It is argued here that a post-Marxist constructionist sociology of consumption is desirable for three reasons. Firstly, the liberal theory of `economy and society' designates consumption as falling on the `society' side, with material processes belonging to `the economy'. Problematic consequences of this separation are illustrated with reference to difficulties in the social scientific measurement of poverty. Secondly, the Marxist subsumption of consumption under production neglects the independent influence of distribution and circulation. Finally, Baudrillard's claim for a pure sphere of consumption driven by symbolic media overlooks the contribution that human work, such as shopping, makes to consumption. It is claimed that what is needed now is a constructionist sociology of consumption, that can show how the possibility to consume is an outcome of the everyday practices of social life. A model of the social construction of consumption is proposed, and it is described with special reference to issues of gender division.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AXINN, J. and STERN, M. 1988. Dependency and Poverty.Lexington: Lexington Books.
2.
BANE, M. 1986. `Household Composition and Poverty', in Danziger, S. and Weinberg, D. (eds.), Fighting Poverty: What Works and What Doesn't.Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
3.
BAR-HAIM, G.1987. `The Meaning of Western Commercial Artifacts for Eastern European Youth'.Journal of Contemporary Ethnography16: 205-226.
4.
BAUDRILLARD, J. 1975. The Mirror of Production.St. Louis: Telos.
5.
BAUDRILLARD, J. 1981. For a Critique of the Political Economy of the Sign.St. Louis: Telos.
6.
BECKER, G. 1981. A Treatise on the Family.Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
7.
BENNHOLDT-THOMSEN, V. 1981. `Subsistence Production and Extended Reproduction', in Young, K., Wolkowitz, C. and McCullagh, R. (eds.), Of Marriage and the Market.London: CSE Books.
8.
BERK, R. 1980. `The New Home Economics', in Berk, S.F. (ed.), Women and Household Labor.Beverly Hills: Sage.
9.
BERK, R. and BERK, S.F. 1983. `Supply-Side Sociology of the Family', in Turner, R. (ed.), Annual Review of Sociology, Vol. 9. Palo Alto: Annual Reviews Inc.
10.
BERK, S.F. 1985. The Gender Factory.New York: Plenum.
11.
BIANCHI, S. and SPAIN, D. 1986. American Women in Transition.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
12.
BIVENS, G. and VOLKER, C.1986. `A Value-Added Approach to Household Production'.Journal of Consumer Research13: 272-279.
13.
BLANK, R. and BLINDER, A. 1986. `Macroeconomics, Income Distribution, and Poverty', in Danziger, S. and Weinberg, D. (eds.), Fighting Poverty: What Works and What Doesn't.Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
14.
BLAU, F. and FERBER, M. 1986. The Economics of Women, Men, and Work.Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
15.
BLUMSTEIN, P. and SCHWARTZ, P. 1983. American Couples.New York: William Morrow.
16.
BRANNEN, J. 1987. `The Resumption of Employment after Childbirth', in Allatt, P., Keil, T., Bryman, A. and Bytheway, B. (eds.), Women and the Life Cycle.New York: St. Martin's Press.
17.
BRANNEN, J. and MOSS, P. 1987. `Dual Earner Households', in Brannen, J. and Wilson, G. (eds.), Give and Take in Families.London: Allen and Unwin.
18.
BRANNEN, J. and WILSON, G. eds. 1987. Give and Take in Families.London: Allen and Unwin.
19.
BURKHAUSER, R. and DUNCAN, G.1989. `Economic Risks of Gender Roles'.Social Science Quarterly70: 3-23.
20.
BURROWS, R. and BUTLER, T.1989. `Review Article: Middle Mass and the Pit: A Critical Review of Peter Saunders's Sociology of Consumption'.Sociological Review37: 338-364.
21.
CAPLOVITZ, D. 1979. Making Ends Meet.Beverly Hills: Sage.
22.
CHARLES, N. and KERR, M. 1987. `Just the Way it is: Gender and Age Differences in Family Food Consumption', in Brannen, J. and Wilson, G. (eds.), Give and Take in Families.London: Allen and Unwin.
23.
CHEAL, D. 1984. `Transactions and Transformational Models', in Denzin, N. (ed.), Studies in Symbolic Interaction, Vol. 5. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
24.
CHEAL, D.1986. `The Social Dimensions of Gift Behaviour'.Journal of Social and Personal Relationships3: 423-439.
25.
CHEAL, D.1987a. “Showing Them You Love Them`: Gift Giving and the Dialectic of Intimacy'.Sociological Review35: 150-169.
26.
CHEAL, D. 1987b. `Intergenerational Transfers and Life Course Management', in Bryman, A., Bytheway, B., Allatt, P. and Keil, T. (eds.), Rethinking the Life Cycle.Basingstoke: Macmillan.
27.
CHEAL, D. 1988. The Gift Economy.London/New York: Routledge.
28.
CHEAL, D. 1989a. `Women Together: Bridal Showers and Gender Membership', in Risman, B. and Schwartz, P. (eds.), Gender in Intimate Relationships.Belmont: Wadsworth.
29.
CHEAL, D. 1989b. `Strategies of Resource Management in Household Economies', in Wilk, R. (ed.), The Household Economy.Boulder: Westview Press.
30.
CLOSE, P. and COLLINS, R. eds. 1985. Family and Economy in Modern Society.Basingstoke: Macmillan.
31.
CREIGHTON, C. 1985. `The Family and Capitalism in Marxist Theory', in Shaw, M. (ed.), Marxist Sociology Revisited.Basingstoke: Macmillan.
32.
DELPHY, C. 1979. `Sharing the Same Table', in Harris, C. (ed.), The Sociology of the Family.Keele: University of Keele Press.
33.
DELPHY, C. 1984. Close to Home.Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press.
34.
DELPHY, C. and LEONARD, D. 1986. `Class Analysis, Gender Analysis and the Family', in Crompton, R. and Mann, M. (eds.), Gender and Stratification.Cambridge: Polity Press.
35.
EDWARDS, M.1981. `Financial Arrangements Within Families'.Social Security Journal: 1-16.
36.
EDWARDS, M.1982. `Financial Arrangements made by Husbands and Wives'.Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology18: 320-338.
37.
EICHLER, M. 1973. `Women as Personal Dependents', in Stephenson, M. (ed.), Women in Canada.Toronto: New Press.
38.
EICHLER, M.1980. “Family Income” -a Critical Look at the Concept'.Status of Women News6: 20-21, 24.
39.
EICHLER, M. 1983. Families in Canada Today.Toronto: Gage.
40.
ENGLAND, P. and FARKAS, G. 1986. Households, Employment, and Gender.New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
41.
ETZIONI, A.1985. `Encapsulated Competition'.Journal of Post Keynesian Economics7: 287-302.
42.
FEATHERSTONE, M.1990. `Perspectives on Consumer Culture'.Sociology24: 5-22.
43.
FINCH, J. and GROVES, D. eds. 1983. A Labour of Love.Boston: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
44.
FLETCHER, C.1976. `The Relevance of Domestic Property to Sociological Understanding'.Sociology10: 451-468.
45.
FOLBRE, N. 1988. `The Black Four of Hearts: Toward a New Paradigm of Household Economics', in Dwyer, D. and Bruce, J. (eds.), A Home Divided.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
46.
FOLBRE, N. and HARTMANN, H. 1988. `The Rhetoric of Self-Interest', in Klamer, A., McCloskey, D. and Solow, R. (eds.), The Consequences of Economic Rhetoric.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
47.
FOX, B. ed. 1980. Hidden in the Household.Toronto: The Women's Press.
48.
GARDINER, J. 1976. `Political Economy of Domestic Labour in Capitalist Society', in Barker, D. and Allen, S. (eds.), Dependence and Exploitation in Work and Marriage.London: Longman.
49.
GERSHUNY, J. 1982. `Household Tasks and the Use of Time', in Wallman, S. (ed.), Living in South London.Aldershot: Gower.
50.
GHORAYSHI, P.1989. `The Indispensable Nature of Wives' Work for the Farm Family Enterprise'.Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology26: 571-595.
51.
GRAHAM, H. 1984. Women, Health and the Family.Brighton: Wheatsheaf.
52.
GRAHAM, H. 1987. `Women's Poverty and Caring', in Glendinning, C. and Millar, J. (eds.), Women and Poverty in Britain.Brighton: Wheatsheaf.
53.
GRAY, A. 1979. `The Working Class Family as an Economic Unit', in Harris, C. (ed.), The Sociology of the Family.Keele: University of Keele Press.
54.
GRØNMO, S. and LAVIK, R. 1988. `Shopping Behaviour and Social Interaction', in Otnes, P. (ed.), The Sociology of Consumption.Oslo: Solum Forlag.
55.
GUNDERSON, M. 1983. Economics of Poverty and Income Distribution.Toronto: Butterworths.
56.
HAMILTON, R. and BARRETT, M. eds. 1986. The Politics of Diversity.Montreal: Book Center Inc.
57.
HARRIS, C. 1983. The Family and Industrial Society.London: Allen and Unwin.
58.
HAVEMAN, R. 1987. Poverty Policy and Poverty Research.Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
59.
HENRY, S. 1978. The Hidden Economy.London: Martin Robertson.
60.
HERTZ, R. 1986. More Equal Than Others.Berkeley: University of California Press.
61.
HIRSCHON, R. 1984. `Introduction: Property, Power and Gender Relations', in Hirschon, R. (ed.), Women and Property - Women as Property.London: Croom Helm.
62.
HOLTON, R. and TURNER, B. 1986. Talcott Parsons on Economy and Society.London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
63.
HOMER, M. , LEONARD, A. and TAYLOR, P. 1985. `The Burden of Dependency', in Johnson, N. (ed.), Marital Violence.London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
64.
KELLY, J.1986. `Commodification of Leisure: Trend or Tract?'Society and Leisure9: 455-475.
65.
KERR, M. and CHARLES, N.1986. `Servers and Providers'.Sociological Review34: 115-157.
66.
KOHL, S. 1976. Working Together.Toronto: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
LAND, H. 1983. `Poverty and Gender', in Brown, M. (ed.), The Structure of Disadvantage.London: Heinemann.
69.
LAND, H. and ROSE, H. 1985. `Compulsory Altruism for Some or an Altruistic Society for All', in Bean, P., Ferris, J. and Whynes, D. (eds.), In Defence of Welfare.London: Tavistock.
70.
LANGLOIS, S.1984. `L'impact du double revenu sur la structure des besoins dans les ménages'.Recherches Sociographiques25: 211-265.
71.
LANGLOIS, S. 1986a. `Les seuils de la pauvreté', in Gauthier, M. (ed.), Les nouveaux visages de la pauvreté.Québec: IQRC.
72.
LANGLOIS, S. 1986b. `Consommation, modes de vie et éclatement de la masse', in Zylberberg, J. (ed.), Masses et postmodernité.Paris: Méridiens Klincksieck.
73.
LANGLOIS, S. 1987. `Les familles à un et à deux revenus', in Carlsen, J. and Lacroix, J.-M. (eds.), Canadian Society and Culture in Times of Economic Depression.Montréal: Association for Canadian Studies.
74.
LE BOURDAIS, C. , HAMEL, P. and BERNARD, P.1987. `Le travail et l'ouvrage'.Sociologie et Sociétés19: 37-55.
75.
LEWIS, J. ed. 1983. Women's Welfare/Women's Rights.London: Croom Helm.
76.
LONG, N. ed. 1984. Family and Work in Rural Societies.London: Tavistock.
77.
LOWE, S. 1988. `New Patterns of Wealth', in Walker, R. and Parker, G. (eds.), Money Matters.London: Sage.
78.
LUXTON, M. 1980. More than a Labour of Love.Toronto: Women's Press.
79.
MACGREGOR, S. 1981. The Politics of Poverty.London: Longman.
80.
MACK, J. and LANSLEY, S. 1985. Poor Britain.London: Allen and Unwin.
81.
MACPHERSON, C.B. 1978. `The Meaning of Property', in Macpherson, C.B. (ed.), Property.Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
82.
MANN, M. 1986. `A Crisis in Stratification Theory? Persons' Households/Families/Lineages, Genders, Classes and Nations', in Crompton, R. and Mann, M. (eds.), Gender and Stratification.Cambridge: Polity Press.
83.
MARX, K. 1970. A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy.New York: International Publishers.
84.
MARX, K. 1977. Capital.New York: Vintage Books.
85.
MAYER, S. and JENCKS, C.1989. `Poverty and the Distribution of Material Hardship'.Journal of Human Resources24: 88-114.
86.
McCRACKEN, G.1986. `Culture and Consumption'.Journal of Consumer Research13: 71-84.
87.
MILLAR, J. and GLENDINNING, C. 1987. `Invisible Women, Invisible Poverty', in Glendinning, C. and Millar, J. (eds.), Women and Poverty in Britain.Brighton: Wheatsheaf.
88.
MOLYNEUX, M.1979. `Beyond the Domestic Labour Debate'.New Left Review116: 3-27.
89.
MOON, M. 1977. The Measurement of Economic Welfare.New York: Academic Press.
90.
MORRIS, L.1989. `Household Strategies: The Individual, the Collectivity and the Labour Market - the Case of Married Couples.Work, Employment and Society3: 447-464.
91.
NATIONAL COUNCIL OF WELFARE 1989. 1989 Poverty Lines.Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services Canada.
92.
OSTER, S. , LAKE, E. and OKSMAN, C. 1978. The Definition and Measurement of Poverty, Vol. 1: A Review.Boulder: Westview Press.
93.
OWEN, S.1987. `Household Production and Economic Efficiency'.Work, Employment and Society1: 157-178.
94.
PAGLIN, M. 1980. Poverty and Transfers In-Kind.Stanford: Hoover Institution Press.
95.
PAHL, J.1980. `Patterns of Money Management Within Marriage'.Journal of Social Policy9: 313-335.
96.
PAHL, J.1983. `The Allocation of Money and the Structuring of Inequality within Marriage'.Sociological Review31: 237-262.
97.
PAHL, J. 1988. `Earning, Sharing, Spending', in Walker, R. and Parker, G. (eds.), Money Matters.London: Sage.
98.
PAHL, R. 1984. Divisions of Labour.Oxford: Blackwell.
99.
PAHL, R. and WALLACE, C. 1985. `Forms of Work and Privatisation on the Isle of Sheppey', in Roberts, B., Finnegan, R. and Gallie, D. (eds.), New Approaches to Economic Life.Manchester: Manchester University Press.
100.
PARSONS, T. and SMELSER, N. 1956. Economy and Society.Glencoe: Free Press.
101.
PIACHAUD, D.1987. `Problems in the Definition and Measurement of Poverty'.Journal of Social Policy16: 147-164.
102.
PORTES, A. , CASTELLS, M. and BENTON, L. 1989. The Informal Economy.Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
103.
PRATT, G.1982. `Class Analysis and Urban Domestic Property'.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research6: 481-501.
104.
PRATT, G.1986. `Against Reductionism: The Relations of Consumption as a Mode of Social Structuration'.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research10: 377-399.
105.
RITZER, G.1989. `The Permanently New Economy'.Work and Occupations16: 243-272.
106.
ROBERTS, B. , FINNEGAN, R. and GALLIE, D. 1985. `Introduction', in Roberts, B., Finnegan, R. and Gallie, D. (eds.), New Approaches to Economic Life.Manchester: Manchester University Press.
107.
ROBERTS, E. 1984. A Woman's Place.Oxford: Blackwell.
108.
RODGERS, H. 1986. Poor Women, Poor Families.Armonk: M.E. Sharpe.
109.
ROSEN, E. 1987. Bitter Choices.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
110.
ROWNTREE, B.S. 1902. Poverty: A Study of Town Life.London: Macmillan.
111.
RUBIN, L. 1976. Worlds of Pain.New York: Basic.
112.
SAUNDERS, P.1978. `Domestic Property and Social Class'.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research2: 233-251.
113.
SAUNDERS, P. 1986. Social Theory and the Urban Question, 2nd edn.New York: Holmes and Meier.
114.
SAUNDERS, P. 1988. `The Sociology of Consumption', in Otnes, P. (ed.), The Sociology of Consumption.Oslo: Solum Forlag.
115.
SECCOMBE, W.1974. `The Housewife and Her Labour under Capitalism'.New Left Review83: 3-24.
116.
SECCOMBE, W. 1980. `Domestic Labour and the Working-Class Household', in Fox, B. (ed.), Hidden in the Household.Toronto: The Women's Press.
117.
SECCOMBE, W. 1986. `Reflections on the Domestic Labour Debate and Prospects for Marxist-Feminist Synthesis', in Hamilton, R. and Barrett, M. (eds.), The Politics of Diversity.Montreal: Book Center Inc.
118.
SEN, A. 1981. Poverty and Famines.Delhi: Oxford University Press.
119.
SEN, A. 1984. Resources, Values and Development.Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
120.
SEN, A. and SENGUPTA, S. 1985. `Malnutrition of Rural Children and the Sex Bias', in Jain, D. and Banerjee, N. (eds.), Tyranny of the Household.New Delhi: Vikas.
121.
SIIM, B. 1988. `Towards a Feminist Rethinking of the Welfare State', in Jones, K. and Jónasdóttir, A. (eds.), The Political Interests of Gender.London: Sage.
122.
SMITH, J. 1988. `Poverty and the Family', in Sandefur, G. and Tienda, M. (eds.), Divided Opportunities.New York: Plenum Press.
123.
STICHTER, S. and PARPART, J. 1988. `Introduction: Towards a Materialist Perspective on African Women', in Stichter, S. and Parpart, J. (eds.), Patriarchy and Class.Boulder: Westview Press.
124.
STINCHCOMBE, A. 1983. Economic Sociology.New York: Academic Press.
125.
SWEDBERG, R.1986. `The Critique of the “Economy and Society” Perspective During the Paradigm Crisis'.Acta Sociologica29: 91-112.
TOWNSEND, P. 1970. `Measures and Explanations of Poverty in High Income and Low Income Countries', in Townsend, P. (ed.), The Concept of Poverty.London: Heinemann.
128.
TOWNSEND, P. 1979. Poverty in the United Kingdom.Berkeley: University of California Press.
129.
TOWNSEND, P.1987. `Deprivation'.Journal of Social Policy16: 125-146.
130.
UNGERSON, C. 1987. Policy is Personal.London: Tavistock.
131.
VEBLEN, T. 1918. The Theory of the Leisure Class.New York: Huebsch.
132.
VEIT-WILSON, J.1987. `Consensual Approaches to Poverty Lines and Social Security'.Journal of Social Policy16: 183-211.
133.
WALKER, R. 1988. `The Costs of Household Formation', in Walker, R. and Parker, G. (eds.), Money Matters.London: Sage.
134.
WALLERSTEIN, I.1988. `Should We Unthink Nineteenth-Century Social Science?'.International Social Science Journal118: 525-531.
135.
WALLMAN, S. 1984. Eight London Households.London: Tavistock.
136.
WESTWOOD, S. 1984. All Day, Every Day.London: Pluto Press.
137.
WHITEHEAD, A. 1981. “I'm Hungry, Mum`: The Politics of Domestic Budgeting', in Young, K., Wolkowitz, C. and McCullagh, R. (eds.), Of Marriage and the Market.London: CSE Books.
138.
WILK, R. 1989. `Decision Making and Resource Flows Within the Household', in Wilk, R. (ed.), The Household Economy.Boulder: Westview Press.
139.
WILSON, G. 1987. Money in the Family.Aldershot: Avebury.
140.
ZELIZER, V.1988. `Beyond the Polemics on the Market'.Sociological Forum3: 614-634.
141.
ZELIZER, V.1989. `The Social Meaning of Money'.American Journal of Sociology95: 342-377.
142.
ZOPF, P. 1989. American Women in Poverty.New York: Greenwood.
