Academic evaluations of the relationship between religion, secularization, and far-right collective actors have grown increasingly complicated. New religious immigrants, seen as invaders importing contradictory values imposed on the populous by EU elites, may threaten Christian and irreligious Europeans. Europe has been secularizing for decades, concurrent with a resurgence in far-right collective action, but this far-right resurgence has also accompanied an increase in religious discourse in politics. In this study, I investigate the relationship between religion, secularization, and far-right collective action utilizing three case studies. I find, with some caveats, that in Hungary, Fidesz motivates Christian voters with religious nationalist appeals, while assertive secularization motivates irreligious voters in the Netherlands. Italy is more complex, where far-right collective actors are less able to monopolize social issues. These findings speak to the critical role religious values and institutions play in shaping voter preferences and present competing options for secularist politics moving forward.
ÁdámZBozókiA (2016a) State and faith: Right-wing populism and nationalized religion in Hungary. Intersections2: 143.
3.
ÁdámZBozókiA (2016b) ‘The god of Hungarians’: Religion and right-wing populism in Hungary. In: MarzoukiNMcdonnellDRoyO (eds) Saving the People: How Populists Hijack Religion. London: Hurst & Company, pp.129–237.
4.
AkkermanT (2005) Anti-immigrant parties and the defence of liberal values: The exceptional case of the List Pim Fortuyn. Journal of Political Ideologies10(3): 337–354.
5.
AkkermanT (2012) Comparing radical right parties in government: Immigration and integration policies in nine countries (1996–2010). West European Politics35(3): 511–529.
6.
AkkermanT (2015) Gender and the radical right in Western Europe: A comparative analysis of policy agendas. Patterns of Prejudice49(1–2): 37–60.
7.
AlexanderJ (2013) Struggling over the mode of incorporation: Backlash against multiculturalism in Europe. Ethnic and Racial Studies36(4): 531–556.
8.
ArzheimerKCarterE (2009) Christian religiosity and voting for West European radical right parties. West European Politics32(5): 985–1011.
9.
BaderV (2007) The governance of Islam in Europe: The perils of modelling. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies33: 871–886.
10.
BaleT (2003) Cinderella and her ugly sisters: The mainstream and extreme right in Europe’s bipolarising party systems. West European Politics26(3): 67–90.
Ben-PoratGFilcDOzturkAE, et al. (2023) Populism, religion and family values policies in Israel, Italy and Turkey. Mediterranean Politics28(2): 155–177.
13.
BetzHGMeretS (2009) Revisiting Lepanto: The political mobilization against Islam in contemporary Western Europe. Patterns of Prejudice43(3–4): 313–334.
14.
BornschierS (2010) Cleavage Politics and the Populist Right: The New Cultural Conflict in Western Europe. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
15.
BrackeS (2011) Subjects of debate: Secular and sexual exceptionalism, and Muslim women in the Netherlands. Feminist Review98(1): 28–46.
BrubakerR (2017) Between nationalism and civilizationism: The European populist moment in comparative perspective. Ethnic and Racial Studies40(8): 1191–1226.
18.
CaljéJM (2019) Polarization in the European Union and the implications for Israel: The case of the Netherlands: Psico-USF. Psico-USF24(3): 71–79.
19.
CaianiMCarvalhoT (2021) The use of religion by populist parties: the case of Italy and its broader implications. Religion, State & Society49(3): 211–230.
20.
CasanovaJ (2009) The secular and secularisms. Social Research76(4): 1049–1066.
21.
CasanovaJ (2012) The politics of nativism: Islam in Europe, Catholicism in the United States. Philosophy & Social Criticism38(4–5): 485–495.
22.
CremerT (2022) Defenders of the faith? How shifting social cleavages and the rise of identity politics are reshaping right-wing populists’ attitudes towards religion in the west. Religion, State and Society50(5): 532–552.
23.
CremerT (2023a) A religious vaccination? How Christian communities react to right-wing populism in Germany, France and the US. Government and Opposition58(1): 162–182.
24.
CremerT (2023b) The rise of the post-religious right: Christianism and secularism in the French rassemblement national. Party Politics29(1)40–50.
25.
CremerT (2023c) The Godless Crusade. Cambridge; New York; Melbourne, VIC, Australia; New Delhi, India; Singapore: Cambridge University Press.
26.
De JongRVan der KolkHVoermanG (2011) Verkiezingen op de kaart 1848–2010. Tweede Kamerverkiezingen vanuit geografisch perspectief. Utrecht: Uitgeverij Matrijs.
27.
De KosterWAchterbergPVan der WaalJ, et al. (2014) Progressiveness and the new right: The electoral relevance of culturally progressive values in the Netherlands. West European Politics37(3): 584–604.
28.
De LangeSLArtD (2011) Fortuyn versus wilders: an agency-based approach to radical right party building. West European Politics34(6): 1229–1249.
29.
ElcottDMAndersonCCCremerT, et al. (2021) Faith, Nationalism, and the Future of Liberal Democracy, 1st edn. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
FeketeL (2016) Hungary: Power, punishment and the ‘Christian-national idea’. Race & Class57(4): 39–53.
32.
Fernández-ReinoMStasioVDVeitS (2023) Discrimination unveiled: A field experiment on the barriers faced by Muslim women in Germany, the Netherlands, and Spain. European Sociological Review39(3): 479–497.
33.
FonerNAlbaR (2008) Immigrant religion in the U.S. and Western Europe: Bridge or barrier to inclusion?The International Migration Review42(2): 360–392.
34.
FroeseP (2001) Hungary for religion: A supply-side interpretation of the Hungarian religious revival. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion40(2): 251–268.
35.
FroioC (2018) Race, religion, or culture? Framing Islam between racism and neo-racism in the online network of the French far right. Perspectives on Politics16(3): 696–709.
HeinJNiaziT (2016) The primordial refugees: Religious traditions, global forced migration, and state–society relations. International Sociology31(6): 726–741.
38.
HelblingMTraunmüllerR (2020) What is Islamophobia? Disentangling citizens’ feelings toward ethnicity, religion and religiosity using a survey experiment. British Journal of Political Science50: 811–828.
39.
ImmerzeelTJaspersELubbersM (2013) Religion as catalyst or restraint of radical right voting?West European Politics36(5): 946–968.
40.
InglehartR (2021) Religion’s Sudden Decline: What’s Causing it, and What Comes Next?New York: Oxford University Press.
41.
JansenGde GraafNDNeedA (2012) Explaining the breakdown of the religion–vote relationship in the Netherlands, 1971–2006. West European Politics35(4): 756–783.
42.
JoppkeC (2018) Culturalizing religion in Western Europe: Patterns and puzzles. Social Compass65(2): 234–246.
43.
KondorK (2022) A commentary on the so-called defense of Christian Europe: The Fidesz party’s response to the migration crisis in Hungary. Hungarian Studies Review49(1): 93–105.
44.
KulskaJ (2023) The sacralization of politics? A case study of Hungary and Poland. Religions14(4): 525.
45.
KuruA (2007) Passive and assertive secularism: Historical conditions, ideological struggles, and state policies toward religion. World Politics59(4): 568–594.
46.
LadiniRBiolcatiFMolteniF, et al. (2021) The multifaceted relationship between individual religiosity and attitudes toward immigration in contemporary Italy. International Journal of Sociology51: 390–411.
47.
LambR (2011) When human rights have gone too far: Religious tradition and equality in lautsi v. Italy note. North Carolina Journal of International Law and Commercial Regulation36(3): 751–772.
48.
LindersNDudinkSSpieringsN (2023) Masculinity and sexuality in populist radical right leadership. Politics & Gender19(3): 653–674.
49.
LubbersMCoendersMScheepersP (2006) Objections to asylum seeker centres: Individual and contextual determinants of resistance to small and large centres in the Netherlands. European Sociological Review22(3): 243–257.
50.
MarcinkiewiczKDassonnevilleR (2022) Do religious voters support populist radical right parties? Opposite effects in Western and East-Central Europe. Party Politics28: 444–456.
51.
MarcinkiewiczKDassonnevilleR (2023) Vaccine or catalyst? Christian religion and populism in Europe: A rejoinder to Inglehart’s ‘religion’s sudden decline’. Electoral Studies82: 102593.
52.
MarzoukiNMcDonnellDRoyO (2016) Saving the People: How Populists Hijack Religion. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
53.
MetzROrossO (2020) Strong personalities’ impact on Hungarian party politics: Viktor Orbán and Gábor Vona. In: GherghinaS (ed.) Party Leaders in Eastern Europe: Personality, Behavior and Consequences (Palgrave Studies in Political Psychology). Cham: Springer, pp.145–170.
54.
MinkenbergM (2018) Religion and the radical right. In: RydgrenJ (ed.) The Oxford Handbook of the Radical Right. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.366–393.
55.
MolleA (2019) Religion and right-wing populism in Italy: Using ‘Judeo-Christian roots’ to kill the European Union. Religion, State & Society47(1): 151–168.
56.
MondonAWinterA (2017) Articulations of Islamophobia: From the extreme to the mainstream?Ethnic and Racial Studies40(13): 2151–2179.
57.
MontgomeryKAWinterR (2015) Explaining the religion gap in support for radical right parties in Europe. Politics and Religion8(2): 379–403.
58.
MuddeC (2007) Populist Radical Right Parties in Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
59.
MuddeC (2019) The Far Right Today. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
60.
MuddeCKaltwasserCR (2018) Studying populism in comparative perspective: Reflections on the contemporary and future research agenda. Comparative Political Studies51(13): 1667–1693.
61.
NorrisPInglehartR (2004) Sacred and Secular: Religion and Politics Worldwide. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
62.
NorrisPInglehartR (2019) Cultural Backlash: Trump, Brexit, and Authoritarian Populism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
63.
NortonA (2013) On the Muslim Question. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
64.
OzzanoL (2019) Religion, cleavages, and right-wing populist parties: The Italian case. The Review of Faith & International Affairs17(1): 65–77.
65.
OzzanoL (2020) The Masks of the Political God. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
66.
PassarelliGTuortoD (2018) The five star movement: Purely a matter of protest? The rise of a new party between political discontent and reasoned voting. Party Politics24(2): 129–140.
67.
PirroALP (2023) Far right: The significance of an umbrella concept. Nations and Nationalism29(1): 101–112.
ReinhardtSHeftAPavanE (2024) Varieties of antigenderism: The politicization of gender issues across three European populist radical right parties. Information, Communication & Society27: 1273–1294.
70.
RibberinkEAchterbergPHoutmanD (2017) Secular tolerance? Anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion56(2): 259–276.
71.
RooduijnMPirroALPHalikiopoulouD, et al. (2024) The populist: A database of populist, far-left, and far-right parties using Expert-informed Qualitative Comparative Classification (EiQCC). British Journal of Political Science54: 969–978.
72.
RoyO (2020) Is Europe Christian?New York: Oxford University Press.
73.
ScappiniE (2021) Is there really ‘another’ counterexample to the secularization thesis? religious dynamics in italy between 1910 and 2013. Review of Religious Research64(1): 103–126.
74.
SchwörerJ (2018) Right-wing populist parties as defender of Christianity? The case of the Italian Northern League. Zeitschrift Für Religion, Gesellschaft Und Politik2(2): 387–413.
75.
SchwörerJFernández-GarcíaB (2021) Religion on the rise again? A longitudinal analysis of religious dimensions in election manifestos of Western European parties. Party Politics27(6): 1160–1171.
76.
SchwörerJRomero-VidalX (2020) Radical right populism and religion: Mapping parties’ religious communication in Western Europe. Religion, State and Society48(1): 4–21.
77.
SiegersPJedingerA (2021) Religious immunity to populism: Christian religiosity and public support for the alternative for Germany. German Politics30(2): 149–169.
78.
StockemerDNiemannAUngerDSpeyerJ (2020) The “Refugee Crisis,” immigration attitudes, and euroscepticism. International Migration Review54(3):883–912.
79.
StroopeSFroesePRackinHM, et al. (2021) Unchurched Christian nationalism and the 2016 U.S. presidential election. Sociological Forum36(2): 405–425.
80.
ThorleifssonC (2017) Disposable strangers: Far-right securitisation of forced migration in Hungary. Social Anthropology25(3): 318–334.
Van der MeerTLubbeRVan ElsasE, et al. (2012) Bounded volatility in the Dutch electoral battlefield: A panel study on the structure of changing vote intentions in the Netherlands during 2006–2010. Acta Politica47(4): 333–355.
83.
Van KesselS (2016) Using faith to exclude: The role of religion in Dutch populism. In: MarzoukiNMcDonnellDRoyO (eds) Saving the People: How Populists Hijack Religion. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.61–77.
84.
VaughanKR (2021a) Anti-immigrant sentiment and opposition to democracy in Europe. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies19: 540–556.
85.
VaughanKR (2021b) Religious moral communities or secular tolerance? Individual-, national-, and regional-level explanations for restrictive refugee policy preferences in Europe. Sociology of Religion82(3): 305–331.
86.
WolkensteinF (2023) Christian Europe Redux. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies61(3): 636–652.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
