Evaluating the transition from Regional Development Agencies to Local Economic Partnerships: The views of SMEs in the British West Midlands

Abstract

After the election of the Conservative-Liberal Democrat Coalition in 2010, the UK Government instituted a radical reorganisation of governance structures for subnational economic development in England. This involved the abolition of Regional Development Agencies and the introduction of Local Enterprise Partnerships, defined as ‘joint local authority-business bodies brought forward by groups of local authorities to support local economic development across “functional economies”’ (Department for Business Innovation and Skills, 2010: 10). This article contributes to the debate about Local Enterprise Partnerships through an exploration and analysis of the views of small and medium enterprises (SMEs) with regard to lessons to be learned from the old Regional Development Agency system and the transition to the new Local Enterprise Partnership system. Empirically, it focuses on the experiences of digital media firms in the West Midlands region (and now in the Greater Birmingham and Solihull Local Enterprise Partnership). The article draws on desk research and in-depth interviews with Regional Development Agencies and Local Authority employees involved in economic development, industry representatives and business support organisations, in addition to interviews with small and medium enterprise owners and self-employed consultants/freelancers. The research reported here adopted a longitudinal approach with four rounds of interviews between 2010 and 2013. Overall, disruption to publicly funded networks was seen as a significant cost of institutional change between Regional Development Agencies and Local Enterprise Partnerships. Valued functions of the Regional Development Agency were its role in increasing the visibility and coherence of the digital media sector and supporting networking. However, the SMEs reported considerable uncertainty regarding the role of the Local Enterprise Partnership and were concerned about the loss of well-functioning programmes and institutional support structures.

Keywords

digital media Local Enterprise Partnerships Regional Development Agencies West Midlands

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Advantage West Midlands (AWM) (2002) Delivering Advantage. The West Midlands Regional Economic Strategy and Action Plan, Birmingham: AWM.

Advantage West Midlands (AWM) (2007) Screen, Image and Sound. Strategic Cluster Plan 2008–2011, Birmingham: AWM.

Advantage West Midlands (AWM) (2012) Making a Difference 1999–2012, Birmingham: AWM.

Andres

Chapain

(2013) The integration of cultural and creative industries into local and regional development strategies in Birmingham and Marseille: Towards an inclusive and collaborative governance? Regional Studies 47(2): 161–182.

Ayres

Pearce

(2013) A Whitehall perspective on decentralisation in England’s emerging territories. Local Economy 28(7–8): 801–816.

Bailey

(2011) From RDAs to LEPs: Challenges and prospects. Regions Magazine 248(1): 13–15.

Bellini

Danson

Halkier

(2012) Regional Development Agencies: The Next Generation?, London: Routledge.

Bentley G and Pugalis L (2013) New directionsin economic development: Localist policy discoursesand the Localism Act. Local Economy 28(3): 257–274.

Bentley G, Bailey D and Shutt J (2010) FromRDAs to LEPs: A new localism? Case examplesof West Midlands and Yorkshire. LocalEconomy 25(7): 535–557.

10.

Brown J, Chapain C, Murie A, et al. (2007) From a city of a thousand trades to a city of a thousand ideas. Birmingham, West Midlands, UK. Pathways to creative and knowledge based regions. ACRE Report Number 2.3. Amsterdam: AMIDSt. University of Amsterdam.

11.

Brown J, Lutz J, Gibney J, et al. (2010) Policies and strategies for the creative knowledge economy in Birmingham and the West Midlands Region. How to enhance the city’s competitiveness. ACRE Report Number WP10.3. Amsterdam: AMIDSt. University of Amsterdam.

12.

Clarke

Cochrane

(2013) Geographies and politics of localism: The localism of the United Kingdom’s coalition government. Political Geography 34: 10–23.

13.

Cochrane

Colenutt

Field

(2013) Developing a sub-regional growth strategy: Reflections on recent English experience. Local Economy 28(7–8): 786–800.

14.

Cox E (2010) Local Enterprise Partnerships – We have to get this right. IPPR. Available at: http://www.ippr.org/articles/56/582/local-enterprise-partnerships–we-have-to-get-this-right (accessed 28 December 2013).

15.

Dahlström

James

(2012) Regional policies for knowledge anchoring in European Regions. European Planning Studies 20(11): 1867–1887.

16.

Department for Business Innovation and Skills (BIS) (2010) Local Growth: Realising Every Place’s Potential, London: HMSO.

17.

Department for Business Innovation and Skills (BIS) (2011) Abolition of Regional Development Agencies. Risk Assessment, London: HMSO.

18.

Doyle

(2013) Local Enterprise Partnerships to deliver progressive social outcomes. Local Economy 28(7–8): 921–926.

19.

Fineberg

(2013) Promoting sustainable local economic development for all areas: Looking forward or looking back? Local Economy 28(7–8): 914–920.

20.

Furmage D (2012) Developing next generation clusters and business support for the creative and digital industries: Discussion paper. Available at: http://www.cluster2020live.eu/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/Developing-next-gen-clusterssupport-discussion-paper-3Sept12.pdf (accessed 20 December 2013).

21.

Greater Birmingham and Solihull Local Enterprise Partnership (GBSLEP) (2013) Delivering Growth: Strategic Framework. Birmingham: GBSLEP.

22.

Halkier

(2006) Institutions, Discourse, and Regional Development, Brussels: PIE Peter Lang.

23.

Harrison

(2011) Local Enterprise Partnerships, Loughborough: Centre for Research in Identity, Governance, Society (CRIGS)/Globalization and World Cities (GaWC) Research Network.

24.

Harte D (2010) The West Midlands’ Digital Media Sector – A Cluster Approach. Available at: http://daveharte.com/creative-industries/paper-on-advantage-west-midlands-digital-media-cluster/ (accessed 28 November 2013)..

25.

Heseltine

(2012) No Stone Unturned in Pursuit of Growth, London: BIS.

26.

HM Treasury (2013) Spending Round 2013, Norwich: TSO.

27.

James

(2012) Education and skills policy for the knowledge economy: Insights from territorial innovation models and territorial knowledge dynamics. European Planning Studies 20(11): 1803–1821.

28.

Jones

(2010) Here we go again: The pathology of compulsive re-organisation. Local Economy 25(5): 373–378.

29.

Licari D (2009) Creative Regions: Regional Analysis on Future Trends for Digital Creative Industries in West Midlands/United Kingdom. CReATE. Available at: http://www.lets-create.eu (accessed 28 December 2013).

30.

Mason

(2007) Digital Central: Mandate for Action: What the Digital Sector in the West Midlands needs to Succeed, London: Pembridge.

31.

NESTA (2008) Beyond the Creative Industries: Making Policy for the Creative Economy, London: NESTA Policy and Research Unit.

32.

Peck

Connolly

Durnin

(2013) Prospects for ‘place-based’ industrial policy in England: The role of Local Enterprise Partnerships. Local Economy 28(7–8): 828–841.

33.

Pugalis

(2010) Looking back in order to move forward: The politics of evolving Sub-National Economic Policy Architecture. Local Economy 25(5): 397–405.

34.

Pugalis

(2012a) After regions: What next for local enterprise partnerships? Regions Magazine 286(2): 23–25.

35.

Pugalis

(2012b) The governance of economic regeneration in England: Emerging practice and issues. Journal of Urban Regeneration and Renewal 5(3): 235–252.

36.

Pugalis

Bentley

(2013a) Economic development 2010–2013: A mid-term assessment. Local Economy 28(7–8): 935–947.

37.

Pugalis

Bentley

(2013b) Storming or performing? Local Enterprise Partnerships two years on. Local Economy 28(7–8): 863–874.

38.

Pugalis

Fisher

(2011) English regions disbanded: European funding and economic regeneration implications. Local Economy 26(6–7): 500–516.

39.

Pugalis

Townsend

(2013) Trends in place-based economic strategies: England's fixation with ‘fleet-of-foot’ partnerships. Local Economy 28(7–8): 696–717.

40.

Reid

Albert

Hopkins

(2010) A Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative Industries, London: The Work Foundation.

41.

Rossiter

Price

(2013) Local economic strategy development under Regional Development Agencies and Local Enterprise Partnerships: Applying the lens of the multiple streams framework. Local Economy 28(7–8): 852–862.

42.

Shaw

Greenhalgh

(2010) Revisiting the ‘Missing Middle’ in English Sub-National Governance. Local Economy 25(5): 457–475.

43.

Shaw

Robinson

(2012) From ‘regionalism' to ‘localism’: Opportunities and challenges for North East England. Local Economy 27(3): 232–250.

44.

Shutt J, Pugalis L and Bentley G (2012) LEPs – living up to the hype? The changing framework for regional economic development and localism in the UK. In: Ward M and Hardy S (eds) Changing Gear – Is Localism the New Regionalism. London: Smith Institute, pp. 12–24.

45.

Taylor

(2010) Clusters: A mesmerising mantra. Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie 101(3): 276–286.

46.

Technology Strategy Board (2009) Creative Industries: Technology Strategy 2009–2012, London: Technology Strategy Board.

47.

Visser

E-J

Atzema

(2008) With or without clusters: Facilitating innovation through a differentiated and combined network approach. European Planning Studies 16(9): 1169–1188.