How to measure balance in clinical practice. A systematic review of the psychometrics and clinical utility of measures of balance activity for neurological conditions

Abstract

Objective: To identify psychometrically robust and clinically feasible measurement tools of balance activity in people with neurological conditions to recommend for use in clinical practice.

Data sources: MEDLINE, CINAHL, EMBASE, PEDro and AMED.

Review methods: Independent reviewers selected and extracted data from articles that assessed the reliability, validity, sensitivity to change and clinical utility of measures of balance activity in adult neurological conditions. Quality assessment was based on Jorstad et al. Measures with ‘good' psychometrics and ≥9/10 clinical utility scores were recommended.

Results: Nineteen measurement tools were selected. Of these, the Brunel Balance Assessment, Berg Balance Scale, Trunk Impairment Scale, arm raise and forward reach tests in sitting and standing, weight shift, step/tap and step-up tests reached the required standards and are usable in clinical practice. The Brunel Balance Assessment and its associated functional performance tests have the additional advantages of being a hierarchical scale with established lack of redundancy.

Conclusion: The measurement tools identified above are psychometrically robust and feasible to use in clinical practice. Future objective measure development should consider the theoretical construct of the measure, the minimal detectable change and use in clinical populations other than stroke.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Chartered Society of Physiotherapy. Core standards of physiotherapy practice. London, Chartered Society of Physiotherapy, 2005.

Intercollegiate Stroke Working Party. National clinical guidelines for stroke, second edition. London , Royal College of Physicians, 2004 .

Rudd A. , Pearson M. , Georgiou A. Measuring clinical outcome in stroke (acute care): clinical effectiveness and evaluation unit. London, Royal College of Physicians, 2000.

Department of Health. National services framework for long-term conditions. London, Department of Health, 2005.

Greenhalgh J. , Tyson S. , Long A. & Flynn R.

How do multidisciplinary teams use clinical outcome measures in clinical practice?

Proceedings of Society for Research in Rehabilitation in Clinical Rehabilitation , 2006; 20(12): 1105.

Grimmer K. , Bialocerkowski A. , Kumar S. Implementing evidence in clinical practice: the therapies dilemma . Physiotherapy 2004; 90: 189 94 .

National Audit Office. Reducing brain damage: faster access to better stroke care. London, National Audit Office, 2005.

Pollock A. , Legg L. , Langhorne P. Barriers to achieving evidence-based stroke rehabilitation. Clin Rehabil 2000; 14: 611 17.

Tyson S. , Watson A. , Moss S. et al. Development of a framework for the evidence-based choice of outcome measures in neurological physiotherapy. Disabil Rehabil 2008; 30: 142 49.

10.

Bronstein A. , Brandt T. , Woolacott M. Clinical disorders of balance, posture and gait. London , Arnold, 1996.

11.

Shumway-Cook A. , Horak FB Assessing the influence of sensory interaction on balance: suggestion from the field. Phys Ther 1986; 66: 1548 50.

12.

World Health Organization. ICF-Introduction, the International Classification of Functioning Disability and Health. Geneva, WHO, 2001.

13.

Tesio L. , Perucca L. , Franchignoni FP , Battaglia MA A short measure of balance in multiple sclerosis: validation through Rasch analysis. Funct Neurol 1997; 12: 255 65 .

14.

Fujiwara T. , Liu M. , Tsuji T. et al. Development of a new measure to assess trunk impairment after stroke (Trunk Impairment Scale): its psychometric properties . Am J Phys Med Rehabil 2004; 83: 681 88.

15.

Liu M. , Chino N. , Tuji T. , Masakado Y. , Hase K. , Kimura A. Psychometric properties of the Stroke Impairment Assessment Set (SIAS) . Neurorehabil Neural Repair 2002; 16: 339 51 .

16.

Verheyden G. , Nieuwboer A. , Mertin J. , Preger R. , Kiekens C. , De Weerdt W. The Trunk Impairment Scale: a new tool to measure motor impairment of the trunk after stroke. Clin Rehabil 2004; 18: 326 34.

17.

Verheyden G. , Nuyens G. , Nieuwboer A. , Van Asch P. , Ketelaer P. , De Weerdt W. Reliability and validity of trunk assessment for people with multiple sclerosis . Phys Ther 2006; 83: 66 76.

18.

Blum L. , Korner-Bitensky N. Usefulness of the Berg Balance Scale in stroke rehabilitation: a systematic review. Phys Ther 2008; 88: 559 66.

19.

Mao HF , Hsueh IP , Tang PF , Sheu CF , Hsieh CL Analysis and comparison of the psychometric properties of three balance measures for stroke patients. Stroke 2002; 33: 1022 27.

20.

Whitney SL , Poole JL , Cass SP A review of balance instruments for older adults. Am J Occup Ther 1998; 52: 666 71.

21.

Anemaet WK , Moffa-Trotter ME Functional tools for assessing balance and gait impairments. Topics Geriatr Rehabil 1999; 15: 66 83.

22.

van Peppen RP , Hendriks HJ , van Meeteren NL , Helders PJ , Kwakkel G. The development of a clinical practice stroke guideline for physiotherapists in the Netherlands: a systematic review of available evidence. Disabil Rehabil 2007; 29: 767 83.

23.

Fitzpatrick R. , Davey C. , Buxton MJ , Jones DR Evaluating patient-based outcome measures for use in clinical trials. Health Technol Assess 1998; 2: 1 74.

24.

Yoward LS , Doherty P. , Boyes C. A survey of outcome measurement of balance, walking and gait amongst physiotherapists working in neurology in the UK. Physiotherapy 2008; 94(2): 125 132.

25.

Jørstad EC , Hauer K. , Becker C. , Lamb SE Measuring the psychological outcomes of falling: a systematic review. J Am Geriatr Soc 2005 ; 53: 501 10.

26.

Collin C. , Wade D. Assessing motor impairment after stroke: a pilot reliability study . J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1990; 53: 576 79.

27.

Duarte E. , Marco E. , Muniesa JM , Belmonte R. , Diaz P. , Tejero MEF. Trunk control test as a functional predictor in stroke patients. J Rehabil Med 2002; 34: 267 72.

28.

Feigin L. , Sharon B. , Czaczkes B. , Rosin AJ Sitting equilibrium 2 weeks after a stroke can predict the walking ability after 6 months. Gerentology 1996; 42: 348 53.

29.

Nieuwboer A. , Feys H. , De Weerdt W. , Nuyens G. , De Corte E. Developing a clinical tool to measure sitting balance after stroke: a reliability study . Physiotherapy 1995; 81: 439 45.

30.

Kairy D. , Paquet N. , Fung J. A postural adaptation test for stroke patients. Disabil Rehabil 2003; 25: 127 35.

31.

Harburn KL , Hill KM , Kramer JF , Noh S. , Vandervoort AA , Teasell R. Clinical applicability and Test retest reliability of an external perturbation test of balance in stroke subjects. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1995; 76: 317 23.

32.

Pyoria O. , Era P. , Talvitie U. Relationships between standing balance and symmetry measurements in patients following recent strokes (5= 3 weeks) or older strokes (4=6 months) . Phys Ther 2004; 84: 128 36.

33.

Kokko S. , Paltamaa J. , Ahola E. , Malkia E. The assessment of functional ability in patients with Parkinson’s disease: the PLM-test and three clinical tests. Physiother Res Int 1997; 2: 29 45.

34.

Tyson SF , DeSouza LH Reliability and validity of functional balance tests post stroke. Clin Rehabil 2004; 18: 916 23.

35.

Di Fabio RP , Badke MB Relationship of sensory organization to balance function in patients with hemiplegia. Phys Ther 1990; 70: 542 48.

36.

Visser M. , Marinus J. , Bloem BR , Kisjes H. , van den Berg BM , van Hilten JJ Clinical tests for the evaluation of postural instability in patients with Parkinson’s disease. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2003; 84: 1669 74.

37.

Tyson SF , DeSouza LH Development of the Brunel Balance Assessment: a new measure of balance disability post stroke. Clin Rehabil 2004; 18: 801 10.

38.

Bernhardt J. , Ellis P. , Denisenko S. , Hill K. Changes in balance and locomotion measures during rehabilitation following stroke. Physiother Res Int 1998; 3: 109 22.

39.

Smithson F. , Morris ME , Iansek R. Performance on clinical tests of balance in Parkinson’s disease. Phys Ther 1998; 78: 577 92.

40.

Bohannon R. Correlation of lower limb strengths and other variables with standing performance in stroke patients. Physiother Can 1989; 41: 198 202.

41.

Bohannon RW Selected determinants of ambulatory capacity in patients with hemiplegia. Clin Rehabil 1989; 3: 47 53.

42.

Bohannon RW Standing balance, lower extremity muscle strength, and walking performance of patients referred for physical therapy. Percept Motor Skills 1995; 80: 379 85.

43.

Bohannon RW , Leary KM Standing balance and function over the course of acute rehabilitation. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1995; 76: 994 96.

44.

Bohannon RW , Walsh S. , Joseph MC Ordinal and timed balance measurements: reliability and validity in patients with stroke. Clin Rehabil 1993; 7: 9 13.

45.

Steffen T. , Seney M. Test retest reliability and minimal detectable change on balance and ambulation tests, the 36-item Short-Form Health Survey, and the Unified Parkinson Disease Rating Scale in people with parkinsonism. Phys Ther 2008; 88: 733 46.

46.

Duncan P. , Weiner D. , Chandler Jea. Functional reach: a new clinical measure of balance. J Gerontol 1990; 45: M192 M197.

47.

Duncan PW , Studenski S. , Chandler J. , Prescott B. Functional reach: predictive validity in a sample of elderly male veterans . J Gerontol 1992; 47: M93 M98.

48.

Giorgetti M. , Harris B. , Jette A. Reliability of clinical balance outcome measures in the elderly. Physiother Res Int 1998; 3: 274 83.

49.

Hill K. , Ellis P. , Bernhardt J. , Maggs P. , Hull S. Balance and mobility outcomes for stroke patients: a comprehensive audit. Aust J Physiother 1997; 43: 173 80.

50.

Weiner D. , Duncan P. , Chandler J. , Studenski S. Functional reach: a marker of physical frailty. J Am Geriatr Soc 1992; 40: 203 207.

51.

Weiner DK , Bongiorni DR , Studenski SA , Duncan PW , Kochersberger GG

Does functional reach improve with rehabilitation?

Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1993; 74: 796 800.

52.

Hill KD , Bernhardt J. , McGann AM , Maltese D. , Berkovits D. A new test of dynamic standing balance for stroke patients: reliability, validity and comparison with healthy elderly. Physiother Can 1996; 48: 257 62.

53.

Goldie PA , Matyas TA , Spencer KI , McGinley RB Postural control in standing following stroke: Test retest reliability of some quantitative clinical tests. Phys Ther 1990; 70: 234 43.

54.

Berg K. , Wood-Dauphinee S. , Williams JI , Gayton D. Measuring balance in the elderly: preliminary development of an instrument . Physiother Can 1989; 41: 304 31.

55.

Qutubuddin AA , Pegg PO , Cifu DX , Brown R. , McNamee S. , Carne W. Validating the Berg Balance Scale for patients with Parkinson’s disease: a key to rehabilitation evaluation. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2005; 86: 789 92.

56.

Chou CY , Chien CW , Hsueh IP , Sheu CF , Wang CH , Hsieh CL Developing a short form of the Berg Balance Scale for people with stroke. Phys Ther 2006; 86: 195 204.

57.

Wang CH , Hsueh IP , Sheu CF , Yao G. , Hsieh CL Psychometric properties of 2 simplified 3-level balance scales used for patients with stroke. Phys Ther 2004; 84: 430 38 .

58.

Kornetti DL , Fritz SL , Chiu Y-P. , Light KE , Velozo CA Rating scale analysis of the Berg balance scale. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2004; 85: 1128 35.

59.

Beckerman H. , Vogelaar TW , Lankhorst GJ , Verbeek ALM. A criterion for stability of the motor function of the lower extremity in stroke patients using the Fugl-Meyer Assessment Scale. Scand J Rehabil Med 1996; 28: 3 7.

60.

Carr JH , Shepherd RB , Nordholm L. , Lynne D. Investigation of a new motor assessment scale for stroke patients . Phys Ther 1985; 65: 175 80.

61.

Verheyden, G. and Kersten, P. Evaluating the construct validity of the trunk impairment scale: a Rasch analysis of its subscales. Clinical Rehabilitation, 22(7), 664.

62.

Sandin KJ , Smith BS The measure of balance in sitting in stroke rehabilitation prognosis . Stroke 1990; 21: 82 86.

63.

King M. , Judge J. , Wolfson L. Functional base of support decreases with age. J Gerontol 1994; 49: M258 63.

64.

Nashner L. Adaptation of human movement to altered environments. Trends Neurosci 1982; 5: 358 61.

65.

Pollock AS , Durward BR , Rowe PJ , Paul JP

What is balance?

Clin Rehabil 2000 ; 14: 402 406.

66.

Frzovic D. , Morris ME , Vowels L. Clinical tests of standing balance: performance of persons with multiple sclerosis . Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2000; 81: 215 21.

67.

Tsang YL , Mak MK Sit-and-reach test can predict mobility of patients recovering from acute stroke. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2004; 85: 94 98.

68.

Brusse KJ , Zimdars S. , Zalewski KR , Steffen TM Testing functional performance in people with Parkinson disease. Phys Ther 2005; 85: 134 41.

69.

Sanford J. , Moreland J. , Swanson LR , Stratford PW , Gowland C. Reliability of the Fugl-Meyer Assessment for testing motor performance in patients following stroke. Phys Ther 1993 ; 73: 447 54.

70.

Ahmed S. , Mayo N. , Higgins J. , Salbach N. , Finch L. , Wood-Dauphinee S. The Stroke Rehabilitation Assessment of Movement (STREAM): a comparison with other measures used to evaluate effects of stroke and rehabilitation . Phys Ther 2003; 83: 617 30.

71.

Berg K. , Wood-Dauphinee S. , Williams J. The Balance Scale: reliability assessment with elderly residents and patients with an acute stroke. Scand J Rehabil Med 1995; 27: 27 36.

72.

Berg K. , Wood-Dauphinee S. , Williams J. , Maki B. Measuring balance in the elderly: validation of an instrument. Can J Publ Health 1992; 83(suppl 2): S7 11.

73.

Chern JS , Yang SW , Wu CY Whole-body reaching as a measure of dynamic balance in patients with stroke . Am J Phys Med Rehabil 2006; 85: 201 208.

74.

Corriveau H. , Hebert R. , Raiche M. , Prince F. Evaluation of postural stability in the elderly with stroke. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2004; 85: 1095 101.

75.

English C. , Hillier S. , Stiller K. , Warden-Flood A. The sensitivity of three commonly used outcome measures to detect change amongst patients receiving inpatient rehabilitation following stroke . Clin Rehabil 2006; 20: 52 55.

76.

Liston RA , Brouwer BJ Reliability and validity of measures obtained from stroke patients using the Balance Master. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1996 ; 77: 425 30.

77.

Niam S. , Cheung W. , Sullivan PE , Kent S. , Gu X. Balance and physical impairments after stroke. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1999; 80: 1227 33.

78.

Nilsson L. , Carlsson J. , Grimby G. , Nordholm L. Assessment of walking, balance and sensorimotor performance of hemiparetic patients in the acute stage after stroke. Physiother Theory Pract 1998; 14: 149 57.

79.

Paltamaa J. , West H. , Sarasoja T. , Wikstrom J. , Malkia E. Reliability of physical functioning measures in ambulatory subjects with MS. [erratum appears in Physiother Res Int 2006; 11: 123]. Physiother Res Int 2005; 10: 93 109.

80.

Smith PS , Hembree JA , Thompson ME Berg Balance Scale and Functional Reach: determining the best clinical tool for individuals post acute stroke. Clin Rehabil 2004; 18: 811 18.

81.

Stevenson TJ Detecting change in patients with stroke using the Berg Balance Scale. Aust J Physiother 2001; 47: 29 38.

82.

Malouin F. , Pichard L. , Bonneau C. , Durand A. , Corriveau D. Evaluating motor recovery early after stroke: comparison of the Fugl-Meyer Assessment and the Motor Assessment Scale. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1994; 75: 1206 12.

83.

Loewen SC , Anderson BA Reliability of the Modified Motor Assessment Scale and the Barthel Index. Phys Ther 1988; 68: 1077 81.

84.

Poole JL , Whitney SL Motor assessment scale for stroke patients: concurrent validity and interrater reliability. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1988; 63: 195 97.

85.

Morgan P. The relationship between sitting balance and mobility outcome in stroke . Aust J Physiother 1994; 40: 91 96.

86.

Verheyden G. , Hughes J. , Jelsma J. , Nieuwboer A. , De Weerdt W. Assessing motor impairment of the trunk in patients with traumatic brain injury: reliability and validity of the Trunk Impairment Scale. S Afr J Physiother 2006; 62: 23 28.