Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2014-10
Effectiveness of constraint-induced movement therapy on upper-extremity function in children with cerebral palsy: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
To systematically examine the research literature on the effectiveness of constraint-induced movement therapy on improving arm function in children with cerebral palsy, and to assess the association between the study effect size and the characteristics of the patients and intervention protocol.
Data sources:
A systematic literature search was conducted in PubMed, PsycINFO, Cochrane, CINAHL, Web of Science, and TRIP Database up to May 2014.
Review methods:
Studies employing randomized controlled trial design, children with cerebral palsy, comparing constraint-induced movement therapy with another intervention with a focus on arm function, and upper-extremity measures were included in this review. Methodological quality was evaluated using the Physiotherapy Evidence-based Database (PEDro) scale.
Results:
The literature search resulted in 27 randomized controlled trial studies with good methodological quality that compared constraint-induced movement therapy with other intervention therapy. Overall, constraint-induced movement therapy provided a medium beneficial effect (d = 0.546; p < 0.001) when compared with conventional therapy. For the subgroup analyses, presence of a dose-equivalent comparison group, intervention location, and time of follow-up were significant factors. Studies examining constraint-induced movement therapy effect without a dose-equivalent comparison group showed a large effect in children with cerebral palsy, but studies with a dose-equivalent group only showed a small effect. Children who received home-based constraint-induced movement therapy had a better improvement in arm function than those who received constraint-induced movement therapy elsewhere.
Conclusion:
The research literature supports constraint-induced movement therapy as an effective intervention to improve arm function in children with cerebral palsy.
GordonAMCharlesJWolfSL. Efficacy of constraint-induced movement therapy on involved upper-extremity use in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy is not age-dependent. Pediatrics2006; 117(3): e363–373.
2.
SakzewskiL. Bimanual therapy and constraint-induced movement therapy are equally effective in improving hand function in children with congenital hemiplegia. J Physiother2012; 58(1): 59.
3.
SakzewskiLZivianiJAbbottDFMacdonellRAJacksonGDBoydRN. Randomized trial of constraint-induced movement therapy and bimanual training on activity outcomes for children with congenital hemiplegia. Dev Med Child Neurol2011; 53(4): 313–320.
4.
HoareBJWasiakJImmsCCareyL. Constraint-induced movement therapy in the treatment of the upper limb in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2007(2): CD004149.
5.
HuangHHFettersLHaleJMcBrideA. Bound for success: a systematic review of constraint-induced movement therapy in children with cerebral palsy supports improved arm and hand use. Phys Ther2009; 89(11): 1126–1141.
6.
NascimentoLRGloriaAEHabibES. Effects of constraint-induced movement therapy as a rehabilitation strategy for the affected upper limb of children with hemiparesis: Systematic review of the literature. Rev Bras Fisioter2009; 13(2): 97–102.
7.
WHO. ICF: International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2001.
CohenJ. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum, 1988.
10.
CooperHHedgesLV (eds). The handbook of research synthesis. New York City: Russell Sage Foundation, 1994.
11.
BorensteinMHedgesLVHigginsJPTRothsteinHR. Introduction to meta-analysis. Wiley, 2009.
12.
AartsPBJongeriusPHGeerdinkYAvan LimbeekJGeurtsAC. Effectiveness of modified constraint-induced movement therapy in children with unilateral spastic cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled trial. Neurorehabil Neural Repair2010; 24(6): 509–518.
13.
AartsPBJongeriusPHGeerdinkYAvan LimbeekJGeurtsAC. Modified constraint-induced movement therapy combined with bimanual training (mCIMT-BiT) in children with unilateral spastic cerebral palsy: how are improvements in arm-hand use established?Res Dev Disabil2011; 32(1): 271–279.
14.
Al-OraibiSEliassonAC. Implementation of constraint-induced movement therapy for young children with unilateral cerebral palsy in Jordan: a home-based model. Disabil Rehabil2011; 33(21–22): 2006–2012.
15.
CharlesJRWolfSLSchneiderJAGordonAM. Efficacy of a child-friendly form of constraint-induced movement therapy in hemiplegic cerebral palsy: a randomized control trial. Dev Med Child Neurol2006; 48(8): 635–642.
16.
ChenCLKangLJHongWHChenFCChenHCWuCY. Effect of therapist-based constraint-induced therapy at home on motor control, motor performance and daily function in children with cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled study. Clin Rehabil2012; 27(3): 236–245.
17.
ChoudharyAGulatiSKabraM. Efficacy of modified constraint induced movement therapy in improving upper limb function in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: A randomized controlled trial. Brain Dev2012; 35(9): 870–876.
18.
de Brito BrandaoMGordonAMManciniMC. Functional impact of constraint therapy and bimanual training in children with cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Occup Ther2012; 66(6): 672–681.
19.
de Brito BrandaoMManciniMCVazDVPereira de MeloAPFonsecaST. Adapted version of constraint-induced movement therapy promotes functioning in children with cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil2010; 24(7): 639–647.
20.
DeppeWThuemmlerKFleischerJBergerCMeyerSWiedemannB. Modified constraint-induced movement therapy versus intensive bimanual training for children with hemiplegia - a randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil2013; 27(10): 909–920.
21.
EliassonACShawKBergEKrumlinde-SundholmL. An ecological approach of constraint induced movement therapy for 2–3-year-old children: a randomized control trial. Res Dev Disabil2011; 32(6): 2820–2828.
22.
Eugster-BueschFde BruinEDBoltshauserE. Forced-use therapy for children with cerebral palsy in the community setting: a single-blinded randomized controlled pilot trial. J Pediatr Rehabil Med2012; 5(2): 65–74.
23.
FacchinPRosa-RizzottoMVisona Dalla PozzaL. Multisite trial comparing the efficacy of constraint-induced movement therapy with that of bimanual intensive training in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: postintervention results. Am J Phys Med Rehabil2011; 90(7): 539–553.
24.
FedrizziERosa-RizzottoMTurconiAC. Unimanual and bimanual intensive training in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy and persistence in time of hand function improvement: 6-month follow-up results of a multisite clinical trial. J Child Neurol2012; 28(2): 161–175.
25.
GeerdinkYAartsPGeurtsAC. Motor learning curve and long-term effectiveness of modified constraint-induced movement therapy in children with unilateral cerebral palsy: A randomized controlled trial. Res Dev Disabil2013; 34(3): 923–931.
26.
GordonAMHungYCBrandaoM. Bimanual training and constraint-induced movement therapy in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: A randomized trial. Neurorehabil Neural Repair2011; 25(8): 692–702.
27.
HsinY-jChenF-CLinK-cKangLJChenCLChenC-y. Efficacy of constraint-induced therapy on functional performance and health-related quality of life for children with cerebral palsy: A randomized controlled tial. J Child Neurol2012; 27: 992–999.
28.
HungYCCasertanoLHillmanAGordonAM. The effect of intensive bimanual training on coordination of the hands in children with congenital hemiplegia. Res Dev Disabil2011; 32(6): 2724–2731.
29.
LinKCWangTNWuCY. Effects of home-based constraint-induced therapy versus dose-matched control intervention on functional outcomes and caregiver well-being in children with cerebral palsy. Res Dev Disabil2011; 32(5): 1483–1491.
30.
RostamiHRArastooAANejadSJMahanyMKMalamiriRAGoharpeyS. Effects of modified constraint-induced movement therapy in virtual environment on upper-limb function in children with spastic hemiparetic cerebral palsy: A randomised controlled trial. NeuroRehabil2012; 31(4): 357–365.
31.
SakzewskiLCarlonSShieldsNZivianiJWareRSBoydRN. Impact of intensive upper limb rehabilitation on quality of life: a randomized trial in children with unilateral cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol2012; 54(5): 415–423.
32.
SakzewskiLZivianiJAbbottDFMacdonellRAJacksonGDBoydRN. Equivalent retention of gains at 1 year after training with constraint-induced or bimanual therapy in children with unilateral cerebral palsy. Neurorehabil Neural Repair2011; 25(7): 664–671.
33.
SmaniaNAgliotiSMCosentinoA. A modified constraint-induced movement therapy (CIT) program improves paretic arm use and function in children with cerebral palsy. Eur J Phys Rehabil Med2009; 45(4): 493–500.
34.
SungIYRyuJSPyunSBYooSDSongWHParkMJ. Efficacy of forced-use therapy in hemiplegic cerebral palsy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2005; 86(11): 2195–2198.
35.
TaubEGriffinAUswatteGGammonsKNickJLawCR. Treatment of congenital hemiparesis with pediatric constraint-induced movement therapy. J Child Neurol2011; 26(9): 1163–1173.
36.
TaubERameySLDeLucaSEcholsK. Efficacy of constraint-induced movement therapy for children with cerebral palsy with asymmetric motor impairment. Pediatrics2004; 113(2): 305–312.
37.
WallenMZivianiJNaylorOEvansRNovakIHerbertRD. Modified constraint-induced therapy for children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: a randomized trial. Dev Med Child Neurol2011; 53(12): 1091–1099.
38.
XuKWangLMaiJHeL. Efficacy of constraint-induced movement therapy and electrical stimulation on hand function of children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: a controlled clinical trial. Disabil Rehabil2012; 34(4): 337–346.
39.
BoydRSakzewskiLZivianiJ. INCITE: A randomised trial comparing constraint induced movement therapy and bimanual training in children with congenital hemiplegia. BMC Neurol2010; 10: 4.
40.
Case-SmithJDeLucaSCStevensonRRameySL. Multicenter randomized controlled trial of pediatric constraint-induced movement therapy: 6-month follow-up. Am J Occup Ther2012; 66(1): 15–23.
41.
DeLucaSCCase-SmithJStevensonRRameySL. Constraint-induced movement therapy (CIMT) for young children with cerebral palsy: effects of therapeutic dosage. J Pediatr Rehabil Med2012; 5(2): 133–142.
42.
DelucaSCEcholsKLawCRAmeySL. Intensive pediatric constraint-induced therapy for children with cerebral palsy: randomized, controlled, crossover trial. J Child Neurol2006; 21(11): 931–938.
43.
GordonAMChinnanAGillSPetraEHungYCCharlesJ. Both constraint-induced movement therapy and bimanual training lead to improved performance of upper extremity function in children with hemiplegia. Dev Med Child Neurol2008; 50(12): 957–958.
44.
HoareBImmsCVillanuevaERawickiHBMatyasTCareyL. Intensive therapy following upper limb botulinum toxin A injection in young children with unilateral cerebral palsy: a randomized trial. Dev Med Child Neurol2013; 55(3): 238–247.
45.
KlingelsKFeysHMolenaersG. Randomized trial of modified constraint-induced movement therapy with and without an intensive therapy program in children with unilateral cerebral palsy. Neurorehabil Neural Repair2013; 27(9): 799–807.
46.
RostamiHRMalamiriRA. Effect of treatment environment on modified constraint-induced movement therapy results in children with spastic hemiplegic cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled trial. Disabil Rehabil2012; 34(1): 40–44.
47.
SakzewskiLZivianiJAbbottDFMacdonellRAJacksonGDBoydRN. Participation outcomes in a randomized trial of 2 models of upper-limb rehabilitation for children with congenital hemiplegia. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2011; 92(4): 531–539.
48.
SakzewskiLZivianiJBoydRN. Best responders after intensive upper-limb training for children with unilateral cerebral palsy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2011; 92(4): 578–584.
49.
El-KafyEMAElshemySAAlghamdiMS. Effect of constraint-induced therapy on upper limb functions: a randomized control trial. Scand J Occup Ther2014; 21(1): 11–23.
50.
CharlesJGordonAM. Development of hand-arm bimanual intensive training (HABIT) for improving bimanual coordination in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol2006; 48(11): 931–936.
51.
DongVATungIHSiuHWFongKN. Studies comparing the efficacy of constraint-induced movement therapy and bimanual training in children with unilateral cerebral palsy: A systematic review. Dev Neurorehabil2013;16(2): 133–143.
52.
GordonAM. To constrain or not to constrain, and other stories of intensive upper extremity training for children with unilateral cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol2011; 53(Suppl 4): 56–61.
53.
HoareBImmsCCareyLWasiakJ. Constraint-induced movement therapy in the treatment of the upper limb in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: a Cochrane systematic review. Clin Rehabil2007; 21(8): 675–685.
54.
NovakIMcIntyreSMorganC. A systematic review of interventions for children with cerebral palsy: state of the evidence. Dev Med Child Neurol2013; 55(10): 885–910.
55.
SakzewskiLZivianiJBoydR. Systematic review and meta-analysis of therapeutic management of upper-limb dysfunction in children with congenital hemiplegia. Pediatrics2009; 123(6): e1111–1122.
56.
TaubE. The behavior-analytic origins of constraint-induced movement therapy: An example of behavioral neurorehabilitation. Behav Analyst2012; 35(2): 155–178.
57.
TaubEGriffinANickJGammonsKUswatteGLawCR. Pediatric CI therapy for stroke-induced hemiparesis in young children. Dev Neurorehabil2007; 10(1): 3–18.
58.
TaubEUswatteGMarkVWMorrisDM. The learned nonuse phenomenon: implications for rehabilitation. Eura Medicophys2006; 42(3): 241–256.
59.
Little-HayesPAllgierAKleinARederRBurchC. Embracing the spirit of inquiry: Creating an evidence-based guideline for using CIMT. Occup Ther Practice2007; 8: 9–15.
60.
AndersenJCMajnemerAO’GradyKGordonAM. Intensive upper extremity training for children with hemiplegia: From science to practice. Semin Pediatr Neurol2013; 20: 100–105.
61.
PidcockFSGarciaTTrovatoMKSchultzSCBradyKD. Pediatric constraint-induced movement therapy: A promising intervention for childhood hemiparesis. Top Stroke Rehabil2009; 16(5): 339–345.
62.
SakzewskiLZivianiJBoydRN. Efficacy of upper limb therapies for unilateral cerebral palsy: a meta-analysis. Pediatrics2014; 133(1): e175–204.
63.
Center CCsHM. Evidence-based care guideline for pediatric constraint induced movement therapy (CIMT). National Guideline Clearinghouse2009; 16: 1–17.
64.
EliassonACKrumlinde-SundholmLGordonAM. Guidelines for future research in constraint-induced movement therapy for children with unilateral cerebral palsy: an expert consensus. Dev Med Child Neurol2014; 56(2): 125–137.
65.
WillisJKMorelloADavieARiceJCBennettJT. Forced use treatment of childhood hemiparesis. Pediatrics2002; 110(1 Pt 1): 94–96.
66.
CorbettaDSirtoriVMojaLGattiR. Constraint-induced movement therapy in stroke patients: systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur J Phys Rehabil Med2010; 46(4): 537–544.
67.
PeuralaSHKantanenMPSjogrenTPaltamaaJKarhulaMHeinonenA. Effectiveness of constraint-induced movement therapy on activity and participation after stroke: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Clin Rehabil2012; 26(3): 209–223.
68.
BruscoNKTaylorNFWattsJJShieldsN. Economic evaluation of adult rehabilitation: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials in a variety of settings. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2014; 95(1): 94–116.
69.
ChenYLeeS-YHowardAM. Effect of virtual reality on imporving upper-extremity function in children with cerebral palsy: A meta-analysis. Pediatric Phys Ther2014; 26(3): 289–300.
70.
TakebayashiTKoyamaTAmanoS. A 6-month follow-up after constraint-induced movement therapy with and without transfer package for patients with hemiparesis after stroke: a pilot quasi-randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil2013; 27(5): 418–426.
71.
ArpinoCVescioMFDe LucaACuratoloP. Efficacy of intensive versus nonintensive physiotherapy in children with cerebral palsy: a meta-analysis. Int J Rehabil Res2010; 33(2): 165–171.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
