The general tendency for post-Communist states has been to adopt strong or `thick' constitutions. This article explains the kind of constitutionalization which will achieve strong constitutional protection. The Russian Federation has chosen to adopt a strong presidential regime together with a potentially `thick' constitution which gives far-reaching human rights protection and constitutionalization possibilities. The result is a rather thin constitution, but which at present seems to conform to the political culture of the Russian state.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Afanas'ev, M. N. (1997) Klientelism i rossiiskaya gosudarstvennost. Moscow: Tsentr konstitutsionnych issledovanii Moskovskoga Obshchestvennoga Fonda .
2.
Baglai, M. B. (2000) Konstitutsionnoye Pravo Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Norma .
3.
Bell, John (1992) French Constitutional Law. Oxford: Clarendon Press .
4.
Blankenagel, Alexander (1999) `Das russische Verfassungsgericht und der russische Konstitutionalismus: Can the Russian Constitutional Court Build the “Russia” in the Open Sea?', in Joachim Jens Hesse (ed.) Verfassungsrecht und Verfassungspolitik in Umbruchsituationen, pp. 255-263. Baden-Baden: Nomos .
5.
Bogdanor, Vernon, ed. (1988) `Introduction', in Constitutions in Democratic Politics. Aldershot: Gower .
6.
Campbell, Tom (2001) `Incorporation Through Interpretation', in Tom Campbell, K. D. Ewing and Adam Tomkins (eds) Sceptical Essays on Human Rights, pp. 79-102. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
7.
Chernichenko, S. V. (1997) `Mezhdunarodnye dogovory i praktika konstitutsionnoga suda rossiiskoi federatsii' , Vestnik Konstitutsionnoga Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii No. 2: 71-72 .
Dunlop, John B. (2000) `Sifting through the Rubble of Yelstins Years' , Problems of Post-Communism47(1): 3-13 .
10.
Ebzeev, B. S. (1997a) `Tolkovanie Konstitutsia i inych zakonov Rossiiskoi Federatsii Konstitutsionnym Sudum', in Teoria Gosudarstvo i Pravo, pp. 451-459. Moscow: Yurist .
11.
Ebzeev, B. S. (1997b) `Rossiiskii federalizm i yedinstvo konstutitsinnogo proststranstva' in Konstitutsionnyi sud Rossiiskoi Federatsii Postonovleniya i opredeleniniya 1992-1996, pp. 506-523. Moscow: Novyi Iurist .
12.
Epstein, Lee, Knight, Jack and Shevtsova, Olga (2001) `The Role of Constitutional Courts in the Establishment and Maintenance of Democratic Systems of Government' , Law and Society Review35(1): 117-162 .
13.
Favoreu, Louis (1990) Le Droit constitutionel, droit de la constitution et constitution du droit' , Revue française de droit constitutionel1: 71-89 .
14.
Fogelklou Anders (1997) `From Party State to Rechtsstaat: The Russian Constitutional Court and the Chechnya Case', in Festskrift Till Stig Strömholm, pp. 223-238. Uppsala: Justus Förlag .
15.
Fogelklou, Anders (1999) `Konstitutionalisering', in N. Berggren, N. Karlsson and N. Nergelius (eds) Makt utan motvikt, pp. 79-108. Stockholm: City University Press .
16.
Fogelklou, Anders (2000a) `Constitutional Order in Russia: A New Territory for Constitutionalism?' , Review of Central and East European Law26(3): 321-357 .
17.
Fogelklou, Anders (2000b) `Russian Constitutionalism? Constitutional Legality in the Russian Federation', Working Papers 57, Department of East European Studies, Uppsala University .
18.
Gadzhiev, Gadis (2001) `Power Imbalance and Institutional Interest in Russian Constitutional Engineering', in Jan Zielonka (ed.) Democratic Consolidation in Eastern Europe Vol. 1: Institutional Engineering, pp. 269-292. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
19.
Huskey, Eugene (1999) Presidential Power in Russia. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe .
20.
Kudryavtsev, Yu. V., ed. (1996) Kommentarij k Konstitutsii Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Fond pravovaya kultura .
21.
Lane, Jan-Erik and Ersson, Svante (2000) The New Institutional Politics: Performance and Outcomes. London and New York: Routledge .
22.
Lazarev, V. V., ed. (2001) Hauchno-prakticheskii kommentarii k Konstitutsii Rossiiskoi Federatsii, 2nd edn. Moscow: Spark .
23.
Linz, Juan J. and Valenzuela, Arturo, eds (1994) The Failure of Presidential Democracy. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press .
24.
Livshits, P. Z. (1997) `Sudebnya praktika kan istochnik prava' , Zhurnal rossiiskogo pravo No. 6: 49-56 .
25.
Luchin, V. O. (2000) `Konstitutsionnye delikty' , Gosudarstvo i Pravo No 1: 12-19 .
26.
Ludwikowski, Rett R. (1996) Constitution-Making in the Region of Former Soviet Dominance. Durham, NC: Duke University Press .
27.
Luryi, Yuri (1999) `The Appointment of a Prime Minister in Russia: The President, the Duma, the Constitutional Court' , Review of Central and East European Law25(4): 585-610 .
28.
MacCormick, D. Neil and Summers, Robert S., eds (1991) Interpreting Statutes: A Comparative Study. Aldershot: Dartmouth .
29.
MacCormick, Neil and Summers, Robert S., eds (1997) Interpreting Precedents: A Comparative Study. Dartmouth: Aldershot .
30.
Nelken, David and Feest, Johannes, eds (2001) Adapting Legal Cultures. Oxford and Portland, OR: Hart .
31.
Nichols, Thomas M. (1999) The Russian Presidency Society and Politics in the Second Russian Republic. Basingstoke: Macmillan .
Okunkov, L. A. (1996a) Prezident Rossiiskoj Federatsii: Konstitutsia i politicheskaia praktika. Moscow: Izd-kajia gruppa INFRA M-NORMA .
34.
Okunkov, L. A. (1996b) `The Stages of Constitutional Reform', in Jeffrey W. Hahn (ed.) Democratization in Russia: The Development of Legislative Institutions, pp. 265-270. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe .
35.
Pavlovsky, Gleb (2002) interview in Expert No. 43: 72-76 .
36.
Peczenik, Alexander (2000) `Why Constitution? What Constitution? Constraints on Majority Rule', in Niclas Berggren, Nils Karlson and Joakim Nergelius (eds) Why Constitutions Matter, pp. 17-60. Stockholm: City University Press .
37.
Preuss, Ulrich (1999) `Verfassungsrechtliche Steuering der politischen Elite', in Joachim Jens Hesse (ed.) Verfassungsrecht und Verfassungspolitik in Umbruchsituationen, pp. 283-294. Baden-Baden: Nomos .
38.
Sadurski, Wojciech (2001) `Conclusion on the Relevance of Institutions and the Centrality of Constitutions in Post-Communist Transitions', in Jan Zielonka (ed.) Democratic Consolidation in Eastern Europe Vol. 1: Institutional Engineering, pp. 455-474. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
39.
Sajo, Andras (1999) Limiting Government. Budapest: Central European University Press .
40.
Sakwa, Richard (1996) `The Struggle for the Constitution in Russian and the Triumph for Ethical Individualism' , Studies in East European Thought48(2-4): 115-157 .
41.
Schwartz, Herman (2000) The Struggle for Constitutional Justice in Post-Communist Europe. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press .
42.
Sergeyev, Victor M. (1998) The Wild East: Crime and Lawlessness in Post-Communist Russia. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe .
43.
Sharlet, Robert (1996) `Post-Soviet Constitutionalism: Politics and Constitution-Making in Russia and Ukraine', in Michael Kraus and. Ronald D. Liebowitz (eds) Russia and Eastern Europe after Communism: The Search for New Political, Economic, and Security Systems, pp. 15-34. Boulder, CO: Westview Press .
44.
Shevtsova, Lilia (1999) Yeltsin's Russia: Myths and Reality. Washington DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Brookings Institution Press .
45.
Shugart, Matthew Soberg and Carey, John M. (1992) Presidents and Assemblies: Constitutional Design and Electoral Dynamics. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press .
46.
Smith, Gordon B. (1999) `The Disjuncture between Legal Reform and Law Enforcement: The Challenge Facing the Post-Yeltsin Leadership', in Gordon B. Smith (ed.) State-Building in Russia: The Yeltsin Legacy and the Challenge of the Future, pp. 101-122. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe .
47.
Stone Sweet, Alec (2000) Governing with Judges: Constitutional Politics in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
48.
Tumanov, V. A. (1996) `Pyat' let konstitutsionnaya yustitsiya v Rossii: uroki, problemy, perspektivy' , Vestnik Konstitutsionna Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii No. 6: 10-15 .
49.
Umnova, I. A. (1998) Konstitutsionnye osnovy sovremennoga rossiiskoga federalizma. Moscow: Delo .
50.
Vitruk, N. (1999) `Pravovye Positsii Konstitutsionnoga Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii: ponyatie, priroda, yuridicheskaya sila i znachenie', in Konstitutsionnoe Pravosudie v postkommunisticheskikh stranakh, pp. 88-105. Moscow: Tsentr konstitutsionnikh issledovanii Moskovskogo Obshchestvennoga Nauchnoga Fonda .
51.
Weigle, Marcia A. (2000) Russia's Liberal Project: State-Society Relations in the Transition from Communism. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press .
52.
Wroblewski, Jerzy (1992) The Judicial Application of Law. Dordrecht: Kluwer .
53.
Yakovlev, A. (1995) Striving for Law in a Lawless Land: Memoirs of a Russian Reformer. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe .
