Objective: To conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis using the International Classification of Functioning to determine the summary effect of electrical stimulation on impairment and activity limitations relevant to gait problems of children with cerebral palsy.
Methods: We identified 40 cerebral palsy and electrical stimulation studies, and 17 gait studies qualified for inclusion. Applying enablement classification methods to walking abnormalities created two subgroups: impairment (N = 14) and activity limitations (N = 15). Overall, 238 participants experienced electrical stimulation treatments and 224 served as a no stimulation control group. Calculations followed conventional data extraction and meta-analysis techniques: (a) individual standardized mean differences, (b) summary effect size, (c) I 2heterogeneity test, (d) fail-safe N analysis and (e) moderator variable analyses.
Results: Common outcome measures associated with impairment (n = 3) and activity limitations (n = 6) were submitted to separate random effects models meta-analyses, and revealed significant cumulative effect sizes: (a) impairment = 0.616 (SE = 0.10) and (b) activity limitations = 0.635 (SE = 0.14). I 2indicated low and medium amounts of dispersion, whereas fail-safe analyses revealed high N-values for both disablement categories. Moderator variable analyses further confirmed the positive treatment effects from both functional and neuromuscular stimulation.
Conclusions: The present systematic review and meta-analyses determined medium effect sizes for electrical stimulation on walking impairment and activity limitations of children with cerebral palsy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Odding E., Roebroeck ME, Stam HJThe epidemiology of cerebral palsy: incidence, impairments and risk factors . Disabil Rehabil2006; 28: 183-91.
2.
Paneth N., Hong T., Korzeniewski S.The descriptive epidemiology of cerebral palsy. Clin Perinatol2006; 33: 251-67.
3.
Koman LA, Paterson Smith B., Balkrishnan R.Spasticity associated with cerebral palsy in children: guidelines for the use of botulinum A toxin. Paediatr Drugs2003 ; 5: 11-23.
4.
Koman LA, Smith BP, Barron R.Recurrence of equinus foot deformity in cerebral palsy patients following surgery: a review. J South Orthop Assoc2003 ; 12: 125-33.
5.
Postans NJ, Granat MHEffect of functional electrical stimulation, applied during walking, on gait in spastic cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol2005; 47: 46-52.
6.
Carmick J.Clinical use of neuromuscular electrical stimulation for children with cerebral palsy, Part 2: Upper extremity. Phys Ther1993; 73: 514-22, discussion 23-27.
7.
Carmick J.Clinical use of neuromuscular electrical stimulation for children with cerebral palsy, Part 1: Lower extremity. Phys Ther1993; 73: 505-13, discussion 23-27.
8.
Carmick J.Managing equinus in children with cerebral palsy: electrical stimulation to strengthen the triceps surae muscle. Dev Med Child Neurol1995; 37: 965-75.
9.
Comeaux P., Patterson N., Rubin M., Meiner R.Effect of neuromuscular electrical stimulation during gait in children with cerebral palsy. Pediatr Phys Ther1997 ; 9: 103-9.
10.
Atwater SW, Tatarka ME, Kathgrein JE, Shapiro S.Electromyography-triggered electrical muscle stimulation for children with cerebral palsy: a pilot study. Pediatr Phys Ther1991; 3: 190-9.
11.
Gracanin F. , Vrabic M., Vrabic G.Six years of experiences with FES method applied to children. Eur Medicophys1976; 12: 61-8.
12.
Dubowitz L. , Finnie N., Hyde SA, Scott OM, Vrbova G.Improvement of muscle performance by chronic electrical stimulation in children with cerebral palsy. Lancet . 1988; 1: 587-8.
13.
Leyendecker C.[Electrical stimulation therapy and its effects on the general activity of motor impaired cerebral palsied children; a comparative study of the Bobath physiotherapy and its combination with the Hufschmidt electrical stimulation therapy (author’s transl)]. Rehabilitation (Stuttg) 1975; 14: 150-9.
14.
Steinbok P. , Reiner A., Kestle JRTherapeutic electrical stimulation following selective posterior rhizotomy in children with spastic diplegic cerebral palsy: a randomized clinical trial. Dev Med Child Neurol1997; 39: 515-20.
15.
Riso RR, Makley. Control of abnormal muscle contractions. NIHR progress report. Bull Pros Res1981; 10: 1-180.
16.
Loeb GE, Richmond FJ, Baker LLThe BION devices: injectable interfaces with peripheral nerves and muscles . Neurosurg Focus2006; 20: E2.
17.
Prodanov D. , Marani E., Holsheimer J.Functional electrical stimulation for sensory and motor functions. Biomed Rev2003; 14: 23-50.
18.
Glass G.Primary, secondary and meta-analysis of research. Educ Res1976; 5: 3-8.
19.
Glass G.Integrating findings: The meta-analysis of research. Rev Res Educ1977; 5: 351-79.
20.
Rosenthal R. , DiMatteo MRMeta-analysis: recent developments in quantitative methods for literature reviews. Annu Rev Psychol2001; 52: 59-82.
21.
van der Linden ML, Hazlewood ME, Hillman SJ, Robb JEFunctional electrical stimulation to the dorsiflexors and quadriceps in children with cerebral palsy . Pediatr Phys Ther2008; 20: 23-9.
22.
Kerr C., McDowell B., Cosgrove A., Walsh D., Bradbury I., McDonough S.Electrical stimulation in cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled trial. Dev Med Child Neurol2006; 48: 870-6.
23.
Dali C., Hansen FJ, Pedersen SA et al. Threshold electrical stimulation (TES) in ambulant children with CP: a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial. Dev Med Child Neurol2002; 44: 364-9.
24.
Katz A., Tirosh E., Marmur R., Mizrahi J.Enhancement of muscle activity by electrical stimulation in cerebral palsy: a case-control study. J Child Neurol2008; 23: 259-67.
25.
Sommerfelt K., Markestad T., Berg K., Saetesdal I.Therapeutic electrical stimulation in cerebral palsy: a randomized, controlled, crossover trial. Dev Med Child Neurol2001; 43: 609-13.
26.
Stackhouse SK, Binder-Macleod SA, Stackhouse CA, McCarthy JJ, Prosser LA, Lee SCNeuromuscular electrical stimulation versus volitional isometric strength training in children with spastic diplegic cerebral palsy: a preliminary study. Neurorehabil Neural Repair2007; 21: 475-85.
27.
Nunes Lcbg, Quevedo AAF, Magdalon ECEffects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation on tibialis anterior muscle of spastic hemiparetic children. Rev Bras Fisiother2008; 12: 317-23.
28.
Maenpaa H., Jaakkola R., Sandstrom M., Von Wendt L.Does microcurrent stimulation increase the range of movement of ankle dorsiflexion in children with cerebral palsy?Disabil Rehabil2004; 26: 669-77.
29.
Maenpaa H., Jaakkola R., Sandstrom M., Airi T., von Wendt L.Electrostimulation at sensory level improves function of the upper extremities in children with cerebral palsy: a pilot study. Dev Med Child Neurol2004; 46: 84-90.
30.
Khalili MA, Hajihassanie A.Electrical simulation in addition to passive stretch has a small effect on spasticity and contracture in children with cerebral palsy: a randomised within-participant controlled trial. Aust J Physiother2008; 54: 185-9.
31.
Jeronimo BP , Silveria JA, Dini PD, David ACSpatio-temporal gait variables of children with cerebral palsy undergoing electrostimulation in the anterior tibial muscle . Rev Bras Fisiother2007; 11: 229-33.
32.
Vaz DV, Mancini MC, da Fonseca ST, Arantes NF, Pinto TP, de Araujo PAEffects of strength training aided by electrical stimulation on wrist muscle characteristics and hand function of children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy . Phys Occup Ther Pediatr2008; 28: 309-25.
33.
Smith BT, Coiro DJ, Finson R., Betz RR, McCarthy J.Evaluation of force-sensing resistors for gait event detection to trigger electrical stimulation to improve walking in the child with cerebral palsy . IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Engl2002 ; 10: 22-9.
34.
Barbosa AP, Vaz DV, Gontijo AP, Fonseca ST, Mancini MCTherapeutic effects of electrical stimulation on manual function of children with cerebral palsy: evaluation of two cases. Disabil Rehabil2008; 30: 723-8.
35.
Bertoti DB, Stanger M., Betz RR, Akers J., Maynahon M., Mulcahey MJPercutaneous intramuscular functional electrical stimulation as an intervention choice for children with cerebral palsy. Pediatr Phys Ther1997; 9: 123-7.
36.
Park ES, Park CI, Lee HJ, Cho YSThe effect of electrical stimulation on the trunk control in young children with spastic diplegic cerebral palsy. J Korean Med Sci2001; 16: 347-50.
37.
Carmick J.Use of neuromuscular electrical stimulation and [corrected] dorsal wrist splint to improve the hand function of a child with spastic hemiparesis . Phys Ther1997; 77: 661-71.
38.
Ho CL, Holt KG, Saltzman E., Wagenaar RCFunctional electrical stimulation changes dynamic resources in children with spastic cerebral palsy. Phys Ther2006 ; 86: 987-1000.
39.
Kamper DG, Yasukawa AM, Barrett KM, Gaebler-Spira DJEffects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation treatment of cerebral palsy on potential impairment mechanisms: a pilot study. Pediatr Phys Ther2006; 18: 31-8.
40.
Kerr C., McDowell B., McDonough S.Electrical stimulation in cerebral palsy: a review of effects on strength and motor function. Dev Med Child Neurol2004 ; 46: 205-13.
41.
Orlin MN, Pierce SR, Stackhouse CL et al. Immediate effect of percutaneous intramuscular stimulation during gait in children with cerebral palsy: a feasibility study. Dev Med Child Neurol2005; 47: 684-90.
42.
Pape KETherapeutic electrical stimulation (TES) for the treatment of disuse muscle atrophy in cerebral palsy. Pediatr Phys Ther1997; 9: 110-12.
43.
Pease WSTherapeutic electrical stimulation for spasticity: quantitative gait analysis . Am J Phys Med Rehabil1998; 77: 351-5.
44.
Pierce SR, Laughton CA, Smith BT, Orlin MN, Johnston TE, McCarthy JJDirect effect of percutaneous electric stimulation during gait in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: a report of 2 cases. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2004; 85: 339-43.
45.
Pierce SR, Orlin MN, Lauer RT, Johnston TE, Smith BT, McCarthy JJComparison of percutaneous and surface functional electrical stimulation during gait in a child with hemiplegic cerebral palsy. Am J Phys Med Rehabil2004; 83: 798-805.
46.
van der Linden ML, Hazlewood ME, Aitchison AM, Hillman SJ, Robb JEElectrical stimulation of gluteus maximus in children with cerebral palsy: effects on gait characteristics and muscle strength. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2003; 45: 385-90.
47.
Wright PA, Granat MHTherapeutic effects of functional electrical stimulation of the upper limb of eight children with cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol2000; 42: 724-7.
48.
Ozer K., Chesher SP, Scheker LRNeuromuscular electrical stimulation and dynamic bracing for the management of upper-extremity spasticity in children with cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol2006; 48: 559-63.
49.
Durham S., Eve L., Stevens C., Ewins D.Effect of functional electrical stimulation on symmetries in gait of children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy. Physiotherapy2004; 90: 82-90.
50.
Johnston TE , Finson RL, McCarthy JJ, Smith BT, Betz RR, Mulcahey MJUse of functional electrical stimulation to augment traditional orthopaedic surgery in children with cerebral palsy. J Pediatr Orthop2004 ; 24: 283-91.
51.
Hazlewood ME , Brown JK, Rowe PJ, Salter PMThe use of therapeutic electrical stimulation in the treatment of hemiplegic cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol1994; 36: 661-73.
52.
Seifart A., Unger M., Burger M.The effect of lower limb functional electrical stimulation on gait of children with cerebral palsy. Pediatr Phys Ther2009 ; 21: 23-30.
53.
Daichman J. , Johnston TE, Evans K., Tecklin JSThe effects of a neuromuscular electrical stimulation home program on impairments and functional skills of a child with spastic diplegic cerebral palsy: a case report. Pediatr Phys Ther2003; 15: 153-8.
54.
World Health Organization.International classification of functioning, disability and health. Geneva: WHO, 2001.
55.
Jette AMThe changing language of disablement. Phys Ther2005; 85: 118-19.
56.
Higgins JPT, Green S eds. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions 4.2.6 [updated September 2006]. The Cochrane Library, Issue 4, Chichester, UK: Wiley, 2006.
57.
Schutte LM, Narayanan U., Stout JL, Selber P., Gage JR, Schwartz MHAn index for quantifying deviations from normal gait. Gait Posture2000; 11: 25-31.
