Background: Goal achievement has been considered to be an important measure of outcome by clinicians working with patients in physical and neurological rehabilitation settings. This systematic review was undertaken to examine the reliability, validity and sensitivity of goal setting and goal attainment scaling approaches when used with working age and older people.
Aims and objectives: To review the reliability, validity and sensitivity of both goal setting and goal attainment scaling when employed as an outcome measure within a physical and neurological working age and older person rehabilitation environment, by examining the research literature covering the 36 years since goal-setting theory was proposed.
Methods: Data sources included a computer-aided literature search of published studies examining the reliability, validity and sensitivity of goal setting/goal attainment scaling, with further references sourced from articles obtained through this process.
Main findings: There is strong evidence for the reliability, validity and sensitivity of goal attainment scaling. Empirical support was found for the validity of goal setting but research demonstrating its reliability and sensitivity is limited.
Conclusions: Goal attainment scaling appears to be a sound measure for use in physical rehabilitation settings with working age and older people. Further work needs to be carried out with goal setting to establish its reliability and sensitivity as a measurement tool.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ward CD , McIntosh S.The rehabilitation process: a neurological perspective. In Greenwood J , Barnes B , McMillan TM , Ward, CD eds. Handbook of neurological rehabilitation, second edition. Psychology Press , 2003: 15-28.
2.
Grenville J , Lyne P.Patient-centred evaluation and rehabilitative care . JAdv Nurs1995; 22: 965-972 .
3.
Rockwood KJ , Joyce BM , Stolee P.Use of goal attainment scaling in measuring clinically important change in cognitive rehabilitation patients . J Clin Epidemiol1997; 50: 581-588 .
4.
Department of Health . National Service Framework for older people. Stationery Office , 2001.
5.
Williams TE.Geriatrics: a perspective on quality of life and care for older people. In Spilker B ed. Quality of life assessments in clinical trials. Raven Press , 1990: 217-223.
6.
Locke EA.Toward a theory of task motivation and incentives . Organ Behav Hum Perform1968; 3: 157-189 .
7.
Locke EA , Shaw K , Saari L , Latham GP.Goal-setting and task performance: 1969-1980 . Psychol Bull1981; 90: 125-152 .
8.
Kiresuk TJ , Sherman RE.Goal attainment scaling: a general method for evaluating comprehensive community mental health programs . Community Ment Health J1968; 4: 443-453 .
9.
Kiresuk TJ , Lund SH. In Attkinson CC , Hargreaves WA , Horowitz MJ , Sorensen JE eds. Evaluation of human service programs. Academic Press ,1978: 341-370.
10.
Calsyn RJ , Davidson WS.Do we really want a program evaluation strategy based solely on individualized goals? A critique of goal attainment scaling . Community Ment Health J1978; 14: 300-308 .
11.
Rockwood K , Stolee P , Fox RA.Use of goal attainment scaling in measuring clinically important change in the frail elderly . J Clin Epidemiol1993; 46: 1113-1118 .
12.
Williams RC , Steig RL.Validity and therapeutic efficacy of individual patient goal attainment procedures in a chronic pain treatment centre . Clin J Pain1987; 2: 219-228 .
13.
Rockwood KJ.Setting goals in geriatric rehabilitation and measuring their attainment . Rev Clin Gerontol1994; 4: 141-149 .
Donnelly C , Carswell A.Individualized outcome measures: a review of the literature . Can J Occup Ther-Rev Can Ergother2002; 69: 84-94 .
16.
Foley A.A review of goal planning in the rehabilitation of the spinal injured person . J Orthop Nurs1998; 2: 148-152 .
17.
Wade D.Goal planning in stroke rehabilitation: evidence . Top Stroke Rehabil1999; 6: 37-42 .
18.
Guthrie S , Harvey A.Motivation and its influence on outcome in rehabilitation . Rev Clin Gerontol1994; 4: 235-243 .
19.
Cytrynbaum S , Ginath Y , Birdwell J , Brandt L.Goal attainment scaling: a critical review . Eval Q1979; 3: 5-40 .
20.
McMillan TM , Sparkes C.Goal planning and neurorehabilitation: the Wolfson Neurorehabilitation Centre approach . Neuropsychol Rehabil1999; 9: 241-251 .
21.
Liu C , McNeil JE , Greenwood R.Rehabilitation outcomes after brain injury: disability measures or goal achievement?Clin Rehabil2004; 18: 398-404 .
22.
Turner-Stokes L.British Society for Rehabilitation Medicine Standards for Specialist Inpatient and Community Rehabilitation Services . Clin Rehabil2002; 16: 39-46 .
23.
Chalmers I , Altman DG.Systematic reviews. BMJ Publications , 1995.
24.
Reber AS , Reber E.The Penguin dictionary of psychology, third edition. Penguin Books , 2001.
25.
World Health Organization . Disability prevention and rehabilitation. Technical Report Series 668. WHO , 1981.
26.
Cornbleth T.Evaluation of goal attainment in geriatric settings . J Am Geriatr Soc1978; 26: 404-407 .
27.
Meer B , Baker JA.The Stockton Geriatric Scale . J Gerontol1966; 21: 392-403 .
28.
Plutchik R , Conte H , Lieberman Met al.Reliability and validity of a scale for assessing the functioning of geriatric patients . J Am Geriatr Soc1970; 18: 491-500 .
29.
Cornbleth T , Cornbleth C.Reality orientation for the elderly . JSAS Catalog of Selected Documents in Psychology1977; 7: 80-80 .
30.
Wressle E , Samuelsson K , Henriksson C.Responsiveness of the Swedish Version of the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure . Scand J Occup Ther1999; 6: 84-89 .
31.
Law M , Baptiste S , Carswell A , McColl MA , Polatajko H , Pollock N.Canadian Occupational Performance Measure, second edition. CAOT Publications , 1994.
32.
Wade D.Assessment of motor function: impairment and disability. In Greenwood RJ , Barnes MP , McMillian TM , Ward CD eds. Neurological rehabilitation. Psychology Press , 1993: 147-160.
33.
Oldridge N , Guyatt G , Crowe J , Feeny D , Jones N.Goal attainment in a randomized controlled trial of rehabilitation after myocardial infarction . J Cardiopulm Rehabil1999; 19: 29-34 .
34.
Oldridge N , Guyatt G , Jones Net al.Effects on quality of life with comprehensive myocardial infarction . Am J Cardiol1991; 67: 1084-1089 .
35.
Kaplan R , Anderson J.The general health policy model: an integrated approach. In Spilker B ed. Quality of life and pharmacoeconomics in clinical trials. Lippincott-Raven , 1996: 309-322.
36.
Torrance GW.Measurement of health state utilities for economic appraisal: a review . J Health Econ1986; 5: 1-30 .
37.
Goodyear DL , Bitter JB.Goal attainment scaling as a program evaluation measure in rehabilitation . J Appl Rehabil Counsel1974; 5: 19-26 .
38.
Melzack R.The McGill Pain Questionnaire: major properties and scoring methods . Pain1975; 1: 277-299 .
39.
Malec JF , Smigielski JS , DePompolo RW.Goal attainment scaling and outcome measurement in post-acute brain injury rehabilitation . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1991; 72: 138-143 .
40.
Lezak MD.Relationships between personality disorders, social disturbances, and physical disability following traumatic brain injury . J Head Trauma Rehabil1987; 2: 57-69 .
41.
Stolee P , Rockwood KJ , Fox RA , Streiner DL.The use of goal attainment scaling in a geriatric care setting . J Am Geriatr Soc1992; 40: 574-578 .
42.
Granger CV , Albrecht GL , Hamilton BB.Outcome of comprehensive medical rehabilitation: measurement of PULSES Profile and the Barthel Index . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1979; 60: 145-154 .
43.
Stolee P , Stadnyk K , Myers AM , Rockwood KJ.An individualised approach to outcome meausurement in geriatric rehabilitation . J Gerontol Ser A Biol Sci Med Sci1999; 54: 641-647 .
44.
Joyce BM , Rockwood KJ , Mate-Kole CC.Use of goal attainment scaling in brain injury in a rehabilitation hospital . Am J Phys Med Rehabil1994; 73: 10-14 .
45.
Folstein MF , Folstein SE , McHugh PR.Mini Mental State: a practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician .J Psychiatr Res1975; 12: 189-198 .
46.
Hunt SM , McEwan J , McKenna SP.Measuring health status. Croom Helm , 1986.
47.
Rockwood KJ , Howlett S , Stadnyk K , Carver D , Powell C , Stolee P.Responsiveness of goal attainment scaling in a randomized controlled trial of comprehensive geriatric assessment . J Clin Epidemiol2003; 56: 736-743 .
48.
Yip AM , Gorman MC , Stadnyk K , Mills WG , MacPherson KM , Rockwood KJ.A standardized menu for goal attainment scaling in the care of frail elders . The Gerontologist1998; 38: 735-742 .
49.
Molloy DW , Alemayehu E , Roberts R.Reliability of a Standardized Mini-Mental State Examination compared with the traditional Mini-Mental State Examination . Am J Psychiatry1991; 148: 102-105 .
50.
Katz S , Akpom CA.A measure of primary socio-biological functions . Int J Health Serv1976; 6: 493-507 .
51.
Fillenbaum GG.Screening the elderly: a brief instrumental activities of daily living measure . J Am Geriatr Soc1985; 33: 698-706 .
52.
Rushton PW , Miller WC.Goal attainment scaling in the rehabilitation of patients with lower-extremity amputations: a pilot study . Arch Phys Med Rehabil2002; 83: 771-775 .
Gompertz P , Pound P , Ebrahim S.A postal version of the Barthel Index . Clin Rehabil1994; 8: 233-239 .
55.
Grise ML , Gauthier-Gagnon C , Martineau GG.Prosthetic profile of people with lower extremity amputation: conception and design of a follow-up questionnaire . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1993; 74: 862-870 .
56.
Gauthier-Gagnon C , Grise MC.Prosthetic profile of the amputee questionnaire: validity and reliability . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1994; 75: 1309-1314 .
