A dangerous liaison? Harnessing Weber to illuminate the relationship of democracy and charisma in the Philippines and India

Abstract

Spanish

French

Democratic elections in the Philippines and India in 2019 yielded a paradoxical result: the strengthening of the political hegemony of personalities partial to authoritarian rule. An examination of economic, social, and political conditions prior to the elections shows that the usual paradigms used to explain voters’ choices – class theory, rational choice theory, and patron–client theory – fail to account for the sweeping victories of Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. A more useful framework is that of charismatic authority derived from Max Weber. Employing this paradigm, the article discusses the origins of charismatic authority in the two polities, the differences in charismatic appeal, the social construction of charisma, charisma and the creation of the Other, and the democratic dialectic at the heart of charismatic authoritarianism.

Keywords

Authoritarianism BJP charisma democracy Duterte Modi Weber

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ABS/CBN (2016) Duterte on drug-related deaths: Expect 20,000 to 30,000 more. 28 October. Available at: www.news.abs-cbn.com/news/10/27/16/duterte-on-drug-related-deaths-expect-20000-or-30000-more (accessed 28 October 2018).

ABS/CBN (2019a) Sara Duterte: Honesty should not be an election issue. 3 March. Available at: www.news.abs-cbn.com/news/03/06/19/sara-duterte-honesty-should-not-be-an-election-issue (accessed 29 May 2019).

ABS/CBN (2019b) Duterte approval, trust ratings climb end-2018: Pulse Asia survey. 11 June. Available at: www.news.abs-cbn.com/news/01/11/19/duterte-approval-trust-ratings-climb-end-2018-pulse-asia-survey (accessed 28 June 2019).

Backus

Drifell

(1985) Inflation and regulation. American Economic Review 75: 530–538.

BBC (2016) President Rodrigo Duterte in quotes. 30 September. Available at: www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36251094 (accessed 28 May 2019).

Bello

(2017), Bloody but unbowed, interview with Leila de Lima for Rappler. Reproduced in Focus on the Global South. 8 Sept. Available in: www.focusweb.org/bloody-but-unbowed/ (accessed 27 January 2020).

Bhatt

(2004) Democracy and Hindu nationalism. Democratization 11(4): 133–154.

Bourdieu

(1991) Language and Symbolic Power. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Brown

(2014) The Myth of the Strong Leader. New York: Basic Books.

10.

Clarke

(2017) Competing Fundamentalisms: Violent Extremism in Christianity, Islam, and Hinduism. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press.

11.

Dayal

(2018) Lynchings and other consequences of targeted hate. In: Dayal

Dabiru

Hashimi

(eds) Dismantling India: A Four Year Report. New Delhi: Media House.

12.

de Beauvoir

(1997) Introduction to The Second Sex. In: Nicholson

(ed.) The Second Wave: A Reader in Feminist Theory. New York and London: Routledge.

13.

Dutt

(2019) This is Modi’s India now. The Washington Post, 23 May. Available at: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/05/23/this-is-modis-india-now/?utm_term=.b121b2feedf9 (accessed 3 June 2019).

14.

DZRH (2017) Speech of President Rodrigo Duterte at conference of local government officials [radio broadcast]. 14 March.

15.

Gavilan

(2019) UN rights chief: Deaths in PH anti-drug operations a ‘most serious concern’. Rappler, 24 June. Available at: www.rappler.com/nation/233803-united-nations-human-rights-chief-deaths-police-anti-drug-operations-serious-concern (accessed 27 January 2020).

16.

Godrej

(2018) Shiv Sena attacks BJP again, with RSS stick. Times of India, 2 April. Available at: www.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/shiv-sena-attacks-bjp-again-with-rss-stick/articleshow/63579125.cms (accessed 16 October 2018).

17.

Hindustan Times (2019) Lok Sabha election results 2019: Decoding polls in 10 questions. 24 May. Available at: www.hindustantimes.com/lok-sabha-elections/lok-sabha-election-results-2019-decoding-polls-in-10-questions/story-iUejE4lKqc6yxcV8oY92LJ.html (accessed 3 June 2019).

18.

Human Rights Watch (n.d.) You can die anytime: Death squad killings in Mindanao. Available at: www.hrw.org/report/2009/04/06/you-can-die-any-time/death-squad-killings-mindanao (accessed 13 October 2018).

19.

Human Rights Watch (2019) Philippines: Events of 2018. Available at: www.hrw.org/world-report/2019/country-chapters/philippines (accessed 27 January 2020).

20.

I-Defend (2016) End impunity, stand up for human rights, uphold due process. 12 August.

21.

Iyengar

(2019) India’s economy stumbles badly as Narendra Modi begins his second term. CNN Business, 31 May. Available at: https://edition.cnn.com/2019/05/31/economy/india-gdp-economy-q4/index.html (accessed 3 June 2019).

22.

Jaffrelot

(2017) Gujarat model? The Indian Express, 20 November. Available at: www.indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/gujarat-assembly-elections-2017-bjp-demonetisation-gst-industrialists-businessmen-4945328/ (accessed 25 November 2018).

23.

Jawed

(2018) 2017’s top fake news stories circulated by the Indian Media. The Wire, 3 January. Available at: www.thewire.in/media/2017s-top-fake-news-stories-circulated-by-the-indian-media (accessed 15 August 2018).

24.

Kershaw

(2000) The Nazi Dictatorship: Problems and Perspectives of Interpretation. London: Arnold Press.

25.

Kitschelt

Wilkinson

(eds) (2007) Patrons, Clients, and Policies: Patterns of Democratic Accountability and Political Competition. New York: Cambridge University Press.

26.

Lande

(1965) Leaders, Factions, and Parties: The Structure of Philippine Politics. South East Asia Monograph Series. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

27.

Lepsius

(2017) Max Weber and Institutional Theory. New York: Springer.

28.

Lipset

(1981) Political Man. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

29.

Lipset

Rokkan

(eds) (1967) Party Systems and Voter Alignments. Toronto: The Free Press.

30.

Martinez

(2019) Misogyny, neoliberalism, and despotism. Focus Policy Review (Critical Junction: Derailing or Accelerating the Dictatorship Express) 7(1): 60–68.

31.

Mehta

(2019) Staggering dominance: The only authentic analysis of this election is two words–Narendra Modi. The Indian Express, 24 May. Available at: www.indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/narendra-modi-lok-sabha-elections-2019-results-bjp-congress-rahul-gandhi-5745371/ (accessed 2 June 2019).

32.

Mishra

(2017) Age of Anger. London: Penguin Books.

33.

Mishra

(2019) How Narendra Modi seduced India with envy and hate. New York Times, 23 May. Available at: www.nytimes.com/2019/05/23/opinion/modi-india-election.html (accessed 3 June 2019).

34.

Mukta

(2000) The public face of Hindu nationalism. Ethnic and Racial Studies 23(3): 442–466.

35.

New Indian Express (2017) Bahujan politics may haunt BJP in West Bengal. 9 December. Available at: www.newindianexpress.com/thesundaystandard/2017/dec/09/bahujan-politics-may-haunt-bjp-in-west-bengal-1723092.html (accessed 11 February 2019).

36.

Orwell

(1941) The Lion and the Unicorn: Socialism and the English Genius. The Orwell Foundation. Available at: www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/the-lion-and-the-unicorn-socialism-and-the-english-genius/ (accessed 27 January 2020).

37.

Purugganan

(2019) The price of taming inflation. Focus Policy Review (Critical Junction: Derailing or Accelerating the Dictatorship Express) 7(1): 20–21.

38.

Ravi

(2018) Debt isn’t killing India’s farmers. Bloomberg, 24 December. Available at: www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-12-24/india-s-farmers-aren-t-committing-suicide-because-of-high-debts (accessed 3 June 2019).

39.

Rogoff

(1990) Equilibrium political budget cycles. American Economic Review 80: 21–36.

40.

Rogoff

Sibert

(1988) Elections and macroeconomic policy cycles. Review of Economic Studies 55: 1–16.

41.

Roy

(2019) India: Intimations of an ending. The Nation, 22 November. Available at: www.thenation.com/article/archive/arundhati-roy-assam-modi/ (accessed 27 January 2020).

42.

Roy

Singh

(2017) Modi’s Dalits or Dalits’ Modi: How BJP beat the maze of caste politics in Uttar Pradesh. Firstpost, 23 March. Available at: www.firstpost.com/politics/modis-dalits-or-dalits-modi-how-bjp-beat-the-maze-of-caste-politics-in-uttar-pradesh-3347354.html (accessed 9 January 2020).

43.

Sadanandan

(2012) Patronage and decentralization: The politics of poverty in India. Comparative Politics 44(2): 211–228.

44.

Satchidanandan

(2018) The idea of India: The case for pluraiity. In: Dayal

Dabiru

Hashmi

(eds) Dismantling India: A Four Year Report. New Delhi: Media House.

45.

Singal

(2018). How demonetization impacted the Indian economy. LiveMint, 30 August. Available at: www.livemint.com/ (accessed 13 May 2019).

46.

Suarez

(2017) Criminality top concern of middle, upper classes – Survey. Rappler, 7 April. Available at: www.rappler.com/nation/166558-pulse-asia-march-2017-survey-national-concerns (accessed 15 April 2020).

47.

Swamy

(2018) Hindu nationalism in India a century in the making. East Asia Forum, 18 May. Available at: www.eastasiaforum.org/2018/05/15/hindu-nationalism-in-india-a-century-in-the-making/ (accessed 23 February 2019).

48.

Teehankee

(2012) Clientelism and party politics in the Philippines. In: Tomsa

Ufer

(eds) Clientelism and Electoral Competition in Indonesia, Thailand, and the Philippines. Abingdon: Routledge.

49.

Teodoro

(2019) Information disorder. Available at: www.luisteodoro.com/information-disorder/?fbclid=IwAR0UHljNNnfNrHYqGoEVqfLKqMXXb9HTH53Q_-YLg4Xv69MXXVz_nnXYmqQ (accessed 19 May 2019).

50.

Venkataramakrishnan

(2019) The election fix: What did we get wrong (and right) about the 2019 Lok Sabha polls? Scroll.in, 3 June. Available at: www.scroll.in/article/924765/the-election-fix-what-did-we-get-wrong-and-right-about-the-2019-lok-sabha-polls (accessed 26 May 2019).

51.

Villanueva

(2016) Duterte likens addicts to zombies. Philippine Star, 24 August. Available at: www.philstar.com/opinion/2016/08/24/1616655/duterte-likens-drug-addicts-zombies (accessed 14 November 2018).

52.

Walker

(2009) Neoliberalism on the ground in rural India: Predatory growth, agrarian crisis, internal colonization, and the intensification of class struggle. Journal of Peasant Studies 35(4): 557–620.

53.

Weber

(1958) From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, ed. Gerth

Mills

. New York: Oxford University Press.

54.

Yadav

(2017) What is to be done? In: A New India: A Symposium on the Current Political Dominance of the BJP, New Delhi, November 2017. Available at: www.india-seminar.com/2017/699/699_yogendra_yadav.htm (accessed 6 August 2018).