The article compares a study of Zimbabwean land reform with several others of the same individualised holdings type in Africa and elsewhere. It makes the point that land reform programmes should be analysed with regard both to gender and class relations among the peasantry. After discussing the historical background to Zimbabwean resettlement policies, the case study takes up topics such as the provision of services, community formation, class divisions, changes in family structure and division of labour and the impact of state officials. The Zimbabwean reform appears to have had more positive effects on women than have most of the others examined. This may be due to the recent prosperity of the Resettlement Areas studied, to the (mixed) impact of a nuclear family model, and to the influence of state officials in curbing male behaviour. However, as in other cases, since women are not granted land rights, they remain dependants of men.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABBOTT, S.1976. `Full-Time Farmers and Weekend Wives: An Analysis of Altering Conjugal Roles'.Journal of Marriage and Family39: 165-174.
2.
AFSHAR, H. ed. 1987. `Introduction', in Women, State and Ideology: Studies from Africa and Asia.London: Macmillan.
3.
ALLAGHI, H. 1984. `Rural Women in a Resettlement Project: The Case of the Libyan Arab Jamhiriya', in ILO, Rural Development and Women in Africa.Geneva: ILO.
4.
ARRIGHI, G. 1973a. `Labor Supplies in Historical Perspective', in Arrighi, G. and Saul, J., Essays on the Political Economy of Africa.New York: Monthly Review Press.
5.
ARRIGHI, G. 1973b. `The Political Economy of Rhodesia', in Arrighi, G. and Saul, J., Essays on the Political Economy of Africa.New York: Monthly Review Press.
6.
BATEZAT, E.et al. 1988. `Women and Independence: The Heritage and the Struggle', in Stoneman, C. (ed.), Zimbabwe's Prospects.London: Macmillan.
7.
BELL, C. and NEWBY, H. 1976. `Husbands and Wives: Dynamics of the Deferential Dialectic', in Barker, D. and Allen, S. (eds.), Dependence and Exploitation in Work and Marriage.London: Longman.
8.
BERNSTEIN, H. and CAMPBELL, B. eds. 1985. `Introduction', in Contradictions of Accumulation in Africa.London: Sage.
9.
BLOOD, R. and WOLFE, D. 1960. Husbands and Wives.New York: Free Press.
10.
BOURDILLON, M. 1982. The Shona Peoples.Gweru: Mambo.
11.
BRANNEN, J. and WILSON, G. eds. 1987. Give and Take in Families.London: Allen and Unwin.
12.
BRYCESON, D.1980. `The Proletarianization of Women in Tanzania'.Review of African Political Economy17: 4-27.
13.
BUSH, R. and CLIFFE, L.1984. `Land Reforms or Transformation in Zimbabwe?'.Review of African Political Economy29: 77-94.
14.
BUSH, R. , CLIFFE, L. and JANSEN, V. 1986. `The Crisis in the Reproduction of Labour in Southern Africa', in Lawrence, P. (ed.), World Recession and the Food Crisis in Africa.London: J. Currey.
15.
CALLEAR, D. 1982. Small Farmer Maize Production in Wedza Communal Area, Zimbabwe. Unpublished manuscript: UNESCO.
16.
CHAMBERS, R. 1969. Settlement Schemes in Tropical Africa.London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
17.
CHEATER, A.1981. `Women and their Participation in Commercial Agricultural Production'.Development and Change (July).
18.
CHEATER, A. 1984. Idioms of Accumulation.Gweru: Mambo.
19.
CHIGWEDERE, A. 1982. Lobola.Harare: Books for Africa.
20.
CLARKE, D. 1977. Agricultural and Plantation Workers in Rhodesia.Gweru: Mambo.
21.
COLSON, E. 1960. The Social Organisation of the Gwembe Tonga, Vol. 1: The Human Consequences of Resettlement.Lusaka: University of Zambia Press.
22.
CONTI, A.1979. `Capitalist Organisation of Production through Non-Capitalist Relations: Women's Role in a Pilot Resettlement in Upper Volta'.Review of African Political Economy15-16: 75-92.
23.
COX, T.M. 1986. Peasants, Class and Capitalism.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
24.
DAVISON, J. ed. 1988. Women and Land: the African Experience.Boulder, Colorado: Westview.
25.
DEERE, C.D. 1986. `Rural Women and Agrarian Reform in Peru, Chile and Cuba', in Nash, J. and Safa, H. (eds.), Women and Change in Latin America.New York: Bergin and Garvey.
26.
DEERE, C.D.et al. 1982. `Class and Historical Analysis for the Study of Women and Economic Change', in Anker, R.et al. (eds.), Women's Roles and Population Trends in the Third World.London: Croom Helm/International Labour Office.
27.
DE SILVA, D. 1982. `Women and Social Adaptation in a Pioneer Mahaweli Settlement', in Wimalaharma, K. (ed.), Land Settlement Experiences in Sri Lanka.Colombo: Ministry of Lands.
28.
DWYER, D. and BRUCE, J. eds. 1988. A Home Divided.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
29.
FAPOHUNDA, E.1987. `The Nuclear Household Model in Nigeria: Public and Private Sector Policy'.Development and Change18 (2): 281-294.
30.
FOLBRE, N. 1983. `Zimbabwe and the Lineage of Patriarchal Capitalism'. Unpublished manuscript: Amhurst, Mass.
31.
GEZA, S.1986. `The Role of Resettlement in Social Development in Zimbabwe'.Journal of Social Development in Africa1 (1): 35-42.
32.
GIBBON, P. and NEOCOSMOS, M. 1985. `Some Problems in the Political Economy of African Socialism', in Bernstein, H. and Campbell, B. (eds.), Contradictions of Accumulation in Africa.London: Sage.
33.
GOLDIN, B. and GELFAND, M. 1975. African Law and Custom in Rhodesia.Cape Town: Juta.
34.
Government of Zimbabwe. 1981. Growth with Equity.Salisbury: Government Printers.
35.
Government of Zimbabwe, Central Statistical Office (CSO) . 1984. Report on Demographic Socio-Economic Survey. Communal Lands of Manicaland Province: 1983/84.Harare: CSO.
36.
Government of Zimbabwe, Central Statistical Office (CSO) . 1985. Main Demographic Features of the Population of Zimbabwe: A Report Based on a Ten Per Cent Sample.Harare: Government Printers.
37.
Government of Zimbabwe, Ministry of Finance. 1985. Transitional National Development Plan.Harare: Government Printers.
38.
GUYER, J.1981. `Household and Community in African Studies'.African Studies Review24 (213): 87-137.
39.
GUYER, J. 1986. `Intra-Household Processes and Farming Systems Research', in Moock, J. (ed.), Understanding Africa's Rural Households and Farming Systems.Boulder, Col.: Westview Press.
40.
GUYER, J. and PETERS, P.1987. `Introduction to Conceptualising the Household: Issues of Theory and Policy in Africa'.Development and Change18 (2): 197-214.
41.
HANGER, J. and MORIS, J. 1973. Mwea: An Irrigated Rice Settlement in Kenya.Munich: Weltforum.
42.
HANLON, J. 1986. `Producer Cooperative and the Government of Zimbabwe'. Unpublished manuscript: London.
43.
HARRIS, O. 1981. `Households as Natural Units', in Young, K.et al. (eds.), Of Marriage and the Market.London: Conference of Socialist Economist Books.
44.
HARRIS, O. and WEINER, D. 1986. `Wage Labor, Environment and Peasant Agriculture in the Labor Reserves of Zimbabwe'. Unpublished manuscript; Worcester, Mass.
45.
HOLLEMAN, J.F. 1952. Shona Customary Law.Cape Town: Oxford University Press.
46.
JACOBS, S. 1989. `Zimbabwe: State, Class and Gendered Models of Land Resettlement', in Parpart, J. and Staudt, K. (eds.), Women and the State in Africa.Boulder, Colorado: L. Rienner.
47.
JACOBS, S. and HOWARD, T. 1987. `Women in Zimbabwe: Stated Policy and State Action', in Afshar, H. (ed.), Women, State and Ideology: Studies from Africa and Asia.London: Macmillan.
48.
JAYAWARDENA, K. 1986. Feminism and Nationalism in the Third World.London: Zed Books.
49.
KAHN, J. and LLOBERA, J. eds. 1981. The Anthropology of Pre-Capitalist Societies.London: Macmillan.
50.
KAZEMBE, J. 1986. `The Woman Question', in Mandaza, I. (ed.), Zimbabwe: The Political Economy of Transition.Dakar: Codeseria.
51.
KINSEY, B.1982. `Forever Gained: Resettlement and Land Policy in the Context of National Development in Zimbabwe'. Africa52(3).
52.
KOSSOUDJI, S. and MUELLER, E.1983. `The Economic and Demographic Status of Female-Headed Households in Rural Botswana'.Economic Development and Cultural Change31 (4): 831-859.
53.
LEE, G. and PETERSEN, G.1983. `Conjugal Power and Spousal Resources in Patriarchal Cultures'.Journal of Comparative Family StudiesXIV (1): 23-35.
54.
LEON DE LEAL, M. and DEERE, C.D.1981. `Peasant Production, Proletarianization and the Sexual Division of Labor in the Andes'.Signs7 (2): 338-360.
55.
LEYS, R. 1984. `Drought and Drought Relief in Southern Zimbabwe', in Lawrence, P. (ed.), World Recession and the Food Crisis in Africa.London: J. Currey.
56.
LUND, R. 1978. Properity to Mahaweli: A Survey on Women's Working and Living Conditions in a Settlement Area.Colombo: People's Bank Research Division.
57.
MABAREKE, M.1986. `Violence against Wives: A Crime Sui Generis'.Zimbabwe Law Review4: 88-111.
58.
MAKAMURE, N.1984. `The Women's Movement in Zimbabwe'.Journal of African Marxists6 (October).
59.
MAY, J. 1983. Zimbabwean Women in Customary and Colonial Law.Gweru: Mambo.
60.
McCALL, M. 1987. `Carrying Heavier Burdens but Carrying Less Weight: Some Implications of Villagisation for Women in Tanzania', in Mommsen, J. and Townsend, J. (eds.), The Geography of Gender in the Third World.London: Hutchinson.
61.
MOLYNEUX, M.1985. `Family Reform in Socialist States: The Hidden Agenda'.Feminist Review21 (Winter).
62.
MOOCK, J. ed. 1986. Understanding Africa's Rural Households and Farming Systems.Boulder, Colorado: Westview.
63.
MOYO, S. 1986. `The Land Question', in Mandaza, I. (ed.), Zimbabwe: The Political Economy of Transition.Dakar: Codeseria.
64.
MPOFU, J. 1983. `Some Observable Sources of Women's Subordination in Zimbabwe'.Harare: Centre for Applied Social Studies, University of Zimbabwe.
65.
MUBI, M.et al. /AGRITEX. 1983. `Women in Agricultural Projects in Zimbabwe'. Unpublished manuscript: Harare.
66.
MUCHENA, O. /Ministry of Community Development and Women's Affairs, Government of Zimbabwe. 1982. `Report on the Situation of Women in Zimbabwe'. Unpublished manuscript: Harare.
67.
MURRAY, C. 1981. Families Divided: The Impact of Migrant Labour in Lesotho.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
68.
NASH, J. and SAFA, H. eds. 1984. Women and Change in Latin America.New York: Bergin and Garvey.
69.
PAHL, J.1980. `Patterns of Money Management within Marriage'.Journal of Social Policy9(3): 313-335.
70.
PALMER, I. 1985. Women's Roles and Gender Differences in Development: the Nemow Case.West Hartford: Kumarian Printers.
71.
PALMER, R.H. 1977. Land and Racial Domination in Rhodesia.London: Heinemann.
72.
PANKHURST, D. 1986. `Wives and Husbands: Rules and Practice'. Unpublished manuscript: Leeds.
73.
PANKHURST, D. 1986. `Women's Control over Resources: Implications for Development in Zimbabwe's Communal Lands'. Unpublished manuscript: Liverpool.
74.
PANKHURST, D. and JACOBS, S. 1988. `Land Tenure, Gender Relations and Agricultural Production: The Case of Zimbabwe's Peasantry', in Davison, J. (ed.), Women and Land: the African Experience.Boulder, Colorado: Westview.
75.
PARKIN, D. and NYAMWARA, D. 1987. `Transformations of African Marriage', in Parkin, D. and Nyamwara, D. (eds.), Transformations of African Marriage.Manchester: Manchester University Press.
76.
PARPART, J. and STAUDT, K. eds. 1989. Women and the State in Africa.Boulder, Colorado: L. Rienner.
77.
PASSMORE, G. 1972. The National Policy of Community Development in Rhodesia.Salisbury: University of Rhodesia Press.
78.
PETERS, P. 1986. `Household Management in Botswana: Cattle, Crops and Wage Labor', in Moock, J. (ed.), Understanding Africa's Rural Households and Farming Systems.Boulder, Colorado: Westview.
79.
PHIMISTER, I. 1988. `The Combined and Contradictory Inheritance of the Struggle against Colonialism', in Stoneman, C.(ed.), Zimbabwe's Prospects.London: Macmillan.
80.
RANGER, T.O. 1985. Peasant Consciousness and Guerilla War in Zimbabwe.London: J. Currey.
81.
RANGER, T.O. 1987. `Thirty-Third Review of the Zimbabwean Press'. Unpublished manuscript: Charlbury, Oxford.
82.
REDCLIFT, N. and MIGNIONE, E. eds. 1985. Beyond Employment: Households, Gender and Subsistence.Oxford: Blackwell.
83.
ROBERTSON, C. and BERGER, I. 1986. `Introduction', in Robertson, C. and Berger, I. (eds.), Women and Class in Africa.New York: Africana/Holmes and Meier.
84.
RODMAN, H.1972. `Marital Power and the Theory of Resources in a Cultural Context'.Journal of Comparative Family Studies3: 50-69.
85.
ROLDAN, H. 1988. `Renegotiating the Martial Contract: Intrahousehold Patterns of Money Allocation among Domestic Outworkers in Mexico City', in Dwyer, D. and Bruce, J. (eds.), A Home Divided.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
86.
SAFILIOS-ROTHSCHILD, C.1970. `The Study of Family Power Structure: A Review 1960-69'.Journal of Marriage and the Family31 (2).
87.
SAFILIOS-ROTHSCHILD, C. 1988. `The Impact of Agrarian Reform on Men's and Women's Incomes in Rural Honduras', in Dwyer, D. and Bruce, J. (eds.), A Home Divided.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
88.
SEIDMAN, G.1984. `Women in Zimbabwe: Post-Independence Struggles'.Feminist Studies10 (3): 419-440.
89.
SNYDER, F. 1982. `Colonialism and Legal Form', in Sumner, C. (ed.), Crime, Justice and Underdevelopment.London: Heinemann.
90.
STONEMAN, C. 1981. Zimbabwe's Inheritance.London: Macmillan.
91.
STONEMAN, C. ed. 1988. Zimbabwe's Prospects.London: Macmillan.
92.
STONEMAN, C.1991. `A Rough Ride on the Road to Market'.The Guardian. London, 25April.
93.
STONEMAN, C. and CLIFFE, L. 1989. Zimbabwe: Politics, Economics, Society.London: Pinter Press.
94.
TADESSE, Z. 1982. `The Impact of Land Reform on Women: The Case of Ethiopia', in Beneria, L. (ed.), Women and Development.New York: Praeger.
95.
VAN ONSELEN, C. 1980. Chibaro.London: Pluto.
96.
WEINER, D. 1988. `Land and Agricultural Development', Stoneman, C. (ed.), Zimbabwe's Prospects.London: Macmillan.
97.
WEINRICH, A.K.H. 1975. African Farmers in Rhodesia.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
98.
WEINRICH, A.K.H.1977. `Strategic Resettlement in Rhodesia'.Journal of Southern African Studies3 (2): 207-229.
99.
WEINRICH, A.K.H. 1979. Women and Racial Discrimination in Rhodesia.Paris: UNESCO.
100.
WEINRICH, A.K.H. 1982. African Marriage in Zimbabwe.Gweru: Mambo.
101.
Women's Action Group. 1984. `Women of Zimbabwe Speak Out'. Unpublished report of WAG Workshop, May: Harare.
102.
YOUNG, K. 1981. `Modes of Appropriation and the Sexual Division of Labour: A Case Study from Oaxaca', in Kahn, A. and Wolfe, A.M. (eds.), Feminism and Materialism.London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
103.
YUDELMAN, M. 1964. Africans on the Land.Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
104.
Zimbabwe Women's Bureau. 1981. Black Women in Zimbabwe.Harare: Zimbabwe Women's Bureau.
