
Clinical Hospital San Borja Arriaran, Santiago, Chile.
Participants:
A total of 102 patients above 60 years of age with extra-articular distal radius fracture were randomly divided into two groups.
Interventions:
The control group (n = 51) received a six-week physical therapy treatment; the intervention group (n = 51) received the same treatment plus a scapular exercise programme.
Outcome measures:
The two groups were assessed at baseline and after the six-week treatment. The arm function was assessed with the disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand (DASH) questionnaire; secondary outcomes were measured by the patient-rated wrist evaluation (PRWE) questionnaire and visual analogue scale (VAS).
Results:
A total of 102 patients, 51 in the control group (40 women; mean age of 65.3 ± 4.8 years) and 51 in the intervention group (42 women; mean age of 67.2 ± 5.4 years), were analysed. At the end of the treatment, the difference between groups for the DASH was 16.7 points (P < 0.001), 1.5 points (P = 0.541) for the PRWE, 0.2 cm (P = 0.484) for the VAS at rest, and 1.7 cm (P < 0.001) for the VAS at movement. All differences were in favour of the intervention group.
Conclusion:
In the short term, adding a scapular exercise programme provides a significant clinical benefit in arm function and pain relief with movement in patients above 60 years of age with extra-articular distal radius fracture treated conservatively.
MacIntyreNJDewanN.Epidemiology of distal radius fractures and factors predicting risk and prognosis. J Hand Ther2016; 29(2): 136–145.
2.
ChungKCShauverMJBirkmeyerJD.Trends in the Unites States in the treatment of distal radius fractures in the elderly. J Bone Joint Surg Am2009; 91(8): 1868–1873.
3.
AyhanCUnalEYakutY.Core stabilisation reduces compensatory movement patterns in patients with injury to the arm: a randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil2014; 28(1): 36–47.
4.
YooIGJungMYJeonHS, et al. Effects of wrist-extension orthosis on shoulder and scapular muscle activities during simulated assembly tasks. Ind Health2010; 48(1): 108–114.
5.
AyhanCTurgutEBaltaciG.Distal radius fractures result in alterations in scapular kinematics: a three-dimensional motion analysis. Clin Biomech2015; 30(3): 296–301.
6.
KiblerWB.The role of the scapula in athletic shoulder function. Am J Sports Med1998; 26(2): 325–337.
7.
KiblerWBLudewigPMMcClurePW, et al. Clinical implications of scapular dyskinesis in shoulder injury: the 2013 consensus statement from the ‘Scapular Summit’. Br J Sports Med2013; 47(14): 877–885.
8.
KiblerWBSciasciaAWilkesT.Scapular dyskinesis and its relation to shoulder injury. J Am Acad Orthop Surg2012; 20(6): 364–372.
9.
LudewigPMReynoldsJF.The association of scapular kinematics and glenohumeral joint pathologies. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther2009; 39(2): 90–104.
10.
Gutiérrez-EspinozaHOlguín-HuertaCZavala-GonzálezJ, et al. Prevalence of scapular dyskinesis in patients with distal radius fracture with or without shoulder pain. Physiother Rehabil2017; 2(2): 140.
11.
CasteleinBCagnieBCoolsA.Scapular muscle dysfunction associated with subacromial pain syndrome. J Hand Ther2017; 30(2): 136–146.
12.
TurgutEAyhanCBaltaciG.Repositioning the scapula with taping following distal radius fracture: kinematic analysis using 3-dimentional motion system. J Hand Ther2017; 30(4): 477–482.
13.
FranchignoniFVercelliSGiordanoA, et al. Minimal clinically important difference of the disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand outcome measure (DASH) and its shortened version (QuickDASH). J Orthop Sports Phys Ther2014; 44(1): 30–39.
14.
GongHSLeeJOHuhJK, et al. Comparison of depressive symptoms during the early recovery period in the patients with a distal radius fracture treated by volar plating and cast immobilization. Injury2011; 42(11): 1266–1270.
15.
KrederHJHanelDPMcKeeM, et al. Consistency of AO fractures classification for the distal radius. J Bone Joint Surg Br1996; 78: 726–731.
16.
BlandJD.The value of the history in the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. J Hand Surg Br2000; 25(5): 445–450.
17.
HardenRNBruehlSPerezRS, et al. Validation of proposed diagnostic criteria (the ‘Budapest Criteria’) for complex regional pain syndrome. Pain2010; 150(2): 268–274.
18.
Gutiérrez-EspinozaHRubio-OyarzunDOlguín-HuertaC, et al. Supervised physical therapy vs home exercise program for patients with distal radius fracture: a single-blind randomized clinical study. J Hand Ther2017; 30(3): 242–252.
19.
EllenbeckerTSCoolsA.Rehabilitation of shoulder impingement syndrome and rotator cuff injuries: an evidence-based review. Br J Sports Med2010; 44(5): 319–327.
20.
KlintbergIHCoolsAMHolmgrenTM, et al. Consensus for physiotherapy for shoulder pain. Int Orthop2015; 39(4): 715–720.
21.
MottramSLWoledgeRCMorrisseyD.Motion analysis study of a scapular orientation exercise and subjects’ ability to learn the exercise. Man Ther2009; 14(1): 13–18.
22.
WattanaprakornkulDCathersIHalakiM, et al. The rotator cuff muscles have a direction specific recruitment pattern during shoulder flexion and extension exercises. J Sci Med Sport2011; 14(5): 376–382.
23.
ReedDHalakiMGinnK.The rotator cuff muscles are activated at low levels during shoulder adduction: an experimental study. J Physiother2010; 56(4): 259–264.
24.
HudakPLAmadioPCBombardierC.Development of an upper extremity outcome measure: the DASH (disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand) [corrected]. The Upper Extremity Collaborative Group (UECG). Am J Ind Med1996; 29(6): 602–608.
25.
KleinlugtenbeltYVKrolRGBhandariM, et al. Are the patient-rated wrist evaluation (PRWE) and the disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand (DASH) questionnaires used in distal radius fractures truly valid and reliable?Bone Joint Res2018; 7(1): 36–45.
26.
HervásMTNavarro-ColladoMJPeiróS, et al. Spanish version of the DASH questionnaire. Med Clin2006; 127(12): 441–447.
27.
MacDermidJC.Development of scale for patient rating of wrist pain and disability. J Hand Ther1996; 9(2): 178–183.
28.
MehtaSMacDermidJCRichardsonJ, et al. A systematic review of the measurement properties of the patient-rated wrist evaluation. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther2015; 45(4): 289–298.
29.
AlfieVGallucciGBorettoJ, et al. Patient-rated wrist evaluation: Spanish version and evaluation of its psychometric properties in patients with acute distal radius fracture. J Wrist Surg2017; 6(3): 216–219.
30.
WalenkampMMde Muink KeiserRJGoslingsJC, et al. The minimum clinically important difference of the patient-rated wrist evaluation score for patients with distal radius fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res2015; 473(10): 3235–3241.
31.
McCormackHMHorneDJSheatherS.Clinical applications of visual analogue scale: a critical review. Psychol Med1988; 18: 1007–1019.
32.
TashjianRZDeloachJPorucznikCA, et al. Minimal clinically important differences (MCID) and patient acceptable symptomatic state (PASS) for visual analog scales (VAS) measuring pain in patients treated for rotator cuff disease. J Shoulder Elbow Surg2009; 18(6): 927–932.
33.
GoldhahnJAngstFSimmenBR.What counts: outcome assessment after distal radius fractures in aged patients. J Orthop Trauma2008; 22(8 suppl.): S126–S130.
34.
KwokIHLeungFYuenG.Assessing results after distal radius fracture treatment: a comparison of objective and subjective tools. Geriatr Orthop Surg Rehabil2011; 2(4): 155–160.
35.
BeatonDEKatzJNFosselAH, et al. Measuring the whole or the parts? Validity, reliability, and responsiveness of the disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand outcome measure in different regions of the upper extremity. J Hand Ther2001; 14(2): 128–146.
36.
TashjianRZ.Epidemiology, natural history, and indications for treatment or rotator cuff tears. Clin Sports Med2012; 31(4): 589–604.
37.
TempelhofSRuppSSeilR.Age-related prevalence of rotator cuff tears in asymptomatic shoulders. J Shoulder Elbow Surg1999; 8(4): 296–299.
