The association between attributions of responsibility for motor vehicle accidents and patient satisfaction: a study within a no-fault injury compensation system

Abstract

Objective:

This study set out to test the relationship between attributions of responsibility for motor vehicle accidents and satisfaction with personal injury compensation systems.

Design:

The study analysed survey data from 1394 people injured in a motor vehicle accident who were compensated under a no-fault personal injury compensation system. Patients’ ratings of satisfaction with the compensation system across five domains (resolves your issues, keeps you up-to-date, treats you as an individual, cares about you, and overall satisfaction) were analysed alongside patient attributions of responsibility for their accident (not responsible, partly responsible, totally responsible). Postaccident physical and mental health status, age, gender, and duration of compensation claim were controlled for in the analysis.

Results:

A multivariate analysis of covariance indicated attributions of responsibility for accidents were significantly associated with levels of patient satisfaction across all five domains under study (F (10, 2084) = 3.7, p < 0.001, η² = 0.02). Despite access to virtually indistinguishable services, patients who attributed responsibility for their accidents to others were significantly less satisfied with the injury compensation system than those who attributed responsibility to themselves.

Conclusions:

Satisfaction with no-fault motor vehicle injury compensation services are associated with patients’ attributions of responsibility for their accident. Compensation systems and other rehabilitation services monitoring patient satisfaction should adjust for attributions of responsibility when assessing levels of patient satisfaction between time periods, services, or injured populations. Differences in levels of patient satisfaction observed between compensation or rehabilitation populations may reflect differences in attributions of responsibility for accidents rather than objective service quality.

Keywords

Injury satisfaction attributions accidents motor vehicles

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Hall

Dornan

. Meta-analysis of satisfaction with medical care: description of research domain and analysis of overall satisfaction levels. Soc Sci Med 1988; 27: 637–644.

Cleary

McNeil

. Patient satisfaction as an indicator of quality care. Inquiry 1988; 25: 25–36.

WorkSafe Victoria. WorkSafe Annual Report, 2013.

DerGurahian

DoBias

. Comparative satisfaction. Modern Healthcare 2008; 38: 6–7.

Victorian Transport Accident Commission. TAC annual report. Melbourne, Victoria: Transport Accident Commission, 2012.

Pascoe

. Patient satisfaction in primary health care: A literature review and analysis. Eval Program Planning 1983; 6: 185–210.

Wartman

Morlock

Malitz

Palm

. Patient understanding and satisfaction as predictors of compliance. Med Care 1983; 21: 886–891.

Marquis

Davies

Ware

. Patient satisfaction and change in medical care provider: a longitudinal study. Med Care 1983; 21: 821–829.

Penchansky

Macnee

. Initiation of medical malpractice suits: a conceptualization and test. Med Care 1994; 32: 813–831.

10.

Ware

Davis

. Behavioral consequences of consumer dissatisfaction with medical care. Eval Program Planning 1983; 6: 291–297.

11.

Strasser

Aharony

Greenberger

. The patient satisfaction process: moving toward a comprehensive model. Med Care Rev 1993; 50: 219–248.

12.

Ware

Snyder

Wright

Davies

. Defining and measuring patient satisfaction with medical care. Eval Program Planning 1983; 6: 247–263.

13.

Staniszewska

Ahmed

. The concepts of expectation and satisfaction: do they capture the way patients evaluate their care? J Advd Nursing 1999; 29: 364–372.

14.

Jackson

Chamberlin

Kroenke

. Predictors of patient satisfaction. Soc Sci Med 2001; 52: 609–620.

15.

Sofaer

Firminger

. Patient perceptions of the quality of health services. Ann Rev Public Health 2005; 26: 513–559.

16.

Rahmqvist

. Patient satisfaction in relation to age, health status and other background factors: a model for comparisons of care units. Int J Qual Health Care 2001; 13: 385–390.

17.

Hall

Dornan

. Patient sociodemographic characteristics as predictors of satisfaction with medical care: a meta-analysis. Soc Sci Med 1990; 30: 811–818.

18.

Hall

Milburn

Epstein

. A causal model of health status and satisfaction with medical care. Med Care 1993; 31: 84–94.

19.

Greenley

Young

Schoenherr

. Psychological distress and patient satisfaction. Med Care 1982; 20: 373–385.

20.

Johnson

Coons

Hays

Pickard

. Health status and satisfaction with pharmacy services. Am J Managed Care 1999; 5: 163–170.

21.

Kaldenberg

. Patient satisfaction and health status. Health Marketing Quarterly 2001; 18: 81–101.

22.

Bair

Kroenke

Sutherland

McCoy

Harris

McHorney

. Effects of depression and pain severity on satisfaction in medical outpatients: analysis of the Medical Outcomes Study. J Rehabil Res Dev 2007; 44: 143–152.

23.

Marshall

Hays

Mazel

. Health status and satisfaction with health care: results from the medical outcomes study. J Consult Clin Psychol 1996; 64: 380–390.

24.

Kane

Maciejewski

Finch

. The relationship of patient satisfaction with care and clinical outcomes. Med Care 1997; 35: 714–730.

25.

Franche

Krause

. Readiness for return to work following injury or illness: conceptualizing the interpersonal impact of health care, workplace, and insurance factors. J Occupat Rehabil 2002; 12: 233–256.

26.

Franche

Severin

Lee

. Perceived justice of compensation process for return-to-work: Development and validation of a scale. Psychol Injury and Law 2009; 2: 225–237.

27.

Cameron

Gabbe

. The effect of compensation claims on outcomes after injury. Injury 2009; 40: 905–906.

28.

Collie

Fitzharris

Gabbe

. Evaluation of a compensation claims management intervention for improving recovery from traumatic injury. Injury 2012; 43: 1335–1336.

29.

Elbers

Hulst

Cuijpers

Akkermans

Bruinvels

. Do compensation processes impair mental health? A meta-analysis. Injury 2013; 44: 674–683.

30.

Murgatroyd

Cameron

Harris

. Understanding the effect of compensation on recovery from severe motor vehicle crash injuries: a qualitative study. Injury Prev 2011; 17: 222–227.

31.

Grant

O’Donnell

Spittal

Creamer

Studdert

. Relationship between stressfulness of claiming for injury compensation and long-term recovery: A prospective cohort study. JAMA Psychiatry 2014; 71(4): 446–453.

32.

Hickling

Blanchard

Buckley

Taylor

. Effects of Attribution of Responsibility for Motor Vehicle Accidents on Severity of PTSD Symptoms, Ways of Coping, and Recovery Over Six Months. J Traum Stress 1999; 12: 345–353.

33.

Delahunty

Haberman

Craig

. Acute and chronic distress and posttraumatic stress disorder as a function of responsibility for serious motor vehicle accidents. J Consul Clin Psychol 1997; 65: 560–567.

34.

Harris

Young

Rae

Jalaludin

Solomon

. Predictors of post-traumatic stress disorder following major trauma. ANZ J Surg 2008; 78: 583–587.

35.

O’Donnell

Creamer

Parslow

. A predictive screening index for posttraumatic stress disorder and depression following traumatic injury. J Consul Clin Psychol 2008; 76: 923–932.

36.

Hart

Hanks

Bogner

Millis

Esselman

. Blame attribution in intentional and unintentional traumatic brain injury: Longitudinal changes and impact on subjective well-being. Rehabil Psychol 2007; 52: 152–161.

37.

Davidson

Van Dyke

Agar-Wilson

. The impact of motor vehicle accidents on the psychological well-being of at-fault drivers and related passengers. J Health Psychol 2000; 5: 33–51.

38.

Thompson

Berk

O’Donnell

Nordfjaern

Stafford

. Attributions of responsibility and recovery within a no-fault injury compensation scheme. Rehabil Psychol. Epub ahead of print 7 April 2014.

39.

Hart

Bogner

Whyte

Polansky

. Attribution of blame in accidental and violence-related traumatic brain injury. Rehabil Psychol 2003; 48: 86–92.

40.

Bulman

Wortman

. Attributions of blame and coping in the “real world”: Severe accident victims react to their lot. J Personality Social Psychol 1977; 35: 351–363.

41.

Tse

Nicosia

Wilton

. Consumer Satisfaction as a Process. Psychol Marketing 1990; 7: 177–193.

42.

Giese

Cote

. Defining consumer satisfaction. Acad Marketing Sci Rev 2000; 1: 1–22.

43.

Aharony

Strasser

. Patient satisfaction: what we know about and what we still need to explore. Med Care Rev 1993; 50: 49–79.

44.

State Government of Victoria. Transport Accident Act 1986. Melbourne, Victoria, 2011.

45.

Cockfield

. Road safety-the experience of the Transport Accident Commission in Victoria, Australia. International Transport Forum Discussion Paper, 2011.

46.

Federal Government of Australia. National injury insurance scheme issues discussion paper. Canberra: Treasury, 2013.

47.

Fronsko

. Road safety and insurance markets overview. International Transport Forum Discussion Paper, 2011.

48.

Tennyson

. The design of auto insurance systems, 2012.

49.

Australian Bureau of Statistics. Motor vehicle census, Australia. 23 July 2013 ed. 2013.

50.

Victorian Transport Accident Commission. Searchable road trauma statistics. Melbourne, Australia: Victorian Transport Accident Commission, 2013.

51.

Haworth

. Powered two wheelers in a changing world—Challenges and opportunities. Accident; Analysis and Prevention 2012; 44: 12–18.