Leading industrialized nations are now involved in the full implementation of national information superhighways. Their efforts will depend largely on the roles and levels of involvement of public institutions and how this is perceived and reacted to by the private sector. Through the evolution of eight scenarios of public institution involvement, this paper extrapolates the consequences that each brings about in the development of a national information superhighway. In particular, this paper examines the consequences of the development of an information superhighway for the UK within the context of each scenario and draws comparisons with developments in other countries. Contrary to popular belief, we show that there is no full solution for the shortcomings experienced in the development of the UK's information superhighway; rather, each scenario offers solutions for a subset of the shortcomings.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AngelidesM.C. (1997). Implementing the Internet for business: a global marketing opportunity. International Journal of Information Management, 17(6), 405–19.
2.
AngelidesM.C., and AgiusH.W. (In press) Multimedia Information Superhighways.
3.
AngelidesM.C., and DustdarS. (1997). Multimedia Information Systems (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, MA).
4.
BasileC. (1995). The US HDTV standard. IEEE Spectrum, 32(4), 36–45.
5.
BellT.E., AdamJ.A., and LoweS.J. (1996). Communications. IEEE Spectrum, 33(1), 30–41.
6.
BenjaminR., and WigandR. (1995). Electronic markets and virtual value chains on the information superhighway. Sloan Management Review, 36(2), 62–72.
7.
BerendtA. (1998). The meaning of convergence. Telecommunications, 32(6), 70–1.
8.
BlackmanC.R., and PrestonP. (1995). Infrastructure competition: towards a two-track telecoms Europe?Telecommunications Policy, 19(4), 251–2.
BrowningJ. (1994). The wired economy. In The World in 1995, FishburnD. (ed.) (The EconomistPublications Ltd, London), pp. 121–4.
13.
BubleyD., and BennettP. (1994). Information Superhighways: The New Information Age (Financial Times Management Report, FT Telecoms & Media Publishing, London).
14.
CaneA. (1994). Fujitsu plans digital challenge in US. Financial Times, 5 December, 11.
15.
CaneA. (1995). Europe hampered by poor vision. Financial Times, 6 February, 15.
16.
CarlsonR.L. (1996). The Information Superhighway: Strategic Alliances in Telecommunications and Multimedia (Macmillan Business, Basingstoke).
17.
Cats-BarilW.L., and JelassiT. (1994). The French videotex system Minitel: a successful implementation of a national information technology infrastructure. MIS Quarterly, 18(1), 1–20.
18.
Central Computer and Telecommunications Agency (1994). Information Superhighways: Opportunities for Public Sector Applications in the UK A Government Consultative Report (HMSO, London).
19.
ClintonW.J., and GoreA. (1993). Technology for America's Growth: A New Direction to Build Economic Strength (Office of the White House, Washington, DC).
20.
CollinsR. (1990). The Second Generation: The Lessons of Satellite TV in Western Europe (PICT, Sussex).
21.
Commission of the European Communities (1994). Europe and the Global Information Society (Commission of the European Communities, Brussels).
CrandallR.W. (1992). Regulating communications: creating monopoly while ‘protecting’ us from it. The Brookings Review, 10(3), 34–9.
24.
DavidP.A., and SteinmuellerW.E. (1996). Standards, trade and competition in the emerging global information infrastructure environment. Telecommunications Policy, 20(10), 817–30.
25.
DixitS. (1995). A look at the video dial-tone network. IEEE Spectrum, 32(4), 64–5.
26.
Department of Trade and Industry (1991). Competition and Choice: Telecommunications Policy for the 1990s (HMSO, London).
27.
Department of Trade and Industry (1994). Creating the Superhighways of the Future: Developing Broadband Communications in the UK (HMSO, London).
28.
EganB.L. (1991). Information Superhighways: The Economics of Advanced Public Communication Networks (Artech House, Boston, MA).
29.
EganB.L. (1996). Information Superhighways Revisited: The Economics of Multimedia (Artech House, Boston, MA).
30.
European Commission (1997). Green Paper on the Convergence of the Telecommunications, Media and Information Technology Sectors, and the Implications for Regulation: Towards an Information Society Approach (European Commission, Brussels).
31.
FoxB. (1995). The digital dawn in Europe. IEEE Spectrum, 32(4), 50–3.
32.
FransmanM. (1997). Towards a new agenda for Japanese telecommunications. Telecommunications Policy, 21(2), 185–94.
33.
FrazierD. (1994). CeBIT ‘94 essay: no transatlantic bridge for the information superhighway. Datamation, 1 March, 100–1.
34.
GershonR.A., and KanayamaT. (1995). Direct broadcast satellites in Japan: a case study in government-business partnerships. Telecommunications Policy, 19(3), 217–31.
35.
GhertmanM., and QuélinB. (1995). Regulation and transaction costs in telecommunications: a research agenda. Telecommunications Policy, 19(6), 487–500.
36.
GoreA. (1995). Infrastructure for the global village. Scientific American: The Computer in the 21st Century: A Special Issue, 6(1), 156–9.
37.
GriffithV. (1994). US cable groups push into telecoms. Financial Times, 31 October, 13.
38.
HarperJ.M. (1995). The case against competing infrastructures. Telecommunications Policy, 19(4), 285–98.
39.
Harvard Law Review (1994). The message in the medium: the First Amendment on the information superhighway. Harvard Law Review, 107(5), 1062–98.
40.
HaslamC., and GroverP. (1996). Break up BT!Wired, 2(4), 31–3.
41.
HattaK., and TakeuchiN. (1995). Facility supply and demand of the trunk line network: some aspects of competition in the Japanese telecommunications market. Telecommunications Policy, 19(3), 201–16.
42.
HeldmanR.K. (1995). The Telecommunications Information Millenium: A Vision and Plan for the Global Information Society (McGraw-Hill, New York, NY).
43.
HouselT.J., and DavidsonW.H. (1991). The development of information services in France: the case of public videotex. International Journal of Information Management, 11(1), 35–54.
44.
Information Highway Advisory Council (1995). Connection, Community, Content: The Challenge of the Information Highway: Final Report of the Information Highway Advisory Council (Industry Canada, Ottawa, Ontario).
45.
Information Infrastructure Task Force (1993). The National Information Infrastructure: Agenda for Action (Department of Commerce, Washington, DC).
46.
International Telecommunications Union (1996). The Changing Role of Government in an Era of Telecom Deregulation: Regulatory Implications of Telecommunications Convergence (International Telecommunications Union, Geneva).
47.
IshizukaA. (1994). Data highway lags in Japan. BYTE, 19(3), 56.
48.
JamesonJ. (1996). New media: the likely development path and future regulatory requirements. Telecommunications Policy, 20(6), 399–413.
49.
KettingerW.J. (1994). National infrastructure diffusion and the U.S. information super highway. Information & Management, 27, 357–68.
50.
KlinglerR. (1994). Cable television: the First Amendment. The Brookings Review, 12(1), 16–19.
LaiV.S., and ReehB. (1995). ISDN implementation in the United States and Germany: a cross-country assessment. Information & Management, 29(1), 131–40.
53.
LangdaleJ.V. (1997). International competitiveness in East Asia: broadband telecommunications and interactive multimedia. Telecommunications Policy, 21(2), 235–49.
54.
LargeD. (1995). Creating a network for interactivity. IEEE Spectrum, 32(4), 58–63.
55.
LeungL. (1995). Lines of battle. Computing, 23 November, 26–7.
56.
LewynM. (1994). The states swing into I-Way construction. Business Week, 22 August, 57–8.
57.
LucasH.J.Jr, LevecqH., KrautR., and StreeterL. (1995). France's grass-roots data net. IEEE Spectrum, 32(11), 71–7.
58.
MarshallA. (1995). Global village rivals power of the state. The Independent, 27 February, 9.
59.
MilesM.B., and HubermanA.M. (1984). Qualitative Data Analysis: A Sourcebook of New Methods (Sage Publications, Newbury Park, CA).
60.
MillerS.E. (1996). Civilizing Cyberspace: Policy, Power, and the Information Superhighway (ACM Press/Addison-Wesley, New York, NY).
61.
NakamotoM. (1994). Laying the groundwork. Financial Times Survey: Japanese Industry, 6 December, 2.
62.
NatarajanK. (1995). Video servers take root. IEEE Spectrum, 32(4), 66–9.
63.
NihoulP. (1998). Competition or regulation for multimedia?Telecommunications Policy, 22(3), 207–18.
64.
NinomiyaY. (1995). The Japanese scene. IEEE Spectrum, 32(4), 54–7.
65.
NoamE. (1992). Telecommunications in Europe (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
66.
Office of Telecommunications (1994). A Framework for Effective Competition (HMSO, London).
67.
Office of Telecommunications (1995). Liberalisation of the British Telecommunications Industry: A Chronology of Events (HMSO, London).
68.
OmuraT. (1997). Japan's stumbling policy for competition in the telecommunications industry. Telecommunications Policy, 21(2), 127–41.
69.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (1992). Convergence Between Communication Technologies (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris).
70.
PospischilR. (1995). A bypass for the local loop: Deutsche Telekom's strategy for fiber to the home. Telecommunications Policy, 19(7), 579–85.
Reed Electronics Research (1998). Analysis of the InfoHighway (Elsevier/Reed Electronics Research, Surrey).
73.
ReinhardtA. (1994). Building the data highway. BYTE, 19(3), 46–74.
74.
SchementJ.R. (1995). Beyond universal service: characteristics of Americans without telephones, 1980–1993. Telecommunications Policy, 19(6), 477–85.
75.
SchoechleT.D. (1995). Privacy on the information superhighway: will my house still be my castle?Telecommunications Policy, 19(6), 435–52.
76.
SchoofH., and BrownA.W. (1995). Information highways and media policies in the European Union. Telecommunications Policy, 19(4), 325–38.
77.
SteinbrinkB. (1994). Europe's many data highways. BYTE, 19(3), 58.
78.
StilesC. (1995). Japanese multimedia industry update. IEEE MultiMedia, 2(4), 8–11.
79.
SugayaM. (1995). Cable television and government policy in Japan. Telecommunications Policy, 19(3), 233–9.
80.
Telecommunications Council (1994). Reforms Towards the Intellectually Creative Society of the 21st Century (Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications, Tokyo).
81.
ThaparN. (1999). Cable giants plan £30bn UK merger. Financial Mail on Sunday, 13 June, 1–2.
82.
Van CuilenburgJ., and SlaaP. (1995). Competition and innovation in telecommunications: an empirical analysis of innovative telecommunications in the public interest. Telecommunications Policy, 19(8), 647–63.
83.
Van der StaalP., GrassmuckV., and HattaK. (1995). ISDN in Japan: actors, status and expectations. Telecommunications Policy, 19(7), 531–44.
84.
VerityJ.W. (1994). Truck lanes for the info highway. Business Week, 18 April, 58–60.
85.
WardD. (1995). Rewiring Democracy: The Role of Public Information in Europe's Information Society. (MacLennan Ward Research Ltd, London).
