Division of Labour and the Design of Systems for Computer Support for Cooperative Work

Abstract

The design of systems which provide computer support for cooperative work (CSCW) has been dominated by models of collaborative teams in academic or design environments. Such settings are characterized by a relatively egalitarian power distribution and a division of labour established locally by the collaborating parties. This paper describes other types of collaborative work in which the rôles of participants are characterized by pre-established divisions of labour and unequal power distribution. A case study is presented of a collaborative group allocating and scheduling service calls in an electricity company. Using the Organizational Requirements Definition for Information Technology (ORDIT) methods for responsibility analysis a number of alternative organizational structures are described which may serve this task. The alternatives are based upon different job design structures which distribute responsibilities to work rôles by different rationales. An analysis is offered of the different CSCW systems that would be necessary to support these alternatives. The paper concludes by examining the implications of pre-established but variable organizational structures for the design of generic CSCW systems.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barras

, and Swann

(1983). The Adoption and Impact of Information Technology in the UK Insurance Industry (The Technical Change Centre, London).

Bjørn-Andersen

, Eason

K.D.

, and Robey

(1986). Managing Computer Impact (Ablex, Norwood NJ).

Child

, Loveridge

, Harvey

, and Spencer

(1984). Microelectronics and the quality of employment in services, in New Office Technology and the Future of Work and Skills, Marstrand

(ed) (Francis Pinter, London), 163–89.

Eason

K.D.

(1988). Information Technology and Organisational Change (Taylor and Francis, London).

Eason

K.D.

, and Sell

R.G.

(1980). Case studies in job design for information processing tasks, in Stress, Work Design and Productivity, Corlett

E.N.

, and Richardson

(eds) (John Wiley, Chichester), 195–208.

Eason

K.D.

, Harker

S.D.P.

, Raven

P.F.

, Brailsford

J.R.

, and Cross

A.D.

(1987). A user-centred approach to design of a knowledge-based system, INTERACT'87. Proceedings of the Second IFIP Conference on Human-Computer Interaction held at the University of Stuttgart, 1–4 September 1987, pp. 341–347.

Gower

J.C.

, and Eason

K.D.

(1984). Defining information technology systems for the electricity supply industry, Human–Computer Interaction – INTERACT'84. Proceedings of the First IFIP Conference on Human-Computer Interaction held at Imperial College, London, 4–7 September 1984.

Grudin

(1989). Why groupware applications fail: problems in design and evaluation. Office, Technology and People, 4, 245–64.

Hales

(1994). Where are designers? Styles of design practice, objects of design and views of users of CSCW, in Design Issues in CSCW, Rosenberg

, and Hutchinson

(eds) (Springer-Verlag, London) pp. 151–77.

10.

Hales

(1995). Working with contexts, powers and stakeholders in configuring standard software, in Proceedings of the Third Triennial Conference on Computers in Context – Joining forces in design, Aarhus, Denmark, 14–18 August 1995, pp. 1–10.

11.

Heath

C.C.

, and Luff

(1991). Collaborative activity and technological design: task collaboration in London Underground control rooms, in Proceedings of the Second European Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work, Amsterdam, 25–27 September 1991. Bannon

, Robinson

, and Schmidt

(eds.), Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 65–80.

12.

Hughes

J.A.

, Randall

, and Shapiro

(1992). Faltering from ethnography to design, in Proceedings of CSCW ‘92, Toronto, 2–4 November 1992.

13.

Hutchins

E.L.

(1990). The technology of team navigation, in Intellectual Teamwork: The Social and Technological Foundations of Co-operative Work, Galegher

, Kraut

R.E.

, and Egido

(eds) (LEA, Hillsdale NJ) pp. 191–221.

14.

Long

R.J.

(1987). New Office Information Technology; Human and Managerial Implications (Croom Helm, London).

15.

McCarthy

(1994). The state-of-the-art of CSCW: CSCW systems, cooperative work and organisation. Journal of Information Technology, 9(2), pp. 73–83.

16.

Olphert

C.W.

, and Harker

S.D.P.

(1994). The ORDIT method for organisational requirements definition, in Human Factors in Organizational Design and Management – IV, Bradley

G.E.

, and Hendrick

H.W.

(eds) (Elsevier, Amsterdam) pp. 421–26.

17.

Pye

, Bates

, and Heath

(1986). Profiting from Office Automation: Office Automation Pilots (Department of Trade and Industry, London).

18.

Turner

, and Kraut

(eds) (1992). CSCW'92: Sharing Perspectives, Proceedings of the Conference on Computer-Supported Co-operative Work (ACM Press, New York).

19.

Weber

(1947). The Theory of Social and Economic Organization (Free Press, Glencoe, IL).

20.

Weisbord

M.R.

(1990). Productive Workplaces: Organizing and Managing for Dignity, Meaning and Community (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco).