We considered (i) whether loan funds managed by Local Enterprise Agencies (LEAs) in England addressed the finance gap faced by new and small firms that are unable to raise investment capital from other sources, and (ii) whether LEA loan funds offered value-for-money and sustainability. Utilising realistic evaluation and data provided by LEAs, we found that funds had a high conversion rate of applications to loans, presumably because most referrals came from advisers and so propositions unlikely to be supported had already been weeded out, and due to high repayment rates. The level of demand suggested that knowledge of the availability of loans from these sources was still low, but that loans from LEAs were genuinely additional for small firms that would not otherwise have been able to raise the required finance from other sources, indeed in many cases leveraging commercially sourced funds. While LEA loan funds were becoming more efficient, they were not – and were unlikely to become – wholly sustainable. The high conversion rate (and low default rate) suggested that the real need for prospective entrepreneurs is effective advice and support to improve their ‘investment readiness’ and thus assist in unlocking the necessary financial support.
Barclays Bank (2001) Profiting from Support, London: Barclays.
2.
BennettRJ (2008) SME policy support in Britain since the 1990s: What have we learnt?Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy26(2): 375397.
3.
BhattNTangS-Y (2001) Making microcredit work in the United States: Social, financial and administrative dimensions. Economic Development Quarterly15(3): 229241.
BristowGMundayM (1997) Economic development co-ordination in the periphery: The case of local enterprise agency activity in North West Wales. Regional Studies31(7): 713728.
6.
CarrJHTongZY (2002) Replicating Microfinance in the United States, Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press.
7.
CollinSFisherTMayoE (2001) The State of Community Development Finance 2001, London: New Economics Foundation.
8.
Community Development Finance Association (CDFA) (2005) Inside Out: The State of Community Development Finance, London: Community Development Finance Association.
9.
Community Development Finance Association (CDFA) (2010) Inside Out: The State of Community Development Finance. London: Community Development Finance Association.
10.
CoshAHughesA (2003) Enterprise Challenged: Policy and Performance in the British SME Sector 1999–2002, Cambridge: ESRC Centre for Business Research.
11.
CowlingMMitchellP (2001) Is the small firms loan guarantee scheme hazardous for banks or helpful to small business?Small Business Economics21(1): 6371.
12.
CraigBRJacksonWEThompsonJB (2007a) Small firm finance, credit rationing, and the impact of SBA-guaranteed lending on local economic growth. Journal of Small Business Management45(1): 116132.
13.
CraigBRJacksonWEThomsonJB (2007b) Does Government Intervention in the Small-Firm Credit Market Help Economic Performance?, Cleveland, OH: Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland.
14.
DerbanWKBinnerJMMullineuxA (2005) Loan repayment performance in community development finance institutions in the UK. Small Business Economics25(4): 319332.
15.
FieldenSLDaweAJWoolnoughH (2006) UK government small business finance initiatives: Social inclusion or gender discrimination?Equal Opportunities International25(1): 2537.
16.
ForsterSLedermanEMayshakJ (2006) Aspire – Microloans for Business: Operational and Funding Lessons for the Future of Microfinance in the UK, London: Esmée Fairbairn Foundation.
17.
FraserS (2005) Finance for Small and Medium Sized Enterprises: A Report on the 2004 UK Survey of SME Finances, Coventry: Warwick Business School.
18.
GlavenH (2013) Inside Community Finance: The CDFI Industry in the UK 2012, London: CDFA.
19.
Her Majesty’s Treasury (1999) Access to Financial Services: Policy Action Team 14, London: HM Treasury.
20.
JacksonA (2001) An evaluation of evaluation: problems with performance measurement in small business loan and grant schemes. Progress in Planning55(1): 164.
21.
LehtonenOLahtiT (2009) The role of advisors in the venture capital investment process. Venture capital11(3): 229254.
22.
McGeehanSGogginN (2008) Inside Out 2007: The State of Community Development Finance, London: Community Development Finance Association.
23.
MasonCMHarrisonRT (2001) ‘Investment readiness’: A critique of government proposals to increase the demand for venture capital. Regional Studies35(7): 663668.
24.
MasonCKwokJ (2010) Investment readiness programmes and access to finance: A critical review of design issues. Local Economy25(4): 269292.
25.
MasonCStarkM (2004) What do investors look for in a business plan? A comparison of the investment criteria of bankers, venture capitalists and business angels. International Small Business Journal22(3): 227248.
26.
Microfinance Information Exchange (2006) Benchmarking African Microfinance 2005, Washington, DC: Microfinance Information Exchange.
27.
OECD (2012) Financing SMEs and Entrepreneurs 2012: An OECD Scorecard, Paris, OECD Publishing.
RichbellSMWattsHDWardleP (2006) Owner-managers and business planning in the small firm. International Small Business Journal24(5): 496514.
30.
RidingAMadillJHainesGJr (2007) Incrementality of SME loan guarantees. Small Business Economics29(1–2): 4761.
31.
RouseJJayawarnaD (2006) The financing of disadvantaged entrepreneurs: Are enterprise programmes overcoming the finance gap?International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research12(16): 388400.
32.
ScottJMIrwinD (2009) Discouraged advisees? The influence of gender, ethnicity, and education in the use of advice and finance by UK SMEs. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy27(2): 230245.
33.
Social Investment Task Force (2000) A Report to the Chancellor of the Exchequer from the Social Investment Task Force, London: Social Investment Task Force.
34.
ThompsonJLScottJMDowningR (2012) Enterprise policy, delivery, practice and research: Largely rhetoric or under-valued achievement?International Journal of Public Sector Management25(5): 332345.
35.
TuckerJLeanJ (2003) Small firm finance and public policy. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development10(1): 5061.
36.
WrenCStoreyDJ (2002) Evaluating the effect of soft business support upon small firm performance. Oxford Economic Papers54(2): 334365.
