Evaluation of IS/IT investments is a notoriously difficult area. Some doubt that IT investments are ever really productive; others point to mismeasurement as a major reason for such a conclusion and for the so-called IT ‘productivity paradox’. The paper reviews traditional approaches to IS/IT evaluation, and discusses their limitations. An eight-stage, multidimensional approach is then put forward to address those limitations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BallantineJ., GalliersR., and StrayS. (1996). Information systems/technology evaluation practice: evidence from UK organizations, Journal Of Information Technology, 11(2), 129–42.
2.
Butler Cox Foundation, (1990). Getting value from information technology, Research Report, No. 75, June, Butler Cox, London.
3.
ChildJ., and LoveridgeR. (1990). Information Technology in European Services (Basil Blackwell, Oxford).
4.
EarlM.J. (1989). Management Strategies for Information Technology (Prentice Hall, Hemel Hempstead, UK).
5.
EarlM.J., and RungeD.A. (1987). Using telecommunications based information systems for competitive advantage, Research and Discussion Paper, RDP 87/1, Oxford Institute of Information Management, Templeton College, Oxford.
6.
FeenyD. (1988). Creating and sustaining competitive advantage with IT, in Information Management: The Strategic Dimension, EarlM.J. (ed) (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp. 98–117.
7.
FitzgeraldG. (1990). Achieving flexible information systems: the case for improved analysis, Journal of Information Technology, 5(5), 5–11.
8.
FitzgeraldL. (1992). Performance Measurement in Service Industries (CIMA Publications, London).
9.
HillT. (1993). Manufacturing Strategy: The Strategic Management of the Manufacturing Function, 2nd edn, (Macmillan, London).
10.
HochstrasserB. (1990). Evaluating IT investments – matching techniques to projects, Journal of Information Technology, 5(4), 215–221.
11.
HochstrasserB., and GriffithsC. (1991). Controlling Information Technology Investments: Strategy and Management, (Chapman and Hall, London).
12.
KearneyA.T. (1990). Breaking the Barriers: IT Effectiveness in Great Britain and Ireland, (A. T. Kearney/CIMA, London).
13.
LandF.F. (1982). Adapting to changing user requirements, Information and Management, 5(2), 59–75.
14.
LedererA.L., and SethiV. (1992). Root causes of strategic information systems planning implementation problems, Journal of Management Information Systems, 9(1), 25–45.
15.
LincolnT.J., and ShorrockD. (1992). Cost justifying current use of information technology, in Managing Information Systems for Profit, LincolnT.J. (ed) (Wiley, Chichester) pp. 68–94.
16.
LucasH.C.Jr, and TurnerJ.A. (1982). A corporate strategy for the control of information processing, Sloan Management Review, 23(3), 281–289.
17.
P.A. Consulting (1990). The Impact of the Current Climate on IT, A Survey Report, P.A. Consulting Group, London.
18.
PeltuM. (1981). Using Computers – A Managers Guide, (The National Computer Centre, Manchester).
19.
RandsT. (1993). Information Systems Resources and Effectiveness: 1992 Survey Research and Discussion Paper, RDP 93/11, Oxford Institute of Information Management, Templeton College, Oxford.
20.
SilkD. (1990). Managing information systems benefits for the 1990s, Journal of Information Technology, 5(4), 185–193.
21.
StrassmannP. (1997). The Squandered Computer (The Information Economics Press, New Canaan).
22.
VowlerJ. (1990). The theory and the reality, Computer Weekly, 15 November.
23.
WillcocksL. (1992). Evaluating information technology investments: research findings and reappraisal, Journal of Information Systems, 2(4), pp. 243–268.
24.
WillcocksL. (ed) (1994). Information Management (Chapman and Hall, London).
25.
WillcocksL. (ed) (1996). Investing In Information Systems (Chapman and Hall, London).
26.
WillcocksL., FeenyD., and IsleiG. (eds) (1997). Managing IT As A Strategic Resource (McGraw Hill, Maidenhead).
27.
WillcocksL., and FitzgeraldG. (1994). A business guide to outsourcing information technology, (Business Intelligence Ltd) p. 371.
28.
WillcocksL., and LesterS. (1997). Assessing IT productivity: Any way out of the labyrinth? in Managing IT As A Strategic ResourceWillcocksL., FeenyD., and IsleiG. (eds) (McGraw Hill, Maidenhead) pp. 64–93.
29.
WisemanC. (1985). Strategy and Computers: Information Systems as Competitive Weapons (Dow Jones-Irwin, Homewood, Ill.).
