Reviewing the earlier literature on methodological issues in comparative research, the paper argues that `in terms of methodology in abstracto and on issues of research technology, most of all that needed to be said has already been published'. Yet the actual research falls short of this available knowledge. Famous publications based on comparative research are really promulgators of research artefacts.
Three goals are being emphasised: (a) to counteract the tendency to reinvent the methodological wheel; (b) to help with ex post interpretations of data from cross-national research; (c) to use the difficulties and pay-offs in comparisons for substantive insights.
Thus, `Galton's problem' - treating countries as independent cases - forces an evaluation of the pervasiveness of diffusion vs. cultural/national identity. The low stability of many measures requires rethinking the meaning of one-point measurements. Comparative surveys are by implication cross-level research. Therefore, the use of country names as explanans requires theoretical notions about the nation as context for actors and institutions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ALLARDT, E. 1966. `Implications of Within-Nation Variations and Regional Imbalances for Cross-National Research', in Merritt, R. and Rokkan, S. (eds.), Comparing Nations. The Use of Quantitative Data in Cross-National Research.New Haven: Yale University Press.
2.
ALMASY, E. , BALANDIER, A. and DELATTE, J. 1976. Comparative Survey Analysis - an Annotated Bibliography 1967-1973.Beverly Hills, Cal.: Sage.
3.
ALMOND, G. and VERBA, S. 1963. The Civic Culture.Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
4.
BANKS, A.S. and TEXTOR, R.B. 1963. A Cross-Polity Survey.Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
5.
BARNES, S.H. and KAASE, M. eds. 1979. Political Action.Beverly Hills, Cal.: Sage.
6.
BENEDICT, R. 1946. The Chrysanthemum and the Sword.Boston, Mass.: Houghton Mifflin.
7.
BOLLEN, K.1983. `World System Position, Dependency, and Democracy'.American Sociological Review48: 468-478.
8.
BORNSCHIER, V. ed. 1980. Multinationale Konzerne, Wirtschaftspolitik und nationale Entwicklung im Weltsystem.Frankfurt/Main: Campus.
9.
BORNSCHIER, V. and CHASE-DUNN, C. 1985. Transnational Corporations and Under-development.New York: Praeger.
10.
BUCHANAN, W. and CANTRIL, H. 1953. How Nations See Each Other.Urbana, Ill.: University of Illinois Press.
11.
CANTRIL, H. 1965. The Pattern of Human Concerns.New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
12.
CANTRIL, H. and FREE, L.A.1962. `Hopes and Fears for Self and Country'.American Behavioral Scientist6 (2) (Suppl.): 4-30.
13.
CANTRIL, H. and STRUNK, M. eds. 1951. Public Opinion 1935-1946.Princeton: Princeton University Press.
14.
COHEN, E. ed. 1979. `Sociology of Tourism'.Annals of Tourism Research6 (Special issue/Jan. & April).
15.
DEUTSCH, K.W.1985. `The Systems Theory Approach as a Basis for Comparative Research'.International Social Science Journal37.
16.
DODD, S.C. and NEHNEVAJSA, J. 1956. `Techniques for World Polls - A Survey of Journal Articles on Cross-Cultural Polling, 1925-1955'. Mimeo. Paris.
17.
DOGAN, M. and PELASSY, D. 1984. How to Compare Nations.Chatham, NJ: Chatham House.
18.
DUNDLER, F. 1988. Urlaubsreisen 1954-1987.Starnberg: Studienkreis für Tourismus.
19.
FLORA, P. , ALBER, J. and KOHL, J.1977. `Zur Entwicklung des westeuropäischen Wohlfahrtsstaates'.Politische Vierteljahresschrift4: 707-722.
20.
FLORA,P. and HEIDENHEIMER,A.J. eds. 1981. The Development of Welfare States in Europe and America.New Brunswick, N.J.: Transaction Books.
21.
FREY, F. W. , STEPHENSON, P. and ARCHER SMITH, K. 1969. Survey Research on Comparative Social Change.Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
22.
GLOCK, C.V. 1954. `The Comparative Study of Communication and Opinion Formation', in Schramm, W. (ed.), The Process and Effects of Mass Communication.Urbana, Ill.: University of Illinois.
23.
GURR, T.R.1968. `A Causal Model of Civil Strife - A Comparative Analysis Using New Indices'.American Political Science Review62: 1104-1124.
24.
GURR, T.R.1974. `The Neo-Alexandrians - A Review Essay on Data Handbooks in Political Science'.American Political Science Review68: 243-252.
25.
HAMAN, M.T. and CARROL, G.R.1981. `Dynamics of Formal Political Structure'.American Sociological Review46: 19-35.
26.
HAMER, T. 1979. Tourismus und Kulturwandel.Starnberg: Studienkreis für Tourismus.
27.
HEINTZ, P. 1969. Ein soziologisches Paradigma der Entwicklung.Stuttgart: Enke.
28.
HEINTZ, P. 1973. The Future of Development.Bern: Huber.
29.
HEINTZ, P. 1982. Ungleiche Verteilung, Macht und Legitimität.Dissenhofen: Rüegger.
HIBBS, D.A.1985. `Macro-Economic Performance, Policy and Electoral Politics in Industrial Democracies'.International Social Science Journal37 (103): 63-74.
32.
HUDSON, K. 1972. Air Travel - a Social History.Bath, England: Adam and Dart.
33.
HYMAN, H. 1964. `Research Design', in Ward, R.E. (ed.), Studying Politics Abroad.Boston: Little, Brown & Co. pp. 153-188.
34.
JACOBS, P. and JACOBS, B. 1971. Values and the Active Community.New York: Free Press.
35.
KOHN, R. and WHITE, K.L. eds. 1976. Health Care.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
36.
MARSH, R.1966. `Comparative Sociology 1950-1963'.La sociologie contemporaineXIV (2), special issue.
37.
MATTHEWS, H. 1978. International Tourism - A Political and Social Analysis.Cambridge, Mass.: Schenkmann.
38.
MERRITT, R.L. and ROKKAN, S. eds. 1966. Comparing Nations. The Use of Quantitative Data in Cross-National Research.New Haven: Yale University Press.
39.
MURDOCK, G.P. 1949 [1966]. Social Structure.New York: The Free Press.
40.
NAROLL, R.1961. `Two Solutions to Galton's Problem'.Philosophy of Science28: 15-39.
41.
NAROLL, R.1965. `Galton's Problem: The Logic of Cross-Cultural Research'.Social Research32: 428-451.
42.
NIESSEN, M. , PESCHAR, J. and KURILSKY, C. eds. 1984. International Vergleichende Sozialforschung.Frankfurt: Campus Verlag.
43.
OLIVIA, C.1987. `Die Vernachlässigung der Bedeutung internationaler Regionen in Datenanalyse und Theoriebildung'.Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie39.
44.
PRZEWORSKI, A. and TEUNE, H. 1970. The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry.New York: Wiley.
45.
RICE, T.W.1986. `The Determinants of Western European Government Growth 1950-1980'.Comparative Political Studies19 (2): 233-257.
46.
RODNIK, D. 1948. Postwar Germans - An Anthropologist's Account.New Haven: Yale University Press.
47.
ROKKAN, S. 1970. `Cross-Cultural, Cross-Societal, and Cross-National Research', in Main Trends of Research in the Human and the Social Sciences.Paris: UNESCO.
48.
ROKKAN, S. , VERBA, S., VIET, J. and ALMASY, E. 1969. Comparative Survey Analysis.Paris: Mouton.
49.
RUSSETT, B.M. , ALKER, H.R., DEUTSCH, K.W. and LASSWELL, H.D. 1964. World Handbook of Political and Social Indicators.New Haven: Yale University Press.
50.
SARAPATA, A.1985. `Researchers' Habits and Orientations as Factors which Condition International Cooperation in Research'.Science of Science5 (3/4): 157-182.
51.
SCHAFFNER, B.H. 1948. Fatherland - A Study of Authoritarianism in the German Family.New York: Columbia University Press.
52.
SCHEUCH, E.K.1967. `Society as Context in Cross-Cultural Comparisons'.Social Science Information6 (5), Oct. Republished in: Guru Nanak Journal of Sociology1 (1-2).
53.
SCHEUCH, E.K. 1968. `The Cross-Cultural Use of Sample Surveys: Problems of Comparability', in Rokkan, S. (ed.), Comparative Research across Cultures and Nations.Paris/The Hague: ISSC/Mouton. pp.176-209.
54.
SCHEUCH, E.K. 1969. `Ökologischer Fehlschluss', in Bernsdorf, W. (ed.), Wörterbuch der Soziologie.Stuttgart: Enke Verlag.
55.
SCHEUCH, E.K. 1981. `Tourismus', in: Die Psychologie des 20. Jahrhunderts.Zurich: Kindler Verlag.
56.
SCHEUCH, E.K. 1988a. Arbeitszeit contra Freizeit? Die Einstellung der Bundesbürger im Laufe der Zeit.Cologne: Arbeitgeberverband der Metallindustrie.
57.
SCHEUCH, E.K.1988b. `Continuity and Change in German Social Structure'.Historical Social Research13: 31-121.
58.
59.
SCHWEIZER, T. 1978. Methodenprobleme des interkulturellen Vergleichs.Cologne: Böhlau.
60.
SINGER, D. and SMALL, M. 1972. The Wages of War 1816-1965.New York: Wiley.
61.
STINCHCOMBE, A.L.1982. Review.American Journal of Sociology87: 1389-1395.
62.
STOETZEL, J. 1954. Jeunesse sans chrysanthéme ni sabre.Paris: Plon-UNESCO.
63.
SZALAI, A.et al. eds. 1972. The Use of Time.The Hague: Mouton.
64.
SZALAI, A. and PETRELLA, R. eds. 1977. Cross-National Comparative Survey Research.Oxford: Pergamon Press.
65.
TYLOR, E.B. 1961 [1889]. `On a Method of Investigating the Development of Institutions Applied to Laws of Marriage and Descent', in Moore, F.W. (ed.), Readings in Cross-cultural Methodology.New Haven: Yale University Press.
66.
VARLEY, C.G. 1978. Tourism in Fiji - Some Economic and Social Problems.Cardiff: University of Wales Press.
67.
VERBA,S. 1965. `Comparative Political Culture', in Pie, L. and Verba, S. (eds), Political Culture and Political Development.Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
68.
VERBA, S. and NIE, N. 1973. Participation in America.New York: Harper.
69.
WALLACE, M.D. and SINGER, D. 1973. `Large Scale Violence in the Global System'. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association meeting, Montreal.
70.
WALLERSTEIN, I. 1974 [1984]. The Modern World System.New York: Academic Press.
71.
WALLERSTEIN, I. 1980. The Modern World System II.New York: Academic Press.
72.
WEEDE, E.1986. `Rent-Seeking or Dependency as Explanations of Why Poor People Stay Poor'.International Sociology1: 421-441.
73.
WIATR, J.J. 1970/71. `Problems of Theory and Methodology in Cross-National Comparative Research', in The Polish Round TableIV;
74.
also 1971, in Indian Journal of Politics No. 1.
75.
ZIMMERMANN, E. 1977. Soziologie der politischen Gewalt.Stuttgart: Enke Verlag.
76.
ZUMA-Nachrichten1987. `Wie stabil sind Umfragedaten?' No. 20, May.
