Objective: A systematic review of the effectiveness of interventions for adult family carers of people with stroke, and an exploratory examination of the relationship between the conceptual basis of these interventions and their effectiveness.
Data sources: Seventeen electronic databases and grey literature sources were searched, including ASSIA, BNI, Cochrane Library, CINAHL, EMBASE, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, Social Science Citation Index and the Science Citation Index, HMIC and the National Research Register. Authors of unpublished material were contacted for data and additional publications. Reference and citation tracking was performed on included publications.
Review methods: Inclusion criteria: randomized controlled trials of interventions aimed primarily at adult family carers of people post stroke; carers were the primary sample; primary outcomes reported were for carers. Two independent reviewers screened titles and abstracts to identify publications and extract data. Quality assessment was performed to weight study findings.
Results: Eight papers were found reporting on six complex, generally heterogeneous, interventions: caregiver training; education and counselling; social problem-solving partnerships, delivered principally by telephone; a psycho-educational telephone support group; a nurse-led support and education programme; and a support programme, delivered either to groups in hospital or individuals during home visits. Half of the interventions were based on stress-coping theories; the remainder did not identify a conceptual basis for the intervention.
Conclusions: Some benefits were reported for all interventions, although trials were generally of low quality, preventing firm conclusions being drawn. The presence of a conceptual basis for interventions does not appear to influence effectiveness.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Hanson E., Magnusson L., Nolan J., Nolan M.Developing a model of participatory research involving researchers, practitioners, older people and their family carers: an international collaboration. J Res Nurs2006; 11: 325—42.
2.
Department of Health.The Carers (Recognition and Services) Act. HMSO, 1995.
3.
Department of Health.Caring about carers: a national strategy for carers. HMSO, 1999.
4.
Department of Health.The Carers and Disabled Children's Act. HMSO, 2000.
5.
Department of Health.The Community Care (Delayed Discharges) Act. TSO, 2003.
6.
Department of Health.Carers Equal Opportunities Act. TSO, 2004.
7.
Audit Commission.Support for carers of older people. Independence and Well-being 5. HMSO, 2004.
8.
Mant J., Wade DT, Winner S.Health care needs assessment: stroke. In Stevens A, Raftery J, Mant J, Simpson S. eds. Health care needs assessment: the epidemiologically based needs assessment reviews. Radcliffe Medical Press, 2004.
9.
Bunn F.The needs of families and carers of stroke patients. In Wolfe C, Rudd T, Beech R eds. Stroke services and research: an overview with recommendations for future research. The Stroke Association, 1996: 247—60.
10.
Wolfe C.The burden of stroke. In Wolfe C, Rudd T, Beech R. eds. Stroke services and research: an overview with recommendations for future research. The Stroke Association, 1996: 13—39.
11.
Intercollegiate Stroke Working Party.National Clinical Guidelines for Stroke, second edition. Royal College of Physicians, 2004.
12.
Brereton L.Preparation for family caregiving: stroke as a paradigm case. J Clin Nurs1997; 6: 425—34.
13.
Han B., Haley WEFamily caregiving for patients with stroke: review and analysis. Stroke1999; 30: 1478—85.
14.
Anderson C. , Rubenach S., Mhurchu CN, Clark M., Spencer C., Winsor A.Hospital or home for stroke rehabilitation: Results of a randomized controlled trial. Stroke2000; 31: 1024—31.
15.
Mant J., Carter J., Wade DT, Winner S.Family support for stroke: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet2000; 356: 808—13.
16.
Lincoln NB, Francis VM, Lilley SA, Sharma JC, Summerfield M.Evaluation of a stroke family support organiser: a randomised controlled trial . Stroke2003; 34: 116—21.
17.
Lincoln NB, Waller MF, Dixon A., Knights P.Evaluation of a multi-professional community stroke team: a randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil2004; 18: 40—47.
18.
Rodgers H., Bond S., Curless R.Inadequacies in the provision of information to stroke patients and their families. Age Ageing2001; 30: 129—33.
19.
Smith LN, Lawrence M., Kerr SM, Langhorne P., Lees KRInformal carers' experience of caring for stroke survivors. J Adv Nurs2004; 46: 235—44.
20.
Patel A., Knapp M., Evans A., Perez I., Kalra L.Training caregivers of stroke patients: economic evaluation. BMJ2004; 328: 1102—104.
21.
Printz-Feddersen V.Group process effect on caregiver burden. J Neurosci Nurs1990; 22: 164—68.
22.
Low Jts, Payne S., Roderick P.The impact of stroke on informal carers: a literature review. Soc Sci Med1999; 49: 711—25.
23.
Visser-Meily A., van Heugten C., Post M., Schepers V., Lindeman E.Intervention studies for caregivers of stroke survivors: a critical review. Patient Educ Couns2005; 56: 257—67.
24.
Forster A., Smith J., Young J., Knapp P., House A., Wright J.Information provision for stroke patients and their caregivers. The Cochrane Library2001; Issue 3.
25.
Jenicek M.Foundations of evidence-based medicine. Parthenon Publishing Group, 2003.
26.
Campbell M., Fitzpatrick R., Haines A. et al. Framework for design and evaluation of complex interventions to improve health. BMJ2000; 321: 694—96.
27.
MedicalResearch Council. A framework for the development and evaluation of RCTs for complex interventions to improve health. Medical Research Council, 2000.
28.
Robinson L. , Francis J., James P., Tindle N., Greenwell K., Rodgers H.Caring for carers of people with stroke: developing a complex intervention following the Medical Research Council framework. Clin Rehabil2005; 19: 560—71.
Dickersin K. , Scherer R., Lefebvre C.Identifying relevant studies for systematic reviews. BMJ1994; 309: 1286—91.
31.
Egger M., Zellweger-Zähner T., Schneider M., Junker C., Lengeler C., Antes G.Language bias in randomised controlled trials published in English and German . Lancet1997; 350: 326—29.
32.
Moher D., Fortin P., Jadad AR et al. Completeness of reporting of trials published in languages other than English: implications for conduct and reporting of systematic reviews . Lancet1996; 347: 363—66.
33.
Critical Appraisal Skills Programme. Public Health Resource Unit, 2002 [online] Milton Keynes Primary Care Trust, Milton Keynes. Accessed 26 January 2007 from www.prhu.nhs.uk/casp/critical_appraisal_tools .
34.
Dixon-Woods M. , Agarwal S., Young B., Jones D., Sutton A.Integrative approaches to quantitative and qualitative evidence. Health Development Agency, 2004.
35.
Pawson R., Greenhalgh T., Harvey J., Walshe K.Realist review — a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions. J Health Serv Res Policy2005; 10: 21—33.
36.
Edwards Agk , Russell IT, Stott NCSignal versus noise in the evidence base for medicine: an alternative to hierarchies of evidence?Fam Pract1998; 15: 319—22.
37.
Grant JSSocial problem-solving partnerships with family caregivers. Rehabil Nurs1999; 24: 254—60.
38.
Grant JS, Elliott TR, Weaver M., Bartolucci AA, Giger JNTelephone intervention with family caregivers of stroke survivors after rehabilitation . Stroke2002; 33: 2060—65.
39.
Hartke RJ, King RBTelephone group intervention for older stroke caregivers. Top Stroke Rehabil2003; 9: 65—81.
40.
Larson J., Franzen-Dahlin A., Billing E., Arbin M., Murray V., Wredling R.The impact of a nurse-led support and education programme for spouses of stroke patients: a randomized controlled trial. J Clin Nurs2005; 14: 995—1003.
41.
Kalra L., Evans A., Perez I., Melbourn A., Patel A., Knapp M., Donaldson N.Training carers of stroke patients: randomised controlled trial. BMJ2004; 328: 1099—101.
42.
van den Heuvel ET, Witte LP, Stewart RE, Schure LM, Sanderman R., Meyboom-de-Jong B.Long-term effects of a group support program and an individual support program for informal caregivers of stroke patients: which caregivers benefit the most?. Patient Educ Couns2002; 47: 291—99.
43.
van den Heuvel ET, Witte LP, Stewart RE, Schure LM, Sanderman R., Meyboom-de-Jong B.Short-term effects of a group support program and an individual support program for caregivers of stroke patients. Patient Educ Couns2000; 40: 109—20.
44.
Evans RL, Matlock A-L., Bishop DS, Stranahan S., Pederson C.Family intervention after stroke: does counselling or education help?Stroke1988; 19: 1243—49.
45.
Adams C.Quality of life for caregivers and stroke survivors in the immediate discharge period. Appl Nurs Res2003; 16: 126—30.
46.
D'Zurilla TJ , Chang ECThe relations between social problem solving and coping. Cogn Ther Res1995; 19: 547—62.
47.
Houts PS, Nezu AM, Nezu CM, Bucher JAThe prepared family caregiver: A problem-solving approach to family caregiver education. Patient Educ Couns1996; 27: 63—73.
48.
Nezu AM, Nezu CM, Perri MGProblem-solving therapy for depression: theory, research and clinical guidelines . John Wiley & Sons, 1989.
49.
Nezu CM, Nezu AM, Houts PSMultiple applications of problem-solving principles in clinical practice. In Kuehlwein KT, Rosen H eds. Cognitive therapies in action: evolving innovative practice. Jossey-Bass,1993: 353—78.
50.
Roberts J., Browne GB, Streiner D. et al. Problemsolving counselling or phone-call support for outpatients with chronic illnesses: effective for whom?Can J Nurs Res1995; 27: 111—37.
51.
Hangar HC, Mulley GPQuestions people ask about stroke. Stroke1993; 24: 536—38.
52.
McCullagh E., Brigstocke G., Donaldson N., Kalra L.Determinants of caregiving burden and quality of life in caregivers of stroke patients. Stroke2005; 36: 2181—86.
53.
Forsberg-Warleby G., Moller A., Blomstrand C.Psychological well-being of spouses of stroke patients during the first year after stroke. Clin Rehabil2004; 18: 430—37.
54.
Sit Jwh, Wong Tks, Clinton M., Li Lsw, Fong Y.Stroke care in the home: the impact of social support on the general health of family caregivers. J Clin Nurs2004; 13: 816—24.
O'Connell B. , Baker L.Managing as carers of stroke survivors: strategies from the field. Int J Nurs Pract2003; 10: 121—26.
57.
Chambers M. , Ryan AA, Connor SLExploring the emotional support needs and coping strategies of family carers. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs2001; 8: 99—106.
58.
Archbold PG, Stewart BJ, Greenlick MR, Harvath TAThe clinical assessment of mutuality and preparedness in family caregivers of frail older people. In Funk SG, Tornquist EMT, Champagne ST, Wiese RA eds. Key aspects of elder care: managing falls, incontinence and cognitive impairment . Springer, 1992: 328—39.
59.
van den Heuvel Etp, de Witte LP, Schure LM, Sanderman R., Meyboom de-Jong B.Risk factors for burn out in caregivers of stroke patients and possibilities for intervention. Clin Rehabil2001; 15: 669—77.
60.
Thommessen B., Bautz-Holter E., Laake K.Predictors of outcome of rehabilitation of elderly stroke patients in a geriatric ward. Clin Rehabil1999; 13: 123—28.
61.
Kotila M., Numminen H., Waltimo O., Kaste M.Depression after stroke: results of the FINNSTROKE study. Stroke1998; 29: 368—72.
62.
Given BA, Given CWFamily caregivers for the elderly. In Fitzpatrick J, Tauton R, Jacox A eds. Annual review of nursing research, Volume 9 . Springer, 1991.
63.
Brereton L.The needs of `new' family carers following stroke: a constructivist study. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, 2005.
64.
Brereton L., Nolan M.Seeking partnerships between family and professional carers: stroke as a case in point. In Nolan M, Lundh U, Grant G, Keady J eds. Partnerships in family care: understanding the caregiving career. Open University Press , 2003: 50—68.
65.
Brereton L. , Nolan M. `Seeking': a key activity for new family carers of stroke survivors. J Clin Nurs2002; 11: 22—31.
66.
Farran CJFamily caregiver intervention research: where have we been? Where are we going?J Geront Nurs2001; 27: 38—45.
67.
Twigg J., Atkin K.Carers perceived: policy and practice in informal care. Open University Press, 1994.
68.
Nolan M., Grant G., Keady J.Understanding family care. Open University Press, 1996.
69.
Jones K.Informal care as relationship: the case of the Magnificent Seven. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs2006; 13: 214—20.
70.
Galvin K., Todres L., Richardson M.The intimate mediator: a carer's experience of Alzheimer's. Scand J Caring Sci2005; 19: 2—11.
71.
Henderson J. , Forbat L.Relationship-based social policy: personal and policy constructions of `care'. Crit Soc Policy2002; 22: 669—87.
72.
Kahana E., Young R.Clarifying the caregiving paradigm: challenges for the future. In Biegel DE, Blum A eds. Ageing and caregiving theory, research and policy. Sage, 1990.
73.
Clarke A., Hanson EJ, Ross H.Seeing the person behind the patient: enhancing the care of older people using a biographical approach. J Clin Nurs2003; 12: 697—706.
74.
O'Neill-Conger C., Marshall ESRecreating life: toward a theory of relationship development in acute home care. Qual Health Res1998; 8: 528—46.
75.
Liaschenko J.Knowing the patient. In Thorne SE, Hays VE eds. Nursing praxis, knowledge and action. Sage, 1997.
76.
Harvath TA, Archbold PG, Stewart BJ et al. Establishing partnerships with family caregivers local and cosmopolitan knowledge. J Gerontol Nurs1994; 20: 29—35.
77.
Brown J, Davies S, Nolan M. Nolan M, Davies S, Grant G. eds. Working with older people and their families: key issues in policy and practice. Open University Press, 2001.
78.
Allen D.Negotiating the role of expert carers on an adult hospital ward. Sociol Health Illness2000; 22: 149—71.
79.
Power R., Langhaug LF, Nyamurera T., Wilson D., Bassett MT, Cowan FMDeveloping complex interventions for rigorous evaluation — a case study from rural Zimbabwe. Health Educ Res2004; 19: 570—75.
80.
Braithwaite V.Contextual or general stress outcomes: making choices through caregiving appraisals. Gerontologist2000; 40: 706—17.
81.
Pickard S.Coordinated care for older people with dementia. J Interprofessional Care1999; 13: 345—54.
82.
Hanson E., Nolan J., Magnusson L., Sennemark E., Johansson L., Nolan M.COAT: The Carers Outcome Agreement Tool: a new approach to working with family carers. University of Sheffield, 2006 .
83.
Anehensel CS, Pearlin LI, Mullan JT et al. Profiles in caregiving: the unexpected career. Academic Press, 1995.
