This paper explores the techniques used by organizations to appraise Information Systems (IS)/Information Technology (IT) investments, and concentrates, in particular, on techniques of capital investment appraisal. We draw on relevant studies reported in both the accounting and finance, and the IS literature, which have addressed their usage. Where possible comparisons are drawn between both sets of literatures. The results of a survey that specifically examined IS/IT investment appraisal practices of a sample of UK companies is also presented. Among the issues discussed include the extent to which capital investment appraisal techniques are used to appraisal investments, the importance of the techniques used and the problems attendant on the decision making process.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AngellI.O., and SmithsonS. (1991). Appraisal, monitoring and control, in Information Systems Management: Opportunities and Risks (MacMillen, Hong Kong) pp. 189–212.
2.
BaconJ.C. (1992). The use of decision criteria in selecting information systems technology investments, MIS Quarterly, 16(3), 335–53.
3.
BadriM.A. (1992). Critical issues in information systems management: an international perspective. International Journal of Information Management, 12(3), 179–91.
4.
BallantineJ.A., GalliersR.G., and StrayS.J. (1994). Assessing the feasibility of information systems/technology projects – recent findings of the use of capital investment appraisal techniques, Warwick Business School Research Paper No 105, 1–21.
5.
BelsonW.A. (1964). Readership in Britain. Business Review, 6, 416–20.
6.
BrealeyR., and MyersS. (1981). Principles of Corporate Finance (McGraw-Hill, Maidenhead).
7.
CarlsonE.D. (1974). Appraising the impact of information systems. Management Informative, 3(2), 57–67.
8.
CarsbergB., and HopeA. (1976). Business Investment Decisions under Inflation: Theory and Practice (Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, London).
9.
ChandlerJ.S. (1982). A multiple criteria approach for appraising information systems. MIS Quarterly, 6(1), 61–75.
10.
ClarkT.D.Jr. (1992). Corporate systems management: an overview and research perspective. Communications of the ACM, 35(2), 61–75.
11.
DicksonG.W., LeitheiserR.L., WetherbeJ.C., and NechisM. (1984). Key information systems issues for the 1980's. MIS Quarterly, 8, 135–4.
12.
FarbeyB., LandF., and TargettD. (1992). Appraising investments in IT. Journal of Information Technology, 7, 109–22.
13.
FarbeyB., LandF., and TargettD. (1993). How to Assess Your IT Investments – A study of Methods and Practice (Butterworth-Heinemann Ltd, London).
14.
GalliersR.D. (1993). Research issues in information systems. Journal of Information Technology, 8(2), 92–98.
15.
GinzbergM. (1979). Improving MIS Project Selection. OMEGA, 7(6), 527–37.
16.
GinzbergM.J., and ZmudR.W. (1988). Evolving criteria for information systems assessment, in 41–52Information Systems Assessment: Issues and ChallengesBjorn-AndersonN., and DavisG.B. (eds), (Elsevier North Holland, Amsterdam) pp. 41–52.
17.
GitmanL., and ForresterJ. (1978). A survey of capital budgeting techniques used by major US firms. Financial Management, 6(3), 66–71.
18.
GurnaniC. (1984). Capital budgeting: theory and practice. The Engineering Economist, 30(1), 19–46.
19.
HakaS.F., GordonL.A., and PinchesG.E. (1985). Sophisticated capital budgeting selection techniques and firm performance. The Accounting Review, LX(4), 651–69.
20.
HamiltonS., and ChervancyN.L. (1981). Appraising information system effectiveness – Part 1: Comparing appraisal approaches. MIS Quarterly, 5, 55–69.
21.
HawgoodJ., and LandF. (1988). A multivalent approach to information system assessment in Information Systems Assessment: Issues and Challenges, Bjorn-AndersonN., and DavisG.B. (eds) (Elsevier, North Holland, Amsterdam) pp. 103–20.
22.
HirschheimR., and SmithsonS. (1988). A critical analysis of information systems appraisal in Information Systems Assessment: Issues and Challenges, Bjorn-AndersonN., and DavisG.B. (eds) (Elsevier, North Holland, Amsterdam) pp. 17–37.
23.
HochstrasserB. (1992). Justifying IT investments, Proceedings of the Advanced Information Systems Conference, London, June, pp. 17–28.
24.
KeenP.G.W. (1991). Shaping the Future: Business Design Through Information Technology (Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA).
25.
KimS.H., and FarragherE.J. (1981). Current capital budgeting practices. Management Accounting, 62(12), 26–29.
26.
KingJ.L., and SchremsE.L. (1978). Cost-benefit analysis in information systems development and operation. Computer Surveys, 10(1), 19–34.
27.
KlammerT. (1972). Empirical evidence of the adoption of sophisticated capital budgeting techniques. Journal of Business, 45(3), 387–97.
28.
KleinG., and BeckP.O. (1987). A decision aid for selecting among information system alternatives. MIS Quarterly, 11(2), 177–85.
29.
LucasH.C., and MooreJ.R. (1976). A multiple-criterion scoring approach to information systems project selection. INFOR, 14(1), 1–12.
30.
LumbyS. (1981). Investment Appraisal and Related Decisions (Van Nostrand Reinhold, London).
31.
McIntyreA.D., and CoulthurstN.J. (1984). Theory and practice in capital budgeting. British Accounting Review, 14(3), 24–70.
32.
MaglittaJ., and Sullivan-TrainorM. (1991). Do the right things. Computerworld: The Premier 100 (supplement), 6–13.
33.
MillerJ. (1993). Measuring and aligning information systems with the organisation. Information and Management25(4), 217–28.
34.
MillsR.W. (1988). Capital budgeting techniques used in the UK and the USA. Management Accounting, 61(1), 23–40.
35.
MooreJ.S., and ReichertA.K. (1983). An analysis of financial management techniques currently employed by large US corporations. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 10(4), 623–45.
36.
MoserC., and KaltonG. (1971). Survey Methods in Social Investigation (Heinemann, London).
37.
NiedermanF., BranchaeuJ.C., and WetherbeJ.C. (1991). Information systems management issues for the 1990's. MIS Quarterly, 7(4), 475–500.
38.
OppenheimA.N. (1982). Questionnaire Design and Attitude Measurement (Sage, London).
39.
ParkerM.M., TrainorH.E., and BensonR.J. (1989). Information Strategy and Economics (Prentice-Hall, New York).
40.
PervanG. (1997). IS executives’ views of the key issues in information management in Australia, in Proceedings Of the Fifth European Conference On Information Systems, GalliersR. (eds), Cork, Ireland, June, 1, 58–72.
41.
PettyJ.W., ScottD.F., and BirdM.M. (1975). The capital expenditure decision-making process of large corporations. The Engineering Economist, 20(3), 159–72.
42.
PikeR.H. (1982). Capital Budgeting in the 1980s: A Major Survey of the Investment Practices in Large Companies (ICMA, London).
43.
PikeR.H. (1988). An empirical study of the adoption of sophisticated capital budgeting practices and decision making effectiveness. Accounting and Business Research, 18(72), 341–51.
44.
PikeR.H. (1989). Do sophisticated capital budgeting approaches improve investment decision-making effectiveness?The Engineering Economist, 34(2), 149–61.
45.
PollardC., and HayneS. (1996). A comparative analysis of IS issues facing Canadian Business, in Proceedings of the 29th Annual Hawaii International Conference on Systems Sciences, Hawaii, NunamakerJ.F., and SpragueR.H. (eds), 2, 68–77.
46.
Price Waterhouse, (1992). Information Technology Review 1991/92 (Price Waterhouse, London).
47.
SangsterA. (1993). Capital investment appraisal techniques: a survey of current usage. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 20(3), 307–32.
48.
ScapensR.W., and SalesJ.R. (1981). Performance measurement and formal capital expenditure controls in divisionalised companies. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 8(3), 389–419.
49.
SchallL., SundenG., and GeijsbeekW. (1978). Survey and analysis of capital budgeting methods, Journal of Finance, 33(1), 281–92.
50.
SchellG.P. (1986). Establishing the value of information systems, Interfaces, 16(3), 82–89.
51.
SagerI., and GleckmanH. (1994). The information revolution. Business Week, 13 June, 35–39.
52.
StrassmannP. (1997). The Squandered Computer (Information Economics Press, New Canaan).
53.
SundemG.L., and GeijsbeekW.R. (1978). Survey and analysis of capital budgeting methods, Journal of Finance, 33(1), 281–87.
54.
WangP., and TurbanE. (1994). Management information systems issues of the 1990s in the Republic of China: an industry analysis. International Journal of Information Management, 14(1), 25–38.
55.
WillcocksL. (1992). Evaluating information technology investments; research findings and reappraisal. Journal of Information Systems, 2(4), 243–68.
56.
WillcocksL. (ed.) (1994). Information Management: Evaluation of IS Investments (Chapman and Hall, London).
57.
WillcocksL. (ed.) (1996). Investing In Information Systems (Chapman and Hall, London).
